Transcript 0:00 [on-hold music] All righty. Chris, welcome to the podcast. Hey, excited to be here. Thanks for doing this. Cool. 0:09 Well, this is gonna be a little bit different because you started your, your newsletter, your media company recently, but you have a lot of background experience before that. 0:17 We'll get into all of it, but just to give people context, can we just start with, you know, what's the name of your newsletter or media company? When did you start it? 0:26 You know, what's the audience size you have now, and how much revenue has it generated so far? Yeah, great. Started a little, little over four weeks ago. 0:33 It's called The Path Less Traveled, uh, really focused on our journey, uh, building and operating an independent business in a, in a landscape that's really dominated by private equity and by consolidators. 0:44 Uh, have about four thousand, just a hair under four thousand s- uh, subs today, about thirty-nine fifty. 0:49 Uh, and then sponsorship revenue in June, I, I signed a bunch of twelve months contracts on June first, which was wild. 0:55 Uh, but I have fixed, uh, monthly fees of twenty thousand five hundred per month, uh, locked in, and then I have some performance-based contracts, uh, that have produced eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars so far with, uh, with actually about another sixty thousand pending, depending on the timing of some of these, uh, some of these relationships that might close with sponsors. 1:14 Awesome. Okay, we're gonna break down all that soon. 1:17 Um, and I wanna talk about your background because it's, it's obviously super relevant to the content that you write, but just tell us a little bit more about, okay, who's the ideal reader for The Path Less Traveled, for the newsletter, and, like, what, what type of stuff do you share with them? 1:28 What are you publishing every single week? Yeah. Great. So, you know, context for us is I, I recently started focusing on how to become acquisitive in our core business, right? We have a, a family of home service brands. 1:38 Uh, and so I was-- I-- That's why I got on, like, social media a few years ago. So I, I, I was, I was never on social. 1:43 Then about twenty-four months ago, I started posting on Twitter and LinkedIn and, uh, quickly jumped up to about forty thousand followers, uh, across those two channels. 1:50 And, and my audience, who I'm talking to, are owners of businesses in my space, right? 1:55 A-and really owners of businesses in my space who don't have a succession plan, and they're-- they wanna think about transition and selling their business and hopefully selling to someone other than private equity, a, a family-owned business that's committed to long-term private ownership. 2:07 So that's, that's who I'm talking to, and that's my audience. A-and that led to interesting discussions because that, that's really-- it's not a huge audience, right? 2:13 You think four thousand subs, how they actually create that much revenue. Uh, but our estimation is about seventeen hundred of them are owners of businesses in our category, right? 2:22 Uh, so folks who I, I would say sort of a high value, high intent audience who are purchasing products and services and technology, uh, that typically has, uh, that's high revenue and high gross margin for my, my sponsor partners. 2:33 Yeah. And that, that's-- a lot of people don't realize this when they're getting into media is, you know, audience value is a lot more important than just how many people are in your audience. 2:43 And we'll t- I'm sure we'll have a lot of discussions about that today. But tell us more about the category of these businesses. So is it all home service businesses? Like, do you have a, a background in, in HVAC? 2:52 Just what does that look like for someone who has no context or experience in that world? Yeah. So, so why people started, like, following, like, why the heck did anyone start listening to me on, on social media? 3:01 We had, we had jumped in to a family business, uh, my-- that my dad started back in nineteen eighty-eight, and it was, uh, when I, I left the Marine Corps, jumped into that business in two thousand fifteen with my brother Joe, when that business was nine million dollars, about forty-five team members. 3:14 And then we, over a period of ten years through today, uh, we've taken that nine million dollar business and, and transformed it into a hundred and sixty-five million top line, about six hundred and fifty W-2 team members. 3:24 And so it's been a really fun success journey, and then recently turned on, uh, sort of the, the inorganic growth, acquisitions. And that's what I talk about. 3:32 So that, that's what I'm, I'm sharing with these owners, how we, how we build and scale an enduring privately held business, how we compete with private equity. 3:38 Uh, I get really tactical around operations, uh, like how we, how we think about capacity management and, and customer service process and new AI tools and how they apply to our business. 3:48 Uh, and so it's things that, that I think are very actionable that, that our readers look at and they're like, "Yes, I can take this and go do it in my business, uh, do it in my business tomorrow." 3:57 So a lot of who I'm talking to in my core audience is really HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and roofing business owners. 4:04 Uh, but it turns out I end up catching-- I have a bunch of folks in pest control and landscaping and really anything residential services. 4:11 And, and I would say there's also a concentration of folks in the entrepreneurship through acquisitions space. So ETA, folks that are looking to get out there and buy a business. 4:19 Um, so that, that, that tends to be the different sorta segments of folks that I'm talking to. Yeah, that makes sense. I wanna dive into that a little bit before we get into the media side. 4:27 I-is your-- So obviously that, that growth is super impressive. 4:31 Is that all-- I'm just kind of-- maybe the audience won't love this as much because it's, it's not media stuff, but is that all in one location or is that throughout the country? 4:39 Is it all HVAC or other services that you're doing as well? Yep. So we have, uh, four brands, uh, and we serve customers in Missouri, Illinois, Tennessee, and Colorado. 4:51 And our services are HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and roofing and exteriors. Makes sense. And I'm assuming for each of those services, there's a different brand. I'm assuming, but, um, maybe it's done differently. 5:03 Yep, no. So HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, those are the-- we have two brands in that space, and that's a natural sort of bundle. 5:08 In this world, you often see businesses that offer all three, uh, they, they kind of naturally support one another and, and are similar in how you, you deliver those services to customers. 5:17 Uh, and then roofing and exterior is, is separate independent brand. Uh, but typically that's the bundle, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, roofing, and exteriors. Interesting. 5:25 I have-- like when I first started my career, I kinda started in the home service business, and my family has a, a background there, but not, not to the scale of most businesses that you work with. 5:37 What type of, like, economics do these businesses have? Like, what type of margins are we looking at, revenue growth? And not necessarily for your business, but like just in, in general out there in the categoryYeah. 5:49 So part of the reason private equity loves this space and why they've been pouring into residential services i-is because of some of the, these business attributes that I'll share, right? 5:57 So in our world, on the service side, and, and by the way, this is not new construction, this is not, uh, big commercial stuff. This is residential service and retrofit. 6:06 We have over fifty percent gross margins, um, whi-which is really healthy. 6:10 Uh, we have negative working capital, which means customers pay us deposits in advance for work, right, for projects, and then everything else, service work and, and the, the completion of project, uh, cash is due, right? 6:20 So we don't, we don't have like big working capital requirements where we need to borrow a bunch of money to fund the projects until we get paid. Uh, I like to say we're negative working capital. 6:28 So when you have that gross margin profile combined with negative working capital, combined with being in a business, uh, that's really resistant to cyclicality, the, the sort of economic ups and downs, because of what we do on the service and retrofi-fit side, uh, it's not nice to have stuff, it's need to have, right? 6:44 So if your home's without air conditioning and it's July or June, uh, you're not, you're not thinking, "Well, maybe I'll get it fixed." You're saying, "Oh my gosh, what do I have to do to get it fixed right now?" Right? 6:53 So we have like largely non-discretionary services, which, which further sort of increases the attractiveness of this, this space. 6:59 Which has led, so if you're not following, uh, for across the country, private equity has gobbled up all of these independents. 7:06 Uh, I mean, heck, like, uh, there are so few anybody that's, uh, ten million or above, uh, in the residential service space, particularly in HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, and now roofing, everyone's just been acquired by these big private equity consolidators. 7:17 So I think for us, we, we really are the voice of the independent, and we're probably one five service and retrofit businesses in this category that are north of a hundred million dollars that are left, that are independent, uh, non-private equity owned in the country. 7:28 Wow. I knew private equity was very interested in the space, but I didn't know, like, how much. Do you know how, like what percentage of those types of businesses at that scale are owned by private equity? 7:37 Even just like a ballpark. I don't think that data is out there. I don't have a percentage. I'll say this, uh, of the businesses north of fifty million, I would put it at eighty-five plus percent, right? 7:47 Businesses north of a hundred million, I, I, I know of a handful, around four or five that are left in the country in this category, pure play residential service and retrofit, that are still independent, and every other one private equity owned. 7:58 A-and I think part of the reason people were jumping ship is it was while private equity at the peak was coming in and paying twenty to twenty-one times EBITDA, which was, which was just nuts. 8:07 And what's interesting is they were doing that when interest rates were zero. So, uh, today there's been some, some noteworthy implosions, right? People that over-levered and then had performance erode. 