Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hey, welcome everybody. I'm Matt McGarry, and I'm here with Ryan Carr. How's it going? Good, man. How you doing? How's the week been? Doing good. We're, uh, 0:14 spending a lot of money on webinar registrations to drive to our webinar and sell our stuff, and they get subscribed to the newsletter too. That's the only new thing going with me. 0:26 I've got-- we're, we're planning to spend, like, this-- it's-- I mention it because it's kind of scary. We're planning to ramp up and spend, like, 100K by July 25th. Or no, June. Yeah, July 25th. Wow. 0:37 And so I've been, like, you know, when you spend that much, everything breaks. It's like, "Oh, my Zapier integration broke." "Oh, why aren't, like, the time zones showing correctly on the registration form?" 0:50 All that type of stuff. So I've been running around doing that. You know, why are my CPMs, why do, why do my CPMs on my ads go from, like, $25 to $90? [chuckles] Yeah. 0:59 Well, it's because we are spending so much money, and then you have to do different things to address that. So things just break with s- with scale, and so I'm working on fixing all that, but it's going good. 1:08 Yeah, that's cool. That's fun. 1:09 I know we talked a, quite a bit about the, uh, the webinar funnel on a previous episode, and it sounds like it's working really well for you, so awesome, awesome to hear that it's, it's scaling as well. Yeah. 1:20 Maybe that'll be the teaser to listen to the episode, you know, a couple weeks from now, because last episode we talked a lot about webinar funnels. 1:28 But now I'll be able-- Next time we talk about it, I'll be able to go back and say, "Hey, I spent 100K in 30 days. Here are the results." 1:35 And I can just share all the results with everybody on the podcast as far as what we actually did. But I wanna wait until this is over to share that. So this is the teaser. We'll, we'll go to [chuckles] the next thing. 1:44 Well, I'm excited for that too, so yeah, a couple weeks from now. Yeah. 1:49 Okay, so one thing I wanted to talk about, I was, I was kind of looking through, like, our mailbag and all these questions we get from people who, who listen to the podcast or people who are just, um, 1:59 in some of the products that I offer and, like, there's really one recurring challenge, and this is, like, a broad challenge and then, then there's more, um, challenges within that main challenge. 2:11 But it's like, how do I get to my first 1,000 subscribers and my first $1,000 in revenue? 2:17 And I, I've seen this repeatedly over and over again, that people, like, if someone can get to their first 1,000 newsletter subscribers and, and 2:26 drive a $1,000 or more in revenue from that newsletter, from the audience that they've built in other places, there is, like, a 99-- 90% chance, I wouldn't say 99, but 90% chance they're going to build a successful six and seven figure business over the next few years. 2:40 But if someone never gets to that point, the, obviously they're not gonna do that, right? So it's like this... 2:47 It's, it's, it's unique in media that you, you have this threshold you have to break through, and people who do break through that threshold are very successful and people who don't, you know, n-never get there and really never have the opportunity for success because they just never got past the initial barrier. 3:01 So I wanna talk about, that's a really broad and challenging topic to cover in just one podcast. Yeah. 3:06 But I wanna talk about not necessarily recommendations for people, but how we would do it and how we have done it and how we are doing it in our businesses and with the people that we've worked with. Yeah. 3:18 Yeah, it is a, it's, you know, it's broad but it's good because I think it gives us an opportunity to speak to a lot of the audience, regardless of, uh, of what spot you're in. I think... 3:31 So where should we start, with growth? Is that, is that what we wanna start with or like growth, g-getting your first 1K? 3:36 There's one thing I wanna mention even before that, but, um, we should mention-- we should also talk about niche selection along with growth- Mm-hmm... 'cause that matters. Like, what you cover, who you serve matters. 3:46 You can't just, we can't just give people a bunch of growth tactics, but they have no idea, like, who to write to. Hopefully they do. 3:53 But one thing I'll say even before that is, like, you have to be more consistent and do this for longer than you think, and it's gonna take longer and be harder than you actually think. Like it's, that's... 4:04 A lot of people get to 1,000 subscribers in 30 days, like Ryan just did that, and you can talk about that later. 4:09 But also, a lot of the clients we've worked with that now have seven or eight figure businesses, it took them, like, a year or two just to get off the ground. 4:17 Like, we did a podcast with Jason Woodruff, the founder of The Pour Over, that people should listen to, and I think it took him two or three years 4:24 of publishing the newsletter and growing until he had enough income to quit his full-time job. Hmm. 4:30 And what you have, like, w-when you're starting a newsletter or publishing content anywhere, whether you realize it or not, you're building a media business, and media has an exponential growth curve. 4:40 It doesn't have a linear growth curve. So, like, growth is going to be flat and slow over time, but as you get progress, it's going to... 4:47 Progress and revenue, audience and revenue, it's going to, uh, you're gonna be able to grow faster and faster. So that's why The Pour Over, like, year one and two, they got to, like, 20,000 subscribers. 4:56 Then year three was, like, 80,000 subscribers, and then year four was, like, 500,000 subscribers, and year five is, like, over a million subscribers. And I'm-- those are ballpark numbers, but they're pretty accurate. 5:07 And revenue also scaled on a similar curve. And so 5:12 what I'm trying to say is, no matter what channel you choose to publish to, whether it's a newsletter, starting a YouTube channel, growing your audience on LinkedIn, like, you have to publish consistently for at least a year to see results. 5:24 And hopefully you'll get traction way sooner, and we have and many people have. But if you're not committing to doing something for a certain amount of times per week or per month for at least one year, 5:35 it's almost better not to even start. I agree with that. Yeah, I think, um, the nature of, like, writing something every week, I think you have to, 5:45 uh, go into it with a belief that you're gonna have some staying power because it's not fun every week. [chuckles] It's, it's, uh, you know, there are weeks that you don't want to publish or, or, you know... 5:57 I, I think it's, it's, the consistency is definitely worth harping on to start here.Yeah. 6:03 I was just having a conversation with somebody today, and I think this is actually maybe a-another good, uh, discussion point, is like they were wanting to partner with Tailwind to build a B2C newsletter. 6:13 And when we first started Tailwind, the idea was, "Hey, we'll just build a newsletter for anybody," you know? Like, we can... 6:20 Because I think back then the, the ad sponsorship market was a little stronger, was much stronger than it is now, um, and a lot of folks were interested in testing newsletter placements, and so there was a good opportunity for even, uh, broader B2C newsletters to make money. 