Transcript 0:00 I'm answering your questions about how to build, monetize your audience, grow your newsletter, sell digital products to your audience. 0:08 So, um, Spencer's gonna ask me some awesome questions that you all, the viewer, has, uh, shared, and some, some, some of the ones that we've got from clients too. 0:18 And before we get started, if you have a question you want me to answer, just drop it in the comment below and like this video and subscribe. So let's get started. All right, Matt. 0:28 What is your take on LinkedIn newsletters? Yeah, this is a funny topic, and I hope people know what this is. If, if you're trying to grow an audience on LinkedIn, you probably know what it is. 0:35 Um, it's not an email newsletter, it's a, it's a newsletter that you send through LinkedIn. So, like, you create it, LinkedIn sends a notification to your connections and followers asking them to subscribe. 0:48 Uh, you write and publish that newsletter, and it's published to your LinkedIn profile. 0:53 Um, sometimes your subscribers will get a notification, and sometimes your LinkedIn newsletter will, will be sent as an email, but it's an email from LinkedIn. 1:01 Like, you don't get access to any of those subscribers' email addresses like you do with an email newsletter. Um, and so it, it's kind of, it's kind of like a glorified post notification feature. 1:11 I wouldn't even call it a newsletter. And my take on it is that 1:16 I've literally talked to hundreds of people who have email newsletters and LinkedIn newsletters, and I've never seen someone successfully use a LinkedIn newsletter to get some type of tangible business result. 1:27 I've seen people build large LinkedIn list and have a lot of LinkedIn subscribers, uh, but I haven't seen someone use LinkedIn newsletters to get more email subscribers, more leads, more clients, customers, something that actually leads to revenue long term or an audience that you can actually own. 1:45 And that's because it- it's just not... Like, people don't read LinkedIn news. They're not that interesting. 1:52 Like, it's better just to put that effort into a good LinkedIn post, an image, a carousel, a LinkedIn video, instead of trying to put it into a LinkedIn newsletter. 2:00 LinkedIn is a platform that's bloated with so many features. Uh, half of them should be deleted anyways. 2:05 And LinkedIn newsletters is one of those features where they thought it was a cool idea, and then the LinkedIn, you know, product managers just never supported it, and it's never really gone anywhere. 2:14 So I, I wouldn't encourage it. I would just say do better LinkedIn posts and find ways like lead magnets and various types of call to actions to get people off platform and onto your email newsletter. 2:28 And one of the, uh, the biggest problems with it is that every time you publish a LinkedIn newsletter, you also publish a LinkedIn post of that newsletter, and that post always has really poor performance. 2:39 Um, and LinkedIn penalizes you for posting multiple times per day. So you might as well just make that LinkedIn newsletter post a regular LinkedIn post, and you'll get way more reach that way. So I could say more. 2:52 It's kind of a, a strange topic, but that's my take. All right, next one. Uh, what newsletter business would you specifically start tomorrow if you had to start from scratch? Yeah. 3:00 This is, this is one I won't answer directly because I think a lot of people are looking for, like, the, the hot newsletter business idea. 3:06 Uh, but the reality is, I mean, newsletters are a channel or a strategy, they're not a business model. So what you're really building is, like, a, a media business or creator business. 3:14 And your newsletter may be the, the primary channel that you build your audience on, and that's great because it's the most valuable place to have, to have an audience, but it's not just a newsletter business, it's a media business. 3:25 Or maybe it's just another business model, like an agency that you build, uh, from your newsletter audience, which is how we originally started. 3:32 We originally had a newsletter, and then we had agency services, and we used the newsletter to get a ton of clients, and we got to seven figures in annual recurring revenue that way pretty quickly. 3:42 Um, but the reality is, w- when you're building a media business, and media just means content, that answer is gonna be totally personal to you. 3:51 And I believe there's, there's a very small or almost non-existing market for mediocre content or bad content. Media is mostly a winner-take-most game or winner-take-all. 4:03 Like, you don't need a dozen different newsletters on how to invest or, you know, business insights or news. You really only need one or two. Same thing for, like, YouTube channels you watch and podcasts. 