Transcript 0:00 Probably the most important thing for publishers to understand is that this is how advertisers are buying. So advertising just gets a lot more valuable whenever you have an audience that's identifiable. 0:11 So what advertisers realized in this process was we need an actual process, we need protocols, so that we can buy and sell first-party data as opposed to third. 0:20 And what they realized really quickly, and it's, it's pretty obvious, is that first-party data is a lot better for targeting than third-party data because it's accurate. [upbeat music] Okay. 0:33 I'm here with Tyler Bishop, the chief marketing officer of Ezoic. How's it going, man? Hey, Matt. How's it going? Thanks for having me on. Thanks for coming. 0:41 Tell people about, like, who you are, what you do, and then I wanna get into, you know, the main thing, what we're gonna talk about, which is how ad revenue is shifting. So this is gonna be pretty interesting. Yeah. 0:55 So I, I guess just to kind of zoom out and give everybody a little bit of an idea of who I am is, uh, so I've been, I've been in the digital publishing space for a little over two decades. 1:05 It's, it's pretty much my whole career. I, I started out, um... I started companies right out of school, and, um, publishing was kind of like my part-time hustle. 1:14 My wife and I were both competing in jujitsu a lot at the time, and jujitsu was, like, a, a field where there wasn't a lot of really good information on the web, and so I started a series of jujitsu websites. 1:24 And, um, marketing was sort of my background, and so the- we actually grew some of those properties to pretty good size and good followings in multiple places. 1:33 And as time went on, I had sold, uh, one of my businesses and had kind of moved on to working in sort of, like, the ad technology and publishing technology spaces. 1:43 And, you know, it's kind of funny being able to sit on both sides of the fence and just seeing how things can help each other, can take away from each other, where there's a lot of things that I think are, I would say unnecessarily complex, but they're complex on purpose. 1:57 And I think that partially it's you've seen over the last couple decades, the barriers sort of for getting into publishing or being successful in publishing, there's all these things that kind of get added on. 2:09 You know, over the years there's been things like ads.txt. 2:11 Uh, m- I mean, I'm old enough to remember mobile first, when all, all of a sudden Google started telling everybody they needed to have a mobile friendly website and things like that. 2:19 So what we've seen over time, I think, is that, you know, my career has evolved along with this industry, and so hopefully I can bring a little bit of clarity to things that, you know, I think are big opportunities for publishers right now. 2:30 Yeah. I think when a lot of people hear the word ad tech, 2:34 they kind of glaze over, and they're like, "I know there's a lot of money in advertising, and I know I could probably do a lot better job, but this, there's, like, a lot of con- confusing stuff, and I'm not quite sure where to start." 2:44 Yeah. I think... Yeah. I was gonna say, I think, like I was telling you before we got on, I think it's a feature, not a bug, you know? 2:50 That this space is complex 'cause there's a lot of intermediaries, and some of them add value and some of them don't. 2:56 And I think, you know, even somebody that sits to where we are, where we can see everything, you know, it, it's even not necessarily a straightforward answer then. 3:04 So yeah, there's a lot to navigate, and I would say it's, it's definitely grown so, uh, over the years. Why do you think there is a shift in programmatic ad revenue to newsletters? 3:15 We were talking about this earlier, but, like, what, what is that and why is that happening? So if we can kind of go back a little bit. 3:22 So well over a decade ago, Google, Facebook, the big tech platforms, they called it, kind of sold the dream to advertisers. 'Cause before that you had... 3:31 and when it came to display advertising and programmatic, which is basically going on the internet and through a platform like a Google AdWords or something like that, advertisers would essentially buy a, you know, like, an audience from contextual or some other form of, like, targeting, but, you know, they would fi- everybody that has the keyword of, you know, uh, applesauce, that would be a weird thing, but, you know, if I'm, you know, marketing my applesauce, uh, a- across display networks, that might be something that I do. 4:01 So they all of a sudden, they decided that because they had this enormous reach, what they could do is they could get, you know, advertisers to start putting tags on their pages that would track users. 4:12 And what they would do then, uh, is then they started something like AdSense out. 4:16 They started having, you know, all this publi- all these publishers start to put display ads on their website so they could make money, and they realized, like, "Hey, we've got a really big network here. 4:26 You can actually target the same visitors because we've cookied them across websites, and we'll sell you advertisers these audiences, and they're way better..." 4:34 They, they sold the dream of they're way better than contextual, they're way better than any other form of targeting 'cause look, we know it's that person that was on your website earlier. We've cookied them. We're sure. 4:44 So that dream got sold to advertisers, and it became the way that almost all programmatic ad buying, which is billions and billions of dollars a year, gets spent by advertisers, so they've got accustomed to it. 4:53 So over the, the last decade, you know, I think that there's a fair amount of skepticism from publishers around how good is some of that data sometimes. 5:01 Google, and if you've ever set up an ad campaign in one of their platforms or Facebook, you know, there's a lot of, you know, audiences like your audience type thing that goes on, and I think those get hidden in there, and publ- and advertisers are relatively skept- skeptical of that. 5:15 Then you started having things like Cambridge Analytica. Do you remember that? Whenever Facebook kind of got in trouble for some of that. Been a long time. I forget a lot of the details, but you can... 5:25 If you wanna share a little bit about that, that'd be interesting. So Cambridge Analytica was a, uh... 5:30 it was kind of a scandal because you had a research firm, I believe out of the UK, I'd have to double-check, that was collecting user data off of Facebook using, using it to profile psychologically users, and then I think they were targeting them with maybe political ads or something like that. 5:44 And that was kind of the first sort of, like, into the public sphere, this sort of, like, this idea of, like, well, hey, data privacy. Like, who's getting my data? Who, who has it? Why? 5:55 Apple sort of realized in sort of competition with these players that, hey, we have a significant amount of the populace that uses our devices. 6:03 We can actuallyWe can control this, and that gives us a little bit of leverage over the Facebooks and the Googles of the world. 6:09 So Apple started, uh, over time blocking third-party cookies on Safari and on, uh, on all their devices by default. Um, a lot of people think, "Oh, well, Safari browsers, I use Chrome on my mobile device." 6:22 Almost every browser is actually Safari on an Apple device. It, the Chrome, uh, a lot of them, they're all sort of like they have to use Apple's SDK for a browser, software development kit. 6:33 So they, they all end up being sort of like kind of a Safari wrapper really, and what that means is, is that today you've got the majority of mobile traffic has no third-party cookies. 6:46 And Google finally joined the party due to basically everybody kind of shouting at them for the last few years as everybody sort of started saying, "We're gonna start blocking third-party cookies by default." 6:58 That's why you had all these cookie banners and things like that. You've even had legislation like California's CCPA where it says you have to be able to delete user data upon request. 7:09 Europe's GDPR, uh, these things are, uh, uh, they're a mess because they put all this sort of like regulatory burden on the publisher to track and get approval from people if they wanna track and collect their data. 7:20 And so it's, it's a pretty big disappointment, uh, if you're a publisher, all this different regulation, and it really hasn't done anything to hinder big tech until now. 7:29 Because the big thing that's shifted here recently is Google said they were gonna depreciate the third-party cookie. 