Transcript 0:00 [on-hold music] Okay. Hey, Ryan. How's it- How's it going? How was your, uh, Christmas and New Year's? Good. Yeah, Happy New Year. It was a good time. Spent a lot of good time with family. 0:14 Uh, and yeah, now just recording this on, is today the 2nd? Yeah, recording this on the 2nd, so it feels like getting right back into the swing of things. 0:25 Uh, maybe not right back, maybe a little slower than- We're getting there. Yeah. [laughs] I think next week everybody's gonna be, gonna be back into it. This week's been a little bit slow. Uh, yeah. 0:34 But, uh, how about, how about yourself? It was good. I kept it simple. I took some time off, but, um, dude, I feel like when you have a toddler, I'm working more before Christmas than I do normally. 0:45 'Cause we were like, we did everything last minute on Christmas Eve, and we're up till like 3:00, 4:00 AM getting things ready for Christmas. [laughs] Like, just wrapping presents takes a long time. 0:56 Had to put together some toys. Like, I put together a Teeter Totter that took, like, two hours. And so I'm exhausted. [laughs] I'm, I'm recovered now, but, like, that was exhausting. I was working all day, cleaning, 1:09 getting ready for people to come over. It was a ton. Yeah. I feel... 1:13 I was-- We're in the middle of moving right now too, so it's like the holidays combined with moving, combined with we threw, like, a, a big New Year's party at our place too. So today we're, we're gonna continue moving. 1:26 Tomorrow we'll be done, and then it's like finally can maybe take a breath just for the weekend, and then work starts up next week. So it's like [laughs] it's kinda crazy, but, uh- Yeah... 1:35 that's, that's what you expect, I guess. That's... It's tough. Are you staying in San Francisco? We're moving, uh, we're moving just north of San Francisco, so we'll be, like, 30 minutes north. But, uh- Cool. Yeah. 1:47 So we'll be, we'll be close to the city still. But yeah. Well, today we're gonna talk about the Honey scandal. Mm-hmm. We're gonna talk about trends, 1:58 what trends we're, we, we're buying, what trends we're selling in 2025. We might talk about one more thing too. 2:03 But before we talk about that stuff, the Newsletter Marketing Summit, our first ever conference, is coming up soon. It's February 27th to 28th in Austin, Texas. 2:12 So if folks wanna check that out, I think it's, we're at, like, 57 or 58 days till the event as of this recording. So the link's below, newslettermarketingsummit.com, 2:22 and we have early bird pricing, so you can save 200 bucks on a ticket with that link. Uh, if you haven't seen the speakers, it's awesome. 2:30 Alex Lieberman from Morning Brew, Sam Parr from Hampton, My First Million, The Hustle, James Altucher, Jay Clouse, a ton of other awesome people. So check that out if you wanna see us in person. 2:42 And now into the content stuff. So have you heard about this whole Honey scandal? And I'm assuming maybe, let's say, 25% of the audience has probably heard about this. 2:52 So I know bits and pieces of it, um, which is actually probably a good position for us to be in as we talk about this, because maybe you can explain it a little bit to me as we explain it to folks listening as well, uh, that aren't as familiar. 3:06 Yeah. So we won't spend too much time on this, but, you know, Honey is a Chrome extension that gives you coupon codes for things when you're shopping online, e-commerce, right? 3:15 Have you, like, heard of the product before? Like, you know how it works and stuff like that? Yeah. So you download- Yeah... the Chrome extension, it's free. 3:20 If you're on a website, it will say, "We have this coupon code," or, "We don't have the coupon code. It's the best deal." And then you click that link, and it applies the coupon code to your cart. 3:29 Or if they don't have a coupon code, it doesn't apply a coupon code. And so a couple years ago, they were one of the biggest sponsors of creators on YouTube. Mm-hmm. They sponsored, like, thousands of videos, 3:40 and including, like, MrBeast, they were one of his bus- biggest sponsors for a long time. I, I would guess, based off of what we know about the pricing for these, they've spent 3:48 millions on influencer marketing across YouTube and other channels. Definitely. 3:52 And I think, like, almost two weeks ago now, we're a little bit late to this, but there was, like, a big exposé video about Honey and why it's a big scam. 4:02 And I just kind of have, like, the opposite take on this [laughs] which is, which is uncommon. 4:06 Like, everybody's talking about how big, how big of a scam this is, and I feel like I can't be the only one who just thought this was obvious how it worked and how they made money, and the people thinking this is a scam are kind of uninformed about how the internet works in general. 4:22 So do you know, like, what the al- allegations are, what the whole, what people are upset about? So- I can break it down for you. Yeah. My, my kind of, uh, 4:34 minimal understanding of it is that they were pocketing essentially affiliate dollars that would normally go to, uh, maybe creators that wh- when their discount codes were automatically applied. Is that correct? Yeah. 4:49 And so maybe just, like, let me break down the business model. So, like, you download Honey, the free Chrome extension to help you find coupon codes. 4:55 It's a free Chrome extension, and so every time you're on a site with a coupon code or without a coupon code, it pops up and says, "Hey, we have this code," or, "Can we check for codes for you?" 5:04 I don't think it actually says if they have a code. I think it says, "Hey, can we check codes for you?" Mm-hmm. And, like, see what's available. I, I used to have it. 5:09 I don't, I don't use it anymore because it's, kind of fell off as far as the, the codes that they were finding for me. Um, and then you click that button, it applies the code or it doesn't apl- apply the code. How, just 5:20 guessing, how do you think Honey makes money? How do you think they monetize their, their business? I mean, I would... 5:27 [laughs] I'm kind of in a similar position where I would think that they would, it would be some sort of affiliate payout for, for purchases. Yeah. I always thought this. Yeah. 5:33 Like, the first time I downloaded this, it's, like, obvious because I see when I use it, it changes the URL, so the referrer is Honey, and so I know they're getting a, an affiliate commission on the sale. 5:42 But I don't mind that because they've provided me coupon codes, and the affiliate commission doesn't require me to pay any more. It doesn't hurt me, the consumer. Right. I either get a coupon code or I don't. 5:54 Um, and Honey gets an affiliate commission, that's fine with me. They can earn, you know, 2% to, I don't know, 15%, 20% maximum on a sale. That doesn't hurt me. 6:02 Maybe that hurts the e-commerce store owner-Who would've made more, but hey, the coupon code's available. Um, that's their decision to have coupon codes out there, not mine. They can disable those if they want to. Mm. 6:14 So I was like, "Who is this hurting?" And the whole concept of the video, um, the YouTuber's like Mega lad, Mega lag, MegaLag. Yeah, I'm saying that right. So it has, like, 50 million views. 6:25 And basically, if you watch the video, like, the first five minutes is, like, just him building up how big of a scam and a fraud this is, and he doesn't explain how it works. 