4:14 Like, there's only so many you can consume, and the winners are gonna take most in that category. And so that's why it's so important to f- identify a niche, find a category, and have unique content to offer that niche. 4:28 And the category that you create or the niche that you select is very dependent on the experience, interest, and passion that you have as the publisher, as the creator. And so it's hard for me to answer that question. 4:41 My background, funny enough, is in newsletters, email marketing, and media businesses. Like, I worked at a company called The Hustle. It was one of the biggest newsletters that has existed. It had a big exit. 4:52 I was super passionate about newsletters even before I worked at that company. 4:55 So I had all this, uh, personal and professional interest and experience in newsletters, and so then I started my media company kind of about newsletters, and we've kind of expanded to covering media overall. 5:07 Uh, but if you don't have a, a background in something, it doesn't have to be business stuff, it's hard for me to give you an idea. So 5:15 what I'm trying to say is, you know, what are you, what are you the best in the world at or what are you so passionate about that you could be the best in the world at? And go and start creating content about that thing. 5:27 Again, media or newsletters are a content business, and you gotta publish content outside of just your newsletter to grow. 5:34 So you gotta find a discovery platform like YouTube, Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram, where you can publish content and grow an audience there. And I would just start doing that. 5:43 And the good thing about those platforms is you don't have to stick to one topic, right? Like, you can create posts on various topics, and over months of doing that on a regular basis, you can see what sticks. 5:55 That's my overall advice. 5:56 But, like, if, if I were to personally do it again, I would, I would stick to some type of B2B niche that I had experience inUm, and again, I don't have a lot of experiences in other niches outside of the one that I'm in. 6:09 Um, but I, I like B2B or the financial or investing niches because there's just a lot of money in those areas. 6:14 You're basically helping rich people get richer, so either serving high net worth investors through valuable content, um, or serving other business executives, founders, and operators through content. 6:29 Um, I personally like the B2B stuff. 6:32 Like, there's B2B newsletters that we've worked with who have 19,000 subscribers, and they're selling sponsorship packages for $20,000, $30,000, $40,000 because they have an audience that is super engaged, and it's of, uh, executives, founders, and leaders in a certain industry. 6:49 And so I think that's-- there's, there's literally hundreds of B2B niches where you could do that in if, if you're, if you're competent. And, um, I think it's a very lucrative, 7:00 sustainable business model that's also relatively low, uh, competition. If you go into, like, the how to invest space or how to make money online or something like that, there's just way more competition. 7:11 Um, so I'm a big fan of B2B media for that reason. But the reality is, like, there's endless niches where you can be successful. It's more dependent on your personal experience. 7:19 And every big client that me and Spencer w- has worked with and the, and the Grow letter team has worked with, everybody who has, like, five, 10 years of experience in something really interesting, or they have a super cool background, even if they're starting from scratch, 7:33 they are way more successful than the person who has been at it for years but really has no first-hand experience that allows them to deliver unique insights. Awesome. All right, next question. 7:46 I feel like we get asked this kind of every other week, but what's your kind of recommenda- recommended platforms for kind of each use case? 7:53 So not necessarily which one's better or worse, but, like, just kind of jumping through platforms, Beehiiv, Substack, Kit, Klaviyo. Yeah. Um, any other kind of channel you want to speak to. 8:00 Email marketing newsletter platforms. So I mean, the main ones, the w- the three that people really consider when they ask us this question are Beehiiv, Substack, and Kit. 8:10 Klaviyo is for, really focused on e-commerce, so I wouldn't do that unless you have an e-commerce business. And if you're not thinking about Beehiiv, Substack, or Kit, 8:19 you, you're probably just thinking about the wrong thing. Like, if you want to build a media business, a newsletter focused business, those are the three best platforms. And so the kind of the pro, pros and cons. 8:28 Substack, uh, has changed a lot in the past three years and is much more of a social media platform with a newsletter feature than a newsletter and email marketing platform. 