Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] And we're back. Welcome to the pod. What's up, Ryan? How's it going, man? Going good. Good to catch up, as always. 0:11 Got a lot of stuff to talk about today, so this is gonna be a fun, fun episode to kind of riff on what we're both doing and have some fun. Sound good? Absolutely. Yeah. Excited to chat. 0:22 I know that you launched the ad network today, the Growletter Ad Network. Yeah, excited to, to learn. 0:29 You shared a little bit with me about like, kind of the goals of that and, and how it, how it's all working, but, uh, I think that's something that would be very interesting to maybe kick things off with. 0:39 Yeah, it'll be fun to talk about. I-- There's still a lot more I'll be able to share as we do more stuff with the ad network in the coming weeks and months. 0:48 And that's one of the reasons I wanted to start this, is because we help newsletters, creators, media companies grow their newsletters. 0:56 We help them get more subscribers, get more customers if they have a subscription information product, stuff like that. But we've never helped people sold ads until now, and that's what the Growletter Ad Network is. 1:08 It's really a ad sales service, and it's also a service to help marketers and advertisers manage the campaigns that they're buying in newsletter ads. 1:15 There's really like a network, and there's two sides to it, or there's a marketplace where there's two sides to it. 1:19 So of course, there's the publishers that have the newsletters, and there's the advertisers that wanna advertise in those newsletters. 1:24 And what we're doing is connecting the two in a way that's very win-win and that is really easy for both parties. 1:33 So, for example, um, for the newsletter publisher, which is most people listening, we don't charge anything up front. We only take a commission. We just use the industry standard commission rate. 1:43 There's no exclusivity to work with us. Um, we price things on a flat fee, so it's not like performance-based. A lot of publishers don't like CPC-based deals where they only get paid per click. 1:53 It's very publisher-friendly in every possible way. But it also helps advertisers too because it saves them a lot of time, right? They can work with us and buy ads across a dozen or more newsletters all in one go. 2:07 We handle all of the creative, all the reporting, all the coordination, all the management, um, all of the, the billing and payment, invoicing, insertion orders. 2:16 We handle all of that for them, and so it just saves them time. 2:20 Both of us have bought a lot of, like, newsletter ads before, and even influencer ads, which are kind of similar in some ways 'cause you're working with individual creators or publishers, and you know how much time it takes. 2:30 And, like, not only the time to manage the things, but also the time to find, vet the right people to work with and do all the math to see if it backs out for you or not is a lot of work. Like, 2:39 t-tell me about your influence [chuckles] experience real quick, 'cause you did a lot of this at The Hustle and Trends, right? Yeah. You spent a lot of money on that. Yeah. 2:46 At The Hustle and Trends and, and other companies, uh, that I've worked with as well. Uh, yeah, I-- It's, uh... It can work. 2:54 It's just a nightmare to manage because a lot of times, unless you're paying for some sort of platform that, uh, that organizes all of these engagements and all the outreach, I mean, it's essentially like outbound sales in some ways, uh, in that you're just kind of emailing folks, you're emailing their management, you're discussing rates. 3:15 Uh, and so doing that across, you know, uh, if you're doing it at scale, like dozens of influencers or dozens of creators, or in this case, dozens of newsletters, that can be really challenging. 3:26 So, uh, if it's, if it's a, uh, a managed service or a network where folks come pre-vetted with, uh, and you have an immediate understanding of the, the rates for, for placements like that, that will definitely save folks a lot of headache. 3:42 Yeah. And I think newsletters can be a lot better than influencer placement. I mean, both can work great, uh, but especially in the way that we do them, but it's just, like, the time involved. And I bought... 3:50 When I worked at The Hustle, I bought a lot of newsletter ads. I've bought some for our agency more recently. 3:56 Th-there's a lot of great ones out there, but if you're managing a multi-million dollar budget and you have to buy across dozens of newsletters all by yourself, you just don't have time to do it because every marketer who's doing this also has other responsibilities too. 4:07 No-- There's really no marketer at a company that's just like, "My job is newsletter ad buyer." Right. Like, that, that job title doesn't really exist. They always have other responsibilities on top of that. 4:17 Hopefully, that job will exist more in the future as the ecosystem continues to grow, but that's one of the problems that we solve for advertisers. 4:25 We also just do all the vetting, and we have access to data that they can never access. 