Transcript 0:00 Hey, everybody. Welcome back to the podcast. I am Matt, and I'm here with Gavin Bechtold, who is one of the head of enterprise partnerships at Ezoic. 0:09 And we wanted to talk today all about website traffic and monetization, something that I think is really overlooked and underutilized. 0:17 A lot of people who have a social audience, a newsletter audience, have a lot more website traffic than they realize, especially since AI and in the past five to ten years, a lot of people are just overlooking the opportunity they have with websites, with the web- website traffic they're getting already. 0:33 I certainly am. [chuckles] That's why I wanted to talk to Gavin about how to monetize that audience that we have from web traffic. 0:39 So Gavin, can you give me like a quick overview of your role at Ezoic, what the company does and what you do? Yeah, sure. So I work directly with Ezoic's largest clients and with our external business partners like you. 0:51 And also great to be here, by the way. Love being able to, to educate people here more on the value of a multi-channel world, world, right? What we're talking about today is diversifying into a, a web audience. 1:03 Ezoic, what we primarily do is we work with media operators, and I know that term is interchangeable, right? 1:09 Um, so we have publishers, which is historically what Ezoic has worked with, people who focused on content sites. 1:14 But today it's people who have video, who have newsletters, and Ezoic works with those folks to, to monetize their digital business with programmatic ads. And what are some of... 1:24 You know, I kind of discovered you through some of my clients that work with you, and people that I know that work with you, like Matt Paulson- Mm-hmm... who has MarketBeat. 1:30 They have six million newsletter subscribers, maybe ten plus, fifteen million plus website visitors per month. What types of... 1:37 And there's a lot of different types of businesses that use Ezoic, but what are maybe some, some clients that you can share that you've worked with and had success with? Yeah. 1:43 So I think in terms of the types of sites that we work with, um, we work with a very broad range of digital businesses. 1:50 Content sites are kind of the traditional one, but we've expanded a lot into digital businesses like SaaS, e-commerce, and even web apps, so like tools, calculators, things like that, where people are engaged with that, that application, and they want a way to monetize it. 2:06 But yeah, you mentioned MarketBeat is a, is a client that your audience will be familiar with who will also be at the, the upcoming New Media Summit, is 6am City. 2:14 Outside of that, some notable names would be like Guinness Book of World Records is another site, and, uh, uh, the LPGA, so, so women's golf. Cool. Yeah. 2:24 And so we'll talk mostly about content businesses, but like if you have website traffic of, of any type, whether you're a gaming website, calculator, speed testing, whatever it might be, a lo- a lot of those sites use Ezoic too. 2:36 Let's get into the, like the main topic. To get into that, I wanna like cover some myths, but I wanna just kinda lay the groundwork first. A lot of people who listen to this are newsletter first or newsletter focused. 2:47 Why should they care about website as a revenue channel? Yeah, that's a great question. So if you go back like five to ten years, this was when an era when you might have heard the term niche sites. 2:57 People who were niche site operators, they would grow a site pretty quickly, and they could rank on Google, this was before LLMs and things like that, and get traffic rather easily. 3:07 And what this created was a lot of creators creating a broad range of websites, some of them low value, and it, it was really a race for ad dollars. 3:15 So what ended up happening was they would put a lot of ads on these sites, making them not the best for the user experience. And what this kinda led to overall is really a race to the bottom. 3:26 But when you shift to today, you see with LLMs and AI overviews dominating Google, really the, the big brands are at the top, and when you look at those sites, you'll see a more thoughtful or curated ad experience. Yeah. 3:39 I haven't thought about niche sites in a while, but the, I mean, that was big, and I used to lot-- see a lot more of those in Google Search results on every topic from gardening to business stuff to more. 3:49 And like a lot of them didn't really build strong brands or, or great content, and they packed with ads, and they packed things with affiliate links. 3:56 And it, it would be like one person or one company operating, you know, dozens of these websites. Yeah. It's like the, uh... Have you ever been to one of those, those recipe sites? 4:05 Those are probably the best example when, uh, you're at home trying to cook something and, uh, read that recipe, and you have a, a pop-up that, that obstructs the, the recipe and the instructions to get that done. 4:15 Yeah, that's a classic example. But a lot of people are doing something much, much different than that, especially a lot of Ezoic clients, and we'll get into that in a second. 4:23 Do you wanna get into why should they care about their website, care about that as a revenue channel? Yeah, definitely. 4:29 It's, it's funny because media operators used to be kinda website first, but it's shifted today where they're becoming more newsletter first. 4:38 But I think one of the things that people forget about websites is a website builds trust. If I subscribe to a newsletter, how many times do you buy something directly within that newsletter? 4:48 I know it definitely happens, but oftentimes I feel like I wanna click a link in that email to go to the authoritative site to build some trust, to build some credibility, perhaps read some reviews if you're selling a service or a product, and I wanna do that before I buy that. 5:03 So I think a website builds trust, it helps defend against competition, and then it also introduces new revenue sources. 