7:34 They kinda didn't, and so you go, "Okay, well, if I'm a publisher, you know, everything is just gonna stay the same, right?" The thing that's really shifted in our industry is that 7:44 advertisers sort of saw this coming, and they realized, like, "Hey, I've gotten really accustomed to being able to buy my audiences programmatically, um, go in, you know, just say I want to just retarget my audience. 7:57 I don't wanna have to try to figure out contextual or figure out clever ways to try to target them. I wanna do it the way that I've always known." 8:03 And one way that kind of classically across almost every space, private, secure, user-friendly, regulatorily, like thumbs up, is the idea that you can use first-party data. 8:15 So first-party data versus third-party is first-party data is it's my website. You come to it, you sign up for my newsletter. I have your email. That's first-party data. 8:26 Uh, third-party data would be like somebody goes to your website, they give you their email, um, and then you give it to me, and then I use it. So that's third party. 8:36 So I'm getting it secondhand from you, and I'm gonna use it for some other purpose. Advertising, let's say in this case. Yeah. 8:44 So first-party data means it's data that you've collected, so if you're a newsletter publisher, that's your list. 8:49 If you have, uh, an app where you, uh, have an online game or you have like, um, you know, gated content or something like that, any of those registered users, any of that data, that's your first-party data. 9:01 And so what advertisers realized in this process was we need an actual process, we need protocols so that we can buy and sell first-party data as opposed to third. 9:11 Uh, and what they realized really quickly, and it's, it's pretty obvious, is that first-party data is a lot better for targeting than third-party data because it's accurate. 9:20 You know exactly who it is, and they have a better relationship with the publisher. Now, here's the thing that I think is all these circumstances, they're all the big tech in this space sorta has like always-- 9:32 Publishers have been just kind of forced to go whatever direction. Th-they don't have negotiation power. 9:36 I mean, you think about it, it's like, I mean, how many times have you had a chance to write, you know, Google or Facebook or Amazon an email and make a suggestion to them, you know? Would you even think- Not many... 9:46 to do something like that? And- No. [laughs] Never, right? It s- it seems like it'd be a waste of your time, and, um, yeah, that's, that's sort of what it's been. 9:55 But because of all these different things and them sort of positioning themselves against each other, what you've wound up with is advertisers sort of like going around and saying, "Hey, we need a m-method to sell and buy first-party data." 10:07 First-party data brings that, you know, advantage. Now there's a roadway, if you will, for publishers to sell directly to advertisers. And before, if you think about it, you have a tag on your website. 10:18 People come, and then you're able to retar-- you know, sell display ads and make money from them and things like that. Um, but the problem is, is that when advertisers go to buy, you know, 10:30 seemingly your ad space, the, the ads that are gonna show on your website, they don't actually know that they're buying from you. So what they do is they go in and say, "I wanna retarget my audience." 10:39 Well, their audience is everywhere. It's on your website. It's on Bill's website. It's everywhere. And so they just buy an audience, so it's all the same. It's a commodity. It's like gasoline. 10:50 But what happens is, is that whenever it becomes first-party data, all of a sudden you're selling directly to the advertiser, and so that means that your audience is your audience. 10:59 They're not buying, you know, like, your audience across a bunch of different websites. Like, it has real value, and so that costs a premium. So advertisers like it because it's better. 11:08 They know exactly where their ads are showing up. They know what audience they're buying. It's the one that they want, and there's no middlemen in the form of big tech here. 11:15 Now, there's a lot of nuance to this to where, you know, like there are different intermediaries and protocols that are in place, but essentially that's the direction that things are going, and that's a good way to think about first-party data versus third. 11:27 First-party data is the lists and people that you collect, and the big opportunity now is there's actually a way to use that to work directly with advertisers so that they can buy ads programmatically through you versus buying them through- Hmm... 11:40 Google. And, um, it's, it's really the last few years that this has matured. It really hasn't existed in the form that it is now. 11:47 And advertisers, if you look at it, I think it's like eighty percent say that they're going to prioritize first-party data this year, and, and even larger amounts said they're only buying first-party data, um, this year. 11:59 Got it. 11:59 So it, it really is the shift in advertising, and it's kind of a-- it's a big one, and no one has really talked about it as much as I think they probably should.I wanna break it down a little bit more, but I also wanna recap a couple things for people who are a little bit new to this and so 12:16 back maybe before the, the cookie, you had contextual targeting. So I have a blog post about applesauce, 12:24 I can have a tag on my website that, you know, has the content of that blog post, and an advertiser who wants to advertise, you know, on content about applesauce can do so. So that's contextual targeting. 12:35 And then we have cookie or, or pixel-based targeting, which is tracking the user with third-party data. I might be getting some of this wrong, but I want you to correct me. Around the web essentially. 12:46 So and that's what most people still see now, right? You know, you- Yeah... 12:48 you go to an e-commerce store to look at a certain product, then you go to websites or blogs or whatever, and you'll probably see some display ads or programmatic ads for that content, is they're retargeting you. 13:00 And it seems like that's maybe the biggest use case for website programmatic is retargeting. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And retargeting is super powerful, right? Someone's already... 13:11 They, they already know you, they're a warm audience essentially, you're gonna have a much higher conversion rate to a sale or, well, any type of conversion in, with a retargeting ad versus a, an ad to, to absolute cold traffic or a cold audience, right? 13:23 And so that's why it's been so dominant over the past, I guess, over 10 years at this point. Um, but now things are changing. You know, Apple has app tracking transparency, which you referred to, right? 13:36 Where you don't have that, um, that cookie on the website or the cookie doesn't work at least, and then Google- They blocked it... seems like they're move... They blocked it. 13:47 Google seems like they're moving away from the cookie too. It hasn't happened yet, but- They, they, they-... it seems inevitable. 13:53 Well, this is the big benefit that publishers have gotten, and it's kind of how Google has mishandled this a little bit, is they've threatened it for... 14:00 I mean, literally, I think I've got an email from 2018 where they said, like, "By 2019, January 1, cookies are gone, so prepare yourselves." And then I think it was earlier this week... 14:12 I mean, and they've gone back and forth, and they've pushed the date back further and further, and I think finally they said, "We're, we're, we're not gonna now. We're not gonna depreciate it." 14:20 And I think the re- part of the reason is that I think in this process I thought that they were pretty sure that they could come up with something that they could force all of the industry into using, but Google has built such a strong grip, uh, over the years on programmatic to where you've got a lot of players in the space. 14:37 Like, one of the things that everyone uses is Google's ad server, Google Ad Manager, which used to be Google DoubleClick for publishers, but they changed the name to Ad Manager and it made things very confusing. 14:49 But Ad Manager allowed basic- is the only ad server that allows access to Google's, what they call Ad Exchange. So publishers may be familiar with something like, uh, AdSense. 