8:38 Like, it, it-- you're very limited on how you can control your brand, your website. You can't do email marketing. You can't do segmentation. There's no open API. You can't integrate it with other tools. 8:49 I- if you just want a simple way to, like, publish things online like Medium used to be, or like Twitter or LinkedIn is, Substack is a, is a good place for that. 8:57 But it's really tough to build a business there unless you kind of get knighted by other big Substackers who are willing to recommend you, or you just happen to know a lot of other people on Substack who will happily promote your stuff. 9:11 I, I don't think it's the platform that you should build your email business around. 9:15 I think it's a great platform for discovery if you use it like LinkedIn or Twitter or YouTube, but it's not, it shouldn't be the bedrock of, of your business. 9:22 There's, there's a lot of platform risk associated with Substack, even though I do like it in many ways. Like, if I, if my mom wanted to start a newsletter, I would put her on Substack. 9:31 That doesn't mean you can't make money there. It just means it's very, very easy to get started. 9:35 Um, that said, if you, if you're thinking, "Oh, I'm gonna start on Substack and then move to something else," just pick the long-term thing from day one, and you can still add Substack onto that later. 9:45 Substack's free to use outside of the subscription fee that they charge you if you sell paid subscriptions on their platform. So start, start with the long-term thing. 9:53 And so the only two that I really consider are Beehiiv and Kit, which are both great options. Um, I've used Kit for a long time. I started my first newsletter there. Um, I've used Beehiiv for a long time. 10:04 That's where I have my current newsletter now. You can't really go wrong with either one. I would say that, um, as far as, like, the email marketing and newsletter capability, they're pretty similar. 10:15 Like, the, the feature set of both those platforms is almost one for one, so it comes down to personal preference and some small nuance details. 10:24 I would say Beehiiv has a better web tool set, so it's, the website builder is easier. The blog, you know, features are easier. 10:32 Um, like, if you wanna have everything on one platform, like your website, your blog post, your landing pages, um, all that and, and your newsletter all in one place, Beehiiv's really great for that. 10:42 The, the Kit web features like landing pages, um, Kit websites and stuff just aren't quite as good yet. And so most people who are successful with Kit use a different tool for their website. 10:53 So they use WordPress or Webflow for their website, and they use Kit for all of their newsletter and email marketing capabilities, and that works totally fine. 11:01 Um, but I think that's one place where Kit needs to catch up. Um, other than that, Kit's awesome. 11:06 An- another con of Beehiiv is it's, it's a newer platform, so it's a little bit buggy, and sometimes you run into some technical issues, but usually those are resolved pretty quickly. 11:16 Anyways, that, that would be what I would pick as one of those two. All right. You kind of touched on organic growth there as an opportunity for, um, Substack specifically. 11:26 Um, but, like, just all platforms, um, in terms of discoverability, where would you kind of focus your time and effort if someone was looking for an organic channel for growth? Yeah, good question. 11:36 So I wouldn't near-- I mean, ev- the reality is everything works. Like, people have built big businesses on YouTube, Pinterest, Facebook, Instagram, et cetera. 11:45 Um, and so it's a combination of, like, where your audience lives and where you are competent creating it. 11:52 And, um, so for example, like if you cover politics and, and you love Twitter or X, like that's a great platform for you, or sports is also good on Twitter or X. 12:01 Um, if you're more B2B or have a professional audience and you like the written word, LinkedIn is probably the best choice. Um-And then there's platforms where just everybody is. 12:12 Like, everybody's on YouTube, most people are on Instagram. Um, and then there's platforms that are a little bit more niche too, that, that are better for certain types of audiences. 