8:16 Uh, so th-there's, there's been some, uh, not successful stories that, that I think have given people a little more caution. That's wild. Yeah. 8:23 And also kind of makes me think like, I don't want a company owned by private equity doing all the stuff in my house. Maybe I'm, I'm wrong to think that, but it's just like a natural reaction I'm sure many people have. 8:32 You want the independently person, like the owner lives in your town, that type of thing. Yeah. Um, or it's just, y-you know, family owned. That just seems a lot more trustworthy. 8:41 Maybe that's just my background because I-- like my dad has a small contracting business and like, it's just like who I grew up working with and, you know, who he worked with. It was always 8:51 the, the small, you know, one or two or a couple dozen people, contractors. Yeah. Well, I, I hope more customers feel the way you do. [chuckles] Absolutely. 9:01 We got maybe like a one-second delay, so I'll try not to interrupt. But, um, one question about this ETA. So unrelated to media, one more question unrelated to media is, you know, entrepreneurship through acquisition. 9:12 As someone like on the inside who's been building these businesses for, for a long time, what do you think about that? 'Cause it's become like, kind of like the hot thing. 9:21 There's a lot of people talking about it, a lot of almost like big media companies built around teaching people entrepreneurship through acquisition. 9:29 Is there just any general reaction or like words of warning or wisdom that you have around that? Yeah. I, I mean, listen, I think it's awesome. 9:37 Like, uh, business ownership, entrepreneurship, I think it's great, and I think the-- unfortunately, I think what most people see, uh, on social media and from, from some of the big accounts that promote, um, uh, ETA and/or sell courses or content around ETA is everyone talks about the success stories. 9:52 Everyone, um, acts like it's, it's-- candidly acts like it's easier than it is. 9:56 I, I mean, listen, I, I like to say these businesses, even my business, some days you, you show up and you feel like it's a knife fight every day to win, to stay alive, to compete. 10:04 Uh, a-and I would just say it's high risk, and I don't think people appreciate the level of risk involved. 10:08 And, and typically, if you're, if you're a searcher and you're using an SBA loan, not only is it high risk, uh, but you have uncapped personal guarantees, right? 10:16 So your, your financial success and your financial well-being individually, uh, is inextricably bound to the success of this business that you oftentimes just put eighty or ninety percent leverage on, right? 10:27 And you're borrowing money that's, th-that in today's environment is costing you ten, eleven percent. 10:31 Uh, a-and so I, I would just say it's risky, but of course, with a lot of risk comes the potential for a lot of reward, right? 10:38 And I think a lot of people focus on the reward and perhaps underappreciate, uh, or don't place enough weight on the, the risk that accompanies operating these, these businesses. Yeah. 10:47 I think a lot of people don't realize that. And there's been a lot of success stories too, of course. 10:52 But it's, it's interesting because basically the, the, the media companies and creators who, who published a lot about that, it's basically business opportunity. You know, media falls into that category. 11:03 And I just always thought it was a little bit strange how that became such a popular business opportunity when there's so much upfront capital and risk involved. 11:10 You know, years ago, it was like start a marketing agency, and obviously that's super competitive, but, you know, anybody can do that without, you know, personally guaranteeing hundreds of thousands of dollars, um, in a loan. 11:22 And just-- So I've just always had kinda like a scratch my head reaction to that, not that home service businesses aren't an awesome thing to get into, but just how popular it's become, um, from that angle has been really interesting to me.I would say I would add, like, the, the, you know, one-- the SBA is great because it makes, uh, makes it, uh, makes business ownership accessible to so many people. 11:42 But the SBA also presents a challenge for buyers because now all suddenly competition on the buy side is so intense and everybody has access to funding, right, up to five million dollars or depending on the real estate, even more than that. 11:55 Uh, so then all of a sudden you're seeing people's willingness to pay is very high up to those lending limit thresholds from the SBA. 12:02 Uh, and so I think you oftentimes find people who are overpaying, and particularly when you're going through a-- you've got a hot category, a business in a hot category, and it's going through a broker who's running an auction process, right? 12:12 Which means, uh, the winner is going to succumb to the winner's curse, meaning they paid more than anybody else was willing to pay, uh, for that business. 12:20 And I think those are, uh, those are dynamics that, that can, you know, lead to some tough outcomes down the road if, if you ended up paying a little bit more than the business, uh, was worth. 12:28 Uh, and/or if you couple that, that sort of high leverage together with any decline in performance of the business, uh, that's when you go underwater, right? 12:35 So you-- I like to say your margin for error when you're levering up ninety percent, ninety-five percent, you just don't have a margin for error. 12:41 You need to execute flawlessly or else you could be, be in, uh, be in hot water. Yeah, it makes a lot of sense. I'm, I'm just interested in the stuff and it's very good advice. 12:50 Let's get into the media stuff, uh, the media and the newsletter stuff. So there's, there's-- all the questions I have for you about this, I know you kinda had some things you wanted to discuss, too. 12:59 You know, why start the newsletter? 'Cause you've been creating content on, on Twitter and LinkedIn for a while. You built up a great following there. 13:06 Uh, why, why go into the newsletter and, you know, start to have, uh, media revenues as sponsorships and other types of media product revenue? What was the reasoning? What are your-- also, what are your goals with it? 13:16 What are you trying to do over the next year or so or longer? Yeah, really good question. So the catalyst for me to start the newsletter was this, you know, I, I don't have a big corporate development team, right? 13:25 So when I'm out there and I'm trying to find people who wanna partner with us, I do it by telling our story, building in public, sharing, sharing openly, uh, and broadly with a lot of people. 13:35 Uh, and then that leads to a lot of the inbound interest where people reach out and say, "Hey. Hey, Chris, would love to talk to you about a partnership. 13:40 I don't have a succession plan," or, "My kids aren't interested," or whatever it is. 13:44 Um, so, so the social, uh, and, and the media and the newsletter as an extension of that really just becomes, uh, my pipeline building tool. 13:51 Uh, and then for folks who aren't interested in selling their business, it just becomes a great source of value for them as they, they learn about our industry and, uh, and our business. 13:59 But I-- so w-why-- so I, on my list, my audience is about, about half of them sort of fit the, the profile of folks that, that we wanna potentially partner with or, or talk to. 14:08 Uh, but what I did, so from a monetization perspective, I said, "Okay, I'm talking to all these folks, and a lot of what they want to know aligns with things like, well, what technology are we using? 14:16 How are we thinking about AI?" Uh, consumer financing is a big, big category 'cause a lot of homeowners need access to it to be able to purchase our services, uh, right? 14:25 So then I, I said, "Well, why don't I go to the partners that we work with, people we actually believe in, uh, products we use, services we, we, we use in our business, and why don't I go and, uh, ask them if they wanna sponsor this newsletter?" 14:36 And I can talk about how we're leveraging their technology, whether it's, y-you know, ServiceTitan, which just IPO'd one of the most successful category leaders in the, uh, uh, software space inside of our industry. 14:46 Uh, I, I said, "Hey, would you guys wanna, wanna sponsor this and be included?" They're like, "Heck yeah, we'd love to." 14:51 And, uh, uh, so they signed up, and then I went to Cybernetic Labs, who does awesome AI, like really transformational agentic AI tools that they're bringing to our business. 14:59 And they're like, they're like, "Heck yeah, we'd love to sponsor." So I, I went to people where it wasn't just like a random ad. 15:04 It was like products I believe in that we actually use in our business, and then being able to share, like, this is how we think about it, this is how we use it, right? 15:11 And so the, the sponsorships feel very organic in the newsletter, uh, and it's actually just talking about how it's, it's creating value, uh, in our business and how it's, it's making sure we operate efficiently and profitably. 15:22 I like that, and that's what you want. You want to be, you know, the best media companies are essentially kind of like marketplaces connecting buyers and sellers that are a really good fit. 15:31 Like it's-- there's a, there's a clear need there. And so you have, you know, 15:35 not that your audience is just buyers, that's just one way to look at it, but you have the, the home service businesses, owners and operators, and then you have the software and technology vendors that, that are the sellers, right? 15:46 And if you can connect them in a tasteful way and basically solve a problem for both parties, you can build a really successful sponsorships and, and partnership business. 15:54 And so that's how I think about it, and that's basically exactly what you're doing. I'm sure there's some tweaks that you'll, you'll work out and we'll talk about, uh, but that's great to hear. 16:03 Well, Matt- And then I like how... One thing- Could I, could I ask you a question, you know, on this? 'Cause as I launched this, you know, I, like, went very quickly. 16:10 I was, I was actually, uh, Walker Deibel, who's a friend who wrote Buy Then Build, re-really popular in the search space, we were riding on a plane together back from this event, and he, he was, he was sort of a thought partner for me as I was launching this newsletter. 16:20 Uh, but I, I-- what I-- so I launched a-almost most of my sponsorships, all but a few are, are sort of a fixed monthly cost. Uh, but then I, I rolled out a few that were based on performance, based on sales. 