4:29 And the simple example of that is if you're an advertiser and you wanna say, you wanna buy in three different newsletters, they're gonna send you their media kits. 4:36 They're gonna tell you, "Okay, here's our list size, open rate, click-through rate, ad clicks, whatever data you want. Here's information on how our audience breaks down in the different job titles, genders, locations." 4:47 But you can't actually verify any of that as an advertiser. You're just kinda taking their word for it. And most publishers are totally accurate, but there are definitely some out there that are not accurate. 4:56 I don't know how your... what your take on this is, but, like, as a buyer, I've definitely seen it before where I'm like, this stuff just doesn't match up at all. 5:02 And I've even seen it just, like, working with various people throughout the past five years of doing this. And so basically, we're going in kind of like a trusted third party that just verify that information. 5:12 Like, is that all, is that all correct? 5:14 And so either we're getting access to the publisher's email service provider, or at the very least, we're getting on a call with them and, um, doing screen shares to, like, see everything and break everything down. 5:23 Most people already have access to their ESPs. And so you can just have more trust when you actually pull the trigger on ad that it's actually is what they say it is. 5:32 And again, it's very rare that that stuff happens, where it's just there's deliberate inaccuracies or lies, but that does happen for sure for any type of ad. 5:42 Like, whether it's influencer, newsletter, whatever, it definitely happens, and so just having someone to verify that I think is helpful. Yeah, totally. 5:49 And like, I think it, it helps to have somebody in that third party, so as an, as that intermediary party, so you guys in this, uh, example, with a pretty... comprehensive, holistic knowledge of newsletters as well. 6:04 So like, you know, I mean, even like stuff like click-through rate can be gamed by bot clicks, but having an understanding of, okay, what is the ad click-through rate? Like, what is the, um, 6:15 I don't know, like even, even what is the conversion rate on similar placements and stuff like that, like really getting down to the actual revenue-driving metrics. 6:22 I feel like that kind of stuff would be really helpful for advertisers as well. 6:25 And then, you know, when expectations are, uh, are set properly in those kinds of, uh, deals upfront, it's better for everybody 'cause they book more, uh, the publishers make more, and, and the brands have somewhere that they can like stick with and actually run multiple placements over a long period of time. 6:45 It really is, and there's like a lot of nuances that advertisers and publishers don't realize when it comes to buying ads. Like, 6:53 you need to focus on ad clicks, you need to consider bots, you need to buy newsletters that have really high engagement. 6:59 So like even if it looks like a good deal, like, "Hey, this is a really good price for the amount of clicks I'm getting and for the amount of whatever I'm getting," but you see their engagement and they have like a 30% open rate, 20% open rate, that's a sign that the audience just doesn't care about this crap. 7:11 Like it's just... It doesn't matter to them. And so like there's certain open rate thresholds and click-through rate thresholds that you wanna see as an advertiser. 7:18 You also wanna look at what their, um, sign-up sources are, so where are they getting subscribers? 7:23 You know, is that being gamed in a way where they're getting subscribers that don't engage with the advertisers, or they're getting subscribers that are outside of the audience that I wanna target as an advertiser? 7:33 There's like a dozen different things we look at that I don't think most advertisers are. Yeah. 7:38 And we've just seen, like we've been inside the dashboards of so many newsletters where like I know what, what's gonna work and what's not gonna work 'cause I've just seen it so many times. 7:46 And, um, as an advertiser, without really being behind the scenes, you can't really see that. Now, this doesn't mean that we don't want advertisers and brands to work together directly. 7:57 Like that is still the best thing for most newsletters and for most advertisers in many cases, especially if it's the right brand that you can continue to work with long-term over and over again. 8:09 But there's just certain scenarios where it's just not possible. 8:11 Like if an advertiser wants to buy across a lot of newsletters that are smaller, like 10 to 50,000 subscribers, they just don't have the time to do that if they have a big budget and a lot of spend to put out there. 8:20 And maybe they have time to do one, but do they have time to do a dozen when they have the budget to? Like we can help them do a dozen or two dozen that are in that, in that size range. 8:30 And so yeah, it's, that's, that's kind of we're, we're filling in different gaps where it makes sense to. We're also never gonna sell 100% of a, a newsletter's inventory, most likely. 8:40 They still need to go out and sell direct. 8:42 But if we can, you know, work with 20 to 40 newsletters and sell 20% to 30% of their inventory that they wouldn't have otherwise sold without us, it was just money that they were leaving on the table, that's where we can really help people a lot, and that's what I'm trying to do. 8:56 Yeah, I like that because it just kind of plugs in to take care of unsold inventory. Very cool, man. Yeah, I think that does solve a huge problem. 