6:35 For the entire five minutes, he's just, like, building up how awful this thing is, and it almost feels like a sales letter. If you ever, like, sat through, like, a sales pitch- Mm... 6:43 or a video sales letter, you're just, like, t- teasing and building up for, like, the first five minutes before you even share anything informational or, or valuable. That's what this first video felt, felt like. 6:54 And so I was like, I'm, I'm very skeptical when people use the word scam or fraud without any type of proof or evidence on, like, how that scam works or who it hurt. 7:03 And then basically, he describes the scam as this, basically. Honey goes out and sponsors YouTubers. They pay them money. They sponsor couple thousand YouTubers. They pay them a flat fee for a brand deal, most likely. 7:17 They promote Honey. Their audience installs Honey, and frankly, it's gonna be a fraction of their audience. You know, they might have a maximum of, like, 1% of their audience that actually converts to a Honey user, 7:29 maybe slightly more. 7:31 And then the whole scam is that when that YouTuber has affiliate links in their YouTube description, when someone clicks on that, if they choose to click on the Honey popup and apply a discount code, instead of the YouTuber getting that affiliate commission, Honey will get that affiliate commission. 7:49 And that is essentially the scam or the fraud that this person is exposing. And I'm like, isn't this obvious? Especially if you're someone who's promoting it, wouldn't you understand how it works? 7:59 And especially if you're someone who's already doing affiliate marketing, wouldn't you understand how this works? And so how is that a scam or a fraud? Is it misleading? That's debatable, 8:10 but I don't see how that's a scam or a fraud. Yeah. It, to me, I don't necessarily see directly how it's hurting creators because w- I mean, I guess if... 8:23 The fact that they're targeting creators for their marketing of it maybe means that there's more of an overlap where that could, uh, cause problems. So, like, say, again, like, l- let's use, like, uh... 8:36 [laughs] I mean, maybe not the best example because he's making tons and tons of money off of all of his placements anyway, but, like, MrBeast. 8:42 So, like, Mis- someone from MrBeast's audience downloads Honey based on the spon- them sponsoring the video, then I guess there is a percentage of that creator's audience where if they click, uh, if they're using Honey, to your point, it's like there's a lot of conditions that need to be fulfilled for it to actually take dollars out of the pocket of the creator themselves, right? 9:03 Um, so yeah, I don't know. It's, it's, uh- I, I think it's a big stretch. Yeah. I, I think you're right. 'Cause first of all, look, the creator's getting paid. 9:11 It's also important to note the consumer isn't getting hurt in any way. 9:15 Maybe the e-commerce store owner is getting less profit, and maybe the creator is getting less affiliate revenue, but the consumer isn't being hurt at all. And- Yeah... 9:25 you know, like, you really have to stretch this out. So, like, 1% of my subscribers or viewers download Honey. That's a lot. If a, if a lot, if, if that many, that's a huge conversion percentage. 9:36 And then what percentage of those actually click on a, an affiliate link in my description? And then what percentage of those actually click the Honey popup? It's like- Right... it becomes very minuscule. 9:46 And now Honey is marketing outside of that channel too, and so maybe more people have downloaded it. I, I imagine Honey has t- millions or tens of millions of users. 9:54 But if we wanna think about this further, would a YouTuber or a creator or a media company, would they rather have a sponsorship brand deal where they get paid a flat fee 10:04 of thousands or tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of dollars upfront, guaranteed, or would they rather have the possibility of more affiliate revenue if someone clicks a link in their description? 10:17 Like, which one would they rather have? And if you look at YouTubers' revenue channels, the vast majority is brand deals and YouTube AdSense. It's either AdSense number one or brand deals number two. 10:30 Affiliate revenue is usually much further down on that list. It's, it's one, two, five, maybe 10% of their total revenue. It, it's minuscule compared to the brand deals. 10:39 And so I would think if I were in that position, I would rather have the brand deal from Honey than the potential for a little bit more affiliate revenue from my links. 10:49 Yeah, and not to mention, like, putting, putting our marketing hat on a little bit and even thinking about those edge, edge cases like we're talking about, I would imagine that they would still... 10:59 Like, like, marketers at these brands are still tracking, like, volume of folks that are clicking the links too, like, on the landing. 11:07 So, like, i- if anything, it might encourage, like, rebooking with that creator, uh, just seeing that folks are even just clicking on them, even if the revenue's getting attributed to, um, to, to Honey or, or however, however that works on their back end. 11:19 But yeah, no, I agree with you. I think it's, um... 11:22 Like, having learned what I've learned about it, uh, just over the past, uh, day or so after, after we kind of discussed this a little bit, um, yeah, I think, uh, it is, like, an edge case. 11:34 I don't, I, I wouldn't classify it as, like, a scam, right? Like, if that's, if that's the kind of word that somebody was going for. Yeah, a scam is a mali- a malicious thing that hurts the consumer. Yeah. 11:42 That is, like, outright lying. I, I don't see it as that. I think, like, the, the term scam, like, people use that word to mean it's not a good value. Mm. But that's not what the word scam means. 11:54 And so if you don't see it as a good value to you or the creator, it... Maybe Honey's not a good value. I don't know. But- Yeah... the word scam is- isn't the right, [laughs] isn't the right term for this. 12:05 Um, and it's just crazy. I think this is gonna hurt a lot of YouTube creators too, 'cause this is one of the... I mean, sponsorsFollow other sponsors or other advertisers. 12:14 And if they see, okay, this is one of the biggest supporters of YouTube channels over the past couple years, and now they're getting demolished by the entire YouTube community, and they're sh- those YouTubers are destroying the Honey brand, why would I wanna spend my ad dollars on YouTube creators when they could turn on me? 12:29 Is that what's happening currently? Like I, I, to be honest- Everybody's come out against Honey, like in like- Yeah... dozens of channels, um, have basically said, "Oh, this is misleading, this is bad." Hmm. 12:41 Dozens of creators. And then the average, you know, YouTube viewer is totally on board, like, "Oh, this is awful." 'Cause first of all, they have this preconceived notion that all advertisers are bad. Mm-hmm. 12:49 And also they're just totally uninformed about how affiliate marketing works, and they don't understand this is the trade-off. Like you get a free Chrome extension because they monetize through these affiliate links. 13:01 You don't have to download it. You don't have to click it. It's your choice as a consumer. It doesn't hurt you in any way. Right. But there's, there's a whole group of people that are just quick to call anything a scam. 13:11 Yeah. Well, and also [chuckles] you think about how YouTubers get clicks anyway, right? 13:16 I mean, like, if you have a big bold claim like, "Honey is a scam," uh, and a thumbnail, like I think I saw the thumbnail of the video, uh, and it, you know, it 13:26 super dramatic and, um, and inflammatory, like that's what gets clicks, right? So I mean, there's almost... 13:33 It's encouraged just based on the nature of the platform to, to make a big bold claim like that, and then yeah, other folks are gonna jump onto that. So yeah, to, I... Just to put a bow on it, like I think, uh, it's... 13:45 When you first asked me, you're like, "How would you think Honey makes money?" Uh, that's how I thought they were making money in the first place, was through affiliate, uh, payouts. 