Transcript 0:00 [on-hold music] All right, we're back. Ryan, how's it going? Good, man. Good to see you. Uh, yeah, doing great. How about yourself? Yeah, good to see you too. I always enjoy catching up. I'm looking forward to this. 0:13 I've had [chuckles] a very long day, and so I was-- I'm a little wiped out, but, um, g- doing this gives me, gives me some energy. 0:21 So I did a, a live webinar today at 12 for, like, two hours and then did some customer support and stuff after that and jumped over here. Nice. That's a lot of talking already today. So [laughs] hopefully... 0:35 Yeah, no, I feel that. I, mine is- Yeah. I was telling you my, uh, I'm on the road, so hopefully my audio is okay. I know we, uh, we, we invested some in upgrading our, our individual audio setups. 0:46 I don't have my audio setup with me right now, so hopefully it's not too gnarly. It's actually pretty good, but, you know, it'll be better next week. I actually got a new mic. 0:53 I won't talk too much about this, but next week both of our audio should be better, so- Sweet... that'll be fun. Where, where are you-- Can you talk about where you're traveling to, or is it- Yeah... you got family? 1:03 Christmas time. Yeah. I'm in Park City. Park City, Utah, for some skiing. We do, like, an annual ski trip with friends. The snow is not great yet. 1:09 It's still early season, but it's fun to, fun to warm up at least for the rest of the season. So, good times. Cool. Park City. That sounds fun. Yeah. Yeah. I gotta go skiing. 1:20 I haven't done that in ages, and it's about that time of year. T- let's, so we're gonna talk about today, um, kinda like a year in review episode. 1:28 It's not gonna be completely comprehensive, but we're gonna talk about some of the things that happened in the newsletter industry this year, 2024, when we're recording this. 1:35 We should release it this year or early next year. And some stuff we did in our businesses personally and what our plans are for next year. 1:45 So, do you wanna kick us off on any, like, key things that happened this year or concepts that would be good to cover? Sure, yeah. 1:53 Yeah, I, I mean, I kn- you told me w- or I guess we were planning on, on doing kind of like a year in review. 1:59 Um, and so I, I kinda wrote down some notes just on themes, uh, throughout just newsletters that, uh, I think we saw over the course of the year. 2:08 I think, you know, last year, at the end of last year, I was, I was doing some looking back just on conversations that we had and podcast episodes that we had, and it's funny to see, uh, towards the end of 2023, we had this conversation about, like, are we in a newsletter bubble? 2:21 And I think, uh, I think we were back then. 2:25 I think, uh, I think there were a lot of people that were starting newsletters thinking that, uh, a newsletter, uh, as a standalone business was something that would be easy to stand up and easy to sustain. 2:36 And I think what we saw, uh, over the course of this year, towards the beginning of the year and then just kind of as the year progressed, was kind of a deflation of that bubble, um, at least as, at least as i- in terms of newsletters as a standalone business, right? 2:50 So spinning up a newsletter and saying, "I'm just going to, uh, start from zero, and I'm going to create a seven-figure business that relies on, uh, just, like, advertising a- and sponsors," right? 3:03 Um, I think that we did see that trend recede. Um, so, um, I think that prediction was, uh, was pretty relevant. And we also saw a lot of copycats, like the- Yep... that was a lot of the trend. 3:16 It was like there was a couple things that happened. There was, like, the Milk Road acquisition that I think happened in 3:22 November of 2022, and that happened in, like, 10 months, and I was behind the scenes on that, and a lot of people, like, saw that and they were like, "Oh, this, they did this in 10 months. 3:32 I can just start my own newsletter on XYZ topic, crypto, AI, et cetera, and do the s- exact same thing." But they didn't really see all the stuff that went into that and what actually happened. 3:43 And then the second thing was, like, I believe ChatGPT came out in August 2023 or, like, late 2023, and then really started picking up in 2024 this year, of course. 3:55 And then there were a bunch of newsletters that, that hopped onto that pr- trend or a bunch of entrepreneurs that hopped onto that trend in many different ways, but one of them being starting the newsletter covering what's happening in AI. 4:05 Mm-hmm. 4:05 And you saw a lot of these people, like Rowan from The Rundown and Superhuman AI and AI Tool Report and Mindstream and a couple others, The Neuron, like grow to 500,000, 600,000 subscribers really, really fast, like in a period of six to 12 months. 