5:11 Yeah, I really do think, and I'm, I'm guilty of this, that people have just, because email is a trend right now, and a trend for a good reason, they've overlooked their website in, in many ways, not including just like ad revenue, but just like lacking about pages, lacking review pages, case studies, like everything. 5:27 They don't realize people, like when they-- Before they buy something, like they said, they go to the landing page, but they're also gonna go to your homepage, click around, look at every page. 5:33 They're gonna search you on Google, you know, look at reviews, look at other stuff about the service before they make the transaction, the purchase decision. Okay. 5:41 What can you do with a website that you simply just can't do with a newsletter? Yeah. It's a good question. So with a website and a newsletter, I think you can do a lot of similar things, right? 5:50 They, they have similar monetization models. You can do direct sponsors in both newsletter and website. You can sell a product, you can sell a course, you can sell something with an affiliate link. 6:00 But there hasn't really been an effective programmatic solution in newsletters. 6:04 What you can do is if you're driving traffic or if you're driving users from your newsletter to your website, that gives you the opportunity to add that display ad or programmatic revenue on top of that. Yeah. 6:16 That's, that's a good point. A lot of people don't, don't realize that about newsletters. 6:18 The more advanced people here too.Do realize that, but like there's not a Ezoic or a Google AdSense or a, a YouTube ad network for email that where you can almost automatically monetize, which, which is a really special thing that you can do with websites and maybe one or two other things. 6:35 That's about it. That doesn't really exist in email. 6:36 You have to sell something, your own product through email, or you have to sell direct sold ads, which is really challenging for a lot of reasons, and not even a great business model for everybody. 6:45 And websites have that. 6:47 Another thing I forgot to mention about why a website's important that we didn't cover from the previous topic was that if someone's reading your newsletter content on a regular basis, they wanna have like a go-to place to look at all of your content, your previous content, newsletters they've read before, content they forgot about. 7:04 And if you don't have a great website experience and blog and content experience to do that, you're missing out on people building a deeper relationship with you, and also you monetizing them more. 7:14 I, I overlook this a lot, that's why I'm talking to you. 7:16 But like even just by publishing my newsletters as blog posts, we're still getting a, a meaningful amount of traffic just by whether it's from the newsletter, somebody even clicking like the view online link at the very top of the newsletter, or just searching it and like reading the content there because the inbox is not a good place for that. 7:31 Like people will read a newsletter when they receive it, they'll archive it, but they're not revisiting content or going back to old content in email. They do that on your website. Yeah, no, it's, it's a good point. 7:40 And, and I think one of the things that, that newsletter operators can do is they can think about intentionally driving visitors in their newsletter to their website, 'cause I think that's, that's something else that oftentimes is overlooked, and they're really simple, like a, a read more button. 7:54 You can do a roundup of stories, and they can all link back to your website, and that's something that's going to get more eyeballs on your site. 8:01 And then again, it gives them-- gives you that opportunity, opportunity to monetize those users who visit your site. 8:07 But, but it really increases the lifetime value of users, uh, because you're opening up a new monetization channel that didn't exist previously. Yeah. Why don't we, um, we'll come back to the lifetime. 8:17 Well, actually, let's do, let's do that now. Let's address that now 'cause this is a really interesting thing you talked to me about earlier. 8:22 How does having a well-monetized website affect the lifetime value of a newsletter subscriber? Yeah. So it, it does it in a, a couple of ways. 8:30 We touched on it a little bit already, but kind of a- about building that, that trust and that credibility. 8:35 So someone's going to buy something from you, and your programmatic ads aside, if you have a service or a course or something like that, people wanna read more about it, and that can help improve conversions for you. 8:45 But then the second thing that it does is you can also serve programmatic ads alongside your content or in unobtrusive locations on the site. And what that allows is you can earn a certain value or a certain... 8:59 In our business, it's called RPM, so it's revenue per, per thousand page views. 9:03 Depending upon how much traffic you're g- you're getting to your site, those figures can be very meaningful, and then you can use that to increase the lifetime value, value of a subscriber, reinvest it back into your business, do a bunch of different meaningful things with that money. 9:15 Yeah. And that becomes really impactful, especially as your audience grows. And we'll talk about, you know, RPMs and maybe exact like a ballpark of what people could earn later. 9:23 If you're, if you're even just getting 1% of your newsletter opens to your website and just excluding like any products that you have or services that you sell, and we're just talking about, you know, sponsorship and ad monetization. 