16:31 Uh, and I'm interested what, what I-- how do you think about when to have a fixed monthly cost versus when to offer a performance-based, uh, sponsorship? 16:39 And then, uh, to that latter point, how do you track attribution, uh, for, for some of these performance-based sponsorships? 16:46 I have UTM links from Beehiiv where I can see people that click on it, but that's really the beginning and end of my current setup. 16:52 So I, I don't really know other than if they tell me who actually purchased the services. Yeah. I'll get into that, and that's, um, that's a question a lot of people have. 17:00 There's, there's not a perfect answer, but I have a lot of ideas. 17:02 One thing I'll just add before that, just to finish, like, the high level stuff, is that I, I like that this is basically you getting paid to build your pipeline for partnerships and acquisitions through building the audience 17:14 i-in a, in a media capacity or as in a newsletter, essentially. So I think that's really cool, too. It's not just the media company by itself, it's, it's flowing into your main business, and I like to see that. 17:25 Bus- this is maybe kind of foreign to me and you, but, like, there's some people I talk to who start a media company, but they have this successful business, and the media company or newsletter has nothing to do with their business, and that's always a big mistake, and you'reYou're having it flow into your main business, which is the smart thing to do. 17:40 Anyways, okay, to get to the sponsorships, um, fixed versus performance. So a-all the big sponsorship businesses that I talk to, they want fixed fees. 17:52 Uh, but also because this is so new and it makes sense to do performance stuff 'cause you, you wanna prove yourself, you're still building the audience. 18:00 Um, maybe 'cause the audience might grow really quickly, there's also potentially more upside when you're doing performance-based stuff versus when you have a fixed thing, you, you cap what your upside can be when you have a fixed sponsorship. 18:10 So performance can be a great option too. We don't-- we probably won't get into like, okay, what you're getting paid, uh, per performance, but we don't need to get into the numbers. 18:19 But like, are you getting paid per lead or per sale? Per sale. Okay. And either way can work. I just wanted to confirm, because that will change how we track things. 18:30 So per sale, sometimes it makes it a little bit more difficult. And probably the main reason people don't like performance, including me, is because attribution is just so hard. 18:39 Like, there's no perfect way to have attribution, because someone could like discover the product through your newsletter and then go Google it and sign up there, and then even though you were, um, you know, the first person to show them, you don't get credited for the, for the attribution. 18:55 Do you have any type of exclusive offer that's just relevant to you? So the simple example is like, okay, the product's a hundred bucks, but if you use Chris thirty at checkout, you get, you know, thirty percent off. 19:08 And basically that creates a like a financial incentive for the attribution to be tracked through you. 19:14 Is there anything-- and obviously you wouldn't have exactly that because these are SaaS products, but something like that. Does that exist? 19:20 Uh, no, but I, I love that thinking where-- 'cause, yeah, it's not like you check out online. These are typically like bigger sales that get involved, right? 19:26 If it's a CRM migration or integrating a new financing partner. 19:30 But to your point, if it's like, hey, mention that you heard from The Path Less Traveled and you get ten percent off your first year, you know, whatever it is, like something, uh, that would be, uh, I think that's a good thought, but I don't currently do that. 19:41 Right now, unless they tell [chuckles] the sponsors that they heard it from me, uh, so these are-- here, these are some good lessons for me in four weeks in. Yeah. 19:50 And I think that's why I mentioned this before I even got into like the UTM parameters and stuff is like that stuff is important, but all that stuff can break, and it doesn't work in every scenario. 19:59 But when you have some type of special offer that incentivizes your audience to make sure they know about that special offer, meaning the vendor, then attribution works almost every single time. 20:12 And it doesn't have to be a discount. It could be, you know, an extended free trial. It could be a, a free setup or like waiving the setup fee. 20:21 Uh, there's like creative ways you can do it, because not everybody wants to give twenty percent off, and that doesn't work for every single, uh, software. 20:27 So there's like creative ways you can do it outside of just a, a fixed discount. 20:31 And then also some people feel like if the pricing isn't transparent, they're just gonna raise their ten-- price by ten percent and then give them a discount. So you can be creative with it is what I'm trying to say. 20:41 So I think you-- if you can change that or do that in the future, that's a must-have. And then the tracking really depends on what their systems are. Um, so you wanna use UTM parameters for every time you share a link. 20:52 That's super important. When you-- like Beehiiv has that built in. When you share a link in the newsletter, like your UTM parameters are, uh, attached to it. 21:00 But you should probably have like an agreed set of UTM parameters that both you and the sponsor agree on. 21:06 Ideally, in a performance-based deal, you would also have what we call like a co-branded or dedicated landing page, where it's just one page that's dedicated to The Path Less Traveled and the vendor. 21:17 It can just be a duplicated, a duplicated page, their normal landing page. Maybe it has like both of your logos at the top. 21:23 And then on that page, on their end, they need to put like a custom form or a survey, um, or checkout page that's just dedicated to your partnership. 21:33 So they know all the leads, all the sales, all the whatever that come through that landing page and that, uh, specific survey or button are attached to you. And so that, that's basically how we do it. 21:43 And it involves some degree of trust, where you have to trust that they're reporting accurately or they're sharing, um, some type of shared tracking, uh, analytics or even a spreadsheet with you. 21:56 There's, you know, there's many different ways to do it. 21:58 Like we used to do a lot of these when I worked at The Hustle, and we had a reporting tool, uh, that was called like Sisense or like we even used Hubspot for this too. 22:07 And basically that software tool that we had would allow us to sh- create a report that both we could see and our partner or vendor could see. And so both of us have access to the same data. 22:18 It's not like us copy and pasting the data, it's just you see the exact, um, report that we do. And so some companies have that. 22:25 Sometimes if you're just collecting lead, leads through a Typeform, of course, you can connect a Typeform to a Google Sheet, and then you both have access to that Google Sheet where all the leads are being populated there. 22:35 Every situation is different, though. Yeah. Hey, Matt, can I, uh, uh, just quick, uh, technical thing. Can I switch my Wi-Fi network here? I'm like coming through spottier. Um, do you mind if I do that real quick? Yeah. 22:49 All right. Where were we at? We were at, uh, tracking, uh, performance-based sponsorships. Yep. What-- could I ask, uh, uh, pivoting from that, and I think that's all great. 23:00 I think, I think I have some good, good action and takeaway from there. 23:03 How do you think about like within the Beehiiv platform, like given what my audience is and who I'm targeting, like do you think Boosts is a useful tool for me to use or not really? 23:13 Not at your stage because, you know, it's really just like, you know, pocket change, what you're getting from Boost. 23:19 You know, you're gonna earn approximately, you know, thirty to sixty cents per subscriber for, from Boost, and I'm talking about Boost to monetize, right? For you, it doesn't make sense. 23:31 However, for people who are just starting from scratch, they're doing this as a side hustle, it's like take every penny you can get. In your situation, it's not a good fit. And so that's to monetize. 23:40 You can also use Boost to grow, right? Where you're, um, paying other people two, three bucks per subscriber.I would only do that if you can find another newsletter that's like a really good fit for this. 23:51 And there actually might be some out there, 'cause there's more and more newsletters popping up every day that are covering, uh, maybe it's potentially some similar topics or have the audience overlap. 24:00 So if you have a good fit, you could do it to grow, um, but you're probably not gonna get-- you're probably only gonna get, like, three to five percent of your overall subscribers that way. Got it. Okay. 24:11 Yeah, I've, I've dabbled with it, turning on boosts, but it, yeah, it is hard 'cause I'm like, I, you know, I'm trying to decide which newsletters are a fit that I actually wanna pay to boost. Yeah. I'm gonna... 24:20 Connection-- How's that sound now? Try talking again. The connection slowed down for a second there when you started talking. Yeah. Sorry. I th-I think something's going on, I think, at my house for whatever reason. 24:31 Okay. We had a quick, uh, interruption for a technical issue, but we're back. So Chris, um, where should we start off with? Or where should we, uh, cont- what should we continue with, rather? Yeah. 24:42 I, I would love your perspective on how to leverage the paid subscriber function. So, like, in my newsletter, my two core publications each month, around the first and the fifteenth, are free. 24:51 But then I've layered in some, like, more tactical publication releases where I'll go really deep on a specific facet of our business or, uh, a specific area that I think readers are interested in. 25:02 And then I'll, I'll typically put a paywall, like, halfway through that content. Uh, and so I did that. 25:07 I, I did, I did two of those so far, and I, I promoted them a little bit on social, but I, I-- and I got, I think I've got, like, ninety paid subs that signed up, and I priced them at six ninety-nine a month or, like, seventy something bucks. 25:21 Okay. Seventy-two bucks maybe for the year. But I'm interested in your thoughts on how do I think about paid subscriptions. Should I turn them on? Should I not? 25:27 Uh, it's not a ton of money, but it's a-an interesting way to add value and another monetization channel. Yes. This almost gets into, like, the, the business strategy question. 