9:03 Uh, I mean, I think there's so many newsletters, newsletters that we work with, newsletters that I've, uh, spoken to, you know, the, the operation founders. 9:11 I think that's the number one challenge for folks out there right now, are people that came into newsletters, built sizable lists that might even have good engagement, but now they're just having trouble on the monetization side because the plan that they went into it with was, "We're gonna monetize this primarily through sponsorships, uh, and through, and through ad revenue." 9:33 And I think the environment has changed a little bit, uh, which is why I think an ad network like this will help a lot of people. But the environment has changed a little bit in that I think 9:44 generally folks are wary to go into... Generally, uh, brands are, are more wary going into CPM deals, right? 9:52 Or the CPMs that they're willing to pay, uh, for newsletter sponsorships are lower than they've been, I don't know, like maybe like two years ago or, or a year and a half ago. Is that your experience as well? 10:02 There's a harsh reality. Yeah, there's a harsh reality that's we, we have to talk about, where over the past, I think since 2022, 10:10 there have been a lot more newsletters pop up, and therefore a lot more newsletter ad inventory. 10:14 And the amount of advertisers in the space I don't think has grown a lot, and I wanna fix that, but I don't think it's grown a lot. I don't... Also, I don't have data on exactly how many advertisers there are right now. 10:24 We, we have some like data tools that we buy to get an idea of this stuff, but there's not a lot of sophisticated insights into how many newsletter advertisers there are. 10:33 But I don't think it's grown a lot in the past two or three years. But the number of newsletters has grown a lot. 10:38 And also all these advertisers' budgets since 2022, like most have gotten smaller because the economy has like, in some ways it's contracted, like interest rates have gone up a lot. 10:49 Advertisers are just being a lot more shrewd with their budgets. 10:53 And so we ta- I think one of the best ways to get a handle on this is just talking to the biggest newsletter publishers because they have the most ads sold over the longest period of time at scale. 11:04 And so a lot of those ones I've talked to were like, "Hey, back in 2020 through 2022, we would see like a $50 to $70 CPM. Now we're more at a $30 to $50 CPM, and, you know, we don't necessarily have, um, more inventory. 11:19 And so we're able to fill those spots just at a lower rate. Like we're still able to get advertisers, but at a lower rate." So that's one of the challenges that you see. 11:26 And then a lot of, on the smaller side of the newsletter publishers, they're just not... 11:31 Uh, first of all, you have the chicken and egg problem, where it's like it's hard to get sponsors when you have a small audience, and it gets easier as you grow your audience. So that's a big challenge. 11:39 And then the second part is they're just not doing enough outreach, not having enough conversations with advertisers because they don't have time. Mm-hmm. 11:47 Like, um, they're, they're writing content, you know, managing their business, growing their list, all this stuff, but you really need to be reaching out to dozens or even over 100 different prospects every single month to sell out your aventor- ad inventory, especially if you're someone who has like five newsletters a week and you have at least one ad in each of those newsletters. 12:06 And you do that through building a ad sales team-But at the same time, people have that chicken and egg problem again, where it's like they're not big enough to hire a salesperson, so therefore they can't do the outreach, they don't have time for it themselves. 12:17 And so until they bridge that gap, they're not gonna have the sponsors coming in. 12:22 And so we can assist with that, but also, like, you just gotta, you gotta do more outreach, and you gotta try and grow as fast as you can so you can get over that gap and actually get to the bigger advertisers. Yeah. 12:32 I think the-- there's, there's sometimes just mismatched expectations too, and I think that the, uh, a lot of the solutions that you see now, like with Beehiiv's ad network, for example, where a lot of it is... 12:44 I, I know they just launched a CPM option or C- or CPM partnerships are now available on Beehiiv. But for a long time it was CPC, it was cost per click, so more performance-based. And I think that was a-an attempt to get 12:58 expectations between brands and publishers more aligned. Because I think, like, brands are going into this with a performance mindset a lot of the times, right? 13:08 Like, unless they have a, an entire budget for brand awareness, uh, or kind of like larger awareness plays that aren't as necessarily like one-to-one with, "Hey, we need to pay this much for a conversion." 13:18 And so I think then, like, retention becomes an issue, right? So even if they, even if they're reaching out to 100 brands a month, they have like an entire cold outreach apparatus for, for outbound sales. 