9:35 Mm-hmm. You have ads in the newsletter to monetize that subscriber, and when they click and go to your website, you have programmatics, programmatic ads there to monetize them too. 9:42 So you're kinda getting this double whammy that can increase the subscriber LTV a lot. And I haven't really heard that talked about, so I want-- I'm glad we covered it here. 9:49 What type of, um, you know, revenue opportunity do you think people are leaving on the table by just not having any website monetization in place or just not investing time into this? Yeah. 10:00 It's, it's pretty massive, actually. And, uh, I have a couple of good examples that I think kinda help, help illustrate this. So there are two, two large businesses, the first one being, being Duolingo. 10:10 Duolingo is the modern language learning platform. They have a website, they have a web app. And I was looking at their financials, and about 8% of their revenue is from ad revenue. 10:21 That percentage may sound small, but this business does $750 million a year. So when you break that down to, to 8% of revenue being from ads, actually $60 million per year. Same thing with, with Netflix. 10:34 Netflix does about $1.5 billion a year from, from advertising alone, and that's only about 3% to 4% of their business, which is a $42 billion a year business. 10:44 If that helps conceptualize it, you know, we work with multiple million dollar a year businesses. You can end up making six figures per month or per year from programmatic ad revenue alone. Yeah. 10:54 And, and Matt Paulson, I for- he shared these numbers before, but I unfortunately I forget them. 10:58 He's largely a business that they sell things via email, kind of performance marketing type things, and they'll sell these paid newsletters and get commissions on them. 11:06 They also have their own subscription business, kind of like a Duolingo or Netflix, but in a very different category. 11:11 But s- even then, still a, a large chunk of his revenue, and, you know, it's not like 50%, but it's a meaningful chunk, comes from- Mm-hmm... website programmatic. 11:19 It's a very high margin revenue that doesn't require a lot of team time or resourcesFrom a business owner's perspective, right? 11:25 It's like you set this up, you work with Ezoic or whoever you might work with, and like you're not delivering a product or service. There's not really cost of goods sold, or if there are, it's very little. 11:34 It's almost automatic revenue. Yeah, you're exactly right. Programmatic ads are, are bought and sold automatically, so the advertisers bid on it in real time, and then, and then you get paid out. 11:44 It's really low lift where even if you're doing direct sponsorships, like if you're selling, uh, an ad in your newsletter or on your website, may-maybe you're a local newsletter or local news site, you work with a lot of local businesses, but that requires you as the individual or, or maybe you have a sales team or a sales rep that is going out there and, and trying to secure those deals. 12:03 So that comes with time, that comes with expenses. There's a lot of overhead there. But programmatic is, as you mentioned, automatic and kinda just hums along in the background. Yeah. 12:12 And that's what's so, so cool about it. 12:14 It's like for a lot of people, it's not gonna be fifty percent of their revenue, but adding two, five, ten percent of revenue that didn't exist before, and it's automatic is, is a huge impact to any business, and it could be more for some people. 12:25 I wanna get into like the-- our myth-busting portion of this. Is there anything people should understand before we get into that? Like we're gonna talk about first-party data. We might wanna define that. 12:35 I think people understand what programmatic ads are. We talked about the difference between direct sold, which is like you doing all the manual service work, and programmatic is, is automatic. Yeah. 12:44 I think one term that would be important to define before we dive into that is first-party data, and I think this is really relevant, especially for your audience, who are a lot of newsletter operators. 12:53 So first-party data is basically any data that is identifiable, so that's things like an email, which you already gather from your newsletter list. 13:01 It is a phone number, which you might be gathering if you're doing anything with a-an SMS list, and then basic things like a name. But, but email and phone number at their... is what it is at-- in its simplest form. 13:12 And identified users are really important in our space because they produce about two to three times more revenue from programmatic from a non-identified user. 13:22 And non-identified user would be someone arriving from Google Search or even an LLM or social. So that's, that's a pretty big difference. 13:30 And the reason that that advertisers pay more is because this data is what we call it's deterministic, meaning the advertiser knows more about that user, and they're willing to pay a premium for that. Yeah. 13:43 That's an important thing to note. 13:44 It's like if you have this first-party data, which most people here have an email list, at least some people have, have phone numbers too, you can make more money from programmatic ads for the reasons that we'll get into later. 13:53 We won't explain all that now. Yeah. But, um, I didn't know about this until about a year or so ago when, when you and your team told me. It's really powerful. 14:00 And then one final thing I wanna mention, and it's hard to get like the exact numbers on this because it really varies a lot by industry and site, is like RPMs. Like what should people expect? 14:09 And it's gonna be different if you're like a gardening site versus a financial news site. Mm-hmm. Um, and it's gonna be different based off of how many ads you choose to place on your pages. 14:18 But like if someone has no i-- like they've never done programmatic ads before on their site, what type of RPM should they expect? Yeah. It's, uh... 14:25 We get that question all the time, but the, the truth is it's, it's really difficult to answer because of all those factors that you mentioned. 