4:23 And people were like, "Oh, if I just start an AI newsletter, I can do the same and I'll make a bunch of money." But they didn't... 4:29 None of those newsletters really shared what their revenues were, and the ones that I just mentioned have been very financially successful, but, like, they, they quickly filled up the need for that- Mm-hmm... 4:37 in that space, and the people who just did the exact same thing, copy and pasting what they did, didn't have much success. So I think that was a lot of the reason for it. 4:45 I think Beehiiv also got a lot more popular, and Beehiiv is... I wouldn't say Beehiiv is a part of the bubble, but it just makes starting the newsletter easier. Mm-hmm. And so that helped too. 4:54 Substack helped of course too. But I think, like, I, I, I see that being really the biggest reason for the bubble, not because 5:02 there's something fundamentally wrong with the email newsletter, but because, like, a c- a few of these events happened and a lot of, you know, low-experience people jumped in with the wrong ideas and the wrong information. 5:13 [lip smack] Yeah. I mean, because i- in theory, 5:18 especially without starting one, uh, or without having experience in media, you might think, "Oh, all I have to do is just, like, write, uh, a roundup of stuff that's happening in an industry and I can make a seven-figure business." 5:30 Um, and especially if you see, like to your point, these acquisitions, these large public, uh, hyped up acq- acquisitions happening, yeah, it's, it's easy to get, to get onto that bandwagon. 5:42 Um, but yeah, I th- I, I think, you know, you nailed it. 5:45 It's funny, in preparation for this, I was looking at, uh, some, some stuff that Beehiiv put out, and apparently, like, 11% of the newsletters that were spun up in 2023 on Beehiiv were related to AI. Yeah. 5:58 That was crazy. And that, that really illustrates the, um- Yeah... what the bubble was. It wasn't really a newsletter bubble. It was more like an AI newsletter bubble- Yeah... 6:05 of people just thinking this was the next get rich quick opportunity.And, um, it is a great opportunity. 6:11 It's just like you kind of alluded this, Ryan, it's like you don't just spin up a newsletter, write generic content, 6:17 grow to thousands of subscribers, and then sponsors just come running to you like they wanna work with you. You know, there's like three concepts to this business. 6:24 It's like you write the content, grow the list, and then sell. Either you're selling sponsorships or you're selling a product or service to your audience. 6:32 And the sell part, the part where you actually make money, is the hardest part. Mm-hmm. The first two parts are relatively simple, and you don't have to have revolutionary growth strategies or content to be successful. 6:43 I've seen that with a lot of people I've worked with. But selling ads and selling products to your audience is harder. 6:49 Getting people to send you money and pull out their credit card is a lot harder than a lot of people realize. 6:53 And so like that, that doesn't just come automatically when you have the audience, you still have to do the right things there. Yep, absolutely. 7:01 A-and then kind of counter to that, I think one, one thing that we saw was a greater proliferation of, uh, newsletters as kind of a fundamental piece of the marketing stack for, for other businesses and brands. 7:15 So not necessarily, uh, uh, you know, whereas newsletters as a business may have shrunk or at least the trend, uh, started to decrease. 7:26 I do think that we saw more and more businesses that have products and services to sell start to pick up and incorporate newsletters as a fundamental piece of their stack. 7:35 You know, if they're creating o-organic social content or video content, now they've introduced newsletters as, as a channel that, uh, that drives leads and drives revenue for them. 7:46 And I do think that's something that we'll see continue into twenty twenty-five and beyond. Uh, but I think that's an important distinction. It's, it's, uh, businesses that have products and services to sell. 7:56 It's not the newsletter itself is not the whole business, but they've adopted newsletters as an important channel, and I think that was a, a big theme in twenty twenty-four. 8:03 Yeah, I think we can say like we're bearish on newsletter-only businesses, 8:08 um, but we're, we're bullish on newsletter-focused businesses that use that as their main channel to build an audience and then sell to that audience. Mm-hmm. And it's no different than... 8:21 Well, I should say it is different in some ways, but it's similar to what many businesses have done, like, you know, HubSpot mostly grow through SEO. Some businesses mostly grow through Facebook ads, others grow through 8:32 whatever social channel. Well, with a newsletter, you're building that audience on a platform that you own, whi-which is email, right? 8:39 And you have a direct line of communication, much higher engagement, and you can build deeper trust and convert more of that audience into a customer if you do it that way. 8:48 But the whole, like the newsletter advertising industry is still re-- I think it's still really young. I don't know how you feel about this, but, uh, it's still very young and fragmented, and 8:57 it's not as simple as like YouTube AdSense. You know what I mean? So like you have a YouTube channel, you get a thousand subscribers, you can turn on AdSense, and I don't know, you make... 9:06 You might make one to ten dollars per one thousand impressions. There's, there's no switch you can flip with newsletters. 