13:30 If you book some-- if you book one of those brands and, and expectations aren't set correctly, they might be expecting like direct one-to-one performance or like a positive return on their ad spend with the first, uh, newsletter that goes out, right? 13:45 So I, I don't, you know, I'm not necessarily- Yeah. And then they're not renewing because they don't-- those expectations are not aligned. Yeah. And then you have to do more outreach to find more people. 13:54 It becomes kind of like a, a negative spiral. Yeah. And, and I'm not ex- I'm not even like talking towards a solution with this. 14:02 I'm just saying this is the environment that we're in now where, uh, it, it seems like brands have an expectation of, uh, like performance advertising like you would find with maybe like, uh, Meta or with, with a different, uh, self-serve ad platform. 14:17 And publishers have come to expect much higher CPMs because of this big interest in newsletters, this big kind of boom that happened over the last two or s- two years or so, three years or so. 14:27 And so that's, that's the environment that we find ourselves in now, and I think an ad network like this is a step in the right direction because it kind of maybe matches expectations, uh, between the two parties, gives publishers, you know, an opportunity to find sponsors. 14:42 So yeah, I, I'm a, I'm a big fan. Yeah, and we just give people advice, like we- Yeah. 14:47 We strategize with the publishers and the advertisers, like the publisher's like, "Hey, you are charging too much," or, "You need to charge more." 14:52 Like we just tell people that, like, "This is what is working, this is what's gonna work. You either need to raise your prices or lower your prices." 14:57 We wanna work off a base of the pricing that people already are using, right? But if it's just totally-- if it's not gonna get the advertisers any results and they're not gonna renew, that's not gonna work. 15:07 You really wanna have a 50% or higher renewal rate. So after someone buys, you know, one ad or a package of ads, they at least half of them buy more ads after that. If you're not there, your pricing's probably off. 15:20 Maybe your ad, um, placement itself isn't formatted in the right way or like the placement isn't good, where it's not driving results. Or maybe your just communication expectations are really bad. 15:31 Maybe you're working with the wrong types of advertisers potentially. But you know, you, you also, you, you can't just blame the advertiser for that. 15:37 It's, it's at least 50% on you, the publisher, to get that renewal rate up. 15:42 Um, and most people are probably sitting closer to like a 20 or 30% renewal rate for, for their advertisers when they need to be 50% plus, and the best brands are at 70% plus, right? Yeah. 15:53 And that's, that's really the only way to build a great business is because you can't be just going after new people every single month and like having all these sales calls and sales emails. 16:02 Like you have to keep your business. Like it's fundamental, but like that's a lot of newsletter publishers are not doing that. They're just churning through more and more people. 16:10 You have to retain people, and so we're gonna help people do that, but it's also just good advice to hear in general. Yeah. I think that's something you learn, uh, building an agency as well. 16:20 [chuckles] I think as we both know, it's like retention is such a huge piece of the equation. On, on the topic of like ads, uh, I think this is a good, maybe a good focus just for the conversation. 16:29 It's just sponsorships and placements and, uh, and kind of the ad, I guess, ecosystem. Interesting, you know, I think takeaways from our experiments. 16:40 I'm not sure how, how many, uh, newsletters you see approaching ads this way, but most folks are, are building, uh, their ads, their sponsored placements as like separately formatted sections, right? 16:54 And I think it's, it makes it easier 'cause it's more plug and play, especially if you're running like an operation where you're, uh, churning out a lot of content and it's just easier for you to just plug in like an ad section and then run it if it's like a daily newsletter or some sort of update format newsletter like that. 17:10 I think an underutilized tactic, uh, at least just in, in the newsletters that I subscribe to and newsletters that we've worked with, is trying to incorporate the call to action more n-naturally as part of the content of the newsletter. 17:24 Because I think there's an, uh... 17:27 Our-- We've been trained just through, you know, folks who, who subscribe to newsletters, but also just people in general existing in, [chuckles] in, uh, in the world, have been trained to skip ads, right? 17:38 Just with our eyes and with our reading habits. So when you see an ad so, uh, separately, distinctly formatted from the rest of the newsletter, your, your inclination is gonna be to totally skip it. 17:50 So I think if you're somebody who's, who's starting off with sponsorships and, and maybe, maybe your first few sponsorships, uh, brands that are, that are buying placements in your newsletter, I would go the extra mile and see how natively you can incorporate, uh, their content or a link to, a link to their product or service into your newsletter and make it flow as naturally with the rest of the content as possible. 