14:33 The audience and the demographics play into that a ton, like what location they're coming from. Are they from the US? Are they from India? Ultimately, how many ads do you wanna have on the page? 14:42 And then do you have any of that first-party data available? And then another factor is how engaged are the users on your site? 14:48 Are they spending minutes reading about a topic, or are they just getting something quick and leaving? So the RPMs can vary ve-very broadly. 14:56 We've seen them as high as six hundred dollars, but more of an average would probably be like in the, the fifty to a hundred dollar range. That's higher than a lot-- than a lot of people think, and that I thought too. 15:07 With that RPM, is that-- that's inclusive of multiple ads on a page, right? I'm assuming you wouldn't get a fi-- forty or fifty dollar RPM if you just have one ad on the page. You might need two, three, et cetera. Yeah. 15:17 You would need more than one in most cases. I would say three is like a good benchmark to start with, especially if you, if you haven't had ads on your site before. There's different formats that you can, can also use. 15:29 There's video, um, you may have seen some of the, uh, they call them anchor units, but it's kind of like an adhesion unit that, that sticks to the bottom of the page. Yep. And those perform really well. 15:39 Yeah, I think a lot of people have seen those, kind of like a sticky bottom ad that, like, that can be, um, minimized too. 15:44 The reason I mention that is because I don't want people to think, "Hey, if I put like one little ad in the corner of my website where no one can see it, I'm gonna make forty or fifty dollars per one thousand visitors." 15:53 Like you need to have a- Yeah... 15:55 a smart strategy, and that's what-- that's one of the things you help people do is like where to place ads, how many to have, how to maximize user experience and revenue at the same time, and maybe we'll get into some of that. 16:04 But it's a lot... I mean, a lot of people are kind of lucky to sell a direct sold ad in their newsletter at a, uh, forty or fifty dollar RPM or CPM. 16:13 Sometimes in the newsletter we'll use the term CPM, even though RPM's more accurate even for email. Not to mention, like that's direct sold. You had to like close the person. 16:22 If you have a salesperson, you gotta give them a commission, you have to write the copy, you have to sh-share a report with the advertiser. There's so much more work involved. 16:29 What I'm trying to say is the RPMs on web traffic are a lot higher than people realize, depending on the type of audience engagement and industry that you're in. Mm-hmm. 16:36 Anyways, let's get into the myth-busting part because my objective was this-- with this is like I have all these misconceptions about website traffic and monetization. 16:44 I know a lot of people do that I-- do too that I talk to. So let's try and bust some of these myths that people had. 16:50 And the first is kinda what we were talking about, which is like everybody worries that ads are gonna like clutter my website, hurt my user experience, my visitors are gonna leave and never come back because I have an ad on my website or my blog. 17:01 Can you kind of a-address that, that worry? Yeah, absolutely. It all comes down to control at the end of the day because you as the operator of your site, you can control the ad experience. 17:10 And I think a, a better way to think about it is, is bad ad strategy is cluttered, but ads aren't clutter themselves. And ads don't have to dominate the experien-experience. They can be designed to respect it. 17:22 You can blend it in with the content. You can also show ads to free users versus paid users, so that's something that I think your audience may not realize. 17:30 If you have a paid or premium subscriber channel, you don't have to show ads to them. Um, so it's not like you have to show ads to, to all types of users. 17:37 But at the end of the, end of the day, I think most audiences aren't anti-ads. They are anti bad experiences. Yeah, like disruptive ads that block a reading experience, especially on, on mobile, right? 17:49 But like when you talk to people who have this concern, is there anything like you recommend? 17:54 Like assuming they have a typical content, you know, blog style, article style site, like what types of ad formats to use, how many ads per page to start with, or just anything likeGeneral best practices that you tell people when they're getting started One of the things that we look at is, is something called ad density. 18:09 And what this does, it measures and it balances the ads on the page with the content. So you want to achieve an ad density that, that isn't obstructive to the viewing experience. 18:19 And we actually have tons of cases where the ad density goes down when they begin using Ezoic, and they actually m- make more ad revenue. And th- that example is if they were coming over from another ad network. 18:31 Obviously, if you're coming over and you haven't used any ads at all, it's all going to be a net positive. Yeah. That's interesting. 18:36 One related to that question is people are worried ads aren't relevant to their audience. Like, they think people are gonna get served, like, random irrelevant ads- Mm-hmm... 18:44 to their readers, or maybe even stuff that's, like, adult content or something like a lingerie ad, and they don't want that on their blog, for example. You know, how do you handle that? Yeah. 18:52 So I think one thing to point out first is ads are actually more relevant than I think they've ever been, and a lot of that is related to first-party data. 18:59 Because when that's available, and you have that newsletter list, and you can pass that subscriber information along, which is all done privately, um, but that gives a lot more information to the advertisers, so they can match up an ad that's relevant to that user. 19:11 And we've seen this a lot with, with retargeted ads over the years. So, you know, on a site and you're shopping for Nike shoes, you can get an ad for, for Nike while you're visiting that site. 19:22 Now, that's highly relevant to the user. Maybe as the owner of the site, you may not think that's relevant to your content. So I think that's something to distinguish. 