6:35 I don't think that same opportunity exists today, and we've talked a lot about that, but, um, they were asking, you know, like, "What is the road to profitability for a brand new B2C newsletter?" And 6:47 for me, the number isn't 1,000. I thought I, I, I put-- threw it out there as 10,000, I think is when you could start, and it totally depends on niche. 6:56 It depends on where you're starting from a relationships and, like, brands that you can work with standpoint. But, like, 10,000 is, like, table stakes, I think, for a broader B2C newsletter. 7:06 I don't know if you agree with that. For, for advertising revenue, yes. And I- Yeah... 7:10 I think we'll share some frameworks later for it's like, okay, when you get to this audience size, you have, you have this capability, or you can do this or that. But yeah, you do-- that's another key 7:19 audience, um, milestone that can unlock potential sponsorship revenue. Mm-hmm. Um- But stick- sticking to the question, yeah, I guess 1,000- Yeah... if we wanna do that. But yeah. Yeah, I think I, I have some, like... 7:33 That's why I don't recommend going, like, broad and consumer 'cause when you're more niche, d- you don't have to be B2B, but just more niche, uh, you have a much better... 7:42 You have a bigger advantage to sell products directly to your audience, and that's how you're going to-- or services as well, and that's how you're going to make money when you have 100, 500, 1,000 subscribers, and that's gonna give you the, the runway momentum to keep growing, um, so later on you'll, you'll have more scale. 8:01 One thing I wanted to add to, like, the consistency thing, 'cause that goes hand in hand, it-- consistency almost falls right into the niche or, or the content you're writing because if you don't love the audience that you're serving and you don't love the content you're creating, you can't do it consistently for at least a year. 8:17 And so that's how you should select a niche. You should basically scratch your own itch, solve your own problem, 8:23 serve-- like, talk about which something you deeply know already, and serve an audience you deeply care about. 8:28 Doesn't mean you have to be the world's best expert, um, but it's has to be something that you are willing and excited to become an expert in and something you can, you could see yourself five, 10 years from now being one of the world's leading experts in or being one of the loids-- world's leading voices in. 8:47 That doesn't happen for everybody, but, like, if you keep doing it for 10 years, you'll get there, and so that's-- you have to have that mindset going into it. 8:55 If you don't, like, if you're just like, "Oh, I wanna pick, like, the most... Like, I wanna use some, like, formula to pick the most financially beneficial thing that I don't really care about. Like, I wanna go into, 9:05 you know, re-- you know, news for people who own retirement homes," maybe that's a great financially beneficial niche for some people. 9:13 But if you don't really know or care about that pe- thing and the people you're writing for, you'll never succeed. Yeah. 9:18 Now, some people do know and care about that niche, and that's a great niche for them, but it's probably not for you. 9:22 So you gotta pick a lane that works for you, and it's probably gonna be pretty narrow at first, but over time that will broaden and, you know, get bigger as you expand the audience and as you develop more interest and skills. 9:35 Yeah. I mean, honestly, like, creating-- being beholden to creating regular content about stuff that you're not interested in or have no interest in, it sucks. [chuckles] It's like, it's not a fun process. 9:50 And to your point, it's like the way folks are gonna get value, like, people pay, people pay... 9:57 The people that pay for consulting, the folks that they're paying for consulting are people that know more about that subject than 99%-plus of people, right? 10:07 I would say if you want to-- if you're looking for, uh, a focus for something you're publishing, uh, whether that be, like, a newsletter or blog or media company, podcast, YouTube channel, whatever, it's like just the, the easiest framework that I could think of is like, what are you better... 10:23 Uh, everyone is better than 99% of the population at something, uh, just, I think just by, you know, the profession that they're in or where they've spent their, uh, their time gathering experience. 10:34 For us, it was obviously newsletters, which is why we started the Newsletter Operator Podcast and why we both work in that, in that field, and people pay us to, to help them with that. 10:41 Everybody has something like that, and I think that's your competitive advantage when you're publishing a newsletter or creating media. 10:48 So I think that's a, that's a good starting point to both define the niche and define kind of the content strategy. 10:54 Yeah, and also it could be what problems do you have that maybe you haven't completely solved, but you're going to solve and you wanna help other people solve as well. Or it could be, uh, maybe you're not 11:06 better than 99% of people. You probably are, but you're just insecure. That's another thing that people have to realize. But what do you wanna be an expert at? And that's a great thing to write a newsletter about. 11:18 And so you can basically just share what you're learning. Even if you're two steps ahead of someone, you can be very successful. A good analogy for this is like, you know, do you play golf? 11:27 I don't, but it's a good example. I play golf. I'm not good at golf. I should not be writing a golf newsletter, but... [chuckles] Yeah, but, like, so if you wanted to... 11:34 If you-- So you play golf, but you're not an expert. If you wanted to hire a coach, and let's say you are, let's say you're, like, a two. You're probably better. 11:43 Let's just say you're a two out of 10 as far as, like, golf skills, and Tiger Woods is a 10. Do you need to hire someone who's an eight, nine, or a 10 to help you? No. 11:51 You can probably hire someone who's, like, a five or a six. 11:54 So they're really just two steps ahead of you, three steps ahead of you, and if you wanted to get better, you'd happily pay someone who's a five or a six at golf. 12:01 You don't have to be a 10 to publish a newsletter, write content, or-Do consulting. And so that's the analogy that I like to use. So if you're a five at Facebook ads or a five at 12:14 whatever topic, I'm struggling to find examples, you can help a lot of people who are at the one, two, and three range, even if you're not an eight, nine or 10 yet. And so- Yeah... don't, don't be intimidated by this. 12:24 No. And there's a lot, there's a lot to be said just for like earnestly providing free value, right? 12:29 Like, if you're putting work in to compile something that you have confidence is gonna be valuable to the person reading it, whether it's just something that they can like, like I'll use the example of the stuff that we're doing at Mood Board. 