18:15 Because then-People are more likely to read it, they're more likely to see it as an actual endorsement, and they're more likely to click on it. Um, so just a tip from the testing that we've done. 18:24 I mean, like we had-- we were working with a newsletter that they were sending four times a week, um, and we took over their content for them. 18:31 Uh, and one of the, one of the big changes we made to the newsletter, uh, especially just driving to their offer, was having the CTA or like the call to their actual offer not be a separately formatted placement like that and incorporating it naturally, and it like 5X'd the number of leads that they were getting from their newsletters month over month. 18:48 So I do think that there's data to show that, and also just intuitively, I just think it works better. It definitely does. It can be a little bit tricky, but there's some people who do this well. 18:57 One, I think 1440 kind of does this sometimes. I don't know if you've read their newsletter, but they, they do a really good job of formatting. Mm. 19:07 And a lot of times they'll have like a primary ad, which is about 30 or 40% of the way through their newsletter. 19:15 And the way that they do it is the way that you should do it, where that ad section, it just looks like any other content section. 19:20 There is a sponsor disclosure and there is a logo, but it just looks like another piece of content, but it's about the advertiser. 19:27 And then oftentimes at the end of the newsletter, sometimes, not always, but they'll try and like tie in that advertiser into something and plug it again at the end. 19:35 And that maybe is a little bit more of a systematized way to do that. 19:39 For me, that might look like, like I write a deep dive every week, so I might like have the advertiser section up top, and then somewhere in my deep dive I will find somewhere to like mention the advertiser because it relates to what I'm writing about or segue to like having a, a brief call to action for the advertiser or a personal endorsement or an, a recommendation of the advertiser. 19:56 Yeah. That really goes a long way. Endorsements are powerful, and that's what advertisers want, and that's what... If you show that you really-- 20:04 this product really works, you really use it, it works for other people that you know or people that, that read your newsletter, that's gonna be way more effective. 20:11 And so I always try and do that if it's a product that I actually use and I do research on products that I haven't used before by asking my readers or asking my community what their experience with this is. 20:21 And also just talking from your personal experience, that's great, where it's like, "I use this product, here's how it worked for me," or, "I asked my readers about this, and here's what they said about it," rather than just plugging in whatever ad copy that you get. 20:32 That's gonna work a lot better. I think just going the extra mile to really be thoughtful about how you promote this, thinking like... 20:38 think like you're the owner of this product, and how would you promote it if you actually owned it? Most people just don't do that. They're just like, um, it's like copy and paste. Like- Yeah... 20:46 and that, that's just not gonna work. Yeah. And it's... they're... 20:51 you know your audience better than, or you should know your audience better than anyone, and they're, they're tuning in to, to read your words, your takes, your perspective, your style. 21:02 Uh, so I also think it's worth, if, if the advertiser's open to it, and again, this is, this, I think, will vary based on the size of your operation. 21:11 But I think it's actually very important if you're a smaller newsletter publisher and you have, uh, a- and you're wanting to, 21:17 uh, drive performance for an early sponsor, is see if they're open to you copywriting the actual placement itself. 21:24 And, and inq- e- even if it is a separate section, just having it be in your words or in your style, I think will go a lot further to drive performance. And not, not all brands are open to that either. 21:35 But, um, it, it's, I think it's just worth... Uh, this is something... I mean, at The Hustle, for example, we had a team of, of great copywriters, uh, who would actually write the ads for, for brands, right? 21:45 And it's very rare nowadays. Like, no one has that anymore. Yeah. Like, the c- Hustle had a, a full-time copywriter, Bobby. Yeah. And that was his entire job, was just to write the ads. Full-time, decent paying job. 21:56 [chuckles] I wouldn't say well-paying, this is The Hustle, right? But, um- Yeah, but- I'm sure he, he did well. Yeah. 22:01 Well, Bobby was great at what he, great at what he did, great at what he does, and I'm sure that his, uh, the c- the fact that he was writing the copy is what got these brands maybe to s- to read an ad in an addit- in an addition of The Hustle and say, "Oh, wow, this is great," like, "We should be in this," and then renew once they were already, uh, uh, customers or, or working with The Hustle. 22:23 So- He really was good, and that's... Yeah, he does like these presentations about ad copywriting. 22:27 We need to have him on to do one of those, 'cause I haven't really seen anything that level since then, and it really makes a diff- and a lot of it was his unique perspective and stories. 