14:59 So AdSense is an ad network, so, like, to avoid, like, all the conflation and convolution that can happen here, an ad network is essentially somebody that has, like, a relationship with advertisers and publishers. 15:13 You can kind of think of it as like a broker, right? And so I know a lot of advertisers, I know a lot of publishers, like, they both wor- work with me. 15:21 So working with an ad network the size of Google and AdSense is a great idea. Now, there's a lot of ad networks. 15:28 I mean, there's li- there used to be literally thousands, and they've all sort of, like, kind of repositioned themselves in different ways throughout the industry, but you can kind of think of it as, "Well, I don't wanna work with one, I maybe wanna work with, like, a lot of them, but how do I make sure that, like, you know, I'm getting the best deal all the time?" 15:44 You have what's called, like, an exchange. Um, so an exchange is basically all the ad networks basically compete whenever something is for sale. So Google's Ad Exchange is by far the largest. 15:53 You know, compe- competitors go into Google's Ad Exchange, and Google required that everybody use their ad server if they wanted to use their exchange. 16:02 So you've kind of forced everybody into this sort of tunnel where they have to use a lot of Google technology, and there's been a fair amount of, you know, innovation and also sort of, uh, questioning, I think, over the years about how fair is that competitive environment when Google has all the data, they're also, you know, they're a competitor as well as the one that are owning the ecosystem and the technology that both the advertiser and the publisher have to use to display these ads. 16:25 And so I think that they were fairly sure along the way, like, "Hey, we can come up with a first-party data sort of, like, rule set that everybody else will have to play along with and, you know, it'll just be business as usual." 16:38 Well, the problem is, is that I think, you know, when this started happening, Google would propose things that they thought were, you know, like, something that everybody would go along with, and the industry in advertising, they've, they kinda had enough and they were like, "No, we don't like that idea. 16:52 We want something that's more open." And that's sort of what we've gotten. 16:55 We've, we've gotten what, uh, is kind of collectively referred to as identity pro- protocols, which is basically a way of preserving privacy when all this stuff happens. 17:06 So you've got a list of emails for your newsletter, you probably, like, value those. Those are probably some of the most important things for your business, right? Yep. 17:14 You, you wouldn't just, like, give them away to somebody or you wouldn't wanna compromise them because, yeah, it's like it- that's your audience, right? Absolutely. 17:23 So the identity protocol sort of protects that a little bit. So the idea behind it is all that l- the list that you have, before it goes anywhere, it gets hashed. 17:33 So you can kinda think of it, it's not the same thing as encryption, but it's like encryption in that it basically- Yeah. Familiar... 17:39 mixes it all up, and then you take your part of the encryption and you put it up to one of these identity pro- providers that then does the same thing with an advertiser that has basically the other half of that hashed email, and they sort of pair them up together in the cloud. 17:55 And so that way, the advertiser and the publisher both keep their lists, they never go anywhere else, and you basically have these sort of, like, keys that are attached to, you know, an email address or a phone number or something like that, that then gets matched, you know, without anybody else that aren't, you know, basically publisher or advertiser side-Having any, you know, intuition around who that might be, and then that's how your, the targeting takes place now. 18:21 And that- that's sort of like both a kind of a like very granular look, and then sort of like kind of a step back look at why things have happened this way, in particular around first party data. Okay. 18:33 So we can still do retargeting without cookies and third-party data by using a method like this, right? 18:42 Yeah, you can use- So as long as the advertiser knows who they wanna retarget, they have first party data on them, they can match that to a publisher and still retarget them with this method. That's correct. 18:51 And the other thing that I think we found that's really interesting about this, and it's one of the things that, uh, you know, I think is probably the most important thing for publishers to understand is that this is how advertisers are buying. 19:03 And because of the way that the ad space works is that you've got a small number of parties that are really the most relevant as it relates to when you have a visitor on your site, whether they come from, you know, your newsletter, or they're, you know, somebody that maybe came through a marketing campaign or something and they're visiting for the first time. 19:22 What you have is somebody that's on that page, and maybe you have their email, maybe you don't, and if you're retargeting them, uh, as an advertiser or you can maybe even think of it as, you know, like you're just trying to reach somebody like that person, you have to kind of decide if you're one of these really popular like ad exchanges or networks. 19:40 Um, I'm getting millions and millions of requests for bids all the time, like which ones do I wanna prioritize? 19:46 And the answer is, is like the ones that, you know, have identity protocols just set up which means like, "Hey, I have an audience that, that's for sale. 19:55 This visitor on here now might not be somebody that I recognize, however I have this set up because I do have an audience." 20:02 That's a really big quality marker for both advertisers who look at it like, this is somebody that's not clearly trying to commit some kind of like bid fraud which is... 20:10 I mean, depending on who you ask it's like, it's like steroids in sports. It's like how much ad fraud is there in the space between 80% and 20%, you know? 20:19 It's like you have your people that it's like it's all fraud, and then you have your people that are like, "No, there's almost none." 20:25 It's probably in the middle, but if you're an advertiser you're looking to cut it out any way you can. 20:30 So by being set up to sell directly with advertisers and use first party data, it's a pretty big quality signal to advertisers. 20:38 So what we've seen is y- we've seen revenue on average be about 20 to 25% higher from programmatic advertising just because of the setup with first party data. 20:50 And then when the users are identified, you're looking at probably making about double what you would make from like traditional third party cookies. 20:58 So advertising just gets a lot more valuable whenever you have an audience that's identifiable like, you know, you have a newsletter, or logged in users, or something like that, regardless of whether or not- Yeah... 21:08 the user that's on the page is somebody that is, you know, known to you or not. So let's break that down. So 25 even up to double, um, 25% higher or even twice the increase. Is that the increase on the CPM or the RPM? 21:23 Like what's the, what's the metric that you use- Yeah, yeah... to measure that? 21:27 So for, for publishers it would be RPM, but, you know, I always kind of look at it as RPM is rate, so that rate's what you pay, what you get paid, and C, CPM, is cost, so that's what you pay. 21:37 So advertiser metrics- Got it... 21:39 are CPMs and publisher metrics are RPMs, and they get used interchangeably in our space, but I always like to point it out because they, they, they can mean slightly different things, and, um, it's just all the little tricky things that the, this industry has inside of it. 21:53 But yeah- [laughs]... 25% higher RPMs, uh, traditionally if you are just setting these things up, and then, yeah, you're looking at double, uh, for your identified visitors. 22:04 So the, the actual uplift total is gonna be somewhere in between on average. And then RPM is, is revenue per 1,000 users? Is that the right definition? Yeah, rate per mil. So if you're like, wait a minute, mil? Thousand? 22:19 Uh, mil means thousand, and I think it's Latin. So that's how old- Yep... 22:24 a lot of things in advertising are, is we're paying for, uh, a Latin word for thousand and impressions which impressions refer to, you know, like impressing the ads physically on some, a physical piece of paper or, you know, something like that, and neither of those things exist anymore [laughs]. 