12:41 The idea is just like something that, that people can copy-paste. Is it always rocket science that we're sending over, like this, the, this, the workflows that we're sending over? 12:49 Not always, but it's always useful, right? And it's free. 12:52 And so I think if you can provide people-- If you put in the work to be confident to know that, "Hey, I'm providing somebody with value that they didn't have before," I just think that's a good framework too. 13:04 And that, I think that that breeds confidence in continuing to publish 'cause you feel good about what you're putting out into the world and it's not just like fluff, right? Yeah. 13:12 And the easiest way to do that is just like you learn something and then you share what you learn or you summarize it, or you do something and you share the results of what you did. 13:19 So like I posted 500 or let's say 50 TikTok videos, and here's what happened. 13:26 Or what you're doing right now with Mood Board is like, I use these AI workflows in my business or with my clients and like, here's what actually worked or here's the prompt that is actually working for us that we're using. 13:38 And, um, that's a great-- that's really the best, whether you're a beginner or an advanced person, that's the best type of content. When you become more advanced, 13:46 you can do less of that because you've just had so many experiences. You can put the dots together and just give people like a A to Z tutorial or you can, you know, give them the news. 13:56 This is-- What we're talking about right now is more about, um, expert and an, an analysis level content. 14:02 We're not talking a lot about what I would call like reporting or news or journalism 'cause that's just not our expertise. 14:09 But yeah, even if you wanted to like-- You think about journalists, like over time they become an expert on the topic, but when they first start, they're just researching and reporting what they learn, and they're doing it from a third party perspective, just trying to tell the truth and tell-- show you what's happening, hopefully in most cases. 14:28 Um, and no one's like, "Oh, these journalists don't know everything about whatever industry they're covering." Like, they, they expect that, uh, based off of what it is. Anyways. 14:38 [chuckles] No, I think, I think that's a good, uh, like preface though to diving in because I think, you know, talking about niche, talking about content, that is also something that we get a ton, a ton of questions about. 14:49 So like on the mailbag theme, I think that's probably one of the most asked questions that either of us get is picking that. 14:55 I guess talking about growth, like actually, so now you've picked your niche, you've picked your topic. 15:01 I mean, this is another really-- We were talking, I guess zero to a thousand was kind of the, the framework that we're talking about or the, the way that we're framing the question, right? Yeah. 15:09 For audience, and then we'll get into zero to a thousand revenue after that. So the way that I've approached this brand new kind of media property that, that we've launched, and the way that I would advise 15:25 almost everybody to get to a thousand would be organically with a focus on, with just a, a tremendous focus on the quality of the list that you're building and like the, um, 15:38 the alignment of your ICP with the actual people on the list. 15:44 So like if you're targeting small gym owners, for example, like making sure that the organic marketing that you're doing is reaching those folks and not necessarily putting a, a high, um-- Like speed is important and speed get, like breeds confidence and momentum and all that. 16:03 But I do think that it's worth focusing on the quality of the list over speed to start. I don't know if you- And that'll make you more money, right? Because- Yeah... 16:14 if you, if you, if you're gonna sell a product or service to your audience, which is really the only way, way to make money. 16:20 What people don't realize is the only way to make money is to sell a product or service to your audience, whether you ha-- own that product or service or a sponsor or advertiser does. 16:29 And they want, whether it's you who's selling their product or the sponsor, they want a targeted high value audience that fits their ICP, their ideal customer profile. People have gotten a lot smarter. 16:40 They don't really care about someone who has an email list of a hundred thousand or a million people that aren't targeted and they're low engaged, and they're just in all different categories. 16:48 They want targeted high value email list. And then one thing I'll add to what you said is that, you know, when you build the audience slow and steady over time, 16:56 let's say it takes you two, three years to get to an audience of, you know, 50,000 people, 100,000 people, yeah, everybody would like to grow faster, but that audience isn't gonna go away anytime soon. 17:09 What happens to some people really is they, they go viral, they hit a trend, or they have some type of arbitrage opportunity, and they grow their audience to tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands, let's say in six months. 17:22 Well, those types of audiences o- often go away over the next six months. Uh, but people who do it the right way, focusing on the fundamentals, build very sustainable businesses. And so it's not that 17:36 fast growth isn't, isn't good, um, but the wrong type of fast growth can actually be bad for you. And so going slow and steady isn't a bad thing at all. Yeah. 17:45 I mean, I think the, the focus on vanity metrics, like overall list size, which, you know, can or can't be a vanity metric depending on the quality of the list, right? 17:53 But like that's where a lot of folks, when this kind of reemergence of newsletters around the time that The Hustle got acquired and, uh, Morning Brew got acquired and kind of the big boom that, uh, that, that we were a part of-When that started happening, there was a lot of focus on just overall list size, and it's like, "Oh," like, "how fast can I get from zero to ten thousand to a hundred thousand subscribers?" 18:16 And I have a, I have a list of, you know, five hundred thousand subscribers that I grew in, like, four months. Um, 18:23 the reason why people were doing that is because they were focusing on monetizing through sponsorships, which were generally structured back then as CPMs, so people were getting paid out based on how many thousand subscribers they had, just even just, like, on the list, not even opening the email necessarily, just on the list. 18:43 That's not the case anymore, to your point. 18:45 Like, advertisers have kind of wised up to, to, to that kind-- to those approaches to, to, uh, sponsorships, and a lot of times they're getting paid on performance now, so how many people are actually clicking the ad, how many people are converting on the ad. 18:58 Um, so really, like, I wouldn't even put too much-- I wouldn't put too much thought on that top level, uh, like, list size anymore. I would be excited... 19:08 Honestly, if you're somebody who's just starting out, I would get into the weeds, like, and you're gonna do this as just a, a-- just by nature of being excited when you're starting something. 19:18 But, like, every single subscriber that comes onto the list, look at them. 19:22 Like, look them up on LinkedIn, see who they are, and if they fit your ICP, you're gonna be really encouraged by that, 'cause now that's one more person that you're writing directly to on the list. 19:30 You know, if you have a hundred of those people that, that you can look up and say, "Those are exactly the kind of person I'm writing for," I think that's better than having a thousand people who are, like, okay fits, right? 