13:53 So [chuckles] And this guy in the video, I mean, I, I don't really know him or, or know his content, so I'm not, I'm not necessarily criticizing him individually, just this, this movement or this like news story in general, I'm criticizing it. 14:04 He's like, "Well, I discovered and I found out this hidden way," and he acted like this was some huge discovery and that no one was talking about it. I think no one was talking about it because it was just so obvious. 14:16 Right. Everybody knew this. I bet a minimum of 50% of the people that they actually sponsored knew how it works. You can read them their terms and conditions. 14:24 When he, the, the YouTuber, he reached out to Honey support to ask them questions about this, and they're like, "Yeah, this is how it works." They just explained it like, [sniffing] 14:31 like nothing is, is wrong because nothing is wrong. Yeah. And, um, I, I think it's crazy. 14:36 One other thing is like a lot of YouTubers, they put affiliate links in their YouTube description, and they don't disclose that those are affiliate links. I don't really care about that, but 14:45 many people would see that as unethical, and I think it may be un- illegal if you're not disclosing an affiliate link, because you are getting paid for that. And so that's very common. 14:54 And so, like in this whole process, he was showing screenshots of YouTubers who didn't disclose their affiliate links, and so isn't that misleading or a scam or unethical? He didn't point that out at all. So I'm like, 15:07 this whole thing is a way to generate views by destroying a company. I don't really care about Honey. They're owned by PayPal, right? But- Yeah... I just thought it was really strange. 15:16 And if you don't like it as a creator or a publisher or as a user, you don't have to use it. It just, they made this service, it's a trade-off, you know, use it or don't use it, it's free, it doesn't hurt you. 15:25 The only thing that he covered about Honey that I thought was misleading, that I didn't like about them is they changed their business model. 15:34 And so it basically used to be a service where they would scour the internet for coupon codes and find you the best coupon code that they could find, and that was their messaging. 15:43 Like, we'll find you the best coupon code. 15:46 Later on, I don't know if it was before or after the PayPal acquisition, they stopped doing that, and they basically, instead of having like affiliate mar- model, they basically have a partnership model where they partner with thousands of e-commerce stores and merchants, 15:58 and those stores control the coupon code. And so that store will provide a 5%, 7%, maybe 10% or 20% coupon code, and then Honey will give that to you. Hmm. 16:10 So and rather, rather than Honey scouring the internet, they're working directly with the brand and using the brand's coupon code. 16:17 And so there may be a better coupon code out there on the internet if you were to find it or get access to it. 16:24 So Honey's still saving you 10%, but maybe you could have saved 15% if you found a different coupon code somewhere else. Hmm. 16:31 Um, and so people didn't like the fact that Honey previously marketed themselves as the way to find the best coupon code, and I believe when they made this change, and if you look at their website now, 16:40 they just market themselves as a way to find coupon codes. They don't say the best coupon code. So they changed their business model, they changed their marketing messaging. 16:49 However, all of the old YouTube sponsorships still use the old marketing messaging where it's like the best coupon code, the most amount of money saved. And so people are like, "Oh, that's misleading, that's a scam." 16:59 I, I think that's problematic, but also I, I, I bet that they changed all of their messaging when this change actually, actually happened. If they didn't and they misled people, that's a problem. 17:10 I just don't see the business model or the way this, this works a- as a problem. Hmm. Yeah. I would, I would be interested to know why they made that change. Maybe it was even with the affiliate cut. Uh, I mean, 17:23 after an acquisition, they're probably looking at ways to, to just grow revenue, and partnerships might be just a, a good way to do that. 17:29 Um- Yeah, I think it's just a better business model than just like finding the coupon codes. They can work directly. 17:35 They were probably working with third-party affiliate networks before, and now they're working directly with the, um, store owner, the brand owner, so they make more money than having the other third party in the way taking a percentage of that, that commission. 17:48 So, and like Honey is not the only, you know, tool or, or Chrome extension or website that does this. It's like pretty common. Yeah. Just interesting stuff. I think the scam is overblown, for what it's worth. 18:00 [laughs] But yeah. Um- Yeah, I could go on. It just, uh, this just like killed me. It's just like a lack of understanding of how the internet works and what a scam is. 18:11 And how affiliate- And people like- How just what affiliate marketing is and, and all of... Yeah. Hundred percent. Yeah, just people out for views over nuance. 18:17 Like there's a lot of nuance to this, and-People just want it to generate the most amount of views, which is why YouTube is, like, a tough place for journalism and thing- [chuckles]... things like that. Um, okay. 18:29 I hope people didn't mind that topic too much. I'm trying to expand the, in the different things that are, like, not all newsletter stuff. But let's talk about some newsletter stuff. Awesome. 18:37 Um, I know we-- So before we started recording here, we were talking about, uh, kinda the idea of buying and selling trends for 2025, right? 18:47 You want to explain kind of what that is, like buying and selling trends for 2025? Yeah. So b- if, if we're saying, "I'm buying this trend," that means 18:55 I'm betting on it, I think we're gonna see more of it, I would put my money behind it. If I'm selling the trend, I'm betting against it, we're g- I think we're gonna see less of it. And so that, that's how it works. 19:06 And so we wanna talk about, you know, what's changing in the, the newsletter, media, education, and creator space in 2025, what trends we're betting on, or what trends we're buying and what trends we're selling. So 19:18 we can break that down now. Do you wanna have, uh... Do you wanna share one first? I got, I got a ton as well. Sure. Um, okay, yeah. 19:25 So, uh, this first one that I have, I mean, a lot of these we've talked about in bits and pieces, but I think this is a good roundup. So the first one I have is kind of a video-first content strategy. 19:36 So, uh, leading with video first for creators. And I think that this is just, we're seeing this be rewarded algorithmically across all of the major platforms right now. 19:48 Um, I mean, we just spent so much time talking about, uh, YouTube. Uh, like, YouTube is obviously a great place to not just grow an audience, but, uh, grow a business and drive, drive qualified leads to a business. 20:00 LinkedIn is promoting video, uh, a- and, and providing larger reach to video posts. Uh, Twitter, uh, or X is doing the same. Um, and so I think just leading with video first. 20:12 And what I mean by le- by a video first as opposed to just, like, a video only, and this will go into another kind of trend that I have, uh, maybe potentially after this. 20:20 But putting, uh, a ton of effort into the scripting, production, editing of, uh, video content, and then using that as the foundation for kind of, uh, the distribution of content across other channels. 