19:31 But if you want more control there, something that, that modern ad platforms can do is, let's say you have a site about finance, and you only want contextually financial related ads to show, that's something that can be achieved. 19:44 In addition to that, yeah, there are a lot of restrictions available today, if you wanna block certain ad categories, something that maybe won't appeal to your audience, or if you wanna block a specific advertiser that may be a competitor to what you do. 19:57 So there's a lot of different tools that you can use to truly clean up the experience and make the ads more relevant. That's cool. 20:04 But I think a lot of people assume, like, you put them on there, and it's like, whatever shows, shows, and I have no control, but that's s- that's not the case. 20:10 There's a narrative that digital programmatic advertising, like, those budgets are shrinking, and maybe it's not worth investing into because, like, the budgets are getting smaller, so why even spend any time on this? 20:21 What are you actually seeing as far as programmatic budgets? Yeah. Well, generally, advertising has been around for centuries, so it's... that's a form of advertising or marketing that's not going away. 20:31 I was actually just, just looking at something, kind of a side note. The ad spots for the Super Bowl are, are selling for $233,000 per second this year. So there's a lot of, lot of revenue in this area. 20:44 But when it comes to, to Ezoic, what we're seeing in the programmatic world is advertisers are consolidate- consolidating around quality inventory and first-party data. 20:55 So one of the things that, that we did in a, a study at the end of the year, we saw that total identified revenue, so again, that first-party data, that was six times higher with our clients in 2025 versus 2024. Really? 21:08 So let me make sure I understand that. 21:09 If they had the identifil- identifiable audience through first-party data, like email or phone number, that revenue grew 6X year over year, and that's really showing that- The, the amount of- Mm-hmm. 21:20 Yeah, the amount of revenue being allotted, excuse me, being allotted- Okay... to people who, who have first-party data available. 21:26 So it shows that on the creator side, creators are also being mindful and saying, "Let me go out and, and collect some of this first-party data if I don't already have that. 21:34 If I don't have a newsletter list, let me start one," because we're seeing this shift towards advertisers putting more dollars into first-party data. Yeah. 21:44 So it sounds like if you have first-party data, uh, like an email list, and you're also focused on growing that, you have the opportunity to take advantage of some growing budgets in that area. 21:53 And if you don't, which is kind of rare for, for our audience, you should start building that, so you can better effectively m- monetize everything, your website and, and your newsletter can be monetized too. Yeah. 22:02 That's one of the reasons your audience is already in, in such a great place because they have the lists, whether it's email or phone number. It's just a matter of really leveraging that to your advantage. Yeah. 22:13 It's still underlooked by everybody, I feel, but we do have some good people who listen to this that have some, some great email lists and newsletters. 22:19 What scale does advertising-- website advertising become an actual meaningful revenue stream? I think people think it's like a nice to have source of income, so they kind of just ignore it. Mm-hmm. 22:29 What, what types of numbers should publishers expect? 22:31 We talked about RPMs a little bit, but maybe if you wanna give another example, or maybe if you take someone who has, like, a site who gets, you know, an average of 100,000 monthly visitors. Yeah. 22:40 Well, well, I think it's more than a nice to have, um, because kinda going back to that, that Netflix and Duolingo model, they're bringing significant revenue per year, and w- we have loads of media operators that are doing millions of dollars of ad revenue per year. 22:52 When you wanna think about when it becomes meaningful, if you're just starting out, and you have a small list or a small website following, the revenue isn't going to be that significant or move the needle that much. 23:02 Sure, it can be exciting to see, hey, I'm making some, some revenue from my audience, but if you're a larger media operator, then it really doesn't become, I would say, around 250,000 visitors per month, then it becomes, uh, a contributor to your business. 23:16 Got it. A lot of people think that they can just monetize, like, their, their content, so meaning blogs, articles, stuff like that. 23:24 Can monetization only work for traditional blogs or articles, or can you do it for other things too? Like, we talked about tools and calculators. 23:31 Maybe if you have some other examples of, like, utility driven pages that are not just about content and how people are monetizing those. Yeah. 23:37 Utility driven pages are great, so anything from a calculator to even a quiz or a game. 23:44 So for example, was talking to, to Ryan over at 6am City, and, you know, they do a lot of local news reporting, but they also have a section of their site that is really driven around games. 