12:22 So Substack is more of a platform for other writers, journalists, uh, people who care about political issues, uh, business people, professionals, stuff like that. 12:34 So if you kind of fit into that crowd, Substack could be a great discovery channel where you publish on their, their notes platform, which is basically like Twitter, and you build an audience there, and you get email subscribers there, and then you move those subscribers onto a tool like Beehiiv or Kit. 12:49 Uh, so that's, that's the long answer. For us, what we're really focused on is just YouTube. 12:56 It's not for everybody because there's definitely a lot more production that you have to do to put into video content versus text, and there's, uh, more of a learning curve, and we're still figuring it out, right? 13:06 We're, we're trying to do this the best we can, and we're gonna get [chuckles] a lot better a couple months from now. 13:11 Uh, but I, I like YouTube because we put so much effort into our content, especially like our longer form videos, and, you know, on YouTube, like, uh, there's stuff I published a year ago that's still getting two to five thousand views a week, or maybe a month. 13:26 I-- maybe I shouldn't say a week. It's not a lot, but that's actually, that really positively impacts our business. We get more leads and customers that way, and it... 13:34 What I'm trying to say is, like, your content doesn't disappear after a day or a week. If you publish a tweet, it's gone in twenty-four hours, no matter how good it is. 13:41 LinkedIn post, it's gone in a couple of days, maybe a week max, no matter how good it is. Pretty much the same with Instagram, um, and many other platforms too. 13:50 And so I want a place where our content can -- our evergreen content can live and keep getting discovered. 13:55 Like, we wanna, wanna create it once and then it be utilized for a long time, and YouTube's great for that as far as discovery. But like I said, everything works, and you gotta pick one to focus on initially. 14:07 I had a follow-up question, actually. Um, how do you really kinda think about content in terms of what's worth a, a YouTube video, maybe longer form? What's worth a newsletter? What's worth a LinkedIn post? 14:17 Um, maybe for you specifically, like, are you starting with a YouTube, a YouTube video, and then it falls into a post? Or starting with a newsletter, and maybe that turns into a YouTube video? 14:25 How does that content process look for you? Yeah. I, I, it's just, this is gonna be a personal answer, because this is the way that we do it. 14:29 Every-everybody does things differently, but, like, we kind of have, um, a hub and spoke model. So our newsletter is at the center, and everything is a spoke off of that hub, right? So I publish a weekly newsletter. 14:42 That's probably where I've spent most of my content, you know, creation time historically, you know, pretty much like three, four, five hours on Friday. I do that every week. I've been doing that for 140-plus weeks. 14:54 And then we try and repurpose that content elsewhere. So, like, we can maybe summarize that newsletter into a LinkedIn post. We can make one newsletter into multiple LinkedIn posts or tweets. 15:05 Um, hopefully we'll do more of that stuff of, like, Instagram infographics too in the future. 15:09 And then many times, not always, but many times, we could turn that newsletter into a YouTube video script or something else, or maybe even just a, like, a topic that we discuss on a podcast in like a Q&A type setting like this. 15:22 Um, so that's how I do it. Like, in a perfect world, I would write one newsletter a week, and then from that newsletter, we would create one YouTube video and, like, five LinkedIn posts and five Instagram posts. 15:33 Um, not always possible, but that's what we're striving to do. For other people, it's more like a podcast or a YouTube video is their hub. 15:41 So they'll, they'll film a video, record a podcast, and then they'll get five or ten clips from that video or podcast, and they'll be able to take the transcript of that video or podcast and, you know, produce written posts on LinkedIn or, or X with that stuff. 15:54 So I think what's important to understand is, like, figure out what your hub is for your content strategy. Like, where do you wanna direct everyone to, or where do you wanna repurpose from? 16:05 For most people, that's probably gonna be video, podcast, or email. And, uh, focus on that first, because I think if you're just, like, 16:12 s-super scatterbrained and trying to create original content for every platform, it's just not possible. All right. 