20:35 So, uh, you know, obviously there's, there's the obvious, which is, like, clipping videos for, for stuff like TikTok or Reels or, or even LinkedIn or Twitter. 20:43 But then even, uh, taking kind of a transcript of that video, uh, and using it as the basis for more, uh, text-first, uh, content channels like, like X or like sl- like LinkedIn, like using the, the transcript or the ideas from the video that you, that you, uh, put so much effort into a- and basically just starting, starting with the video, branching off to other content from it. 21:03 So that's what I mean by video first, and that's a trend. Yeah. That's the first trend that I would be buying this year. 21:08 Yeah, and if you just look at-- I mean, this may seem obvious to some people, not obvious to others, but if you just look at, like, all the social platforms out there, almost all of them have moved to a focus on video, aside from X and LinkedIn. 21:19 But just in the past six months, they're emphasizing it much more, or even six to 12 months. So, you know, Instagram has basically moved to video first. 21:28 Facebook has moved to video first, although it's still a mix of images as well. Um, obviously YouTube, TikTok, et cetera, the, the ones that have already been video first. 21:38 And that's not going away, it's just the natural... It's just way easier for people to consume video, right? [chuckles] Yeah. 21:44 People are too lazy to read stuff, which is, in some ways, in my opinion, like a sad direction that the internet is going in. That's why I care so much about newsletters, and even podcasts. 21:55 But also podcasts are going video first, because most people are getting most of their podcast views through YouTube and not through RSS. And so I d- I don't love this trend, but I'm buying it too. This year, 22:08 the only really social channel I'm gonna focus on is, is YouTube. All the other ones are gonna be a distant second. 22:15 And the way we're gonna grow our list is YouTube and Facebook Ads, and most of our Facebook Ads will be video ads. [chuckles] So I'm buying that one. Do you have one that you're selling? Yeah. So I have, um, [chuckles] 22:29 this one. This one's maybe a little bit more, like, general and taste-based, but, uh, thread boy content. I am selling thread boy content. 22:37 What I mean by that is just kind of just, like, general information, like roundup content on, uh, on Twitter and LinkedIn meant to, um... It's meant to be clickbaity. Um, a- and I think that it's... 22:52 I mean, I don't know if it's getting deprioritized necessarily by X, but I think people, especially, like, the savvier, uh, like, content consumers on X and LinkedIn, I think they're just getting kind of, like, tired of that content. 23:05 And I don't-- And in my, in my experience and in, in folks that I've spoken to too, it's just not good at driving... If you're trying to build, um... It's good for top of funnel, right? 23:15 So getting maybe, uh, just, like, higher vanity metrics like followers and, and clicks and, and shares and, and retweets. 23:23 But, uh, it's not a great way to build a, a focused audience that is gonna form the basis of, of a business. Yeah. It'll get you followers, not customers. Exactly. 23:35 And also, I just wanna see less of it, [chuckles] so, so I'm selling it. Uh, yeah. Yeah. It's like the, uh... What, what's a good example? Like the why, why a Costco hotdog is still $2. Yeah. 23:45 Or- Or the unknown story of Jeff Bezos... these emails from Steve Jobs. Yeah. [chuckles] It's Jeff Bezos. Yeah. These emails from Steve Jobs will shock you in how brutal he was. Yeah. Yeah, I, I agree. 23:57 I think people want more specificity. They want something that has actionable takeaways. But you still wanna balance that in being broad, because if you just do super niche stuff like I have often done, 24:11 you do kinda hit a audience ceiling at some point. And so I think an example of someone who's done both well is, like, Alex Hormozi. He does really broad content. 24:21 He makes a point for his content to be broad and simplistic, but also helpful and actionable.Um, and so I don't like everybody kind of copying Alex Hormozi, but he-- there's definitely a lot of things to learn from that. 24:33 But can I tell you one I'm buying, which is kind of related to your first one, but also different? So YouTubers starting newsletters. Mm-hmm. This is one I've already seen a lot of. 24:44 Not, not the biggest YouTubers in the world have really done it yet. You know, Colin Samir is a good example we've talked about before. 24:49 They have a great newsletter called The Publish Press, which is more like a media company and not just a newsletter. Uh, there's, like, a cool EDC channel called Exercise Me that started the newsletter. 24:58 There's a lot more, and I think this just comes back to the same framework of, like, I wanna take my audience from a rented platform to an owned platform that doesn't rely on me. 25:09 And also, YouTubers are hyper-conscious of, like, I have to be filming and have my face in every single video to get views and to make money. I wanna have a way to generate revenue without that. 25:17 Usually, a newsletter's the first next step to that. A lot of people, I think a lot of YouTubers in the past have started a podcast, whi-which can be great, and it's, like, less demanding than doing YouTube videos. 25:30 But for a lot of YouTubers, especially the educational or information-focused YouTubers, a newsletter is a much better option than a podcast. 25:37 They're gonna grow it much faster, be able to monetize the audience at a much higher rate, sell them products directly. So I think we're gonna see a lot more of it. I think it's gonna be commonplace 25:46 in 2025, especially for the education or information-focused YouTubers. For the entertainment-focused YouTubers, not so much. 25:55 The smart ones will use email marketing and lead magnets, but for the ones that I just described, we're gonna see a lot more of that. 26:03 I, I'm glad you brought this one up because it's, it's something that I'm very, very bullish on as well. Um, and just a ton of just, like, blue ocean for, for a lot of these folks too, right? 26:12 It's just, uh, a great complementary channel for, for YouTubers, um, and for podcasters too. I would, I would kind of, uh, add those in there too. But yeah, glad you brought that one up. Yeah. 26:26 We should do an episode one time where we pick, like, maybe two or three YouTubers and be like, "If I were this person's CMO, here's how I would build and monetize their newsletter." 26:38 Like, here's how I would create MrBeast... the MrBeast newsletter. Yeah. I don't think he's the best example for, for a newsletter because he's so entertainment-focused, and he has a, he has a younger audience. 26:47 But there, there's a lot of cool ones we could do that for. If people want that, shoot us a email or tweet us or hit us up on LinkedIn. One that I'm selling, to run through one more on my end, 26:59 is a trend I'm selling is, is Substack, and I've been selling this for a while now. Just Substack as a platform. 27:06 People may not be aware of, like, all the ins and outs of Substack, but I would basically say that, like, Substack is trying to build the Amazon for creators and media companies, whereas other email service providers like Beehiiv, Kit, HighLevel, et cetera, they're trying to build more like the Shopify to help people build independent brands that are separate than a platform. 27:30 And Substack has basically continued to double down on building the platform rather than giving the tools that creators need to build independent brands. And so they're pushing more and more people into the Substack app. 27:41 They're trying to get your subscribers to subscribe to, like, six other newsletters after you sign up, follow 10 other people. 