9:12 I mean, Beehiiv's trying to kind of build this with their ad network, which I actually think is one of the top things that happened in twenty twenty-four. 9:19 Beehiiv acquired, uh, Swapstack, I think it was in twenty twenty-four, and then built their ad network from that, from that acquisition, and it makes it a lot more turnkey. 9:29 But you're not getting the most lucrative sponsorship opportunities from that network. 9:32 You're getting more plug-and-play things that are gonna give you a two to four dollar cost per click or a five to ten dollar cost per one thousand opens. Yeah. So the direct relationships are... 9:43 I-if you're doing sponsorships, the direct relationships are where the money is, and that takes time to build. It's funny. 9:49 I'm glad that you brought up Beehiiv and kind of the, the trends of the features that they've released, because I think it's, it's reflect-- it reflects how the focus has shifted, right? 9:59 In just like this newsletter space. You think about twenty twenty-three, all of the hype was around growth, it was around SparkLoop, it was around these kind of co-registration plug-and-play platforms. 10:11 In twenty twenty-four, what we've seen is a lot of the solutions, even just, just, uh, in like the larger economy around this space, like agency services and so, and so on and so forth. 10:22 Um, but Beehiiv in particular, a lot of their features that they've launched around monetization, right? How do you earn money from this, from this list that you've built? 10:29 Because I think everyone's focus has shifted in that direction, uh, and rightfully so. 10:32 I think that's something that we were talking about at the, uh, even early on in twenty twenty-three, we were kind of, uh, flying that flag of, of saying, you know, I think monetization should be one of the first things that if you're building a business around a newsletter, you should, should have that, uh, in mind at the start of the process rather than as an afterthought. 10:48 So it's interesting to see. I think it's, it's, uh, indicative of kind of this bigger shift. Yeah. And I need us to keep going because, 10:55 I mean, there's just like this total irrational thought last year around just, like, just about subscribers. And, 11:02 you know, we talked a lot about, like, subscriber growth on this show too, because it is important, like you have to have the audience. Mm-hmm. 11:08 It's also a little bit easier to talk about because everybody's happy to share how many subscribers they have, but people don't want to share revenue numbers. Yeah. 11:14 And so that's almost another reason why it, it got such a focus, um, on people who were less experienced. But it really, like the number of subscribers really don't matter. 11:22 It's all about what you actually make from them. Right. 11:26 And I think, yeah, I, I, I hope Beehiiv continues to go in that direction because I think they could be doing a lot more with their paid subscriptions, with one-off purchases, email marketing, and yeah, the-there's... 11:41 They're, they're doing a great job, but, um, there's some more things they could do. We, we could... I don't wanna talk about-- 11:46 I don't wanna talk too much about platforms, but that would be interesting conversation, like how platforms have changed in twenty twenty-four. 11:52 Do you have any other, um, stuff to wrap up that point before we move on to other, other points that you have? No. 11:58 I mean, it's, um, I think that, that focus of the features that they've been building and just other platforms as well, not just Beehiiv, but, um, I think that that helps just illustrate that shift. 12:08 But yeah, I mean, a-and it also maybe segues to the next point, which is just, uh, twenty twenty-four, where you saw a big growth of just this economy aroundUh, newsletters and their role in email marketing, whether that be, uh, you know, SaaS products, whether that be, uh, agency services or, or, or service offerings. 12:29 I think just the entire, uh, ecosystem continued to grow, and I don't see it slowing down, honestly. I think it's, I think it's gonna continue through 2025, and I think there's a lot of opportunity still. 12:40 But yeah, I mean, Beehiiv's obviously one of the biggest, if not the biggest players in, in that economy. Uh, and so I think, you know, interesting segue to, to just the, the larger growth of the space. Yeah. 12:51 There, there's more of an-- There wasn't really an ecosystem in 2023. 12:55 Like, there wasn't many agencies or contractors or service providers doing much, but now you have people for growth, the deliverability, design, content, um, even strategy. 13:06 Like, I can probably think of at least six to 10 different agencies who do stuff around newsletters, including me and you. 13:13 You know, we have-- I have Growletter and you have Tailwind, which people can see down [chuckles] below in the descriptions. But, so th-that's one, like vendors. 