16:17 Shifting gears, um, super broad kind of question here, but where do you kind of see AI fitting into the, the newsletter world? Obviously, it's, it's already been, um, 16:27 pretty progressive just in terms of, of increasing your, your writing ability and all kinds of things. But kind of how do you personally approach that? 16:34 What do you see, kind of how that affects the industry, um, without kind of losing a personal touch for- Yeah... the newsletter world as a whole? 16:41 I'm not the AI guy, because I, I really care about human touch and, um, making it personal, and like, I respond to customer support emails, and I plan to do that for a long time. 16:53 So, so there's a balance, but the way we treat it, and, and we're always trying to -- we're still trying to figure this out, is like using it more like a delegator or an employee. 17:03 Um, as someone you work with and give feedback to, not someone that you just completely delegate to. 17:10 So like, if, like I'm ha- w-with my newsletters, like, I'm writing a first draft, and then I'm putting that into Claude, and I'm having a conversation with it to try and improve things or edit it, proofread it, uh, punch up the content and make it better. 17:23 I'm not just saying, "Here's a topic, here's source material. Write the newsletter for me." Because that output, 17:29 the content output's really poor, and actually, I think it's always going to be poor to some degree, uh, compared to some original insight that you had, and then using AI to punch it up. Yeah. 17:39 Do you have examples of how you specifically kinda prompt it to- Yeah. Maybe we'll make a video about it... like, give you feedback or what does that look like? Again, it's, it's relatively unsophisticated. 17:47 Like, I'm writing a first draft. I'm putting it in first for just proofreading and copy editing, so just grammar stuff, which is, you know, something I'm not great at. And so then, like, that's step number one. 17:58 I'll, I'll update the grammar and, um, any, any misspellings. And then step number two is like, you know, clarification. Is something not clear? Could something be reworded? Um, you know, you can also... 18:10 Like, there's oftentimes I'll have different sections of the newsletter where I know, like, this section isn't strong.Uh, maybe I have a listicle in, like, step number two or, or item number two. 18:21 I'm just not quite sure how to explain it there. I don't have enough context or detail. I could ask it for more information on that topic. Uh, so that's one way. 18:29 Or maybe, like, I'm struggling to write an intro or an outro, and I could ask it to do that. So it's like... 18:36 You know, it's kind of like if, if I don't have a writer, but, like, if I had a writer, these are conversations that I would have with that writer, and I would tell them what to do. 18:42 But the nice thing about AI is, like, you don't really have to be polite or... Y- and you can do this, you know, an unlimited amount of times without annoying them because it's AI. All right. Um, next question here. 18:54 How do you decide when to pivot your content strategy versus kind of staying consistent? 18:59 I mean, this could be, uh, super broad, but wondering if you kinda even have encouragement even for someone who wants to, to stay consistent or needs to understand the difference a little bit. 19:06 Well, there's two different things here because there's, you know, channels that you publish to. Like, do you keep publishing to Twitter, YouTube, et cetera? Um, I guess then maybe it's three different things. 19:15 Then there's, like, the format in which you publish. Like, is it a podcast? Is it a scripted video? Is it a Q&A? Is it a vlog? Um, and then there's, like, topics. What do you actually talk about? 19:26 So th- you know, content strategy, it's at least three elements, maybe it's more. Um, and so we're gonna have to address each one of those. Yeah. 19:36 And maybe we don't need to go super deep right now, but let's go newsletter specific. Uh, someone's been writing for 52 weeks in a row about their favorite topic or, or something. Um, how do you begin to analyze that? 19:48 Of like, is it worth another year of being consistent or when to kind of pivot via newsletter? Yeah. 19:53 I think i- if you're not growing and you're not, um, you're not getting good engagement, you're not getting good feedback, you're not getting sales because people don't really think the content's valuable, 20:04 I mean, you're, you're probably gonna know after 30 days of that, assuming you have, you know, at least 1,000 subscribers who are, 20:11 uh, actually signed up for the thing intentionally and are, are giving you that, uh, positive or negative feedback. Or feedback just by complacency, by not reading it at all, by not opening it at all. 20:22 That's still feedback, even though they're not actively responding in a positive or negative way. Um, so I think, like, 30, 60 days max, and then that's when you can edit. Okay, do I pick different topics? 