19:42 Yeah. And you can Google their email address and see that type of stuff, or you could have a post-sign-up survey that gives you some more data on that type of stuff. 19:50 And really, what we're talking about, like, your first one thousand subscribers and one thousand in revenue, that second one k is way more important. Like, you should track your revenue way more than your, 19:59 your email subscribers, because, I mean, the reality is when you start building a list of tens of thousands of people, a lot of those are secondary email addresses, a lot of those are not engaged, and that's really not what matters in the business. 20:10 And so just-- It matters because you need leads to sell things to, but it's, like, revenue and how you're serving people is, is goal number one. Audience size i-is secondary. 20:22 I, I wanna get more tactically into the growth stuff now, uh, but one final thing I wanna mention is, um, just on the consistency, it's like you have to be able to, to love this enough where you'll do it for free. 20:32 So, like, you need to be comfortable publishing one newsletter per week f-for free for a year. I think you'll make money a lot faster than that, but just, like, go into it with that mindset. 20:42 You have to be p-comfortable publishing, you know, two to five social media posts on one platform and one newsletter a week for a year. Or maybe if you're doing YouTube, one video a week for a year. 20:53 Like, if you're not excited and comfortable doing that for free, odds are you're not gonna be super successful. And, and it is harder than it looks. Like, I started the newsletter back in, like, twenty seventeen, 21:06 um, and I had these, like, same challenges. Like, I didn't know what to write to. I felt, you know, insecure about, uh, my content and expertise, and I shut it down like a month later. 21:17 The content actually wasn't bad, looking back, and if I would've kept doing that consistently, I don't know if it would be a huge business, but it would've helped me a lot more in life. But I, but I just shut it down. 21:26 I also made the mistake of trying to publish a daily newsletter, which was stupid, because you can't do a daily newsletter consistently for, for months and years. But you can do weekly. Yeah. 21:34 Daily, I feel like is-- That's like the-- That is the mistake that I, I've, I've seen the most people, uh, make, and I think we've, like, in the past made that mistake as well with, like, encouraging that with partners. 21:45 We don't, we don't make that mistake anymore, um, because it is, like, it is very difficult to keep up with. You need a team. That's for businesses at scale. It's not for people who are starting a business. Yeah. 21:57 And then one more thing, uh, I wanna confess is, like, I started my newsletter in January of twenty twenty-three, and so maybe I've published like a hundred and twenty-something issues. 22:06 I think we said it on the podcast, but I forget the number. So for like a hundred plus straight weeks, and I've worked a lot of Saturdays to get those out there. 22:15 You know, I've worked like most Saturdays from like eight to five or nine to five, I've worked to actually publish that newsletter, 'cause a hundred and thirty weeks straight, so maybe a little bit less than I expected. 22:25 But since January of twenty twenty-three. And so, like, that is probably m-more than I expected going into it. 22:31 The commitment's been worth it because it's, it's helped me in so many ways and helped grow my business in so many ways, so I wouldn't be here without that. But just, like, know what you're getting into. 22:40 You're gonna have to do some, some nights and weekends when you're first starting out to, to get this out there. I don't think everybody has to work weekends to succeed, but that's what I've had to do. 22:49 It definitely takes more time than you initially think. Um, yeah. And it's easy to get carried away, too, uh, [chuckles] by putting-- like, trying to write too much. 22:59 Uh, and so yeah, I think it's also worth, uh, from a content perspective, like, if you, if you're just starting, like, start with just, like, five hundred words. 23:08 Like, just get, like, five hundred words out there, and people-- that's actually something people will read all of, too. You have to give yourself constraints. 23:13 Like, that's- Yeah...a weekly newsletter, that's a constraint. A newsletter that's five hundred words or less, that's a constraint, and that's a really good idea, so I'm glad you mentioned that. 23:22 But continue, and then what we'll go into to growth when you're ready. No, I was saying let's just hop into the, to the growth tips now. I know you said you had some more tactical insights here. Yeah. 23:32 So how do you think about this? Like, we've both done it, like, and you did it recently. So when I started in January '23, I think I got to a thousand subscribers maybe, like, one to two months. 23:43 I could probably look it up and see. You got to a thousand subscribers within, like, nineteen days, right? Yeah. For, for Moodboard? 23:50 Well, maybe let's just both describe how we do- did it, and then we can talk about how other people could, could do the same. Do you wanna go first on that? Yeah. 23:59 So I mean, we've talked quite a bit about, uh, the s- the general-- I guess the main strategy that drove probably like eighty to eighty-five percent of subscribers on Moodboard, which is organic LinkedIn posting, specifically kind of like a, I don't wanna call it engagement farming, but, uh, this comment to get strategy. 24:15 I actually-- It's funny, uh, the-The mood board edition that went out today is a prompt that will turn any of your newsletters or blog posts into a LinkedIn post that-that's formatted the same way that, that I've been formatting those posts. 24:28 And so that should hopefully be helpful to anybody who wants to try it out. And you can see Ryan Carr on LinkedIn to see these posts. I think you've got-- Like, how many posts did you do? 24:36 So these are comment to get posts where, like, people comment a word, and they get essentially a, a lead magnet, which is really just a email-gated newsletter issue that Ryan wrote. Yeah. 24:46 And they get access to that, um, when they comment a word and, and you DM that and you reply to their comment with that link to enter their email to get access to that thing. So the ex- the examples on your LinkedIn. 24:56 But, like, how many issues did it take you to get to-- Or no, how many LinkedIn posts did it take you to get to 1,000 subscribers? I think it was three. Um- Three? The f- the fir- Yeah, it was three. 25:07 I thought it was-- Damn, I thought it was more than that. Okay, that's fine. But the fir- but the first two popped off. Uh, the fir- the first two, uh, both drove a ton of comments. Because it was three... 