27:48 Everything for them is about the Substack ecosystem, growing the ecosystem, and that goes against growing your independent media business or creator business. 28:00 And they've had so much time to provide the basic tools that people need to run a media business, like email marketing automation, 28:08 website customization, the ability to customize your sign-up flow so you can choose what your landing page, thank you page, sign-up process, checkout page, you can choose what that looks like. 28:18 Substack hasn't allowed any of that because they want it to be a platform that is closer to something like Twitter or Facebook than your own website or email list. And I'm very bearish on that. I think the reason 28:33 creators and founders go to email service providers and tools like this is because they wanna be independent from social media, independent from these huge platforms and algorithms, not reliant on them. 28:44 And so Substack, even though I love their mission initially, I think it's changed, and they're trying to build this basically social network and app 28:52 that's just another platform where creators are gonna get the crumbs, essentially, and all be fighting over them, just like we are on every other social network. Agreed. 29:02 Uh, yeah, I know we, we talked a bit about Substack either last episode or the episode before. 29:08 But yeah, I think just especially with kind of the ascendancy of, of Beehiiv and with Kit, uh, and the lack of progress just in working towards building the tools and 29:20 the views and the visibility and the reporting that, that creators just kind of need and expect now, um, I would agree. I think that that is one that I would also be selling. Yeah. 29:29 And to clarify, I don't think it's gonna be shut down or go bankrupt. They've raised so much money. They have, really have a ton of runway. 29:35 They have a lot of big journalists in publications on their platform, a lot of the ones that I like, like The Free Press has been pretty successful on Substack. 29:42 But also, if you look at The Free Press, they've allowed them to do things that they don't let other publications do. 29:47 Like, they have everything custom for The Free Press, and everybody else on Substack is relegated to the same shit, essentially. So not saying Substack is bad, I'm just selling it as a trend. 29:58 And I think the, the main reason why they've been so successful is because they just made it so damn easy to start a newsletter, and I think that's awesome. And so if people just want the easiest platform that doesn't... 30:10 that's more of a hobby-based thing, it's not gonna be a business for you, you just wanna spin up a newsletter in five minutes, you don't care about the money, Substack can be great. 30:17 Like, I would recommend Substack to my mom if she wanted to build a newsletter, right? And I think that's what attracted, like, a lot of journalists to the platform is like, "I just want something super easy. 30:25 I don't wanna think about tech or anything. I just wanna write stuff, and then I want, I want you, the platform, to get audience for me, get subscribers for me." 30:35 And Substack has done a pretty good job at that.I don't think the audience part is gonna continue. 30:40 I think that network effect is, is shrinking, and people are already seeing way less free and paid subscribers from the Substack network than they did six, 12 months ago. Like, that growth has flatlined. 30:53 Um, but I think that that's what's made them successful initially. I don't think that's gonna continue, and eventually the more business savvy journalist types are gonna get off the platform. Yeah. 31:03 I think that's a good one. I agree with all the points you're making there. All right. Should I give another one that I'm buying here? Yeah. Um, okay. So, uh, I'll make the distinction here. 31:14 So definitely not buying AI-generated content, but I am-- what I would buy is AI-assisted workflows. So like AI-assisted workflows for content creators. 31:24 And this kind of feeds into, um, the video first stuff in some ways, but I just look at, uh, tools like Bluecast, uh, or, or like Spiral, tools that are... 31:36 make it very simple to repurpose content that you've already put a ton of time into thoughtfully producing, which I think is the key, right? 31:44 Uh, to this equation is, is putting a ton of work, uh, and thought into the initial content, but then using, uh, AI tools or, or AI workflows that you've set up to repurpose those and just have more of a presence on other platforms. 31:59 Um, and I think it just allow-- it's gonna allow creators to become a lot more prolific across a lot wider space with, uh, with, you know, a-- without needing like a superhuman level of effort to stay relevant on all these different platforms. 32:13 So I think that there are some really cool tools that, that have already come out, tools, tools that I've messed with and used, uh, and, and workflows that, that we've incorporated into our processes as well. 32:22 I just think it's a, it's a trend that's gonna keep growing obviously just, just because of how, um, prevalent AI is becoming, uh, in pretty much every part of, uh, of online life. 32:33 So, uh, that is definitely one that I would be buying. Buying that too, especially if it can become more AI agent-like. Yeah. And like, I think workflow is like half the way there. 32:43 The, the next step is an agent that does all that for you without you having to do any inputs outside of the initial content, so that'd be awesome. I still think the tools are like okay. Yeah. 32:52 But we see the potential for sure. Yeah. They still require some editing. Um, so that's, uh, a, a good or a bad thing depending on how you look at it. Um, 33:02 selling, uh, we talked about this a little bit last week, or again, uh, losing track of, of time with the holidays, but, uh, vanity metrics and posting about vanity metrics. 33:14 So, um, t- you know, I think early on, uh, in kind of this big newsletter boom, there was just so much hype around open rate, um, even click-through rate I think is becoming [chuckles] less and less reliable just with- Subscriber number. 33:27 Yeah, subscriber number. And I think it, it produced a, uh, a maybe mis- uh, misled focus, uh, for a lot of people that were building newsletters. 33:38 Um, so I think van- I think vanity metrics, uh, and, and posting about metrics like open rate, like, uh, like number of subscribers, like click-through rate, 33:47 I think that that's gonna be, uh, on the way out and I think a greater focus on, on revenue, especially if you're a newsletter business, uh, I think that's gonna be the way forward and, and, and honestly a healthy change as well. 34:01 Absolutely. Gotta focus on revenue. Okay. Um, one that I'm buying in 2025 is newsletter ad networks. 34:10 And so what, what this means is a network, a marketplace, or even a service that helps advertisers and marketers buy ads and newsletters successfully. 34:20 And there's not really a lot of options for this now, but there are a lot of newsletters, a lot of great publications, audiences that these newsletters have, and there's a lot of ad inventory, 34:31 but it's not being filled in a consistent way or in any type of automated or, or, or, um, or way like that. 34:42 So the ones that are out there are Liveintent that recently was acquired for a ton of money at a very high multiple. I, I forget the number. 34:50 Let me know if you know it or if you can pull it up, like in the tens of millions, I believe. Beehiiv has an ad network. Kit has an ad network. There's a couple other ones that I don't know as well. 35:00 W- Wellput has a good ad network that I think they're doing a good job with. 35:04 And all of these except for Liveintent are, are pretty n- new and very much in the startup phase, and they still rol- don't really have that critical mass or network effect of advertisers and publishers. 