22:36 Like, as an employee of The Hustle, he would talk about the brand and his experience with it, and it was funny and cheeky, but it also had like the key benefits and stuff. 22:45 We had some other writers that were like trying to be like funny and cheeky, but like also didn't get to the point and didn't tell me like why this mattered, which I hated. 22:55 Um, there's like the David Ogilvy quote, it's like, "It's better to be clear than clever," and some writers miss that. So anyway, side note, but I think, I think it's important. 23:04 Also, one just stat is like 80 to 85 to 90% of the advertisers that we're talking to and that publishers tell me that they're talking to are all direct response focused, results focused. Like- Interesting... 23:16 you know, 10% is brand or other objectives, 90% is direct response. Yeah. It's, 23:23 it's, it's tough to, [chuckles] to es- I mean, I think, you know, you can get the e- economics to work, but it's definitely tough depending on the offer, right? 23:32 And I think we, we talked about this in a past episode, but I think the higher ticket the offer, the better your odds as long as you have the targeted... 23:39 as long as your, your, uh, the audience that you're going after is targeted enough, right? So if you're like an agency and you're looking to advertise in newsletters, I think that's actually a great idea. 23:48 I think agencies should advertise in newsletters more because- We were just talking to one the day who's crushing it with it. Yeah. 'Cause it's, uh- Yeah... it's, it's a great source of leads. 23:57 If you're able to find a newsletter that's just marketers at, uh, like SaaS companies, and you're a, uh, you're an agency who works with SaaS companies' marketing teams, it's like what, what better targeted audience are you gonna find? 24:10 You know, even, even using something like Facebook or so- [chuckles] it's like you're not gonna find a better opportunity, so... Facebook doesn't really work well for agencies. 24:16 Really, newsletters are way better for agencies and service business than, than Facebook is. And Google can work, but it's like crazy expensive, and those keywords are super competitive. 24:25 So it's, it's probably the best paid source for, for, for newsletters.Yeah, and I think, I mean, there's something that we've tested- For agencies. Yeah, for, for agencies. 24:34 And I think something that we've tested a lot too, um, and I think it's a great funnel is meta ads to... Sorry, that's my doorbell. Yeah. 24:43 And I was gonna mention, one thing that Ryan mentioned before was that if your ad is priced so that if the client that buys that ad is able to get just one customer from that ad, and it pays for itself or it has an ROI, 24:56 then you're in a really good position, and it makes selling much easier. 'Cause you can basically say, like, "Hey, if you-- like this is your LTV, it's $10,000 per customer. I- my ad placement right now is 3,500 bucks. 25:06 If you get one, just one client from this, you're getting an ROI." Um, or if it's higher priced, it's breakeven, right? If you get two, it's an ROI. Um, you wanna work, like really the best newsletter 25:19 advertisers are people who have an LTV, like a minimum LTV of $1,000, preferably an LTV that's in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, right? But it's usually like 1K to 100K. It's a big range, I know. 25:32 But w- you can't really sell products that are like cost hundreds of dollars or cost tens of dollars in a newsletter. That math just doesn't work out. It has to be that type of LTV. Yeah. 25:42 And I think that's, that's been a huge learning for us, like doing what we're doing at Tailwind, which is why we've started to focus more on agencies and coaches and consultancies. 25:51 I think the, uh, that funnel just works so well, where it's value-dense newsletter to those high-ticket services, and then to add an additional layer to that top of funnel, uh, something that I think we've tested a lot and seen work really well, as long as you have an understanding of your LTV, and I think that's super important to note, is, uh, like meta ads funnel to the newsletter and then do the actual selling in the newsletter. 26:15 So using some sort of a lead magnet, uh, as, uh, you know, the, the kind of v- top, top front end or the, the, the very front end, I guess, and driving folks on your email list, providing a super value-dense, uh, newsletter to them for free and doing the actual selling in that newsletter and, and getting, you know, moving leads further down the funnel using the newsletter. 26:37 So pretty-- I think it's a, it's an awesome funnel for agencies, for coaches, for consultancies. Yeah, I mean, it's kinda what I do. Um, it's basically exactly what I do. 26:46 Most of our subscribers from my newsletter now are coming from Facebook, and I think we're about like f- I'm, I'm about like 50 subscribers away from 30,000 subs. 26:55 And social has been great, but you just kinda reach, reach a cap of what's possible there. Um, and I'm not... 27:02 I'll grow a lot more from social over time, but, but paid is great because I've been able to get a great ROI on it. And then the one- I'm curious, like- Yeah. 27:09 Sorry, not to interrupt, but I'm curious, like has your-- w- do you measure like folks coming from Meta like that make it all the way to being paying clients and like how's that backed out for you? 27:21 Yes, but more on the course because we only have for our agency, for our growth services, we only have 30 clients and we've got thousands of subscribers from Meta. 27:30 I c- and it's also, it's like it's only 30, it's a small sample size, so it's like hard to even say like which ones... I can see which ones like signed up from Meta. I'm sure some of our agency clients did, most didn't. 27:41 But as far as course customers, yes. I can go and see, okay, how many course purchasers signed up from Meta Ads, for example. What was their, the value of their purchase, and what's our return on ad spend? 