22:42 For the most- Yeah, that's funny. And mil is like still used for, for so many terms now. Okay, so and then what, um... 22:50 This, this might be a hard question to answer, but like your typical publisher who has AdSense or some type of programmatic on their site without first party data like we discussed, what type of RPMs are they seeing? 23:01 And it depends a ton on the vertical industry niche, how many ads they wanna display on the site, but do you have any ballparks for what that can look like? Yeah, so it, it, it depends. 23:11 Uh, I always tell people between $1 and $1,000 because it depends that much. 23:16 Uh, I'll give you a couple examples, but I, I'll kind of give you maybe like the better answer to the question, uh, that you asked, which is, you know, like what is the difference between, you know, various essentially like options and available solutions? 23:28 So like something like AdSense is working with a, a single ad network, probably one of the best, um, just because it's Google and they have such a huge wealth of advertisers. 23:37 I always say like, how many advertisers are out there running a programmatic campaign and they're not running anything through Google? Very few. But the, the thing that kind of... 23:48 So you go, oh well, like how much different can it be? You know, how many advertisers, how much competition is there if, you know, I were to use two ad networks, so let's say. 23:57 The thing is, is that a lot of these other networks and intermediaries that advertisers will use or buy through, or even publishers can kind of like tap into, is they're providing more data. 24:06 So like Google only might have a really limited amount of data on somebody, but you might have a, you know, like an ad network or what they call like a DSP, uh, demand side platform[chuckles] It's an advertiser's- Yep... 24:20 like buying tool, and they may have like, uh, all Verizon customer data or something like that for whatever reason, and that data may actually like p- prove really helpful for an advertiser 'cause they might say, "Well, well, now with this context, I'm willing to bid a lot more because that's exactly who might be shopping for a Lexus today," or whatever it is. 24:40 And so you've got AdSense, which, you know, is a really good ad network, but w- what you really want is you want as much good data on users and as much access to advertising campaigns that are just running broadly off of programmatic as possible. 24:55 So you're talking about the, the uplift from something like an AdSense to a more sophisticated, what they call, like ad stack. 25:01 You're looking at, you know, you might be able to m- depending on how good the site is, you might be able to double revenue just in something like that. Interesting. And then on top... 25:11 So then on top of that, you might say, "Well, I have a pretty good audience, and I might not be able to go out and sell direct deals to advertisers myself." So like if I, if I call Coca-Cola up and say, "Hey, 25:24 do you want to run some ads in my newsletter?" 25:27 No one at Coca-Cola is answering the phone because they're like, "Likson, I spend $50 million a quarter on ads, and 49 million of that 50 go into, you know, Google and whoever, and I spend, you know, like 10 minutes thinking about that extra million that I put, like wherever else." 25:44 Um, but when they go on, they go, "Hey, look, I set aside some of my programmatic budget for really good ad space, and I want to basically buy from maybe a handful of like niche places that like look like really good spots for my audience." 26:00 So you can actually set up these things called programmatic direct, which mean... 26:04 You know, private marketplace deal that allows basically then advertisers to go and see like these buckets of sites that have said, "I've set aside my better ad space," you know, the big spot at the top of the page or something like that, for premium advertisers. 26:18 And that may give you like another, I don't know, anywhere from 10 to 40% bump just by having something like that set up. 26:26 And then you've got what we just talked about, which is with first-party data, which on top of all those other things, let's say you've done all those other sort of like, you know, check those boxes somehow, then you've got implementing first-party data, which on top of that, you know, you're looking at 20 to 25% instantly off of being able to get into some of these places that might not be taking your bids or allowing you even access to the advertisers to bid on the inventory because your, your requests are getting timed out because, you know, they don't know if you're a good enough sort of like request bid for the advertisers. 26:59 And then you've got, you know, the 50%, uh, uplift or the doubling of your revenue just from, from the visitors that actually are on your list, the audience that is known, because advertisers are so thirsty for this right now and there's way more demand than there is supply. 27:13 Because it's, it's, it's really a pain in the ass to set this up as a publisher, a huge pain in the ass. Got it. Before we... I wanna dive into like why it's, that's a challenge, but, um, for people who... 27:25 There's people listening who they have a lot of website traffic, they have a valuable audience both in their newsletter and website, but they're not running any type of website programmatic or display. 27:36 Like what are the advantages to doing so? You know, what type of... I know we can't really predict RPMs, but maybe if they're in like the financial niche, they might expect this range or something. 27:46 Like why should they go out and implement programmatic if they haven't done it before? Maybe they're selling ads directly in their newsletter website or selling another type of product. 27:55 So- Like why set this up if you haven't yet? So m- my advice... So I, I mean, I'm, I'm pretty staunch on this. Uh, it- so one of the things about me is I'm an artist, and I'm an artist in that like, uh, I always tell... 28:10 I've told investors over the years, I was like, "Look, this is what I wanna do. I wanna build this, or I wanna make this, or I want this business to be successful." 28:17 I'm sure a lot of the people listening to this, I think publishing is a very pure-spirited s- so, for the, s- uh, form of like, uh, making a living in that like you're usually passionate about whatever it is you do, and so you have a perspective on it. 28:29 And that perspective means, like I, I've told people before like, "Look, I, I don't know a lot of businesses that set out to have a great business and that makes them something that like is actually valuable." 28:38 It's like usually somebody sets out to solve some type of problem, and that ends up meaning they're a really valuable business. 28:44 And I would say that, you know, if you're a publisher and you started out on this, I look at this entire space and I go, "Okay, realistically, if we look at..." We can go back thousands of years, um, literally thousands. 28:59 You can find ads on stone tablets, and the reason why that works is because, uh, I'm, I'm pretty, I'm pretty staunch about this because I, I, I believe it, it's that the advertising model is kind of perfect, and it gets mutated, and it gets manipulated, and it can... 29:13 We all have beefs about advertising. There's things that I hate about it. 29:16 It's like, you know, I personally, like I've always had this idea that if everybody in the entire space just decided one ad, like one ad on a website, advertisers can only buy one ad at a time, ads would literally cost probably like 100x more than they do, but they'd be more effective. 29:34 Publishers would make more from single... Like everybody would win with that, but it's kind of like, you know, it only takes one to mess that up, and we- [chuckles] Yeah... 29:41 we have adflation, which is basically you have the opposite thing occurring, which is Google and Facebook and the like, you know, they, they all just, they wanna make sure that they keep being able to sell, you know, more and more of what they've got. 29:55 There's more demand for advertising every year, and advertising executives have, you know, bonuses tied to keeping CPMs low and dumb things like that. 30:03 And so the only way to keep the prices low while flooding the market with more of it is to devalue it. Um, and so that's, that's how we've gotten to where we're at. 30:11 And so if you go, "I, I just don't want any part in that," my, my whole thing is that the model works because it's a really, really good one. It's passive. It's like the user pays nothing. They get the content for free. 30:21 You know, the, the publisher gets paid a fair wage for creating something of value, and the advertiser wins because they reach the audience that they want.And because of that, that fair trade-off, I think that there's a place in ads for everything. 