35:17 They're also still figuring out the technology, how to price it, how they do it, like it's very much in the developmental stage. 35:23 It's very much the Wild Wild West when it comes to newsletter ads, and there is a huge opportunity for a player or, or it's probably gonna be between one to three players that consolidate this space, bring all the best publishers and advertisers together, make a lot of money and, and grow the ecosystem because of that, right? 35:39 I hope that player does it in the right way that is both right for the publisher and the advertiser. Um, there's a lot of w- wrong ways to do this. One of the wrong ways to do this, I think, is how Liveintent did it. 35:51 N- not that there's anything wrong with their business, but all the ad formats, all the ad placements are just banner ads. You know, they're, they're squares, they're rectangles. I just don't love how that looks. 36:02 I don't love how it makes your brand feel. Um, nothing against Liveintent, I just don't, I just don't love that. However, they still have been very successful just with banner ads. Do you know the acquisition number? 36:11 I can, I can pull it up too. It was 250 million. Yeah. Yeah. 36:15 250 million for a email banner ad network, essentially, and that's like underselling it a lot because they're, they're very smart and successful, and they've been doing it for a long time. 36:24 But I think, you know, if, if we're gonna see a successful newsletter ad marketplace, 36:30 um, and there's successful ones out there, but just if we're gonna see one at that scale, I think it's, it's gotta be native ads that look like the newsletter content. 36:37 It's, it's gotta have flexible pricing, so I think-And this is the tricky part is, is pricing. Like, I don't think it can be CP- 36:46 CPC only, meaning cost per click, so the publishers only get paid per click, 'cause that's not fair, 'cause then they're not getting awarded for all the impressions that they drive. Mm-hmm. 36:54 I don't know if it'll be CPM only either, because then, you know, the clicks aren't valued as much, and those CPMs can be gamed. Maybe it's a hybrid of both. Maybe you pick either one like Beehiiv is doing. 37:05 I don't know the answer, and this is one of the million-dollar questions out there. Um, and then you also have to like put the... 37:12 The technology is really tough because after an email is sent, that ad can't be changed, unlike a website ad. Like, you visit a website, that can change any second. 37:20 You can also do retargeting with website ad because you can pixel that user, um, and retarget them across the web. You can't do that with email. So it has technical challenges too that need to be overcome. 37:30 But if the pricing challenges are overcome, the technical challenges are overcome, and you actually get the marketplace of buyers and sellers together, there's gonna be a very big business that makes this entire s- space way more successful. 37:42 100% agree on this. Um, one more, I don't know if you mentioned it, but Paved I feel like is another one that are trying to solve this problem as well. Yeah, they're a big player. We should mention them. 37:51 And they're also doing it in a way that, uh, describes, I don't know, just like kind of the, the, the self-serve nature of it, I think is, is pretty interesting as well, right? 38:01 Um, and that's again, just what Beehiiv and, and those folks are doing as well. So, um, yeah, 100% on board with that. 38:08 Um, and yeah, one of the bigger problems that I think remains to be solved just in this space, uh, is, is how to match the folks buying and selling ad inventory. 38:20 Um, so yeah, I think that's- And, and that's why there's not as many successful you- newsletters as there might be YouTubers, for example, right? 38:26 Because with YouTube, it has this amazing thing that no other platform has, where you have AdSense. Like, if you get even 5,000, 20,000 views a month, you're, you're making some money. 38:36 Maybe the CPM's only like one to $10, but and y- but you're doing that automatically, and they get all the sponsors for you. With any other platform, you don't have that. 38:46 So if newsletters can have something similar, even if you don't have an amazing CPM, 38:51 that's gonna help so many people get started, and then they'll make more money in other ways through direct brand deals, selling their own products, stuff like that. Love it. Um, okay. Here's a broad one. 39:02 Uh, uh, two, two broad ones. T- one broad buy, one broad sell. 39:07 Broad buying, and I don't think this will be a surprise to anybody, but, uh, B2B newsletters, like newsletters for, uh, B2B and for high-ticket services, I think that that is, uh, only gonna continue. 39:19 Uh, just I think we've obviously done a lot of testing here and just seen a lot of success with like driving leads for, for high-ticket services, for agencies, for co- consultancies, um, folks that are serving business owners, and especially, uh, kind of these nicher, uh, areas or, or focuses for newsletters. 39:38 I think, uh, there's just so much opportunity. And so that, that would be the buy. Um, I don't know if there's anything you wanna add there. 39:44 I have, um- We've talked so much about B2B newsletters, but- On my buy list, the top one was B2B creators. Okay, cool. So similar, but slightly different in how, 39:52 um, the content's delivered or how the brand is structured. Yeah. Coming from a creator who's ideally like a, an expert professional in that space. Like Lenny's newsletter is a great example. 40:02 He was a product manager or some type of executive at Airbnb, and then he starts a newsletter on project management and design and, you know, building a startup, and so he's been super successful. 40:15 And so I think you just have a, a better audience building advantage and a trust advantage if you're a B2B creator versus a B2B brand, but both can work super well. 40:23 And the opportunities are just huge there because you're able to work with advertisers that can't be as successful with Facebook and Google, so they need to spend on niche publications and creators like you, and they're willing to spend a lot more because they have a much higher customer lifetime value. 40:39 So if you have an audience of 5,000 HR professionals and executives, you can make a lot of money from that audience, and there's many other niches where you can do the same. 100%, yeah. 40:49 So I think glad to hear we're in alignment there. Again, I don't think that would be a surprise to anybody that's listened to like more than two episodes of us talk. So, [chuckles] um, but no. 40:59 So that's, that's my big broad buy, I would say. That was also number one on my list. Um, and then selling, and this one I think there could be some exceptions to. 41:06 Um, I saw a LinkedIn post from yourself, Matt, uh, and it sounds like we're probably in, in pretty close alignment here. 41:13 But, uh, premium newsletters or paid newsletters, um, at least as kind of the, uh, the primary source of revenue for a business or for, for a newsletter, uh, I guess like a newsletter business, if you wanna call it that. 41:27 I think that, uh, again, having done a lot of testing, um, I think that there are some things that can make it successful. 41:32 If you have a really strong personal brand and kind of a, a rabid fan base, I think that you can build, uh, a, um, meaningful revenue from a premium or a paid newsletter. 41:43 But I would say in 90-plus percent of cases, I think it's way easier to monetize through other means and other channels and offers, um, especially, uh, you know, if you're, if you're looking at the amount of effort that has to go into to a paid newsletter, um, to make it worth paying for, uh, for most people. 