25:35 I think it depends on what business, what type of business you wanna build. So you kind of started with free content, and then you've started building part-partnerships. You've signed some annual contracts, 25:46 some performance-based stuff. So, like, partnerships and sponsorships are essentially one business model, kind of within the, within the media model. 25:53 And then paid subscriptions are, uh, almost another model that require different deliverables, different customers, uh, different skill sets. 26:02 And they're, they're one that I'm usually not a fan of, of, like, being the first product to sell to your audience. So I am a big fan of selling what I call, like, information products or paid media products. 26:13 So that could be a report, a digital product, a course, a community, that type of stuff. You know, you know all that stuff, right? Paid subscriptions are really tough for a couple reasons. One is just 26:25 you've had some success, which is great, but it's hard to get people to commit to a subscription, even if it's relatively inexpensive, which yours is. Like, I've found, like, people will happily pay... 26:37 Or it's easier to get someone to buy something for, like, a thousand dollars one time than it is to buy something for fifty to a hundred dollars a month. 26:44 And then a lot of times people find that, okay, I have that fifty or a hundred dollar a month subscription, and my average retention is, like, six months. 26:50 And so I would have made more money if I just sold them o-one thing for a thousand dollars. 26:55 And then the other challenge is, like, if you have a lower price point, around ten bucks a month, which is-- which you're closer to, you just have to get a lot of customers to get to the level a lot of people want to. 27:05 You know, a lot of people's goals are like, "I want this to be a six-figure paid subscription," or, "I wanna do seven figures in revenue with this paid subscription." 27:12 And at that price point, it's just-- it's really hard to close thousands of customers and retain them and deliver. And then the final thing is just the commitment. 27:21 Like, if someone signs up for an annual plan, you're committing to that deliverable, whether it's one newsletter a week or whatever it might be, for an entire year, unless you partially refund them. 27:31 And then maybe business goals change, maybe your priorities shift, uh, maybe you see that, oh, the opportunity isn't here, it's somewhere else, and so I don't wanna continue this subscription. 27:41 And so just, it can become a lot of time to fulfill that thing, uh, for not a lot of customers. 27:47 And so I've, I've talked to, like, dozens of people who have tried to launch one of these as their first product and then shut it down a couple months later and, and put a wh- a whole bunch of sunk cost into it. 27:59 So I think it's great to sell something. What, what I would... And this is gonna be completely in a different direction than what you were aiming towards, is like, I would just try and sell a one-off thing. 28:09 So like, I would just create one of those reports or one of those newsletters, and then I would just call it a report instead of a newsletter, 28:18 and I would just sell it for ten dollars, twenty-nine dollars, forty-nine dollars and just see what the response is. 28:24 And then if you have another idea that you think would be useful, you create another report, sell that for another fifty bucks or ninety-nine bucks, whatever you choose to do. 28:31 I actually think you'll make more money that way. And then if you're like, "Oh, these, these reports are ripping," and like, "I wanna keep doing these," and like, "People really want these, 28:40 uh, every single month," then you can turn them into a we-weekly or monthly paid newsletter. And so kind of the opposite of what you wanted, but yeah. 28:49 It's, it's just, um, you've got this advertising business working and it's like sometimes if you can spread yourself too thin and actually wind up moving slower that way and making less money that way. 29:01 And the final challenge is like when you put your best content behind a paywall, it becomes harder to grow your audience, right? 29:08 Versus if all your best content is free, you know, more people can see that, share that, you can repurpose that content to social media. And so there's all these pros and cons with paid subscriptions. 29:18 Not that they don't work, because there are like people who have paid, you know, subscriptions that are doing seven, eight, nine figures in recurring revenue annually, some really big newsletter businesses like that. 29:29 But it's, it's hard to start with. Yeah. No, that's really, really a good perspective. 29:35 And I, I go back to too in my mind, I have to always remember like the, the genesis of this effort was pipeline building for our core business, which means I wanna get this content in front of as many people as I can, right? 29:46 And typically, it kind of supports that, that supports the sort of free approach. So maybe, uh, you know, maybe, maybe it's not worth-Uh, leaning too heavily into the paid sub world. 29:56 Uh, what about, uh, Matt, do-- like shifting- Yeah... gears a little bit. I'm thinking about, like, the welcome email. 30:02 Like, a-and I noticed when I signed up for yours, right, you asked me all kind of like those all kinds of questions. There was a survey, you were collecting a lot of information. 30:09 Like, tell me about how I should think about what I should know about my audience and the welcome process and/or information that I should think about collecting. Yeah. 30:18 I think about this as, um, just going like one level higher. It's just like onboarding, and your welcome email is a part of onboarding. 30:25 So it's like after they hit submit on that form where they put their email address in, what happens next? So typically you'll have like a thank you page. You may not have that yet. That's okay. That could be added later. 30:35 And of course, they'll receive the welcome email immediately. People often have like a survey. 30:40 So we call this onboarding process the signup flow or the subscribe flow, and it, it has a couple purposes, so I'll actually just run through all of it because I think all of it's pretty relevant to what you do. 30:51 Especially when I'm talking like B2B media operators, people have more niche publications. I really recommend having a signup flow that consists of, okay, one, your landing page, that's the obvious one. 31:01 And then immediately after the next step is a, is a survey. We call it a post-signup survey, where it's just three to six multiple qu-choice questions that just give you more data about who the subscriber is. 31:12 And so you can sign up for my newsletter and see mine. My questions won't be relevant to you because my audience is different, right? So I'm asking things like, how many subscribers do you have? 31:20 How does your business generate revenue? Is it advertising, subscription, information products, something else? You might ask like team size or revenue. Totally. I was about to say like what industry is it? Roofing? 31:31 Is it HVAC supply? That would be super valuable. Team size would be super valuable. And are you thinking about a transition in the next twelve months, right? Something that like... Perfect. 31:38 Like that information would be incredibly valuable. Absolutely. Yeah, and it might only just be those three questions. That's totally fine. I like three to six because... 31:45 And you want them to be multiple choice, because if you do too many of them, people don't complete it. Um, and too few, it's just not enough data for you. 31:50 So that's useful for your goal of, you know, partnerships, but also then you have that data to share with sponsors and, uh, help, help you in those sponsorship sales conversations. 32:00 And then finally, with, with Beehiiv, which you use and other tools too, you can bas- you can send dedicated emails based off of those responses. 32:07 So if someone says, "I'm in plumbing," and you have something that you wanna market to plumbing businesses, you can just send the email just to those folks. You can segment them. 32:15 And that's, that's generally more effective than sending the marketing email about plumbing to your entire list. You just send it to the people who are actually, uh, it's actually most relevant towards. 32:26 So after someone completes that survey, or even if they just click X and move on from that survey, they'll be, they'll be redirected to a thank you page. 32:34 In the thank you pages, I kind of think about jobs to be done for a thank you page. It's just like get someone excited to actually read the newsletter, 32:42 because I like to say your landing page and the stuff before sold them on subscribing, now your thank you page ex- has to sell them on actually reading. 32:49 And that's just as important because, I mean, how many times have you signed up for something that's like, I sign up and then I never open it and read it. 32:54 So get them excited to read, tell them what to expect, like when you send it, what they're gonna get in each email. And then I like to have some type of incentive or teaser to w- to open the welcome email. 33:05 Because if they open the welcome email, we do things inside the welcome email that improve our deliverability and other things, and I'll tell you about that in a second. So I like to say like, "Hey, I just..." 33:13 I don't know what you have, but like, "Hey, I just sent you my best guide on XYZ in the welcome email. Go check it and, uh, open it for that." Or, "I put a free gift inside the welcome email. Go find it." 33:22 Or you could even say like, "If you're not gonna be officially subscribed until you open the welcome email and follow the instructions inside." You could even say something like that. 33:30 And so hopefully immediately after they see the thank you page, they go up, open the welcome email. It doesn't always happen that way, but like hopefully that happens in a perfect world. 33:37 And the welcome email is just as important as all the other stuff. And so the welcome email strategy that I do is more about email deliverability. 33:44 Because the biggest challenge with-- And when I say deliverability, I mean both deliverability and inbox placement. So deliverability is like, does the email actually get to the inbox? 33:53 And then inbox placement is what tab does it show up in? Does it show up in primary promotions, updates, or potentially even spam? 34:00 And odds are like a lot of your welcome emails are gonna go to promotions or updates, and that's just, you can't really avoid that, but it's like, how do you get it out of there? 