13:21 Then the other side of that is platforms, which are the Beehiiv, the Substacks, Kit. 13:25 Another thing that happened is ConvertKit changed their name to Kit, which I don't think is huge news, but that's worth mentioning, I guess. And those-- I feel like those are really the big three players. 13:34 You have the legacy ones like MailChimp, ActiveCampaign, a couple others. Anything interesting that these have done over the past year? Um, I feel like Substack h-has been a perp- perpetual mess in my opinion. Mm-hmm. 13:50 I don't think they prioritize people who are building independent businesses. 13:53 They basically-- I think one thing they've done this year is they've definitely shifted to building a platform rather than a place where you can build your own platform as an individual creator or company. 14:03 They're moving more... 14:04 I like the analogy where like s- you know, Substack is more like Amazon, where you sell on their platform or write on their platform, and Beehiiv and other options like, like Kit are more like Shopify, which allows you to build an independent business essentially. 14:19 And that distinction has grown more and more. So like s- I think, I think it was this year when Substack... And if we're, if we're wrong on some dates, forgive us because we're just riffing a little bit. 14:29 But Substack launched Notes, which is like their Twitter competitor. They emphasize their app way more, and like everything in their ecosystem is all about getting you to like... 14:38 Not, not everything, but most things are about focusing on getting you to follow other people on Substack Notes and getting you to download the app. 14:45 Even their recommendations, like we talked about Substack recommendations, where you sign up for a newsletter and you see multiple other newsletters. Now you see other newsletters, but you also see who you should follow. 14:54 And it's like, why would I wanna grow my newsletter on this platform if you're recommending other people they should follow that aren't even newsletters? It's just-- It just seems 15:03 like a very bad idea to me to be building your audience there. What do you think about Substack? Yeah. I mean, it's, it's, uh, it's kind of a walled garden a little bit, right? 15:13 And I think it's not-- For that reason alone, it's, it's not super, uh, friendly to, to people that are building with like a long-term mindset for, for how their newsletter fits into their, their larger business. 15:25 They don't have the same real... 15:27 At least the last time that I was, uh, helping manage, uh, you know, just anything for, for folks on a Substack, uh, newsletter, I just remember the visibility into the metrics that I wanted visibility into was just not available. 15:41 And so, it was just the reporting... And you, you know, I'm sure they have the resources to fix these kinds of problems. Um, whether they have the interest or willingness to do so, I, I don't know. 15:51 Um- It's just not in their interest, right? Yeah. What was that tool that where you, where you could do like automated email marketing on Substack, but then they shut it down? What was that tool called? It was Yemm. 15:59 A-and that really shows me like what their vision is. Like, if there was a tool... Like, y- to build a independent media business, you want automated email marketing where you can send emails in a more sophisticated way. 16:11 Mm-hmm. And instead of making that better, they shut it down and focused on building a social platform. So it's like that's... That really just shows me what, what they're about. Yeah. 16:21 And what was interesting is i- with the, the acquisition of Yemm, uh, my, uh, my hope was that, uh, in seeing that and speaking to the people who, who were behind that, 16:32 um, that they were really pushing to build growth features and revenue-driving features for creators that, that would, you know, really move the needle and maybe, uh, bring some folks back to Substack and have... 16:47 and basically just have a, uh, a new competitive sense in the space, but, uh, it doesn't. I think they, they pretty much just kind of closed shop on it a-and focused- Yeah... that, that energy elsewhere, so. 17:00 It's disappointing because the original mission of Substack, I'm really on board with, you know, free speech, um, getting your audience to subscribe to you, pay for your content, I think is awesome. 17:10 Nothing against the people at Substack, I just disagree with the, the vision of what they're doing, um, rather than building like a toolkit, they're building a platform. 17:19 And I don't think, you know, Beehiiv and all the other things are perfect either, right? But I like their vision better. And, um, there's a lot-- There's just more good options now than there ever was before. 17:29 So you have Beehiiv, you have Ghost, you have Kit, GoHighLevel. There's a couple more good options out there that people can use. Also, you don't have to just use one. 17:37 That's another thing that a lot of people don't realize. Like, a lot of the, the best operators, they're using multiple email service providers. Yeah. That's very true. A-and yeah, I think the, the overall... 