27:53 Yes, I can see that. And, um- Nice... you know, Meta isn't the number one source. Like there's nothing better than organic. I think actually our number one... 28:00 I think I posted about this a couple weeks ago, but like our, I think our number one source for purchases was direct traffic. 28:05 I think number two is actually Google Search, which is interesting, and I need to put more, more effort into search and SEO. And I think Meta might be number three. 28:12 And I have to do an update of that because we had a new cohort. I have to do a- another analysis after every single cohort, uh, because that's how I do my courses. Like it's, it's four times a year. 28:21 Um, we do a cohort, and I have to do an analysis after each one. But yeah, it works for me, and I also-- we're starting to sell more ads in the newsletter too. 28:30 It's not gonna be a big part of our business, but I've got, you know, three or four ads a month that I can sell that have been... Like we've had, we've had a very high renewal rate on the ads, so that's a good sign. 28:41 And then one more thing I wanted to mention was one thing people got to think about just, just to close the loop on the advertising stuff is you probably can't build a very big advertising business just selling ads in the newsletter alone. 28:55 So just the most common ad placement is called like a primary ad. It's like headline, sometimes an image, 50 to 100 words that might sell on a 50 to $100 CPM or like a five to $10 CPC backed into a flat fee. 29:10 Especially if you're not sending five to seven days per week and you don't have one to two ads in each of those issues, it's hard to build a big business on that alone. 29:18 Um, like if you're a weekly newsletter and you just have one ad per week, you're not gonna build a seven-figure business off of that. 29:24 But you can do deeper partnership integrations or, or, or custom or sponsored content that can be really interesting. So you can sell webinars, um, and promote that webinar to your audience. 29:35 Usually, you can sell a webinar for like five to 10 times what you would sell for one primary ad. So if I'm selling one of, one of my primary ads for 1,000 bucks, I can sell a webinar promotion package for $10,000. 29:47 And if I sell one of those a month, I'm gonna be in a much better position. 29:51 Um, you can sell sponsored content where you basically write a deep dive about the advertiser, publish that as a newsletter and publish that as a blog post and social media post. 29:58 You can put together custom packages based off of what your advertisers want and need, and that's really how all the most successful media companies are doing things. Like no one's just... 30:07 Like there's very few big companies that only have newsletter ads. One example of someone who does is like Fourteen40. 30:14 They have an eight-figure business with just ads in the newsletter, but that's, you know, almost a exception to the rule, right? 30:21 Most people have different types of sponsorship packages based off of their advertiser needs. I think that's a really, really important point. 30:28 Yeah, I think you, you have to, to achieve like in the aggregate what would be the CPMs that, uh, that folks maybe went into building a newsletter... uh, thinking they would, they would receive. 30:40 So like, maybe like two years ago, like these kinds of like seven, 50 to $70 CPMs. If you want to actually achieve that on your list, I think you're absolutely right. 30:47 You have to be creative with how you structure and package these, uh, these partnerships. Uh, and it could be as simple as I think the second option you gave there, was just having a dedicated email blast, right? 30:59 Like a deep dive or something that you just write. And those are always, by the way, gonna convert much, much better than a, like a, than like an inline newsletter spot, right? 31:10 Like, if you have like a present- you know, your newsletter presented by X, that is never going to convert as well as sending a dedicated email that's well-written copy and, and very natural-feeling copy that's your end- endorsement of that product and, and basically nothing else. 31:30 So having that as like a kicker or an added, like that might help you achieve the brand's goals as well. 31:37 And then to the point we were making earlier, it's like then it's renewals, it's a higher lifetime value of your relationship with that brand, so it helps everybody. So I think you're absolutely right. Packaging- Yeah... 31:47 stuff like that is, is a huge thing. And you become less transactional too, because before they see you as like, "I'm, I'm buying these ad placements in the newsletter. 