30:32 We- we're talking to a ton of e-commerce companies right now that are trying to figure out, like, you know, during the checkout phase or in different parts of their site, like, does it make sense to show ads here? 30:42 We- we've specialized in machine learning for a really long time and being able to figure these things out, what affects user behavior. 30:48 And one of the things that we've learned is that, you know, ads have an impact on user behavior sometimes. Sometimes yes, sometimes no. Sometimes it's really big, sometimes it's really small, sometimes it's not at all. 31:01 Um, but knowing the difference between when that is and when it's not, it, it makes a significant difference because it's the difference between leaving, you know, maybe, you know, half your revenue on the table or not. 31:13 And so I think it's one of those things to where it's like if you're s- to me, it's a no-brainer. It's you, you should be making money from advertising, even if it's in a limited form and a small percentage of revenue. 31:23 I use "Hot Ones" as an example, the, the YouTube sh- show. They make 85% of their revenue from selling hot sauce. I love it. I like the show. I've, I've had them on stage- Right... 31:32 at events that we've been at and talked to them, uh, at length about it. I love that business model. I wish every publisher could just sell hot sauce. Um, but I don't think it's gonna work so well. 31:41 It works great for them. If you, if you happen to be, you know, in a unique position where you can sell something or there's a model that's just very unique to you, I think that that's what you lean into. 31:52 But I, I also think that there's an opportunity with, with advertising that isn't, I, I don't think should, should be ignored. I think it... 32:00 And it also protects you long term, I think, as well, because it's a, it's a form of revenue that really can't go away. Yeah. 32:06 And my feeling on it is like, I think you should sell your own stuff and other people's stuff too. 32:12 So like, I think it's you wanna monetize 100% of your audience with advertising, which is why it's so awesome, and you also wanna monetize, you know, 1% to 10% of your audience to a higher degree by selling a product directly. 32:24 Now, there are some companies that just pick one of those, and they do great, but most media companies should be doing both to some degree. 32:31 And a lot of people I talk to just have no website ads at all, even though they have a lot of valuable website traffic, and so I think that's a missed opportunity. 32:39 Even if your newsletter is the primary thing, you know, let's still take advantage of the website real estate too. It doesn't have to be 10 ads on every page. 32:47 But even now, you know, a lot of people also feel like, you know, website programmatic just isn't what it used to be. 32:53 There's some publishers I've talked to, especially like MarketBeat, that are seeing like this, you know, display and programmatic is, is becoming a, a bigger percentage of their revenue than it was in the previous five years. 33:04 Yeah. So it's not dead by any means. I- I've heard that for like a decade, so this, this idea. So if anybody's interested, you can go to adrevenueindex.ezoic.com. It's industry recognized. Everybody says it's accurate. 33:16 Pe- people even that don't, like, you know, that would, I would say, are competitors or competitive with us in the industry all give us props for it. 33:23 So we've tracked ad revenue rates that publishers collect across the globe for, uh, about eight years now. 33:30 And outside of like the kind of like economic dip after COVID, 'cause it kind of like really surged during, what you see is that ad rates have just been going up pretty much in a linear fashion for a long time. 33:41 You can see the seasonality of it. So in any given part of the year, like if you look at January compared to, you know, like November, you know, like every year is down, you know? 33:52 But if you flip that and you go look at November, it used to be, and th- na- it, this past year is another great example, we set the record on Black Friday, and every year the record for amount of money that publishers make from advertisers programmatically gets broken on Black Friday. 34:06 We had an exception, I think, in 2023, uh, but since then it's, you know, every year, boom, record, record, record. And that's because advertising follows global GDP. 34:16 So you think about it, there's more people in the world. Countries are continuing to evolve, become more industrialized, so the gross domestic product of the world, uh, goes up every year. 34:28 Advertising is a percentage of that because advertising is, it's this organic sort of like ami- amalgamous sort of like underlying thing that lives in the economy where advertising does work, believe it or not. 34:40 Like, we all sort of know it. Um, some of us don't wanna recognize when maybe we're influenced by it. 34:45 But the thing is, is that advertising works, and because of that, that percentage just follows the same percentage with GDP going up. 34:52 So ad dollars keep going up, and so then the only question you have to ask around something like programmatic is, are advertisers spending more or less on digital? Because they're spending more overall. 35:02 So sure, they're spending more money on things like maybe podcasts or things like, um, you know, connected TV, being able to buy ads on Netflix or Hulu or something that- Yeah... maybe was harder to do before. 35:14 Um, but that's TV's budget and video budget. Programmatic is still stealing revenue from print and a lot of those other sources. 35:21 So what we've seen is the opposite, is that programmatic revenue's gotten a lot more lucrative. Now, the thing is, is it used to be you could throw ad tags on your website and really clean up on what was available. 35:32 Like we kinda, I walked you through the stages earlier of like, you know, you're basically doubling each layer of s- more and more sophistic, complex tech and sort of like protocol that you're adding on top of it. 35:43 So I would say the difference between, you know, somebody that's just running programmatic and somebody that's doing it enterprise level is, you know, you're talking about literally maybe 5 to 10X difference in the amount of money that you're making from it. 35:58 That's an important thing to note, you know, just kind of doing the basics and then doing it at the enterprise level, 5 to 10X more revenue from the ads is a huge difference. 36:07 So I wanted to, I wanna talk about how people can do that in a second, but also what's like the, um, when it says like network index, and it says, you know, 54 or 73 or something, like what's that number mean? Is that- 36:19 Yeah. So it's a composite. So what we do is we normalize sort of ad rates across publishers of all different sizes and things like that and take out outliers. 36:28 So you can kind of think of it as like conglomerative average. So like-One to 100. So like how good were ad rates on this day? It was a 54. Eh, you know, like pretty, pretty average, you know? 36:40 So 100 would mean it's a record, so there's only 100 on the board. One, I've never seen it, but, um, it, it would- Yep... basically mean that nobody made any money that day. 36:50 So what you're kind of s- what you should see as an average is basically like 50 across the board. 36:55 So if you see on March 13th that it's, you know, 48, it's like on that day, you know, you're seeing that publishers on average collected less money than they have over the course of whatever the timeframe is that you're looking at. 37:08 Now, if you're looking at, you know, something and it's like 68, that means on average publishers are making more than they were, you know, on average over the course of the history of the index. 37:17 So it's actually kind of... 37:19 It, it's really kind of a tricky thing to try to figure out, and I remember when we first set it up, there was a lot of people in the industry that were really grateful because as a publisher, you don't know, like I said before, like, what's a good CPM between a dollar and $1,000? 