25:19 Yeah, 'cause it was... Honestly, it might have even been-- It might've been two. How many subscribers are you at now, and how many posts have you done now? Um, let me take a look. 25:31 I think we're at, like, 1,700 subscribers now, um, and we've done, I think today was the eighth that we just put out. But the-- There was a h-huge amount of growth just, um, from, uh, the... We did a couple. So, 25:50 not everyone's gonna hit the first two, just, I think because of the, how viral the, the potential for virality of the actual subjects themselves, which was, like, AI video, which was the hype at the time. 26:01 Those two popped off, and so yeah, within 19 days. So yeah, it must have been either two or three because, um, yeah, because it was just weekly, right? So... You do one post per week and one newsletter per week. 26:15 Yeah, and I, I just looked at my stats. I went from zero to 1,000 in about 30 or 40 days, um, from, from January '23 to February '23. 26:24 And it's-- I actually had a-- I wrote about this on, on my, uh, blog newsletter operator dot com. People can go back and see, like, how I got my first 10,000 subscribers, which also will cover how I got 1,000. 26:35 It was very similar. So, so at that time, Twitter was a much better platform for growth. Now I've moved to LinkedIn, you've kind of moved to LinkedIn. You're posting there, there more too. 26:46 But it was like, I would do-- I think at that time I was doing, like, two threads per week consistently, and there would be a call to action for the newsletter at the end. 26:53 And then I would do at least one, what we call pre-call to action before my newsletter was published. And so it's just a teaser. It's just like, "Hey, um, tomorrow, you know, my 27:06 s- uh, email list subscribers are gonna learn how to do this cool thing. If you wanna learn too, click the link in my bio to subscribe, or click here to subscribe," and then I would have a link in the next tweet below. 27:16 And so it's just teasing the newsletter content and asking people to subscribe. I didn't do the comment to get stuff back then, but, um, in concept, the strategy is similar. Yeah. 27:27 And I think, I think the-- exactly, that the concept is what's important here, and the concept is just repurpose your newsletter [chuckles] content and, like, tweak it so that it's-it's more, uh, attuned to the platform that you're posting on. 27:38 Um, like, that's literally the only posting that I've done on LinkedIn, and I need to change this. 27:43 I need to actually, like, focus more on native posting on the platform as opposed to just this strategy, although it's worked so far. 27:49 But the only posting that I've done, um, has been taking the newsletter and teasing it, uh, via this comment to get strategy on LinkedIn, um, and that's driven all the subscribers. 28:03 So I write the edition, I turn that edition into a LinkedIn post that teases it and kind of hypes it up, and then that in turn drives subscribers to the content. 28:12 And that's how I would think about it is, like, we've talked a lot about this in past episodes where we've talked more about, like, content repurposing. 28:19 But the newsletter should basically serve as, like, the central hub for-- Because you're, if you're spending all this time on a weekly newsletter or how- whatever the cadence is, just use the work that you put into that and perfecting that and really polishing it and chop it up and repurpose it across other channels. 28:36 Um, that's the smart way to do it, I think. And then, you know, there's, there's, uh, uh, it's not, you know, there are other, there are other great ways to, to develop content as well. 28:44 Um, but if you're-- for a newsletter, if the focus is growing the newsletter, I think that's the easiest way to do it. Yeah. I have, um, a discussion point I wanna bring up in a second that's about this. 28:54 But one thing I'll say is just, we didn't mention this, but you really have to have some type of discovery platform to grow your newsletter. 29:00 So it could be paid ads, which isn't great for beginners, or it could be social media, like LinkedIn and Twitter, Instagram, or it could be a video platform like YouTube or TikTok. You, you have to have one of those. 29:10 The other discovery platform is Google Search, which is also really hard right now, and also almost impossible for beginners because you don't have domain authority. 29:17 So you have to have one of those because newsletters can't be discovered. 29:19 You're just s- uh, it's a-- Newsletters are a tool for retaining, building a relationship, and, and monetizing an audience, and they do a better job than any other channel at that. 29:29 But a newsletter in itself is not going to grow your audience magically, organically, right? So you have to have something like LinkedIn or something else. 29:37 But, um, so the, the-- maybe a discussion topic would be, like, if you had all the time in the world, uh, and the ability to do so, and I think we'll-- we both have the skill for this, how would you just juice LinkedIn or whatever platform you choose? 29:50 So you might choose LinkedIn, maybe I'll talk about Twitter. Like, how would you just juice it and get the most subscribers from that? I'll-- If it's okay, I'll just share my- Go for it... 29:59 my, uh, my thought process for this first. So, you know, I have one weekly newsletter. I would repurpose that into at least... 30:06 And I'll just do LinkedIn too, because this can apply to Instagram, it can apply to anything else. Um, I would repurpose that into at least three separate LinkedIn posts, whether it's, like, long text, image carousel. 30:17 Like, I can, I can get a-- I, I write, like, a 500 to 1,000 word newsletter, I can get at least three posts out of that. 30:22 Mm-hmm.Put the newsletter itself or like the, the article in the newsletter behind an email gate like you would do, and I would do one comment to get post per week. 30:33 Before that news-- And you have to do that after the newsletter's published, right? 30:37 Before that, um, newsletter's published, I would do a pre-call to action, so teasing what I'm about to send to my list and telling people to subscribe to get it. 30:45 And then outside of that, so basically I only have three like value-focused posts for my newsletter. 30:52 I would probably write three more posts that are just original content or answering questions or talking about a stream, whatever it is, so you just have more value-add content. 31:00 Each of those is gonna have a call to action in the comments, or it's gonna direct people to my bio to sign up at the end of that post. But that's just the start. 31:07 Like what a lot of people are missing is, is the next thing. So 31:11 if people like your stuff, they're gonna click on your profile, and so I'd optimize my profile to drive people to my newsletter landing page, and I would have a link for that in my profile or a lead magnet too. 31:21 Sometimes lead magnets are more effective than just the newsletter because they can be an additional incentive to get people to subscribe. And I would go further. 31:29 This is what people don't do, but it's actually some of the most powerful stuff. 31:32 Everybody who follows me on LinkedIn or connects with me or follows me on whatever platform, I would send them a warm DM and basically ask them to subscribe and be like, "Hey, thanks for connecting. Thanks for following. 