20:36 Do I pick a different format for the newsletter? Do I go longer? Do I go shorter? Something else. Um, but I think the, the real kind of trick for this is, like, 20:47 you, you shouldn't be iterating on the newsletter content so much, you should be iterating on your social content. Because you can't build a media business if you don't have an organic discovery channel. 20:56 We talked about publishing to, like, all the social platforms or YouTube. You don't need to do all of them, but, like, pick one, and that's where you can, like, iterate every single day. 21:04 You can post a new topic every day. You can try a new format every day, and you can s- see what resonates there way faster than with email. And so, 21:14 you know, what I find is, like, you know, I'm not really iterating that much based off of the feedback I'm getting from my newsletter content. 21:21 I'm iterating way more based on the feedback I'm getting from my LinkedIn content, for example, or, um, YouTube content, or stuff like that. 21:29 And then also just the conversations I have with customers and with clients, because I find what's, what's personal is universal. 21:34 So if I know, like, I talked to three customers this week who are struggling with this problem, I should create content about that, and that never fails me. All right. Kind of shifting gears here. 21:43 How do you think about changing the name of a publication? We just got this in our, our community group this week. Um, but they've kind of... 21:52 Um, not necessarily a full pivot of content, but certainly a, a publication name change that they're going after. How do you begin to think through that? 22:00 And then even down to the specifics of how do you communicate that to your audience? Um, I know you've, you've answered this before, but would love to hear kind of another specific answer. Yeah. Keep it simple. 22:10 Um, think about how you would talk to someone about this in person. Um, just like how you communicate in real life, and try and replicate that in your email communications. 22:21 So I'll answer that, but also I would say, you know, be careful of changing names. A, a lot of media companies tend to have, like, a lot of names for a lot of different things. 22:28 Like, your newsletter has one name, and then your overall company has another name, and then your product has another name, and then your podcast has... It becomes, like, very confusing very quickly. 22:36 So I would, uh, try and, you know, have like a total of one to three names for everything in your business. Like, if... 22:44 Our company is called Growletter and, like, we made the mistake of calling our newsletter Newsletter Operator. 22:49 We, we should've just called it Growletter or, like, Our Newsletter, and then our product has a different name. Um, it just... It's, it's a mess. 22:56 So what I'm trying to say is, like, first of all, try not to expand your names too much. 23:01 Just try and keep everything under one if possible, because that simplifies it for you, and it makes it easier for you to be remembered by customers. 23:09 But what I would just say is, like, a week before the announcement, um, let people know that you're changing the name. You don't have to say the name, but, like, one or two reminders before you're gonna change the name. 23:20 And then when you do change the name and, like, change all the branding, obviously announce it in that email. 23:25 And then I would have one or two reminders after you change it just to remind people that you did, because not everybody's gonna see the initial announcement. 23:32 That's the simple way to do it, two reminders before, one announcement, two reminders after. It can get way more complicated if you're rebranding your entire company and you're changing your domain name. 23:42 I don't wanna get into that [chuckles] because it's not super exciting. But one brand that did this really well is actually Kit, who used to be called ConvertKit. 23:49 So if you wanna see an example of that, I would try and look into what they did and kind of emulate that. And they were doing, um, a annou- Like, they were saying that their name was going to change, 24:01 uh, from ConvertKit to Kit for, like, three months before, and, like, all of their social bios were updated, their emails were, like, updated. It's like, "Kit, soon to be..." 24:09 Or, "ConvertKit, soon to be Kit," for, like, months in advance. And then they finally did the announcement. Um, and then they probably had some reminders afterwards too. 24:17 But they executed it perfectlyUm, so I would try and look back and see what they did. 24:22 Um, they also d- funny enough, tried to change their name, I think in 2020 and completely failed, and people hated it, and like they got a lot of backlash, and they [chuckles] immediately switched it back to ConvertKit. 