37:32 Like, I know two websites that both publish content on Apple technology, and they make... The difference between them in revenue is one makes twice as much as the other one. 37:42 It's the type of content and where the audience come from that makes that difference. The content itself and the sites, you wouldn't know by looking at them. 37:49 So if you're the one that's making half as much, you're going, you know, am I making a bad amount? Or if my revenue goes down or up, is that a good thing? Did everybody else's go down? Did everybody else's go up? 38:00 It's a good tool for that because I think that's the question that we see the most is, is- Yeah... is everybody else seeing this or is it just me? And we'll put that in the description below, too. That's a great tool. 38:10 And then before I get into the, the next question, like, when you said, like, type of content and where the audience is coming from, can you share an example of that? 38:17 Like, this type of content, this audience source is going to be able to be monetized more. What does that mean? Yeah. So i- you think about it in terms of just value. 38:28 So I think a lot of times we frame these things in terms of, like, an advertiser's making these decisions. It's machines that make these decisions most of the time. 38:35 It's not like an advertiser's going, "I think that's a good person, I think that's a bad person, um, for my audience." And I think the way that you can look at it is, let's say you're searching for, um, 38:47 you know, maybe you're looking for, um, instructions on how to install, like, a new air filter in a lawnmower or something like that, so you, you type it into something like a search engine. 38:56 You go to a website, and now you see maybe ads for air filter related stuff or something like that. 39:02 Um, and advertisers are bidding on that audience, and so all they're bidding on in that case maybe is, you know, the person, the visitor's coming from a search engine, Google. 39:10 Um, and maybe there's something contextual or maybe I'm, you know, I've targeted that person on my air filter site. Either way, they're seeing the same ads on the page. Um, but let's say not... 39:19 So that's, that's a commodity user, I would say. So they're coming from a search engine. 39:23 They didn't come to that website directly, meaning, like, it's not like that's their go-to website for information, news, you know, expertise. 39:30 It's like that just happened to be the one that Google said, "Hey, this might have the information you're looking for." 39:35 Now let's say that's a mechanic, and they're actually working on a vehicle, so they are somebody that is a professional, and perhaps they come to the site directly because they're like, "Look, this is the automotive expert that I trust. 39:49 This is his site or his parts index or something like that." 39:53 Uh, so they come directly, so the advertiser is gonna see that, and they're gonna go, "Okay, well, this is somebody that came to the site directly for that information. Maybe it sh- has some form of expertise." 40:03 And they're gonna see the same ads with the same content, uh, but you have two visitors with different context there. 40:09 Now, like I said, if you look at it through the view of the advertiser, it makes sense sort of, like, logically to us, but the thing is, is it also makes sense in reality, and that's how these machines are gonna work. 40:19 So over time, what you're gonna find is those people that come directly, those experts, they're gonna click on more stuff, they're gonna buy more things, they're gonna revisit that advertiser's site 'cause they go back on their phone later on and they're like, "I want to check out that thing that I saw that ad for on Matt's site," or whatever it is. 40:35 And so these things actually do work in reality, and the machines are really good of keeping track of it. 40:41 And so with lots of data over time, that's how you start to see something where you would have, like, maybe a direct visitor being worth a lot more on one site than a search visitor or something like that. And- Yeah... 40:51 that's why you, you can actually see ad rates change over time for sites, partially because this data gets collected and advertisers are able to see campaign performance across history. Is there, like, if... 41:03 Is there a way to stack rank, like, the value of traffic by source? You know, maybe direct is number one, search number two, is social number three? I don't know, I'm just kind of listing out, you know. 41:14 I'm trying to think 'cause we, we... I've got a, I've got a study up on our website somewhere on this from a couple years ago. 41:19 So for every s- I would always say, like, broadly I can, I can give you sort of, like, a good estimate of how these things work, but for every single site, like, you could be just the exact opposite, just, it just depends. 41:32 But usually you can make some of these determinations yourself better than, than I could. 41:36 So, like, direct audience or email, you know, things that, that would basically declare this audience is coming here specifically to my site, that's kind of, you know, universally the best. Google search is not bad. 41:48 It's, it's actually pretty good. It's better than some forms of social a lot of times. Yeah. I remember a long time ago Pinterest traffic being worth a lot on average, but again, it d- it, it sort of depends. 41:59 And you can kind of, like, start to think of it in terms of how many peop- w- what is the percentage of fraud that is likely to come through this traffic source, you know, to a site like mine? 42:09 And then you can kind of work backwards from there. 42:11 You know, there's a difference, too, between direct and unknown, so direct means we know that they came directly, whether it's, you know, they typed it into the search bar or they had it bookmarked, and then they get to the site and we have no idea how it got there. 42:25 Um, it's another great reason why first-party data is so helpful. 42:28 It's 'cause first-party data allows you to at least be like, "Look, I know this person and they know me," versus, you know, you have Safari blocking cookies and all user data. 42:37 An advertiser has to just take a shot in the dark and say, "We don't know where this person came from." 42:41 It's like-I mean, we're all-- I would say we're all very skeptical because now, I mean, you think about what a bot is e- with AI and the ability to crawl stuff, what's to take, 42:52 you know, me setting up an automated thing on my phone here and just letting it go just browse the web? It's my phone. 43:00 Like, how, how are you gonna know that's not me as an advertiser or a publisher or anybody else because, you know, it's a robot being me, but it's not me. 43:10 There's, there's not any value in that as an advertiser, and so you have to be able to figure out, how do I sort through that without, you know, getting rid of being able to buy ads on the internet, you know? Yeah. 43:23 Got it. And then tell us like what, what does eZoic do to increase the programmatic ad revenue that people are generating? Like, how, how do you do that? How do you use first-party data in this process? 43:37 Like, just break that down for us. Yeah. 43:39 So I kinda took you through a little bit earlier, like, you know, if you have something like an AdSense and then you're able to add in all the ad networks and actually create a scenario where they're actually competitively bidding, you're testing ad placements, ad sizes, all that stuff on your website. 43:52 You're looking at, you know, like two x, three x higher revenue than just, you know, throwing ad tags on a website. 43:58 Then on top of that, if you have somebody that's selling directly through private marketplace deals and setting those up for your site, uh, have a direct ad sales team that, you know, already has relationships with, uh, brands, which we do. 44:09 So like a good example is, is, you know, eZoic will automatically set all of that up on a site. 44:14 Our technology allows you to basically take an enterprise-level ad stack that you know is, you know, built to work and also automates a lot of that testing stuff that is really s- just gets skipped over a lot of times I think. 44:27 And so you can kind of like have the peace of mind in knowing like I have the best of the best sort of set up on my website with every bra- ad network that's relevant, exchanges, all that kind of stuff. 44:37 But then we also have learned over time that we have a lot of really good quality publishers and, you know, people like Williams Sonoma or, you know, there's brands that just buy directly from us because they're like, "Hey, we really like your sites." 44:50 Some of our publishers, we will go and we'll directly do these deals with them, and that gets added in. We set up the private marketplace deals. 