31:43 I write about this stuff on LinkedIn, but I publish my best stuff in my newsletter. Have you subscribed yet? If not, here's the link to sign up for free." 31:52 And that can take you from converting like 1 or 5% of your followers into a subscriber to converting like 20, 30% of your followers into an email subscriber just by doing that. 32:02 And like if you have the resources, you can have a virtual assistant just do it all for you because it's the same message to everybody. And then the final thing I would do is like 32:11 try and either pay or have some type of arrangement or favor where I'm getting engagement from, from friends and colleagues and other people in my niche. Like, I've done this with you, and you've done it with me. 32:24 Like when you post something, you like reach out to me and say, "Hey, can you give this some love?" 32:27 And I'll give it like a like and comment, which sounds small, but if you do that with even just a handful of people, that has a meaningful impact on your, on h- how the algorithm, you know, treats your content. 32:39 And so I would like to take credit for all your success by commenting. [laughs] No, I'm just kidding. 32:44 But you do that with me, and you do that with like a handful of other people who were, um, who were like, who used to work at The Hustle too. 32:51 And I've-- I don't do that right now, but if I wanted to get the best results, I should be doing that with like 10 to 15 people consistently. Yeah. 32:58 And to your point, it is crazy how a little goes a long way, especially early on if s- if you have somebody, if you ask for that support. Um, and, you know, anybody should be able to do this. 33:08 Just reach out to some friends that also are on LinkedIn and, or Twitter and just say, "Hey, could you just like comment on this real quick or, or like and comment on it?" 33:16 'Cause the- I think to my understanding, if you do that earlier on, then it starts to build momentum for the post, for the post, uh, more effectively. Like it does it faster. 33:27 It gets it out in front of more people to start, and it just kind of like sharpens the curve at w- at which you're showing, uh, impressions. Um, so yeah, I do that with you. 33:35 We have that group chat, um, the Slack channel with like old Hustle folks. I'll usually post in there. It's a must. 33:42 All, all the people I know who have like 100 or 500,000 followers on LinkedIn and, and Twitter, they have an even more coordinated group with usually like 20 to 30 people who are also all have a lot of followers too. 33:54 And when you get engagement from people who have a lot of followers, that's even more effective in driving more views and engagement on the post. 34:00 And so yeah, if you're just starting, you're kind of at a disadvantage, but like you can find three people who are posting similar content. And also like you don't have to ask first. 34:09 You can just start doing it for other people for free with no expected response who are just like you, like them, they're posting similar stuff, and then like after you do it a couple times, then you can reach out to them one-on-one and ask them if you would like to have this type of, uh, relationship where, where you comment and engage with each other's stuff. 34:28 And yeah, that, that probably works on LinkedIn more than like Instagram and, and YouTube, but especially LinkedIn and Twitter, it really matters. And I'm sure there's equivalents for other platforms too. Yeah. 34:39 I think the, um, just spending time on these discovery platforms, I mean, if you-- honestly, if you just have a business, it doesn't, it doesn't even have to be a newsletter. 34:50 If you have a business, I think it's, it's worth investing time in these discovery platforms like LinkedIn, like Twitter, a little higher touch, but YouTube as well. 34:58 Have you ever done a bait post where it's like you write about someone in hopes that they will, um, repost it or engage with it? That, that frankly works. Yes. And I, I haven't done that. 35:09 I can't think of the last-- I'm sure I've done it at least once. I probably should do it more, but like yeah. 35:13 I wrote like a commentary on Alex Hormozi's newsletter on like why this format is cool, and he reposted that, and of course, that gets like 10 times the views that I normally do. 35:22 And that wasn't even the intention because I just... anything about newsletters, I'll talk about. 35:27 There's only so much when it comes to like cool newsletter formats I can share, but I would be doing at least two bait posts per month if I were starting out just trying to get the attention and engagement of people who have bigger audiences than me. 35:40 Yeah. It's-- I forget who coined this. It's a marketer. 35:44 They called it like permissionless co-branding, where basically you are by, just by posting about somebody or about their brand, it's almost like an, an exercise in co-branding, and it will-- and generally it works to your point to get their attention as well, and maybe you get some love from them. 36:02 Um, but it does work really well. Uh, you know who does this? Um, he used to do sales for The Milk Road, uh, W-Wouter, Wouter, who we've had on the pod before. Yeah. Wouter Teunissen. Yeah. 36:15 He has a podcast now where he basically-- or to start, he just created books about the founders of companies that he admired, like Ramp, like Andrew WilkinsonAnd so he created these, you know, and those got a lot of good attention because they're-- it's good content that he put a lot of time into. 36:32 But then as a result of those, as a result of publishing those books, he was-- he had a great in to have those founders on his podcast and to, um, to, to host long form interviews with them. 36:44 And so I think, you know, from a newsletter perspective, just from a marketing perspective, who are the heroes in your field that you'd like to be associated with? 36:52 That might be a good, uh, a good focus for at least one of those posts, uh, a week, uh, on these discovery platforms that we're talking about, or newsletter posts or whatever. Yeah. It's really smart, and 37:05 I think people just get nervous and they don't do it, but just get over that and, and freaking do it. I need, I need to do it more too. 37:10 But the-- the only caveat is like, don't do someone so big where you know they'll never see to respond to it. 37:16 Like I saw all these threads about like on Twitter about Chamath Palihapitiya or, you know, the founder of Nike. It's like that, that's not gonna get you... 37:23 Like that might get some views, but that's not gonna bring a targeted audience that you can sell to, and then they're never going to give you any engagement, um, from that, most likely. 37:32 So, you know, do it, do it more at a, at a, at a lower level, I should say. 37:37 But yeah, any thoughts on how you would kind of juice social if you're just trying to-- if you have all the resources and you're just trying to max it out? 37:44 I mean, I would just increase the cadence that I'm posting at, and I would probably, uh, optimize my LinkedIn profile. 37:50 I-- that's, that is a, uh, that's an AB test that I need to run, and maybe I'll report back on the next pod. But my, my profile is definitely not optimized. Uh, I, the, you know, 38:01 the comment to get posts have been working really well. 38:03 I bet I could increase the volume of subscribers that I'm driving from LinkedIn if I just spent some time on like a cover photo or, uh, or, you know, the featured post section or just... 38:13 I, I, I see a lot of people doing interesting stuff on their profiles that I'm sure increases conversion rate. Um, so I would spend more time there, and then I would just increase the cadence that I post at. 38:23 I know there are different, there are different formats that accomplish different goals. 