17:49 I think the theme here that we're, that we're really getting at is just the overall growth of the space and, uh, and all of these, all of these competing platforms. 17:57 I mean, it's no- it's nothing but good for operators, right? And, and for folks that are building because, uh, the more, the more competition there is, uh... 18:05 I mean, you've seen how quickly Beehiiv, uh, uh, puts out new product, uh, features a-and develops solutions to problems that people are asking, uh, asking about. And so if that's the new rate at which-... 18:17 uh, features are being put at, and that's, that's like the, the bar for, for other companies to meet. Um, yeah, nothing but good for operators, and it has been interesting to, uh- Yeah... to follow along. 18:27 And the, the kind of bubble popping, for lack of a better term, is, is good too, because it, it just takes a lot of non-serious people out of it who are just creating generic content. 18:36 And now I wanna emphasize, like that doesn't mean a newsletter is a bad idea. Like newsletters- Yeah... have been around before the internet, they're gonna be around for another 20, 30 years minimum. 18:48 There's a lot of advantages to it, which people listening probably know that we won't get into. Uh, what we're talking about is just having like a newsletter-only business where you just sell ads. 18:57 And I think this is something interesting where it's like the idea where you have a business where you don't sell anything that you own to your audience, like a product or a service, to me is crazy. 19:08 But a lot of people thought that model was a good idea. 19:11 I think equally having a business where you only monetize a fraction of your audience, like 2%, 3%, or 5% by selling them a subscription or a product, and not monetize the rest through sponsorships is also crazy. 19:24 And I think like both of those are equally crazy. 19:26 And the, the companies that are winning right now are they have a product or service to sell to their audience, and they monetize their audience through thoughtful partnerships. Yeah. 19:36 And, and I'll take that one step further. Uh, and, and I know that you would agree with this as well, Matt, but, you know, starting a, a newsletter business also isn't necessarily in all cases a bad idea. 19:49 Um, you just have to have a vision for the ways that you're gonna monetize that audience as you build it, preferably before you build it. 19:56 Um, but, uh, yeah, I think what we saw is just, um, a lot of folks that were maybe in it for, for the short term, uh, leave the playing field, which again, is, is nothing but a good thing. 20:08 Uh, and yeah, maybe, maybe with more experience too, to start something else. Uh, so yeah. Yeah. And we'll, we'll switch topics in a sec-second but, um, you know, uh, newsletters are, are... 20:18 they're usually a strategy used by media or education businesses, um, other businesses too. 20:24 But, but if you're doing like a newsletter-focused company, and these are really snowball businesses, so like it starts slow, you can't get an audience instantly, but as it builds, it creates a flywheel that keeps growing and growing faster and faster, and it becomes easier to scale. 20:39 So the opposite of that would be kind of what we started with, which was an agency business where, okay, you can get your first client, you know, for $3,000, $4,000 or $5,000 per month. Um, you have immediate revenue, 20:52 you can add clients, but, but growing that is really hard because you either have to spend more of your time or hire more people and build a bigger team. 20:58 So if you wanna double your agency, at the point where I'm at, I, I need to hire at least double the people and work with potentially more than double the clients. Mm-hmm. But to grow my newsletter, I... 21:10 it becomes easier and easier because I already have an audience that's willing to share my content. I'm able to sell ads to that audience at a higher rate, and as I grow, the ad revenue will grow. 21:20 I'll also be able to grow the amount of digital products that I can sell to that audience because I have a bigger audience. And, and so like at first it's really... 21:27 it's like really hard to get that first 1,000 subscribers, 10,000 subscribers. But once you're there, it becomes much easier. Whereas most traditional businesses are the opposite. 21:36 It's easier to start, but harder to scale. And, you know, with, with media and education, we scale through media. Like it's the... it takes the same amount of time to send an email to one person or a million people. 21:47 And so that's the advantage that it gives you, and that's why it's not a overnight success model, even though nothing is. Mm-hmm. That's, yeah, very true. I agree with everything you said. 22:00 I have a dog trying to jump all over me, so- All good. [chuckles]... that's why I'm distracted. Any, uh, final topics that, that you had about like, uh, the space in general? 22:09 You know, uh, I think in terms of may-maybe just for this one, that, that sums it up for me. 22:14 I think i-in terms of the future in 2025, um, I think we'll see a lot more focus on, and, uh, maybe this is 2024 as well, but focus on, on the metrics that really matter to a business. 