44:57 So you're looking at a pretty significant like improvement in just the quality of, you know, ads that you're running and the quality of the sort of technology, and we're always up to date on it. 45:06 So that sort of like already puts you at the top tier of like enterprise-level ad stack. 45:12 But then on top of that, I, I would say the first-party data opportunity that I think is the one that every publisher should look at, regardless whether you, you use eZoic or not. 45:20 We have EasyID, and the reason why we created it was because we saw this and then I remember talking to our, uh, my partner, our CEO, and I was like, "So this first-party data stuff, how easy is it to set up?" 45:32 And he was about ten minutes in before I was like, "Man, I've been doing this stuff for two decades and I'm lost. Like, go back." 45:39 [chuckles] Because you, you think about it, it's like you gotta take your list, you gotta hash all the emails, you gotta hash it in like three different protocols. There's like SHA, like, I don't know. 45:49 There's n- various numbers and then there's one that's not SHA or whatever it is. 45:54 So you've gotta hash it multiple different ways, and the reason is, is because there's multiple what they call identity protocols, which are open protocols that you can submit your hashed emails to that all connect to these different what they call like identity protocol providers, providers. 46:08 So like you have The Trade Desk, um, people might be familiar with them 'cause they're, they're a public company. Yeah. 46:13 But they're, they're probably the biggest threat to Google in terms of, you know, where advertisers and publishers want to like connect to 'cause they have what's called the universal ID. 46:24 So they actually kinda beat Google in this regard in being able to say like, "We have the largest network of first-party data buyers and sellers." 46:32 So like you definitely wanna be connected to them selling first-party data, right? Um, but then there's other ones like LiveRamp and, and other things like that. 46:40 So you wanna be able to hash your emails, submit these sort of like these keys and these hashed emails up to all these different protocol providers, and then you actually have to be able to hook those up to your ad stack so that you're able to then, you know, wheel and deal in that sort of data with the advertisers and through the system and things like that. 46:58 So without having like an experienced like developer, engineer, or maybe a couple that understand sort of the advertising ecosystem, it's y- the chances of you even just doing it right are pretty low. 47:10 So we, we basically created a way that made it so that all you have to do is take your list or your user data, we secure it for you, and then boom, it like you keep your list. It doesn't go anywhere. 47:22 Uh, we set up keys and all that stuff, set it all up, hook it into the ad stack, so all you have to do is just like drag and drop, or, um, we have an SDK, so you can automatically connect it. 47:33 Uh, we have integrations with like all, all the major email providers like MailChimp and stuff like that. So you literally don't have to do anything. 47:39 We even have it so that you can have like the variables or whatever that are connected in your email marketing, so like if I'm, if I'm like, "Hey, Brad," and you just use like a short tag or something like that in your emails, and then you can actually take a link, um, that can, that like identifies Brad as first-party data, so every link that he clicks in the email and it's, you know, like all your known users, that automatically gets identified and so that all the ads they would see on the page that, you know, of the link that they clicked on, that's, that's a first-party data like user, baby. 48:12 That, that's a, that's a high-earning super like valuable ad space that you're able to sell, and that, you know, that makes it worth it to show ads in a lot of ways. And so, you know, my pi- Yeah. 48:23 I, I feel like one of the things is, is like it sounds like maybe I'm-- I'm, I'm trying to pitch our product. I-- Realistically, publishers use first-party data. 48:31 Without using EasyID, I really don't know how most would be able to do it. 48:36 So, you know, I, I, I do think that we have something, uh, pretty valuable there, and I think it's, it, it, it surprises me that no one else had been trying to build this for, you know, the last few years. 48:45 But publishing is usually pretty far behind advertising.Yeah, I haven't really seen anybody out there that does what you do. And the big advantage is, is really two things. 48:55 So one is increases the ad revenue, the programmatic ad revenue per user, and we talked about twenty-five percent earlier, sometimes potentially more. You have some case studies on that I've read, which are interesting. 49:07 And then two is, you just set this up for people, it makes it accessible and easy versus trying to do this by yourself is, is a nightmare. What type of publishers would be a good fit for this? 49:19 Like, it's, it's not for everybody. If you have like a thousand page views per month, maybe it's not for you, but who do you normally work with? 49:25 So norm-- most of our customers, I would say they start out at, uh, probably annually, they're earning between, you know, like some... 49:32 on the smaller end of publishers that where this is gonna be worth it is if they're, you know, earning between thirty and forty, maybe fifty thousand. 49:39 And then on all the way up to, you know, we have customers that are, you know, earning millions a year. And you can kind of look at it as i-in that sort of term. 49:48 But I would also say if you have a mil-- if you have a list size of a million visitors, like that what I would say is be something that like will qualify you as well. 49:58 'Cause I think if you have a list, uh, that i-includes a million users, emails or close to that, I would say that there's a huge opportunity for you i-in advertising, at least in first-party data, that there's probably something there where y-you, you probably would say, "Hey, yeah, I'll, I'll make that money. 50:15 That's a no-brainer." Yeah. 50:18 I think this is so important because, I mean, n-the newsletter advertising space, so just like direct sold newsletter ads or sponsorships, you know, it's been tough, especially the past two years, '23 and '24, like CPMs have gone down a lot in that space, where programmatic has continued to grow, and oftentimes you'll earn more per one thousand website visitors with programmatic, potentially even more with, with this, versus you do from one thousand newsletter opens from one ad in the newsletter. 50:48 Also, because it's hard to have, you know, multiple ads in one newsletter, it's just the nature of a newsletter versus a webpage, right? And so like if you have that list size- I can tell you why that is too. Yeah. 50:57 And the reason is, is because the email is open. Like, you know, like email is something that's like kind of like a great example of the internet, open and free and always has been. It's like you can use... 51:10 It's just yours. And because of that, it's something that's really hard to run scale advertising in. 51:17 And so the industry, the big tech platforms and the advertisers, they haven't really been able to infiltrate it the same way. So you just don't see the dollars flow there. 51:25 Like it's way easier if you have a captive audience in these sort of like closed, you know, walled garden programmatic channels and things like that. So advertisers just aren't used to buying from it. 51:34 I, I buy ads on newsletters, um, and the, the, the problem always is with them is just like scale, scaling reach. Like I have to go out and find like, you know, dozens and dozens of newsletters, uh, to buy from. 51:47 And so I, I would say like this is a, a good way to sort of like, yeah, think about that. 51:52 I, I'm a big fan though, the like of buying and selling ads in your own newsletter, and that's sort of the same idea with first-party data. 51:59 It's like self-reliance is something newsletter publishers already are really good at. Like you, you built your own audience. You didn't need Google, you didn't need Facebook. 52:08 Maybe you used them in the beginning, but like, you know, that's your audience, you own it. 52:12 The problem is, is then when it comes to revenue, that self-reliance, a lot of-- in a lot of cases, especially with ads, it's like you start relying on other third parties. 