42:02 So that would be, I think, a, a broad trend that I would, uh, be selling in 2025. Yeah. Another reason to be selling Substack, because that's the entire business model they're pushing their writers and creators into. 42:17 And there's a lot of great exceptions, but you don't want, you don't wanna put your best content behind a paywall, and we don't have to get into all the reasons why, but it's really tough to make that business model work, 42:26 and there's, there's very few people that have. 42:28 The only exception that's, that's really great is, is Finbub, where, you know, financial publications that are basically selling behind a paywall a newsletter that's stock trading or investing advice. 42:41 And the reason that works is because they're solving a recurring problem. 42:44 The markets are always changing, and so it makes sense to pay for that information that's updated on a weekly or monthly basis, right?Uh, one of the problems with most paid newsletters is they're not solving a recurring problem. 42:55 They're just solving basically a problem that could have been delivered through a one-time information product, a report, a e-book, a course or whatever, but they're just choosing to put that as an annual or monthly subscription and deliver it every week, and people just don't need it delivered that way. 43:12 Yeah. Or it's just not valuable at all, where it's just like I'm musing about these things and, like, I hope you support me through my subscription. That's great, but that's not a business model for most people. 43:20 And that, that's exactly-- that's a really good point to flag, um, I think 'cause there are newslet- I do pay for a handful of newsletters, uh, but I would describe it more as like the Patreon model, where they're just individuals who I'm really curious to hear their thoughts or, or I wanna support them in some way, and so I pay for their newsletter. 43:41 But that's, uh, you know, and that's, that's kind of why I flagged at the start, I think if you have a really strong personal brand and a rabid fan base, then it can work as a way to generate some meaningful revenue from, from a paid, uh, offer like that. 43:54 But for most folks, um, again, and you, again, you flagged FinPub, which I think is a really good exception as well. 44:00 Um, but, uh, I think if you're just starting a newsletter, uh, it might be a tough, a tough way to monetize upfront, and I would, uh, highly recommend, uh, trying other, uh, approaches before you do that. Right on. 44:16 Any other one you wanna, you wanna share? I might have one or two more here. Um, that one, I think that was the last one that I had. Um, let's, let's share the ones that you got, though. Yeah, I'll be quick here. 44:25 So I have, um, the next, next trend of mine is creators in residence, which is very much emerging because I haven't seen many examples of this, and this is the idea that a media company, an e-commerce brand or any type of business is going to hire a content creator as an early employee, 44:43 and it's kind of like just like there's entrepreneurs or founders in residence programs at different, um, venture funds or what do you call them? What's YC called? What's the term for that type of venture fund? 44:53 An incubator. An incubator, where they, like, stay there for one to two years, build a startup, get paid to build a startup, but then also the incubator gets equity in their startup. 45:02 We're gonna see creators in residence where a creator will work at a company for one to two years. They'll create content for them. They'll get paid a salary and, you know, hopefully both sides will benefit. 45:13 The incentives of this still need to work out properly, and it's tricky to get it right. 45:17 And so I imagine the creator would, depending on their experience, they would get a salary of, you know, one hundred thousand to five hundred thousand per year. They would get some equity. 45:26 Maybe they'd get the same amount of equity as their salary is. And then they would have to have some type of non-compete so they don't leave and go to a competitor right away. 45:35 One thing that could be interesting to incentivize a great creator to do this is let them create from their personal accounts, but the only product they can promote is the actual business that they work for. 45:46 But after they leave that business in one to two years, they keep all the followers and audience they gained on those personal accounts. 45:51 And they'll probably be creating for the brand accounts too, but that's an additional incentive to get a great creator at your business. 45:59 Um, and also if you're do- if you're doing like YouTube, for example, you could let the creator keep all the AdSense revenue, but there's a promotion for your brand in every video, so it's another way to incentivize the creator. 46:07 It's tough to get right because you have to have a good creator, but not too good because then they're, like, too expensive for most brands. 46:14 But we're gonna see more of this, and I think it's great for creators who are, like, n-not beginners, but, like, intermediate but not yet advanced, who still want a consistent salary and know this is a means to an end. 46:26 Like, they know they're gonna work here for one to two years, and afterwards they're gonna be much more successful because they worked with this brand. I like that a lot. 46:35 Um, and it's something that you see a lot of media companies doing. Um, like I think about, like, Morning Brew, uh, you know, The Hustle to some extent. 46:45 We did, we did this, uh, we had-- we at least at The Hustle there, it was, like, highly encouraged to have a social presence and, um, you know, there was a, what do you call it? 46:55 Kind of like an engagement, uh, group, I guess, within The Hustle where everybody was kind of promoting each other's content. 47:02 And so y-yeah, I think media companies were definitely, a-and for obvious reasons, ahead of the curve on, on that kind of, uh, model. 47:08 But yeah, I, I definitely see the value in having kind of a more freeform creator in residence role for companies that are outside of media, like bringing somebody in to become a B2B creator, like you mentioned B2B creator being kind of the number one trend you're buying. 47:23 Um, if you're a company that doesn't necessarily, uh, if you're a founder that doesn't necessarily have the, the strong desire to be that creator role in your own company, maybe it's worth bringing somebody on and giving them kind of the freedom to, to build, uh, that, 47:39 uh, that channel and that approach themselves and, and incentivize them for doing so. Especially if you raise venture capital and you just have more marketing budget to spend. 47:48 You know, investing two hundred K per year into this is, is more doable for that type of business or a business that's already producing cash flow. 47:55 And I kinda like this more than, like, the, um, hire a creator model and, like, expect to have them as part of your brand forever 'cause it really never works out. Like, like Buzzfeed did a ton of this. 48:05 All those creators left even well before they had all these financial troubles. Barstool's probably done the best job of it. 48:11 There's a lot of other brands that did a bad job of this, and the creators basically piggybacked off of the brand, were much more successful without them, and only stayed for a short period of time. 48:22 And so I, I like this model because it's like you know it's a means to an end. So it's like in residence. You know it's gonna be a one to two or one to three-year thing, 48:30 and you're both hoping to benefit from this in that period of time, and I think it's just a lot more realistic. 