34:09 And so that's what the welcome email focuses on. So I like to remind people the expectations, like what you're gonna get, and then I usu- we, we give what we call like three deliverability actions. 34:19 So we ask them to move it to the primary inbox, we ask them to reply to the email, and we get them to click a link. 34:27 And the idea is that if, if they do all three of those things, it's going to stay in the primary inbox as long as they continue to interact with emails. 34:33 If they don't do any of those things, it's either gonna stay in promotions or it's gonna go to promotions eventually. 34:39 And so, and that's just because like emails you're interacting with, they're clicking, replying, moving, they go to primary for the most part. Nothing's perfect, right? 34:48 So move to primary is obvious, like that's simple enough. That's one sentence. Click, um, reply is a little bit trickier, so we like to use just a one-word call to action. 34:56 So like, "Reply yes if you actually wanna get this." And that's just like, you don't wanna make them think. 35:01 Some people say like, "Hey, reply and tell me, uh, what's your biggest challenge or what business type do you have?" 35:07 But you actually get a much lower response rate that way because people have to think about their response and take effort out of their day to do so. So it's better than nothing, but I prefer the one-word reply. 35:17 And then to get someone to click a link, you don't have to say, "Hey, go click this link." 35:22 You can just say like, "Here, hey, here's my most recent guide on XYZ," or, "Here's my top three articles that, um, you should read if you're new here." 35:30 And then if they're, if they have good headlines, people will just click them and hopefully read them. And, uh, that's essentially the welcome email. I don't think you... Did you mention... 35:38 I don't think you have to have a survey in the welcome email if you ask it, if you have a post-signup survey. And- What about- Yeah. What should I do for the existing? 35:46 'Cause, uh, you know, I, I regret not having some of these best practices in place, uh, you know, four, five weeks ago when, when we-- I was creating thisUh, what should I do now for the roughly 4,000 subs that I didn't have complete that survey? 36:00 Is there a way to send it and get good engagement for people to actually complete a survey at this stage? Yeah. Yeah, what I would do is, um, 36:10 you know, the great, the great thing about having a post-sign up survey is you're gonna get, like, eighty, ninety percent completion rate. 36:15 And when you ask people later, you're, you're gonna get a much lower completion rate. So it is what it is, and that's... Everybody does this, so you're not, you're not alone. 36:22 What I would do is, like, at the top of your next newsletter say, like, "Hey, I wanna learn more about what you do so I can write better content to help you. Can you take two minutes to complete this survey?" 36:30 And then just you have a link to it, essentially. And you'll get responses that way. It's not gonna be everybody, but it's better than nothing. Yeah. No, that makes sense. 36:39 What about, uh, tell me about how you think about using y- you know, 'cause you're on Twitter, right? And, uh, I see a lot of folks who have, like, social audiences that also have newsletters. 36:49 How do you think about, how do you leverage your social platform to grow the audience and think about, you know, how much is too much when it comes to sort of promoting a newsletter on the social content? Yeah. 37:00 There's definitely people that are way better at it than me, but also they generally have, you know, a much broader potential audience. 37:06 So I've seen, like, some of our clients, they get 100,000 newsletter subscribers from Twitter or LinkedIn. I'm not, I'm not that guy, but I've done okay. 37:14 I think about, like, what, what are the different tactics that actually do that? So just assuming you're, like, creating good content and publishing that regularly, that's just an assumption, right? 37:23 I think having a subtle call to action in almost every piece of content for the newsletter is a good idea. So i- if you do a Twitter thread, the last tweet in the thread is a quick call to action for the newsletter. 37:34 If you do just an individual tweet, you can have, you know, a reply where it's like, "Hey, if you like this, I publish this stuff in my newsletter every week. Subscribe here." 37:42 Those are kind of the, the low-hanging fruit things. And I would do that with, with almost every post, because it doesn't really take away from the content. 37:49 It's not like the entire thread is about how awesome your newsletter is and not sharing anything. You're, you're sharing valuable stuff, and then it's just like, "Hey, if you want more, go here." 37:55 I also think a lot about social bios or, or profiles. So it's like your Twitter profile, your LinkedIn profile, that's, that's prime real estate. 38:02 And if people really like your stuff, they'll read it and then they'll click to your profile. That's almost like a landing page. And so how do we optimize this profile landing page to get more subscribers? 38:11 So, like, the primary link should be to your newsletter landing page. There should be at least something about the newsletter in the bio and some type of call to action for the newsletter in the bio. 38:20 It's even better if you can do an incentive, so it's like, you know, "10,000 plus people who read my newsletter. Subscribe and I'll send you this free lead magnet, this free thing." 38:29 What about, uh, so to that end, so right now if you go on my Twitter, it's has, uh, a link tree, and then I feature the newsletter most prominently at the top of a list of things that include, like, some of our businesses and some of our other, other social channels. 38:43 But it's a link tree- Yep... it's not direct to the newsletter. What are your thoughts on, uh, link tree versus direct to newsletter? Yeah, this is a common topic. So I have really thought strong thoughts. 38:54 It should-- It's just a matter of trade-offs, just like everything is. So you're always gonna get more people to subscribe if you just send them straight to your landing page, where that's the only objective, right? 39:02 It's just like i- if somebody clicks on a landing page, they're gonna have, like, a fifty percent or higher conversion rate to a email subscriber. 39:10 If someone clicks on a link tree, they've got, you know, five different things to choose from. 39:15 You know, ten percent, twenty percent of those people are actually gonna click the newsletter page, and then, you know, forty to fifty percent of those people are actually gonna subscribe. 39:22 And so it's just creating additional friction. The challenge is, like, maybe you, you really need people to go to other things, and so that's useful, uh, to use. 39:32 One thing I would think about is, like, have the least stuff possible and also think about what your goals are. So, like, for yours, you have a link to your Twitter account, LinkedIn, Instagram, and Facebook. 39:45 Probably for you, like, if they're already following you or already visiting your profile on Twitter or LinkedIn, you probably don't care as much about them following you on Instagram as you do subscribing to the newsletter. 39:55 'Cause, like, you wanna de-platform them. You wanna take them off of social to a place where they can get more value from you and you get more value from them. 40:02 And so in your case, I would just go straight to the landing page. 40:05 For some people, it's like, "Hey, I have a consulting business and I wanna have my intro call or my Calendly, and, like, I make ten grand a month from these calls. I don't wanna remove that from my bio." 40:14 In that case, like, something like a link tree makes sense. But at the same time, I kinda think about your thank you page can serve the same purpose. 40:21 So it's like someone subscribed to the newsletter, and then immediately after they subscribe, on the thank you page, you have a call to action for the consulting call or for your Instagram page. 40:30 So that's basically how I think about the trade-offs and, and what to put there. Got it. Yeah, no, that's good feedback. 40:35 The only, only one that I could see that, yeah, I don't really care about driving traffic to the other social platforms, but I do like connecting folks with our sort of parent company, uh, we're, uh, website, hbsolutionsgroup.com, where we talk about sort of our partnership model and, uh... 40:50 So, so the folks that are looking for that, right, those folks that, uh, wanna learn about possibly selling their business or partnering with us, that's also another, like, high-value page I want people to land, if that's what they're looking for. 41:01 Yeah. I totally get that. And that's where I, I, I kind of have similar things where I have different things to promote. So, like, my main link, like my, uh... 41:09 It's like the location link or something you have in, in Twitter. Like, that's the newsletter landing page. And then in the bio, you can have other links. And I put another link to, like, my, my course, for example. 41:19 Same thing on, on Instagram, like, you have, like, your view my newsletter link. So that's gonna go to the newsletter landing page, of course. But then you have a featured section, so you can have other things there. 41:28 And so that's kind of like primary and secondary. 41:29 And then I also think, I didn't realize that, but you should definitely have a call to action for HB Solutions on your newsletter thank you page and in your welcome email. It's like, don't, don't hide that. 41:38 Don't expect them to discover it later. Just, you know, put it out there right away. Yeah, that's good. I like that. Cool. What else? There's, there's a lot. I mean, let me know if you have anything else. 41:47 There's a couple of things I can, I can ask you, but what shall we start with? Uh, wherever you want. Wherever you wanna go. Yeah. I think... 41:55 Remind me how many subscribers you have, 'cause we had to pause the earlier conversation. Just under four thousand. 42:00 Thirty-nine something.And what are your-- we didn't totally work this out last time, but, like, where do you wanna go with this? 42:07 Like, do you have an audience goal in mind, a revenue goal just for the media and newsletter, or, like, a deal flow goal you want for the partnership? That's it. It's a deal flow goal. 42:16 And candidly, I wasn't even, like, thinking about the newsletter itself as a source of income or, uh, you know, as a, as something that I would monetize. It was really entirely about pipeline building. 