52:21 So if you can sell ads directly, whether it's on your newsletter to advertisers or through first-party data, that's like, again, it's like self-reliance. I don't need anybody else to be able to run my business. 52:33 And that's what every publisher has to move towards, you know, if, if they're not there already, and most aren't. And that's the advantage of something like this is like if you have that list size 52:42 and you're generating website traffic from your list and other sources and you're not monetizing it to where you could be, it's a big opportunity. 52:48 Because the newsletter ad space is small and it's, it's not as centralized, and, you know, hopefully it will grow over time and our, our CPMs or RPMs will grow in the actual newsletter ads itself. 52:58 But like, you know, you can make a lot more from the website traffic in many cases, right? And if you have both, that can be and should be a great option for many people too. 53:08 Um, so just things to think about that a lot of people aren't considering. And then, let's see, what else would be good to cover here? 53:16 I think, um, o-one other question I had, is there any type of data publishers should be collecting outside of just the email address? 53:22 So when someone opts in on a newsletter or a form on my site, I collect their email first, right? But should I be collecting things in a, in a survey or form afterwards, like name, phone number, other data? 53:34 Is there anything that's helpful for your purposes or just in general that you've come across? 53:39 You know, I'm not gonna be able to tell you anything in that respect that's gonna be more helpful than, you know, probably you can for, for newsletter publishers. It's, you know, like, you know, know your audience. 53:49 I, I would say from a advertising perspective, there's only two forms of first-party data that really you can deal in, and that's emails and phone numbers. 53:57 Emails are obviously the, the sort of default, and I would say generally a lot of times easier to get. 54:02 But if you have users that are logging in, we've got, um, I mean, dozens and dozens of publishers that have like logged in users, and some of them have told us, and we've seen that like phone number is a little bit easier because people just, they throw their phone number in there, and then that's easier for login 'cause we do like the magic link or two-factor through it anyways. 54:20 But, you know, that's just like anecdotal. 54:21 Like there's no other data that I think one of those two, sometimes both is helpful 'cause it may be, you know, like there's a match with the phone number that identifies one user is maybe way more valuable than their email address or something because of where the data comes from. 54:35 Um, but, you know, I wouldn't recommend that somebody, you know, like go out and strategically go after something like that. 54:41 I will say one of the things that, um, that we have seen publishers use from a data perspective really effectively, so we have, uh, analytics built into our system. 54:50 It's one of the things that probably like we built for us and we built for, it's like a love letter for a lot of our customers, and like I think it gets a lot of love, but it's, you know, analytics is just not sexy. 55:01 It's, so it's not something we really sell, but it, the amount of granularity that you get with, uh, in terms of like looking at the data of where your audience comes from and being able to see-What kind of ad revenue you're earning from different types of visitors broken down by everything from, like, word count to how many times that they've visited and how often they spend on the site. 55:19 You can be like, "Holy," like, "Holy shit," like, "People that spend three minutes on this page earn, like, $20 RPMs versus the people that are, you know, spending a minute on there, and if they spend four minutes on it, they earn, like, $100 RPM." 55:31 Like, how- what do I gotta do to, like, get more of these people spending four minutes on the page or whatever? 55:36 So that kinda stuff is really helpful because I think a lot of times we look at analytics in terms of, you know, traffic and marketing, but, like, rarely do you get to slice it up and be able to see it in terms of, like, revenue that granular. 55:47 And it lets- That's actually really cool, yeah. Yeah, it's super. I, I haven't seen many, many tools like that. I d- I didn't realize that was something that y'all do. Um- It's so hard to do, that's why. 55:56 [chuckles] Like, you can do it with AdSense and Google Analytics, but to connect every ad source, and then you've got the whole thing of, like, somebody bid this, but then they didn't actually pay that, and y- yeah, it's just a wh- whole thing. 56:08 W- we're really good at it. I've, I've not seen anybody... Nobody else offers it off the shelf like us. You would have to have, like, somebody come and very much set it up custom to you. Interesting. 56:18 That, that has a lot of value in and of itself outside of the other stuff you do too, which I think it's interesting to underscore that. 56:24 And, um, yeah, just so- just to recap, like, what we've talked about, like, we're increasing the value of the ad space that we have through first-party data. 56:34 You help people set it up in a way that's, you know, actually doable and easy, and not just impossible to do it yourself. 56:43 And, um, you're building more self-reliant, more sustainable revenue 'cause we can go out and sell directly to advertisers. We don't have to rely on big tech or Google to, you know, basically sell the ads for us. 56:55 Although we can still utilize them- Yeah... we can also do it directly. 56:58 We actually even have a, an app built into our technology, the dashboard, where if, let's say you sell, like an ad to Pepsi, um, for your newsletter and you're running ads in the newsletter, but they also want ads on the site too, you can actually set it up so that you show and run that campaign, like, according to spec. 57:16 So, like, they bought, you know, 10,000 impressions or something like that, you can actually run that so that it, it, those ads get fed in the mix with all the other stuff that runs, so that you fulfill your obligations to Pepsi or whoever it is. 57:28 And on top of that, we take zero... We, we don't take any money from that. That's... You're- you sold that. Like, you keep the money. We're not taking a dime from that. And we've always kind of looked at things that way. 57:38 We built, we built the te- the company because it's like always... I tell people this all the time, I am an artist, and if I didn't work at Ezoic, I would use it as a publisher, and I've always felt that way. 57:49 If people knew what I knew, they would probably use our, you know, like, our company. 57:55 And if I'm-- There's been times whenever there's things that we do or things that I find out that, like, you know, we've shifted our focus from one thing to another, and I look at it and I'm like, "Wait a minute," like, "That sucks." 58:06 Like, "I wouldn't like that, so let's stop doing it." You know? 58:09 Because, yeah, let's build something of value for people, and that's, that's what we've tried to do, is build something to where it's like, if we were in your shoes, what would we, what would we want? 58:19 And, um, yeah, always listening for feedback on that stuff as well. 58:24 I think what you're doing with first-party data is the future of advertising, both programmatic and just advertising in general, so I think it's really fascinating. 58:33 Tell people about, like, where they can find you, where they can learn more about Ezoic. We'll put a link below too. Sure. Um, you can find more at www.ezoic.com. We have a pretty good blog there. It hasn't... 58:44 We, we don't have anything up, like, I think as of this week or the last two weeks, but, uh, we've got a lot of things that are coming through there, and if you wanna scroll through that or even some of, uh, our YouTube channels or if this is a subject you're more interested in, I've done a bunch of interviews and presentations over time, and you can go to the Ezoic YouTube channel, and you can find some of the, the ones, and they're usually titled fairly correctly to where you can kinda get an idea of what subjects we go into. 59:08 So if you're like, "Hey, it seems like that guy knows what he's, knows what he's talking about with this kind of stuff," you can go check out maybe, you know, I go deeper or go off in other areas that maybe you're interested in. 59:19 Um, but yeah, Ezoic YouTube channel and, um, ezoic.com. Yeah. That sounds cool. We'll put a link to that stuff down below. All right. Thanks, Tyler. Thanks, Matt.