48:35 I don't think we're gonna see a lot of creators work with a brand for ten years unless they are a, a huge part owner of that brand. Do you wanna do one more that we're selling? Or I'll say one more that I'm selling. 48:47 You can agree or disagree, right? [chuckles] Let's, let's hear it. Um, okay. This one will be obvious to people who are in the Twitter sphere, but maybe outside of that. So I'm selling overseas recruiting agencies. 48:57 I don't think that all of them are gonna go bankrupt.I just don't think this is the best way to engage with overseas talent. And so basically, an overseas recruiting agency, like a good example is somewhere.com. 49:10 I don't have anything against them. I don't use them. I don't, you know, really know a lot of people have used them. 49:14 But they've been very successful, and they're probably one of the most well-known ones because they have such a big social presence. So they'll go and find you... 49:22 Actually, I shouldn't say this because I don't know their model. Let's just say like the average overseas recruiting agency, not somewhere.com because I don't know their model as well. 49:27 But the average overseas recruiting agency, they'll go and find you a virtual assistant in the Philippines, a salesperson in the Philippines, whatever role they're looking for. 49:36 Usually it's more entry-level roles, maybe usually it's more administrative roles. They will hire that person at their company. 49:43 They'll pay that person, let's say it's a, a virtual assistant, and I've seen the rates that they, they pay their people. They pay them five hundred to eight hundred dollars a month. 49:50 They will charge you three thousand dollars a month, and they'll lock you in for a six to eight-month contract with that person. They have a large markup, and that's their margin, right? I just don't think... 50:00 Yeah, it does save you time to go and work with one of these agencies and have them vet the people for you. 50:06 I just think with the job boards that are out there and that are developing, things like Upwork and, and onlinejobs.ph and other tools that are gonna be built, I think they're just gonna take that middleman out of the picture. 50:17 You know, their profit margin is someone else's opportunity, and there's gonna be other tools and platforms that just make it ea- easier to interface directly with overseas talent rather than working through a third-party agency that has a very high markup. 50:29 And so we've seen a lot of these businesses doing basically the exact same thing, grow really fast in 2024, and I think their growth is gonna slow. 50:38 Some of them are gonna pivot to like a platform or a software model, and some of them are gonna shut down, and that's my opinion. 50:45 Also, one thing is like AI may get a ton better, and AI may take a lot of the virtual assistant type jobs that these companies are mostly recruiting for. [lip smack] Yeah, it's all really strong points. 50:56 Um, and I would definitely agree with you, uh, in just that the, the companies that exist on the model of just marking up the, uh, fee for talent, uh, that does seem just totally ripe for disruption, right? 51:11 By people that can do it cheaper or people that will add, uh, kind of more functionality to, to their, to their program or their offer. 51:19 Um, one company that I would flag that I think is doing kind of interesting stuff in this space is Sagan. 51:24 They're, uh, like a, uh, I think their founder calls it kind of like the Costco of this, uh, of this space, where it's like a membership fee that you pay, and then for that membership fee, uh, if you're somebody that's like interested in pursuing, uh, hiring, uh, you know, like overseas kind of at scale or even just like dipping your toes in the water, for that membership fee, 51:47 they'll place, I think, either a certain number of, and I don't wanna, I don't wanna speak without knowing the details. Either a certain number of or, or maybe it's unlimited for a certain membership tier. 51:56 Um, but then along with that, they give you all these resources for training folks, uh, that you work with overseas for, uh, kind of navigating, uh, the legality, navigating the financial aspect of it. 52:08 They, as part of the membership fee as well, they'll also, uh, provide workshops and training for your overseas talent that they source for you. 52:16 So it's kind of just this like I think the, the, the people that are gonna be successful in this space are those that think of it from a more holistic standpoint, uh, than, "Hey, we'll just mark up the, uh, the placement fee," essentially, right? 52:28 Um- Yeah. And, and they're-- I don't know a lot about them. I haven't used them, but they're an example of someone who's doing things differently, and I think that's who's gonna succeed. 52:35 Like this overseas talent is not going away, obviously. But the way that we interface with them, the businesses that, that make money off of that are gonna change. And I think memberships- Yeah... could be a good option. 52:45 Obviously, platforms like Upwork and Fiverr have already worked. Job boards don't work. There's definitely more creative things out there that we haven't even seen yet that I think are gonna pop up in 2025. Yeah. 52:55 But I don't think it's gonna be the traditional recruiting, you know, 50% markup or more agency model. I don't think that's gonna win out in the end. 53:04 And, you know, Sagan's like an example of someone trying to pounce on other people's margin, and the guy who runs it like does attack-based marketing, where he's attacking all the other ones and trying to expose them to get more people over to his thing, and that definitely works. 53:17 But yeah, it's cool. And also, I think Upwork's like underrated. That's one that I'm buying in 2025 is- I, [chuckles] I agree. Yeah, like- I definitely agree... 53:23 they, they vet people through their review system, through the job success system. 53:27 Um, they now only charge a 10% fee on the contractor's side, the person that you're hiring, um, which is reasonable for all the things that they provide. Most contractors are like pretty cool with that now. 53:38 It used to be years ago, 'cause I used to do Upwork, it used to be 20%, which is a ton, but 10%'s a lot more reasonable. And I mean, there's millions of millions of people on there. So- Yeah... 53:48 that's a great way to start. We've hired a lot of people through Upwork who later came on full-time to our team. Yeah. I've, uh, I've also sourced a lot of great talent through Upwork. 53:57 Uh, folks that I've had like a strong relation- working relationship with for multiple years, and yeah, I wouldn't have found them if, if it wasn't through that platform. So, um, yeah, agree. 54:09 I think that's, that's an underrated solution that maybe some people write off because they think that, uh, it needs to be harder than it is, uh, to find, uh, good people to work with. But, uh, I will also buy Upwork. 54:21 [chuckles] Yeah. I gotta check the stock, but not- Yeah. May- maybe not- Not that it matters... maybe not that. Yeah. But... [chuckles] I bought the stock years ago, and it like tanked by 90%. [chuckles] Okay. 54:29 This was like COVID time type of thing. Yeah. Um, cool, man. All right. That's the podcast. Anything else you wanna mention, Ryan? [lip smack] No. Uh, looking forward to, uh, to chatting again soon. 54:39 Looking forward to be done with this move and, uh, yeah, man. Uh, get some, get some rest over the weekend, and I guess we'll talk soon. Yeah. Hell yeah. All right. Check out Tailwind, Ryan's agency below. 54:50 Check out Growler Letter below, and check out Newsletter Marketing Summit, our event in February. All right. Bye-bye.