23:56 So people go to their site, and they, they play these games, and they're usually playing the game and engaging with the content for several minutes at a time. 24:03 So there's an opportunity to, to put an ad around the game and, and make some revenue from that. Another one is, like, Morning Brew. 24:10 They have a quiz or some type of trivia in pretty much every newsletterAlmost every single day. 24:15 And like, if you have the trivia question in the newsletter and then the answer on the website, that's like a repeatable utility type page that can be monetized from your newsletter traffic, you know, on, on a daily basis and over the long run, that can drive a lot of traffic. 24:28 Did you have another example, or did I interrupt? Yeah, that-- So a separate example would be, um, just, just diving into the, to the e-commerce space. 24:36 We've also seen examples where sure, you are largely selling a product. You have ads down the side or at the bottom of the page. Best Buy, they're, they're all good examples of that. 24:46 It's another way to, to bring extra revenue into your business. 24:50 I think kinda like a, an interesting analogy to think about if you're kind of deciding whether or not you wanna introduce ads to your site is if, if you're a large media operator, I think rejecting ads entirely might be kind of like, let's say you're a upscale restaurant and you're, you're refusing tips on, on principle, but the reality is customers are already conditioned or to tip, and they accept that as part of the model. 25:15 So when you think about it like that, the restaurant isn't necessarily being more premium. It's just choosing not to collect revenue that, that doesn't really change their, their dining experience. 25:24 Yeah, like people don't really notice these types of ads unless they are so poorly designed, and if you have a strategic experience, you're not gonna have that problem. 25:33 Like, you think of like the most prestigious media companies, New York Times, they have programmatic ad website ads on, on pretty much every page. 25:40 Another like utility driven pages, uh, I think these are just smart, is you can monetize them with programmatic, but also they bring more traffic, and they can bring more leads. 25:48 Like, if a lot of marketers who listen to this have seen websites like swipe.co or swipefile.com or like reallygoodemails.com, where it's just like cool examples, and you can filter by category. 25:59 I don't know if there's a term for these, like, but they're, they're utility pages. 26:03 You know, building something like that for your business or your audience is smart not only to attract the traffic and the leads, but also you can monetize that traffic and leads automatically with programmatic. 26:12 Have you ever seen someone put ads on their unsubscribe page for their newsletter [chuckles]? Yeah, I have. Uh, actually, Matt Poulsen does that and does pretty well. 26:19 I was literally gonna say I, I, I guess-- I'm gonna guess Matt Poulsen does that because he optimizes every inch of everything. I haven't actually looked at his unsubscribe page. I'm still subscribed, Matt. Yeah. 26:28 [chuckles] Um, yeah. A lot of- But- If you have a big list, you're gonna get a lot of traffic to that page over time. Yeah. 26:34 I think the, the subscriber take is interesting though, especially if you deal with a lot of people in your space that, that they have a newsletter and people come over to the site, and maybe there's a free reading experience and then a premium or a paid reading experience. 26:50 I think one of the things that people may not realize, but ninety-five percent of users usually don't end up converting, um, whether that be to a paid plan or, or buying something on your site. 27:00 Obviously, that's gonna vary based on your business. When you have a model like that, you're, you're catering towards that five percent or that small percent of users who you think or hope will convert. 27:10 What ads can actually do is they can monetize the users who, who will never pay anyway, so you can kinda take care of those, those freeloaders. 27:19 But then it also gives a clear upgrade path because then you can put it, put it in a prompt and incentivize somebody to remove ads from the free experience. 27:27 They can upgrade and pay for that, that premium ad-free experience in addition to any other features or things that you might offer. Yeah. 27:35 A-another thing related to that is people are concerned that ads may detract or reduce their conversion rate to a paid subscription, a digital product, a course. 27:44 So if I'm someone selling something like that to my audience, are ads gonna cannali- like cannibalize or reduce my conversions? What do you think about that? Yeah. So again, ev-everything has to be done thoughtfully. 27:53 Like to your question about do you wanna put ads on the right next to the subscribe button, probably not. But if you put it in a thoughtful place on the page, then that can actually... 28:02 A, it's not, it's not going to hurt conversions. A-and I-I've gone back to Duolingo a couple times in this conversation. 28:09 Their conversion rate in two thousand and twenty was about four percent for people converting from their free plan to their paid plans. 28:15 But in two thousand and twenty-five, their conversion rate was actually eight percent. 28:19 And during that timeframe, they actually introduced ads on the site, and that was one of the drivers that, that caused people to, to upgrade to that, that premium ad-free experience. That's interesting. 28:30 Yeah, that makes total sense. I didn't realize that. Now let's go back to first party data. There's a concern like, 'cause we didn't totally explain it. 28:37 I don't think people totally understand how it works and how, how exactly you're going to monetize your website through your email list first party data. 28:45 But people are worried about like sharing that audience data with ad platforms might compromise user privacy. You know, they don't wanna share email addresses that have subscribed. 