24:34 But I think they learned from that, and the second time they changed the name, they, they did it perfectly. All right. Next up, how do you begin to think about pricing newsletter sponsorships? 24:43 Um, really it's for, for starting out, and then we can kind of shift into more at scale. Yeah. Well, pri- pricing is more of a factor of supply and demand. 24:52 And so if you're just trying to sell your first sponsorship, you're probably going to want to undercharge to get sponsors and try and sell out, you know, two weeks, 30 days, two months of ad inventory. 25:05 And then once you see that people wanna keep buying more, and it's relatively easy to sell, so you have a lot of demand, um, then you should increase the price, right? And so you're trying... 25:15 You're matching supply and demand. And so, um, the, the really the easiest rule of thumb is to price based off of the average number of unique link clicks that you send to advertisers when you run an ad. So 25:28 that can be challenging if you haven't sold an ad before. But, um, one thing you can do to combat that is you can run ad network ads, or you can run a product as an affiliate. 25:37 So let's say you, uh, run like five ads through an ad network, like the Beehiiv ad network, or you promote, um, an affiliate product as an ad in your newsletter, you do that five times, and let's say, you know, 25:50 you get a certain amount of clicks each time, you add up the average, and the average is 100 unique clicks per ad, and then you're going to base your flat fee on those average, uh, unique clicks per ad. 26:02 And so usually, um, the rate per click, I mean, it, it, it varies so much. It could be anywhere from $2 to $15. 26:12 But for beginners who are just trying to sell their first ad, you're probably gonna price your clicks anywhere from three to six dollars, right? 26:21 Um, so let's say we get, um, 100 clicks per average and we wanna charge $5 per click, then our flat fee per newsletter ad will be $500. So that's our starting price, right? 26:32 I would probably go a little bit lower, like two to three dollars per click, but you get the idea. Um, we go out and try and sell that to advertisers. 26:41 If we close a bunch and we sell out of ad inventory for 30 to 60 days quickly, then we raise the price. 26:46 If we're struggling to sell ad inventory, we lower the price until we're able to sell out for 30 to 60 days consistently. 26:55 And then, of course, as hopefully your ads get more unique clicks over time, um, and you have more demand, you can work on raising the prices over time. And for someone just starting out, would you recommend... 27:04 Is it a, a one-off kind of test with a, with a brand? Um, how do you begin to, to sell into more, more frequent, um, kind of ad placements- Yeah. We have a lot of content on this- Or is it like a package? 27:14 Um, forgetting some of my frameworks, but I, I tr- I try not to sell individual ads because, I mean, the odds if someone just buys one ad from you and your audience just sees it once and has one opportunity to click and buy, like the advertiser's not gonna be super successful. 27:27 So I would, I would try and sell a package of three to five ads minimum and give them like a discount when they buy a package, right? I wouldn't... 27:36 If you're only driving 100 clicks, you know, selling one ad to an advertiser just isn't really worth their time. 27:42 They're not gonna get many results from that, because I mean, imagine like 100 clicks, and then you have like a 30% landing page conversion rate, and then how many of those conversions actually convert to like a qualified lead or a customer? 27:52 It's very few. They might get like one customer or less from 100 clicks. 27:57 And so, but instead, if you sell a package of three to five ads that hopefully generates 100 clicks each, then they're gonna get way better results. And so that's what I would try and do. 28:06 Uh, you're still probably gonna have the price point of, of the pa- ad package be anywhere from $500 to $2,000 because people don't wanna take a big risk and spend a lot of money on their very first ad with you. 28:18 Um, but that's okay. I mean, we gotta get our foot in the door, um, try and over deliver for that first advertiser so that we can get more later. 