42:25 'Cause, right, if you think about traditional-- If I was a private equity-owned business, right, I would have an army of corporate development people or a bunch of bankers on the buy side that are out there hunting for deals for me. 42:34 Like, uh, and those folks are expensive, and you pay them success fees, and, uh, and I don't have that, right? 42:39 So for me, the newsletter is about pipeline building and doing so in a way that avoids using all these costly intermediaries. 42:47 A-and additionally, I wanna directly connect with potential sellers because often I find, uh, I think I shared this with you, like, the, the whole winner's curse at play if you're, if you're buying a business through an auction process with a broker, right? 42:58 If you win that business when, when 40 people were bidding on it, that means you were willing to pay more than 39 other people, right? Which means maybe you overpaid, right? 43:06 So w-we wanna be able to have what we call proprietary deal flow and connect, uh, directly with these, these potential sellers. So the monetization, I was like, I, I was going down that path. 43:15 I'm like, I'm gonna build this newsletter, and then as I was looking at the content and I looked at this opportunity to say, "Well, there's some partners I really believe in, and I wanna talk about these really powerful tools." 43:23 But like, it's like, should I do that for free, or should I talk to them about, uh, about, uh, sponsoring and supporting sort of the production of the newsletter? 43:31 Uh, 'cause ultimately, right now it's just me doing it, and, and I have a, I have a day job, right, running a- Yeah... business. 43:36 And so the, the goal too, by monetizing this, is that I can, I can put some people and teams around it to ensure that the production quality remains high. 43:44 I'm still sort of reviewing and approving and sort of ideating when it comes to the content and what I want in the newsletter, but I want-- the, the income is nice 'cause then it allows me to scale it as it's ind- as an independent business. 43:55 Yeah. So what I'll do is, like, I like this exercise where I kind of like act as your CMO for this. 43:59 And it's like, okay, if I'm in charge, and I'm almost just treating Chris as like talent and, like, him as the o-operator of your main business, you know, what, what would I do essentially? 44:10 And, um, I think about this in like-- I think about this, like, as a standalone media company, not just a newsletter, so I'm also gonna think about, okay, your social content, um, stuff like that. 44:21 And so if the main goal is deal flow, I think you could have something really cool here that in the SaaS world they call, like, negative CAC or customer acquisition cost. 44:28 So the whole-- In the SaaS world, it's like there's a company called FreightWaves that did this, BlockWorks. 44:34 I-if you've heard of, like, Russell Brunson and ClickFunnels, they did this really well, where it's like they create, uh, media products and content, whether it's like newsletters, blog posts, websites, stuff like that, and they monetize that with, with advertising. 44:47 And then people like Russell Brunson will also sell information products like courses and paid webinars and events and stuff like that. And that in itself is profitable and makes money. 44:57 But the whole goal of that is to build an audience profitably so that you can sell them the next thing. So in the case of, like, ClickFunnels, it's software. 45:04 In the case of FreightWaves, it's like a data platform, which is essentially a software too. In the case of you, it's deal flow. 45:09 Even, like, Alex Hormozi is kinda doing this to some degree now too, where he has, um-- I'm sure you're familiar with him, right? You've-- His- Yeah... content's everywhere, so almost everybody is. 45:19 But, like, the way his business works a little bit now is he has obviously all this free content. He has a newsletter, YouTube channel, all this stuff. 45:25 And then mostly the call to action now is for a paid workshop that's, you know, $5,000, and they sell you an upsell at the paid workshop. So, like, that makes the media stuff profitable. 45:38 That pays for, like, all of Alex's production, ad spend, um, you know, content team, all that stuff. 45:44 And then, you know, from all the leads from the content and from the people who attend the workshop, they get proprietary deal flow for their, I guess, basically it's a private equity company. 45:54 And so that's kinda what-- I wouldn't say do all that stuff right now, but as like, over time, you can build something like that, and you already are. You're already doing that now. You're already profitable right now. 46:03 You're just doing it at a smaller level. And so that's, that's how I would think about it. Can you remind me how often you send the newsletter? Like, how many times a week, or is it once a week? 46:12 Uh, typically it's around the first and the fifteenth of the month, but I'll adjust to kinda land on a Tuesday morning typically. So I'll, I'll find sort of a midweek morning that's closest to the first and fifteenth. 46:23 Okay. So it's kinda like bi-weekly right now, twice a month? Yeah. Yeah. And that's great. I would-- I mean, keep doing that. Over time, I think getting to a weekly cadence would be great, but no more than that. 46:32 You don't need more than a weekly newsletter. And you don't have to rush into a weekly newsletter. 46:37 And I would just try and-- and this is a lot of work, and this is why, you know, making money from partnerships and sponsorships helps because you can hire help for these things. 46:44 But, you know, I would ha-have, you know, a weekly newsletter, and I would have a consistent cadence of publishing on Twitter and LinkedIn, maybe even another place too, where you're publishing more like five times a week, really high quality stuff. 46:56 You're, you're publishing a good amount now. I haven't-- I don't know the exact cadence. And a lot of that can be repurposed from the newsletter. 47:02 So there's no reason to just, like, write a newsletter, put all the time into it, and never share that elsewhere. You know, repurpose that into a thread, into a LinkedIn, you know, long post or carousel. 47:11 And so a lot of that is all the same content, just repurposed. And so just, like, more content consistency and velocity is gonna help a ton with both getting newsletter subscribers and ad revenue, but also deal flow. 47:23 You just-- There's almost always a positive correlation between, like, your content quality and velocity and the leads that come in for whatever you're trying to do. For you, it's deal flow. 47:32 So I would do that, and then also because you're doing that, the audience grows, and you can continue to not only sell more partners, but also increase the rates of those partnerships and sponsorship deals and packages over time. 47:44 So I think that's, like, the, the system you're basically doing now, but just, like, continue that with that process. 47:50 You know, I think with an audience size of, like, let's say between 20,000 to 30,000 newsletter subscribers, you can have a seven-figure partnership business i-if it's the people that you-- If the concentration of the list is, you know, like the-- you have now, like the really high quality business ownersUh, high earning business owners, maybe even less, maybe even like fifteen thousand to thirty thousand subscribers. 48:13 You don't need a ma- a massive audience. Um, and you wanna stick, stick with that core demographic because that's who's gonna become, you know, a potential partner and, and be deal flow for you. That's right. 48:23 Another thing- Yeah, 'cause and just reacting to that, and then, and I'd love to hear you keep going. 48:28 But I, uh, it's funny, I, you know, when I got on Twitter two years ago, I, I, you know, I, I constantly have to remind myself, like, I'm not writing-- like I, you-- I don't care about the size of the audience, it's entirely about the quality of the audience. 48:39 'Cause it's easy to write content that appeals more broadly, but like to what end? 48:43 I don't really care about having, you know, X amount, you know, X tens of thousands or a hundred thousand or two or five hundred thousand followers. 48:49 It's about having, uh, you know, whatever, thirty, forty, fifty, sixty of really high quality followers in my niche, in my industry where I wanna grow. Yeah. 48:57 And try and stick with that because it becomes-- when, when you're like couple years into this with the newsletter, it becomes really easy to go start going broader because you chase those like followers and subscribers, but then it's not really the subscribers that you want, and then you kind of alienate the core audience to a degree. 49:13 It's hard to avoid, and so just if, if that's the goal, like just stick with that content and like it's-- you're gonna grow slower, but the audience quality's gonna be high and the trust is gonna be high, and then you're gonna become really-- and you, you already are in many ways, but, but you're gonna become more of like the go-to person for this thing if you stick with that for a very long period of time. 49:32 It does take a long time. But I-- yeah, because that's your goal, I, I would encourage you to do so. It's like even myself, like I started probably more like that. 49:40 Obviously different industry, and I've broadened a lot over time because that fits my business model, but it doesn't fit your business model. So stick to that, stick to that content. 49:49 I think the, the final thing I'll say is like if you want to accelerate this or, you know, three, six months from now you wanna start getting bigger and bigger, you know, one, you could hire a lot more people to help write content. 50:01 I think that's often a good investment if you can find the right people to write or repurpose your content. 50:05 Or even do things like a lot of these, uh, content writers or ghostwriters, they'll like interview you every week and then create content based off of that. 50:13 Or maybe you do a podcast and the entire purpose of the repop-- podcast is just repurposing that content to social media content. So usually that's a good investment. 50:22 If they can help with the newsletter production process or like editing, that's a good investment too because that saves you time. 50:27 And then I think later on, if you really wanted to throw fire on it, you could do some paid growth, whether that's like meta ads, so Facebook and Instagram ads, or even LinkedIn ads that are more targeted towards the type of people you want. 50:39 Like if you have a profitable advertising business, but you don't care about maximizing those profits, you could take fifty percent of that and reinvest that into paid growth with meta and LinkedIn ads and, and generate more and more subscribers and, uh, pipeline for your business. 