28:55 How does first party data in this context actually work, and what are like the protections in place, so not, I'm not, I'm not just sharing all my emails with, with anybody? Yeah. 29:04 Yeah, it's a good question, um, and, and something that, that people should have a concern about because your newsletter list is one of the most valuable things that you can have, and you don't wanna give that away. 29:14 But how it works in this ecosystem is the email addresses, they're all encrypted or hashed. So the best way to kinda think about it, it's like a key going into a lock. 29:23 As the newsletter operator, you have the key, you have the, the email, um, and then on the other side, the advertiser, they have a unique lock for that key to where the information is passed, and they can unlock that and match the user on both sides of the, the system. 29:38 Yeah, and that's just-- I'm glad you explained that because you're not just sending someone a CSV file of all of your email addresses. Like, it's... 29:45 I know this might sound complicated to people who haven't done it before, but it's very simple to do this, to do this- Yeah... 29:48 process, so you can share it with Ezoic or whoever and not actually reveal the email addresses. Yeah, exactly. 29:54 It, it's not identifiable, and then we have a team completely dedicated to compliance and privacy, so it's something that folks shouldn't have to worry about. Yeah. 30:02 And then let's talk a little bit more about like the mechanism in which like this, this first party data is used. So you can make a lot more when you have someone on your site who you have first party data on. 30:13 Do you only make that additional revenue when that traffic like comes from your newsletter, like they're clicking links in your newsletter, then going to your website? 30:19 Like, what if they are on your email list and they visit your website directly?Or they visit it from Google Search or from social. Like- Mm-hmm... do you make more from that user in that context? Just how does that work? 30:31 Yeah. So there's kinda two buckets. So we've talked about identified and non-identified users. 30:35 It, it would be interesting actually if I can share a, some data or a screenshot with you that maybe you can throw up in the, in the notes or, or during our- Yeah... our conversation. Sure. 30:43 Afterwards, we'll put it on screen. The RPM for an identified user coming from an, a newsletter or from SMS, so you can see that RPM clearly versus a non-identified user. 30:54 So you'll see the, the difference or the improvement there. 30:56 One of the things that happens when you have a certain level of identified data, and, and this is in comparison to having no identified data, what will happen is an advertiser will recognize that, okay, maybe 50% of your audience is identified. 31:12 They're coming from text or email. 31:14 They'll pay a premium for those, those users that are coming directly from a newsletter, but they will also pay a little bit more for a user that might arrive from search because they're making the assumption that the rest of your audience is similar to the audience that they already know about and are paying more for already. 31:31 Okay. So they're making that assumption. So you're still getting paid a little bit more because you have so much identifiable traffic, but you're making the most money when the traffic is from email or SMS. 31:42 I was wondering, like, if you have someone who's, like, signed up for your newsletter, and they just happen to, like, go directly to the website a day later or come- Mm-hmm... 31:49 directly from Google Search a day later, if that, if that is trackable through, like, a cookie or through something else. Of course, if they're logged in, you'll think they're a logged-in user. Mm-hmm. 31:59 Then you have that first-party data, but not everybody who listens to this has, like, a registration and login membership function on their content sites. Yeah. Some people do, some people don't. Yeah. 32:09 Yeah, the login is a, is another easy way to, to capture that data. 32:13 You brought up a good point because if you don't have your own built-out login functionality on the site, an easy way to do that is something called Google One Tap or, or Google Single Sign On. 32:24 You probably see it a lot when you go to websites, kind of the, the Google Sign On pops up, and it automatically pulls in your Gmail address. 32:32 Um, but you can actually use something like that to, to pass along that first-party data as well if you don't have the, the resources or the development to, to build out a login functionality on your own. Yeah. 32:42 Publishers, almost everybody's moving towards-- Obviously, they're moving towards newsletters and SMS, but they're also moving towards getting people to register and create an account on the site, whether it's through Google One Tap or through their own membership system they built, and not necessarily pay for a membership or a subscription right away, but just get them logged in. 32:58 Like, maybe you get three articles for free, but then after that, you have to create an account. And then maybe you have 10 articles for free that month, but after 10, you gotta pay for the subscription. It's just- Yeah. 33:08 No-... there's so much valuable in a registered user. Yeah. Another cool thing going on right now is, have you heard of reward ads? Not really. May- I don't know. 33:16 Maybe, but I don't know if I'm really into the same thing. Let me know. Yeah. So ju- just speaking about making a user or, or only allowing a user to access three articles for free made me think of this. 33:26 Instead of having a model where you make people pay or subscribe to gain access to another article, what you could do is you could have them... And this could be an option, too. You could have all these options. 33:38 But you could say, "Hey, click, click this button, watch an ad, and then you'll get access to another article or another three articles." 