28:25 Really, there's always a correlation between like, um, ads in the newsletter and then more advertisers that wanna work with you. 28:31 So like the more advertisers you can get, the more advertisers you're going to get in the future, and so giving people a great deal initially is a good idea. Next question. 28:39 You've certainly written about this a good amount, but, um, I don't know if you wanna give a brief. What's your process for list cleaning? Um, kind of timeframe, engagement level, re-engagement sequences. 28:51 What's, what's your initial, uh, 30-second answer again? Yeah. 28:53 I think most people don't do list cleaning, and it's one of the big reasons why your open rate, your click-through rate, and your devel- deliverability sucks. Um, and it hurts your entire list. 29:04 Like if you have even just 10% of the list who isn't engaged, it hurts your inbox placement with all the people who are engaging to some degree. So we have a couple rules of thumb. 29:14 One is that if someone hasn't opened or clicked an email in 90 days or more, you should unsubscribe them and stop sending to them. They're pretty much dead at that point. It's, it's very hard to win back. 29:23 I would say it's impossible to win back subscribers who haven't opened or clicked in 90 days. You're lost in spam or promotions at that point. You're not coming back. Um, and that's the most important one. 29:35 Two is to have what we call a base sending segment. Don't just send to everybody in your email list. 29:40 Um, and sometimes when you're sending marketing emails, send to even smaller segments who are super relevant, uh, for that message. 29:50 So like a typical base sending segment that we'll do for our weekly newsletter is, um, this, and it's all a or statement. So, um, people who have signed up in the past 30 days, 30:01 or people who have, I believe, one click in the past 120 days, or people who have one open or more in the past 90 days. 30:12 And so, so signed up in the past 30 days, one or more clicks in the past, uh-Was it 90 days or 120 days, and then one or more opens in the past 90 days. Sorry if that's confusing, but we'll try and put it like on screen. 30:28 Um, and so anybody who meets any of those three criterias, we will send to. And so they don't have to match all the criteria, they just have to match at least one of those criterias. 30:37 And that's what we consider to be active subscribers. But someone who hasn't, who doesn't meet that criteria obviously isn't active. 30:42 They haven't opened or clicked in, in a very long time, so we're not gonna send to them. 30:47 And so a base sending segment, just make sure you s- ensures that you send to active subscribers, and when you send to active subscribers, you always have better engagement. 30:55 Um, now that begs the question, what happens to subscribers who are no longer active? 31:00 Um, well, again, it's hard to win them back, and that's why your onboarding is so important and the, the emails that you send every single week are so important, because if they're not good, um, you can't beg them to come back later because they're already, they're already turned off by it. 31:14 Um, but what we do is a re-engagement sequence. 31:17 And so after someone has zero opens or clicks for 21 to 30 days, we'll send them a gentle nudge with one or two emails that basically try and re-pitch and remind them about what you do and why they should care, and we try and get them to move the email to their primary inbox or click a link. 31:35 So that's the re-engagement stuff. 31:36 And it's only one or two emails, because if someone's already disengaged for three weeks or four weeks, I mean, sending them five reminders trying to get them back on to the list in an active way is not gonna help you. 31:49 That's just gonna create more spam. Um, and another reason we do it at 21 or 30 days is because if they're only disengaged for that long, there's still a shot that we could win them back. 32:01 I see a lot of people send these re-engagement emails after someone has no open, no opens or clicks for 60 days or 90 days, and those are terrible because they never work. 32:10 People are far gone by that point, and those types of re-engagement emails will get like a 5% open rate, and you'll win back like five people, and it's a total waste of time, and it probably hurts you more than it helps you. 32:20 Great answer. All right, you wanna wrap there maybe? Yeah, that sounds good. We'll wrap here. And, uh, we're trying to get more questions and especially more strategic questions about like how to build your business. 32:31 If you have like a, a three, five-sentence question, that's totally fine. Uh, so the call to action is subscribe and comment those below, and we will talk about it next week.