38:28 So like I've noticed a lot of people are doing more like, uh, face posting and like personal posting on LinkedIn now, or that they'll be like, "Hey, like here's a little bit about my story," and then it's like a candid looking selfie. 38:40 Uh, I've noticed that everybody's doing that now, and I think it's because they might have shifted their algorithm to where that, that crushes. 38:47 Um, so I would be trying a lot of different stuff and I-- to be honest, like this is all stuff that I do wanna do and I do wanna try. 38:52 So I think as I double down on that platform, hopefully I'll have more, more to report back on. Yeah. 38:59 And e-even just that stuff we just mentioned, that can get you, m- even not at the same volume, can get you to your first thousand subscribers. That almost covers- Yeah... the growth stuff. 39:07 Another thing I encourage, which we won't talk about in detail now, is just reaching out to friends and family and colleagues who this is relevant for and just say like, "Hey, I started a newsletter. It's about this. 39:17 If you're interested, just click here to subscribe." Getting that first 39:21 five subscribers, 10 subscribers, 50, a lot of people just th-think that doesn't matter, but like every subscriber matters right now, and then also holds you accountable to actually publish something. 39:34 And so I, I highly encourage doing that. 39:36 So like the, the odds if you do that, that you will follow through publishing a newsletter are way higher than if you don't, because you, you now have people expecting something from you. 39:44 And I would do that before I publish the first issue. So let's say I'm planning to publish the first issue in like the next seven to 14 days, go ahead and do it now. 39:52 It's okay if they get the newsletter 10 days later, it's totally fine. Just go ahead and get that out of the way so you have someone to write to, to hold yourself accountable. 40:00 It's a really good point, and that is something that I did before I tried any of the organic growth methods that, that we talked about. 40:07 Like I just reached out to, obviously told you, told a few folks, uh, from The Hustle, told, uh, professional contacts, told clients, um, that this is something I was gonna be writing. 40:18 And yes, it does give you the impetus to start publishing, to keep publishing, and also will just open doors too, and opportunities, right? 'Cause they'll tell other people about it. Like you'll get i- the... 40:30 especially if the people you're telling upfront are people that are close to you, uh, which generally I, I would say that's, that's what people would, uh, start with. They'll share with other people. 40:40 I know there were some, uh, some examples of folks that I shared with early on that like gave me free little plugs in their own publications and stuff like that. 40:49 Um, and that, you know, every little bit, every little bit helps for sure. So yeah, it's a, I think that's a, that's a great first step. 40:56 There's, uh, something that happens when you start something, whether it's a business, a newsletter, or anything else, where when you're in the early stages, people are way more willing and happy to help you. 41:06 But after you get past 1,000 subscribers or a certain amount of revenue in your business or even just a certain amount of time, you get past 30 days, 60 days, that kind of goes away or it becomes kind of hard or cheesy to ask for. 41:20 And so there's something to be said about just taking advantage of all that in the best possible way. 41:26 And so like we talk about re-referral programs, for example, they often don't crush it, especially if you have more of a niche audience. But when you're first starting, that actually might be a good idea. 41:37 It's like, "Hey, like we're at..." And like also updating your audience about where you're at. "Hey, we're at 100 subscribers now. 41:43 When we get to 1,000, I'm gonna share this cool thing" or "I'm gonna do this like live call for our subscribers" or whatever. You can share the newsletter referral link to help us get there. 41:52 Um, or after you reach out to your friends and family and you've published the first newsletter, or maybe you do an announcement post on social media that you're starting the newsletter or your, or your, um, the first issue is out, then you could go back to those friends, family, colleagues, clients and say, "Hey, I just announced this on social media. 42:10 I'm trying to get it out there in the world. I would love if you, you know, give this some love or like it or share it or comment or whatever." 42:15 And people are just way more likely to do that when you're first starting, considering they like you and they think the content is valuable, than three months from now. 42:25 And so it's like take advantage of that while you have it 'cause it goes away in like 60 days or 90 days. It's not gonna be around forever.Yeah, that's so true. 42:33 And yeah, yeah, to your point, it's like people wanna help when you have like, like, "Hey, you're my tenth subscriber," when, you know, they're the, the ten thousandth or, you know, what-whatever it is. Uh, 42:44 it's less, uh, less amenable to charity, for sure. [chuckles] Yeah. We don't have a ton of time left. Do you have a couple minutes to go over, Ryan? It's okay if you don't. Of course. Yeah, yeah, yeah. 42:53 And we can also address, like, monetization more in depth maybe on a next, uh, next pod. But yeah, we can at least get started here. Yeah. We'll see what we can... 43:02 So, so we covered like niche consistency, we covered kind of social growth, we covered outreach. I would just focus on those. We also covered like sharing, you know, referrals from your friends. 43:14 You don't wanna overcomplicate this. It's 1,000 people. You don't wanna overcomplicate it, so you don't need a dozen different ways to get 1,000 people. 43:19 So that's all I would focus on, and just focus on being really damn good at it and consistent. And don't expect it to come in 30 days. It's possible, but, you know, it's-- if it takes longer, that's totally okay. 43:31 I guess we should get into just like some monetization basics that are gonna help you get to that first cape, and then we can wrap up the podcast. Would that be cool? Yeah. I think, yeah, absolutely. 43:39 I think there are some broad categories that we could probably just cover briefly and then maybe go more in depth in next time. Yeah. So I think step one is like, 43:47 you know, go into the mindset-- have the mindset going into this that you are building an audience to eventually sell something to them. 43:53 And if you don't know what that is yet going forward, that's totally fine, because by building an audience and building goodwill and building your reputation online, it's gonna be way easier to sell people a product when you do later have that product. 44:04 So you don't have to have the complete roadmap right now. But if you're just building an audience in hopes that sponsors are going to flock to you and throw, throw money at you, 44:15 then you're probably gonna be in a tough position. 