33:44 What that does is it prompts the user to, to watch an ad, and then in exchange, they get access to something, whether that be additional articles, more credits, something like that. 33:53 I haven't seen them in the context of content sites and blogs and articles. 33:58 Of course, I've seen it in, in the gaming context, especially mobile gaming, somewhat common, but also on, you know, like, webpages where you can play games or do quizzes or whatever. But that's cool. 34:07 I just haven't, haven't seen that yet. Is that- Yeah... something you've helped people do with Ezoic? Yeah. 34:11 So traditionally, it was something that happened a lot in games and apps, but it's becoming more common on, on the web experience, and it is something publishers or media operators are, are doing now if they have-- You can call it premium content, or you can just call it, uh, if users wanna get access to something, um, that they're willing to sit through an ad and watch. 34:29 Kinda like if you're on YouTube, and you wanna get to the next segment of that video, you have to watch a short ad. Um, it's the same concept. Yeah. I like that. 34:37 And I think a lot of people, like, memberships or paid subscriptions can be good for some businesses, but they're not for everybody. 34:42 A lot of times, you're better off having people register after a couple articles and unlock more articles through, through a mechanism like this, where you unlock revenue from everybody who does that versus getting a tiny amount to be a paid subscriber. 34:54 And then a lot of these content subscriptions have really high churn, and a lot of times, you're better off with, like, an ad-supported model and maybe just that or maybe a one-off product along with that ad-supported model. 35:05 There's one more concern that I want us to address, which is surprisingly common. People feel like keeping users in my newsletter is better s- better than sending them to a website. 35:14 Like, they hesitate to ask people to click something in the newsletter because they just wanna, like, give them everything in the email and not ever ask them to click anything. Is that- Mm-hmm... a mistake? 35:25 What do you think about that? 35:26 Yeah, well, I think it kinda goes back to how we started the conversation, but if you're keeping people in a newsletter or you're newsletter only, you're missing out on, on an opportunity to, to build trust, credibility, build authority, and then you're also missing out on a opportunity to open up a new revenue source that's ad-supported on your website. 35:45 Yeah, and it's just-- I think just overlooking how people use the internet and read content. Like, people read long-form content on websites. People wanna get out of the inbox pretty quickly. 35:55 They don't wanna be- Okay [chuckles]... in their inbox for an hour at a time reading stuff. It's generally better to have a shorter newsletter. 36:01 I'm a believer that there should still be value in the newsletter without having to click something. So, like, everything shouldn't be clickable to, to get some type of editorial value or content value. 36:11 But, um, if you're not optimizing your newsletter for clicks, especially clicks that go to your website-Uh, that's a, that's a really bad newsletter strategy, in my opinion. Yeah. 36:19 It's all about finding your balance, right? Absolutely. If someone wants to learn more about Ezoic, website traffic monetization, who's a good fit for that? 36:26 Because if you have, if you have two visitors per month, Ezoic's probably not for you. But, like, what type of p- clients and publishers and companies do you work with? Yeah. 36:33 So I think anyone who has a, a meaningful amount of, of website traffic or a subscriber list, about two hundred and fifty thousand visitors per month or subscribers on your list, because with that size of a subscriber list, if you're not actually using it yet to, to drive traffic to your website, then you can actually begin doing that and, and begin generating significant revenue pretty quickly. 36:55 Those would be the, the metrics in terms of the size of the audience. And then, uh, yeah, it doesn't just have to be a content site, it can be those, those web apps or those tools, um, or SaaS businesses. 37:07 Anything like that would be a good fit as long- Yeah... as you meet those traffic requirements. Any, like, final advice or closing thoughts for publishers, founders who are skeptical about website monetization? 37:18 Or just any closing thoughts in general that you think people should know or, or things that we didn't cover? Yeah. 37:23 I think just to kinda wrap it up, I would say that the question isn't whether ads belong in a modern media business, it's whether you're using them intentionally or, or are you leaving money, data, and that leverage on the table. 37:37 Yeah. 37:38 And some of my takeaways from this were, if you don't prioritize your website and website traffic at all, you're leaving a lot on the table, both as far as revenue and user experience and, and the deeper relationship that you can build with an audience. 37:50 And then number two, if you do use programmatic website ads already or maybe direct sell website ads, and you're not using first-party data to increase how much you're making your RPM with Ezoic, you're missing out on a lot of money. 38:02 So [chuckles] I think that's, that's, um... Those are some of my takeaways among many. Yeah. No, that's a good summary. 38:07 I appreciate that, and, uh, it was really a pleasure talking to you and trying to get more information about this opportunity out there. Yeah. This was great. 38:15 I, I l- honestly learn a lot every time I talk to you, and, uh, learned a lot more from this today, and I hope it helps people understand, like, the, the channel, the biggest channel they're probably missing out on. 38:24 I think we did a good job with that. And we'll put your LinkedIn below. We'll, we'll wrap it up there. Thanks. Awesome. And we will see you at the New Media Summit later this month. Yeah. I'll see you soon.