50:52 So I'm doing a little bit of meta ads now, and I've, I've-- and I'm, I'm like torn. I'm, I'm-- what I'm researching, I'm-- I can either very narrowly define my audience, which to some degree I like. 51:01 Like, if I want people in my industry in certain seniority levels or roles or whatever, I can, I can do that. 51:07 But, you know, Facebook, as you're going through sort of the, the setup process for those ads, they're strongly encouraging you to turn on whatever that, like, optimizer tool is or- Yeah... 51:15 like basically let them run and do it independently. But I'm, I'm wondering like, do I do that or do I just like build my narrowly defined audience that I know I want? Yeah. 51:24 So they're-- the problem you have to turn on advantage plus targeting, which is just broad targeting. It's just like target everybody and then let the Facebook algorithm decide who to actually show your ad to. 51:33 And then what they're gonna do is optimize for lowest cost, and it's really the only way to do Facebook ads. 51:37 It's just like you set whatever targeting parameters you choose or you leave it up to Facebook, and then they just find you the lowest cost subscribers. So here's, here's the thing. 51:45 It's like w- when you do the super detailed targeting yourself, even then you truly don't know who you're targeting. No matter how you change, tweak things or click buttons, you're still leaving it up to Facebook. 51:57 And so even for the niche B2B clients we work with, we still recommend advantage plus targeting, but we do some other things to help you find the right people. So one is like, a simple one is like, you know, age. 52:08 A lot of people don't think about this, but f- like the cheapest people to target are people sixty-five plus on Facebook. And if they're not your demographic, maybe you should, you should change that. Maybe they are. 52:18 It's different for everybody. This is more like just speaking to anybody listening. Like if you know like all of your clients are like business owners thirty to fifty, like just target like twenty-five to fifty-five. 52:28 Obviously, location is important, but you're all US pretty much, I imagine. So that's like step number one. And step number two is the more important part, which is targeting through creative. 52:36 And so this, this is actually where it gets hard. You wanna have like dog whistle creative, so it's like only the ch- people you truly want on the list would respond to this and really hear it. 52:45 That's what I mean by dog whistle. And so that could be done through something as simple as like a call-out. 52:50 So it's like four home service business owners doing at least ten million in revenue, and then you get into the ad. It's like that's a simple kind of crude way to do, uh, creative targeting, but it works. 53:02 If you look at like Alex Hormozi's previous company, Gym Launch, they're just going after people that own gyms at a certain revenue level, and almost all their ads have some type of call-out, so you could look at that as an example. 53:13 Yeah. There's other ways to do dog whistle copy where it's just like talking about things that only that audience would align with or, or making promises that only that audience would truly want. 53:22 Like if you wanna take your home service business from one million in revenue to a hundred million, like this is for you. 53:27 And then so the people who are just starting a home service business, they're probably going to engage less with that ad. Or obviously, if they don't have one, they're going to engage less with it. 53:35 You can also do this on the landing page. 53:37 Like you c- [chuckles] this is where it gets kinda cheesy, but like it works, where you can say like, "Only for home service business owners in these spaces doing at least this amount of revenue, not for beginners." 53:47 Like you can start saying those. It just feels silly saying that, but like that type of stuff works to ex- exclude the people you don't wanna target. Because what happens is you get this feedback loop with Facebook ads. 53:56 Like if you do all that right and, and those people sign up, then Facebook will go and find more people who are similar to them, and they're really good at that. 54:03 That's actually how the whole ad system works, is like you get a customer, a subscriber, and then Facebook finds the next person on their platforms who are the most similar to that person based off of their interest data, all the things that they know about them. 54:14 Yeah. And so you have to create these like positive feedback loops, not negative feedback loops.Yep, that's really good. Uh, I like that. 54:21 I need to do-- I mean, right now, like, you know, we-it's funny, internally, we have an agency inside of our core business, but, like, I don't really leverage them to-- for this business, and I kinda created this outside of our core business, so I need to, need to think through to what degree I wanna replicate some of that, that capability, right? 54:37 Videographers, graphic design, all these, all these different things. Yeah. And you don't need a lot. You know, I think with Facebook ads, it definitely helps to, helps to have some support, especially with ad creative. 54:48 But yeah, I think like over time, like a, a content writer and editor would help a lot. And if you wanna do video stuff, obviously you need some video editing, maybe a videographer. But I think you're on the right path. 54:58 LinkedIn ads is kind of a way to like, have better targeting than Facebook because it's more-- LinkedIn is built for B2B. Facebook is more built for consumer. However, Facebook ads definitely work for B2B too. 55:08 Like, everybody is on Facebook or Instagram, business owner or not. So LinkedIn ads, you can do more of that targeting based off of industry, company size, job title. It's, it's very good at that. 55:19 It's not gonna work for everybody, but also because it has that capability, it's about double the cost. 55:24 And so if you get like a good lead on Facebook for five bucks, like that same lead's gonna be ten dollars on LinkedIn. And so you just have to have a system to convert that into a profit. Yeah. 55:34 So you were at, uh, this is a little bit of a squirrel, but you were at The Hustle pri- at some point prior? Yeah. I spent a, a good amount of time there. Not, not a ton. 55:42 So I actually started there after COVID, uh, before they were acquired, and then I stayed on after they were acquired for I think at least a year, and I was still like working on The Hustle, but inside of HubSpot, whi- which was who we got bought by. 55:56 Got it. Yep. In a funny, small world way, Sam Parr went to the same high school I did. I think he was one or two years behind me. He's in my brother's class. 56:04 But I didn't know him in high school at all, but have since just connected with him a little bit. 56:08 But when I, when I launched this newsletter, he, uh, he was-- he happened to be in town one week, this was maybe like three weeks ago, and he came by the office and I pulled up my first draft and he, uh, he went through and punched a bunch of holes in it and told me where I was, where I was an idiot and what I should do differently. 56:21 [chuckles] I'm like, "Great. Thanks." That's very helpful. He's, he's a fun guy, and he's very much like... I've only met him a couple times in person, but he's, um... 56:30 And actually, when I was at The Hustle, I didn't work with Sam a lot because it was a, a bigger company, and I reported to someone else, but he's like the exact same guy in person as he is on his podcast and, um, all that stuff too. 56:43 And what I, what I think Sam's superpower is that a lot of people don't realize, a lot of people think of him as like a podcaster or a, um, like a newsletter guy or something. 56:51 But I think-- and he's obviously very good with all that stuff and other things, but I have never seen a better community builder than Sam, and that's like his superpower that no one really realizes. 57:02 His business now is just a community business. And then I got to see it more firsthand when he built the, the Trends product. Do you remember that? 57:09 It was like The Hustle's premium subscription, and it was only around for a couple years because, um, HubSpot shut it down. But I mean, this, this, the community of tr- of inside Tr- of Trends was just a Facebook group. 57:20 It was just a legendary community. So I got to see him like build that and how he did it. 57:23 And I think because people like that community so much, that was definitely one of the reasons that he went to build a business that was just community because he was so good at, and he saw the, the need in the market there. 57:35 But- Yeah... that was-- 57:37 out of all the things I saw him do, like that's, that's probably the most interesting thing I think a lot of people don't realize is just like the power of being a strong community builder is, is really incredible, and it's like a skill set that can't really be taught or no one r-really talks about. 57:50 Yeah. Yeah. No, it's cool. It's been really neat to see that, the Hampton thing. I mean, gosh, it's been only, what, two years, but it seems like he's really gotten a ton of traction and had a lot of success with it. 58:00 Yeah, we interviewed Jordan, the former CEO of Hampton, on this podcast last... two weeks ago maybe. 58:06 Yeah, and they're at-- this isn't from Jordan, but like they've talked about being north of ten million ARR, and they started in 2022. So it's definitely going good. Yeah. That's awesome. That's cool. What else? 58:18 Anything- There's a lot we could cover. We don't have to go over every single thing. 58:22 But, um, yeah, I'm just excited for you to like, to see more co- like more content production, so I think you're always getting ROI on that. The ads are cool. 58:30 So what I would think about is, you've already kind of done this, where like you're creating this really in-depth content that's like worth paying for, and people are paying for that. 58:38 So if you really wanted to scale things up and grow with ads, like, yeah, you can take 25%, 50% of your partnership budget and reinvest that in the ads. 58:45 But like, that only gets you so far because the partnerships are, are gonna grow slowly over time. What's really nice with ads is if you can invest, you know, 58:55 $1, $5, whatever it is to get a lead, and you know within X amount of time you're going to make $10, $20 back from that lead or subscriber. 59:04 And the only true way to do that is, one, to have a very sophisticated sponsorship business, which, which people like The Hustle did and like Fourteen40 Media does, where you know, like, okay, this is my subscriber, my free subscriber lifetime value, and I know every time I send an email, um, when we sell out of ads, we make five cents per open, and then we make this amount per month, and then we retain subscribers for this amount on average. 