'Cause if you can't sell something to them, are your sponsors going to be able to either? Probably not. 44:23 And real sponsorship revenue unlocks at a, a larger audience scale than you're probably hoping, like a minimum of t-10,000, but really 40,000, 50,000 is where you start to unlock like real sponsorship dollars that, um... 44:38 And that's just gonna take a long time. Um, and that's something to look forward to when you get there, but it's not gonna happen from day one. So do, do you agree with that? Oh, 100%, yeah. 44:46 I think the, you know, that's something the, the s- sponsorship revenue is gonna be kind of like a bonus for most people in the early days, I think. Yeah. 44:57 So I think one way to think about how you-- 'cause you still wanna generate revenue, you know, from day one or, or very early on. So I think the ways you should generate revenue 45:06 should maybe not be about maximizing profits, but maximizing the learnings that you get from this, so that those learnings can inform the product or service that you create and sell to your audience. 45:16 And so I just have some ideas for that, and we can probably wrap up on this. 45:19 So, okay, actually I have one that's doesn't apply too much to that, but, you know, paid recommendations, SparkLoop, Subsquare, Beehiiv, Boost, that's kind of like a no-brainer because you set it up, you earn 40, 50 cents, a dollar per subscriber, and it's just like money that covers your expenses and you don't have to think about it. 45:34 So I would do that from day one. That's not gonna help you learn about, a lot about what people, uh, will buy from you later on, but it's just free money, essentially. Ad network ads, so the Beehiiv ad network, Wellput. 45:47 If there's relevant products or services that you can advertise, and, and usually for this ad network, so you earn on a cost per click, so Beehiiv might pay you $2 per click, $3 per click. 45:57 It's like why not put those in there and see what people are actually clicking on, because that might inform what you could later sell them. Then you have, which is somewhat similar, affiliate offers. 46:05 So like if there's-- maybe you're thinking about selling a product, you could have a similar product, then you promote it as an affiliate. 46:12 It doesn't have to be just affiliate offers, it could be like a agency that you get a kickback or a referral fee from, or a consultant, or any type of referral kickback or affiliate. 46:22 That will give you a lot of data about what people actually buy. And then the, probably the best one here is, is coaching calls. So just 46:30 getting your Calendly up, connecting that to Stripe, charging 100 bucks, 200 bucks, 300 bucks for 30 minutes, 45 minutes, an hour, 46:38 and just seeing what people will pay to talk to you about with is going to inform what product you can create for them way better than almost anything else. 46:49 And, um, just with those three or four things I mentioned, that can get you to $1,000 in revenue. And if you actually do those and you get to $1,000 in revenue, 46:57 you're, you're gonna know 10 or 100 times more than you do now about what people will actually buy from you. The reality is you have no idea when you first start. 47:08 But by creating content, talking to your audience, doing this type of stuff, you're, you're gonna know way more, you know, 30, 60 days from now than you do right now. 47:16 And so is that going to-- are those, you know, um, four things going to give you a multimillion dollar business in, in a year? No. But they're gonna set you up for that later on, yes. Yeah. 47:29 I, I th- I agree with all those. I think those are the major categories. Like my instinct generally is to go higher ticket, um, on that last point, so like the, the coaching calls, managed services, agency services. 47:44 If you're, if you're looking to create or if, if you're looking to make $1,000 in revenue, I think you could do that fairly quickly as long as the content is aligned with some sort of higher ticket managed service or offer, or like agency offer, consulting engagement on the subject of the newsletter. 48:03 So if you're serving like-- If, if your audience is B2B, I think you can actually get to $1,000, $1,000 in revenue at or before the same timeframe that you, uh, that you get 1,000 subscribers. 48:20 Like I think that as long as you're targeting those folks the right way and, and focusing on quality. Oh, certainly before that. Yeah. Yeah. And I, I didn't mention agency services because I think it's awesome. 48:31 Some-- A lot of people just wanna focus all on media and audience, and they don't wanna do any-Managed services or they don't wanna have a service business at all, or they don't wanna have an agency. Right. That's fine. 48:40 Just understand you're dealing with more of an exponential curve, but when you go into an agency or service business, you have more of a linear curve. 48:46 So you can get your first $1,000 of revenue with 10 subscribers, and then one of them buys a $1,000 a month service- Yes... for consulting. Exactly. So, yeah. 48:55 Our, our agency got to like, um, seven figures in annual recurring revenue when I had less than 10,000 subscribers- Yeah... 'cause I didn't need that many people to buy something. 49:03 So agencies are awesome, j- but just know what you're getting into if you're going down the service route. 49:09 But it is a great way to start, and also, like, you'll learn more that could apply to your content by doing some services. So at the very least, do coaching and consulting calls. 49:19 Maybe consider services too, and maybe that will be a whole nother topic we'll talk about on a future podcast. Yeah. I think that was a... I think we covered a lot, um, and I, I... 49:28 Like you said, there's a lot more that we can get into in a future episode. Yeah, I think in the future episode, just to tease it, we'll, uh, maybe talk about what is the first product you sell to your audience. 49:39 So what are the different categories of products, um, product selection, category selection, how to market it, that type of stuff. 49:45 We can talk about that next podcast, uh, 'cause that's, that's probably another 30-minute conversation we don't have time to get into today. But yeah, hope that was helpful. 49:53 Subscribe to this on YouTube, wherever you get your podcasts. The link to me and Ryan's newsletter is below, and anything else we should cover? Well, don't, don't you have an event coming up? Yes. Uh, yeah. I, I forgot. 50:05 Yeah, I have, um, I'm doing an event which is a mastermind and a retreat event. It's limited to 50 people. It's called Audience Camp, and the link will be below, but the website's audience.camp. 50:15 We got some awesome speakers, um, and if you wanna hang out with me and a lot of really smart media founders, um, info and coaching people in Asheville, North Carolina, we have a beautiful outdoor location. 50:27 Um, now's the time to apply and, and, um, purchase the ticket because as of filming this, we're like 58 days away, and there's about maybe 15 spots left total. 50:39 And like, there's a hard cap on how many people we can have at this event. And so I expect probably in the next... 50:45 Hopefully, you see this and there's spots left, but probably in the next 30 days they're all gonna be gone, well before the event. So, uh, thanks for reminding me. That's it. No, that's gonna be awesome. 50:53 That's gonna be so fun. Sounds good. All right. I appreciate it. Bye, everybody.