31:55 I'm just looking at my cost per click, how many clicks I'm getting, how many conversions I'm getting from this." 31:59 But then if you do these deep packages, now you're like a partner, you're like a growth partner to the business, almost like an agency. And in many ways, media companies are very similar to, to advertising agencies. 32:09 There's just, the media companies have an audience, and advertising agencies buy other people's audiences. And so like, okay, now I'm a strategic partner. I'm doing webinars with them. 32:19 I'm giving them advice on, on what to say on the webinar. I'm writing content for them. They can use that content in other places of their business. 32:27 Yeah, just it's, it's a must do if you're gonna build an advertising or s- or sponsorship business. And another thing we won't talk about today is like most people should be selling something to their audience directly. 32:39 Um, whole another conversation, right? But that's a n- a no-brainer for most people out there, um, that I don't see enough of. Yeah. 32:47 I think having a, having a business that you use the newsletter to feed outside of just looking the, at the newsletter as a business unto itself, uh, I think, you know, there are definitely many, many, many examples obviously, of people who, uh, have built newsletters into very successful seven, eight-figure businesses. 33:05 But I think for someone starting off- Yeah... it's, it's gonna be helpful for you to have an offer that you can drive to or a product that you can drive to. 33:13 I think we're gonna move away from talking about this whole newsletter business thing and just talk about newsletters as a core piece of our strategy. Sure. 33:20 I don't even know if we have to even explain all these things to s- like some people, 'cause I think like the beginners like think that, "Oh, I just have a newsletter and then I have a, a massive business overnight." 33:29 But everybody else knows like this is like email newsletters are a key piece of my media or education business, and I'm not gonna monetize my entire business based off of just a ad in the newsletter alone. Um- Yeah. 33:41 Newsletter is a, it's a medium, right? It's like, it's like email marketing or it's like a YouTube channel. I, I think it's actually very different from a YouTube channel. I, I take that back. 33:51 But, uh, it's a, it's, it's a medium through which you can support your business or, or your other projects. It's a way of engaging folks. It's a way of engaging- Yeah... an audience. 34:02 Um- It's a strategy, not a business model. Exactly, yeah. Um- For, for 99% And it can, can support many different types of business models. And we could... 34:11 Yeah, we'll talk a lot about the strategy of how to do that in this podcast. 34:14 In some ways, we have to explain this stuff because like that's the name of the podcast, and like some people think it's all about newsletters when it's really not. That's just one core piece of it. 34:22 But we talk about a lot of things outside of that too, and it's gonna keep expanding as we keep talking about things on this podcast. Yeah. I, uh, we'll just be, we'll just be called The Operator soon, so. 34:34 [chuckles] Eventually. We're just gonna keep removing one letter. Um, but no, I, I like the name. But, um, one, um, you wanna segue to like one, one last topic? I think we covered everything on, on ads. That was good. 34:47 Yeah. I, uh, let's see. Well, I n- I, I think I'm, I was gonna talk a little bit about... We can save that for next time. We'll leave it on a cliffhanger. We can, we can save that for next time. Fair enough. 34:57 I think we're, we're coming up on time. Super special stuff we're about to talk about next time. You gotta stay tuned. Yeah. [chuckles] You have to subscribe. Um, 35:05 and subscribe to the YouTube channel too, because we publish most of these to, to YouTube. And, um, we also sometimes we're gonna do more change ups, like we're interviewing a lot of like ad sales people, 35:17 and then we're gonna like put that all together in like one best of video where it's like, uh, the ultimate guide to selling newsletter sponsorships, and we have like five different conversations from five different really good sellers. 35:28 So yeah, subscribe to the YouTube channel. Follow Ryan on LinkedIn and Twitter. Do you have a newsletter now, Ryan? I, I, I've been getting your emails. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Is that just Tail, Tailwind Studios? 35:38 I've been sending out newsletters to the list. Um, I'll, uh, I'll plug it in the show notes and then we can, uh, yeah, subscribe to that. It's basically just- That sounds good... 35:47 basically just newsletter tips, strategies for growing and selling to an audience. So every Thursday. Yeah. We also need to plug the reader mailbag, where people can ask us questions and we can answer it on the call. 35:59 I've plugged that like once, but I just keep forgetting to mention that. But I'll remember to put that in the episode description so people can ask us questions, and we'll answer it on the next podcast. But yeah. 36:08 All right, that's it. Also, we'll, of course, we talked about the ad network. I will link to that down below too, or you can just find that on my website, newsletteroperator.com. And that's the pod.