59:25 I think that's really hard to do. I think it's a lot easier to just like get people on your list and be good at converting them to a customer, and so you know, okay, 1%'s gonna buy this product. 59:34 And so this isn't really gonna be top of mind for you because it's all about deal flow. 59:37 But like, if you, uh-- I think a cool thing to do would be instead of maybe writing those things as like a, a paid newsletter, and you can... Th-th-there's, uh, basically different mediums are priced at different points. 59:48 That's what I'm trying to say. So like, if you write a report and put it in a PDF, like how much can you sell that for? 50 bucks, 100 bucks, 200 bucks. If you do a paid newsletter, how much can you charge for that? 59:58 10 bucks a month, 50 bucks a month, 100 bucks a month. 1:00:02 But if you just took that same content and like put it in slides and recorded that as a video or taught it to someone live, it's the exact same content, but you could charge way more money, essentially. 1:00:10 That's what I'm trying to say. So like the... 1:00:12 When I, I did a course for the very first time, like a, a year ago or two, and a lot of the core material was just like newsletters I've written, but I put them in slides and I added some details and I recorded them. 1:00:22 And the newsletter was free, and I probably couldn't have charged people any more than like 10 bucks a month for that. 1:00:26 But because I did it in a different medium, I was able to charge $1,000 or $2,000 for the same content. 1:00:33 Since then, it's like the content's evolved a lot, but like that's how I started with the course.And so I think, I think if you wanted to just, like, make more money per subscriber, you could do-- I wouldn't say do a course, but you could do, like, a paid webinar, for example, where it's just like you're gonna teach one topic over thirty minutes or act- over sixty minutes probably, and then over the next thirty to sixty minutes afterwards, you're just gonna answer everyone's questions live. 1:00:56 And so it's not, like, a need to do. I wouldn't say it's low-hanging fruit. But, um, I could definitely see a lot of people, uh, paying for that. 1:01:04 And then the thing is, w-when someone pays you something, when they pay to learn from you, I think they're way more likely to become deal flow because they just have a much deeper relationship with you. 1:01:14 They got to learn your system. They got to ask you questions. You know their name and their face now because you interacted with them live, and then later on, like, you know, becoming a partner becomes a lot easier. 1:01:24 Yeah. No, it's interesting. It's an interesting thought. 1:01:26 I mean, ultimately, I-- at this point, the, the incremental monetization from doing that for me is less, uh, exciting than, like, the-- If it doesn't support deal flow or get us more opportunities, I almost wouldn't invest in it, but it is an interesting thought. 1:01:39 Like, are you more likely to build a trusting relationship with somebody who's engaging with you via video or via whatever, you know, as you, you think about other ways to engage with them beyond just your social media and a newsletter. 1:01:50 So to the extent, like, that type of activity would support pipeline building, I like it. 1:01:55 To the extent it would exclusively just be another monetization channel, I'm less, uh, have less need of that so much as I need opportunities. 1:02:02 What it really has to be is you teach something that is only relevant to the people that you would actually wanna partner with. So you're getting those types of customers that would be potential partners. 1:02:12 So you don't teach, like, beginner stuff. You teach whatever's relevant to those people. And then you teach that, you give all the value, you don't hold anything back. 1:02:20 And then at the end, you say, like, "Hey, if you wanna partner with me," whatever the call to action is to, to build that pipeline. Yeah. 1:02:26 You, you spend five minutes actually giving them a call to action to, to partner with you or, or to apply to work with you in some way. Whatever, I don't, I don't know your whole process, but something like that. 1:02:33 So it's like I would definitely have that pipeline call to action inside the paid product. 1:02:39 It's not that the whole thing is a pitch, it's just, like, at the end, tack that on at the end before you get to Q&A, for example. And I've also seen people do this through live events. 1:02:47 It's like instead of doing it on a webinar and charging a hundred bucks or a thousand bucks, they do it at their office or at a location, and they have thirty, fifty, a hundred people, and they charge twenty-five hundred to five thousand dollars. 1:03:00 And they deliver probably more content, but they still have the same pitch at the end. And you get to, like, shake hands, meet people, and that can become deal flow. 1:03:09 So it's-- I don't think, again, it's not the highest priority, but maybe something in the long run that may be cool. We did something like that. 1:03:14 So we actually, behind me over here, we, we bought an adjacent school building. A, a local district was selling their school, and, uh, so it came up for sale. 1:03:22 It was close to us, right next to us, and so we ended up buying this forty-thousand-square-foot school, and we built a really cool, uh, uh, training space, right? Hands-on. It has a bunch of learning labs- Awesome... 1:03:31 it has classrooms, it has gym- has a gymnasium. 1:03:33 But we've done some, uh, partner training where we'll partner with other sort of, uh, organizations that facilitate a lot of leadership training and co-design some stuff with them. 1:03:42 But similarly, we, when we've launched that publicly, we filled up and charged, uh, gosh, what were we charging? It was, it was three or four thousand per seat, uh, in there. Good. 1:03:52 But we were able to fill that up pretty quickly, and was kind of a, a good way to get in front of and connect with, uh, a lot of owners. But to your point, you know, th-that exists as another channel. 1:04:01 I, I think that is an effective way to get in front of folks, uh, and it's an effective way just from our core business, from our, our school function, to be able to monetize a lot of the internal RWD resources we've invested really heavily in. 1:04:12 So kind of two, two-fold purpose there. Yeah. And I, and I like those more in the virtual webinars or trainings if you have the ability to do so. 1:04:19 And it's like if you already have the space, it's so much easier than paying for a space and booking one. 1:04:24 I have a client who's, like, kind of in a similar model to some degree, where he's in the real estate business, and he's-- he has a newsletter that's to attract deal flow, um, to his real estate business, um, or to, or to, or to get investors for him. 1:04:38 Um, but he basically just does a similar thing where he, he sold a workshop. And he has a similar audience, maybe, like, four or five thousand subscribers, different industry. 1:04:47 And he sold a workshop, twenty-five hundred bucks, thirty people. I forget. Maybe that's not the exact price, but somewhere-- he did somewhere between, like, fifty and seventy-five grand in revenue. 1:04:55 And then a lot of people at the event he thinks he's gonna partner with. He just did this, like, this weekend or last weekend, so we'll see how it turns out. Um, but he's like, "Yeah, how do I... 1:05:06 I wanna do more of these." And we're like, "Okay." And we basically helped him on a strategy to basically do one of these. He calls them boot camps. 1:05:11 Do, do one of these boot camps quarterly, increase the price, get more attendees. And I think he can build a, a seven-figure boot camp business 1:05:21 over the next, you know, twelve to eighteen months that actually still serves his main purpose, which is deal flow, essentially, or, or generating business outside of just the media or the boot camp part. Yeah. Yeah. 1:05:33 It's, it's work, but, like, it's work that he enjoys. He's just doing one boot camp a quarter. It's gonna make money, and it's a model I don't see a lot, but I think it's a really smart model. Yep. 1:05:44 Yeah, I've seen a bunch of those pop up around, uh, ETA, like, uh, entrepreneurship through acquisition, a bunch of the boot camps, workshops that, uh, that seem to be getting a lot of traction. 1:05:52 They seem to fill up and sell out different, different sort of events on how to, you know, take someone who's bought and sold a business via ETA, whether it's a sponsored search or independent, and then they, uh, they teach others how to do it. 1:06:03 It seems like they're filling up rooms. [chuckles] Yeah, it's interesting. 1:06:07 I'm not as in that world as much, but, like, you know, I know, uh, I've talked to Walker a little bit, Walker Deibel, who you mentioned in our earlier recording. 1:06:15 He seems to be have-- like, I think he has one of the be- some of the better information about that. 1:06:19 He's-- I don't know if he does in-person stuff, but, like, he's definitely built a big business around helping people do ETA. Everybody knows Cody Sanchez. She's more broad now. 1:06:28 She's built a big business essentially around that. 1:06:30 Her, her, um, she has, like, one product that's, like, ten thousand dollars a year, which is really just focused on that, and she's at, you know, ten million-plus, uh, recurring revenue. I, I don't have insider data. 1:06:43 That's just based off of, like- Yeah... some pretty clear ways to estimate it. So you can see, like, how many customers people have and then take the price- Yeah... and multiply that. 1:06:52 So it's, it's crazy how big some of these community or events businesses can be and- Yeah... get to that level in a pretty short period of time. Yeah. No. Well, that's great. 1:07:00 Well, hey, I've got a, uh, I got a tune I gotta jump to, but I really enjoyed this. I appreciate you- Absolutely... letting me, uh, me interview you and ask you a bunch of great questions. 1:07:07 This was really helpful, and I actually was taking some notes while we were chatting, so I've got some good, good to-dos for me. Yeah. 1:07:13 This was fun to kinda go through all this, and I think, uh, think people will really enjoy listening. You got some very sm-smart questions. 1:07:18 So just where people can find you, Chris Hoffman on Twitter, LinkedIn, and we'll, we'll put a link to the newsletter in the description below. Great. Does that sound good? Love it. All right. I appreciate it. 1:07:27 Thanks, Chris.