22:30 And something that we've always pointed out, um, you know, 2023 e-even like when, when all this was happening is that, you know, stuff like open rate and click-through rate, open rate more so, 22:41 uh, it's not, it's not necessarily fully a vanity metric, but y-you know, you don't build a business around a high open rate. 22:49 [chuckles] Unless, uh, a- again, un- unless it's, you know, um, a sponsorship-focused business, but even then I think sponsors have become more, um, nuanced- Click-focused... 23:00 and, yeah, more click-focused and, and, and more sophisticated in the ways that they're pricing, uh, engagements and entering engagements with, with newsletter publishers. 23:09 But I think we'll continue to see that trend into 2025. Um, we, you know, again, we've been saying revenue per sub is, uh, is, you know, kind of the... 23:18 e-especially if it's a newsletter-focused, a, a newsletter business, that's the end all be all is how much are you making per subscriber that's coming in, at least in terms of growth or growing a newsletter. 23:27 But I think we'll... a- and I think that platforms will have to adapt to that. 23:31 I think they're gonna have to make their reporting more sophisticated and more accurate, which is a huge challenge that I think everyone's facing right now, is with all of these, uh, privacy blockers and, and shifts in the way that, that email platforms or, or email providers are, are sending data back to platforms. 23:49 There's a real sense of uncertainty around where the source of truth is, right? That is a big problem that these platforms are gonna have to solve going into, into 2025. 23:57 And that's not just newsletters, that's just all email, right? That's just email marketing in general. And so, uh, I think that that, for me, is the big theme that I'll be keeping an eye on. 24:07 Yeah, I mean, that's, that's, that's stuff that people are already working on, so we'll see what happens. Yeah. I think to talk about what you need, so you need, okay, subscriber attribution. 24:16 Where do my subscribers sign up from?Google search, ad, social platform, et cetera. What, what's the engagement of those subscribers by source? Which al- almost nobody does except for Beehiiv. 24:28 So what's the open rate and click-through rate from Facebook versus Instagram, whatever. Um, then you need attribution to a customer, and so wha- which subscriber bought which product, 24:41 um, and where did that subscriber come from, so I, so I know where that purchase essentially came from. But then you also need, okay, of those opens for, for each send, and also by each segment, 24:51 um, and source, what opens are, are bot opens and what are real opens, and then what opens are-- what clicks are bot clicks versus real clicks. Yep. [chuckles] And so it becomes... 25:00 It's not rocket science, but it becomes more complicated, and most platforms don't have all those features, and you kinda have to kinda throw a couple things together to get what I'm talking about. And that's... 25:11 But whoever fixes that problem, I think is gonna have a very big business. But it's- Yeah... it's not quite there yet. It's b- I mean, [chuckles] I absolutely don't have the solution. 25:19 There are people that are much smarter than me on this kind of stuff working on solutions, I'm sure. Um, but yeah, the bot, the bot click and bot open problem, I think is, is just big across all email right now. 25:29 And, um, hopefully someone's able to find a way to solve it in 2025. 25:34 Yeah, for people who aren't aware, bots don't necessarily mean the subscriber isn't a real person opening or reading, it's just a lot of the bots are corporate firewalls. 25:41 So you have a company email, and it's gonna automatically open that email and click every link just to look out for phishing and, and dangerous stuff. 25:49 Even though there still may, may be a real person behind that opening it, reading it, clicking some links, but they didn't click 100% of the links. 25:57 So you don't wanna necessarily remove all the bots from your list either. There, there's, you know, safe bots and there's malicious bots, and it can be confusing. 26:07 Most people don't have to worry too much about this if they're just getting started, but- Yeah... when you get bigger, it becomes something to, to understand. Yeah. All right. 26:17 Well, I think we, we covered a lot in terms of, uh, the broa- kind of broader trends of the space. I know you wanted to, to talk a little bit about, uh, 2024 and 2025 on, on like a personal and personal business level. 26:29 Yeah. Let's just talk about what we're up to. So, uh, do you wanna start, like maybe run me through... 26:34 I think what would be cool to share with people is, okay, what, what did we do this year in our businesses that we felt was impactful, 26:40 milestones or accomplishments or just stuff that worked for us, and then what are our plans next year? Yeah. Love it. I would say 2024 for Tailwind was a real year of clarifying who we serve 26:57 and what our focus is. So we only launched Tailwind as a s- and Tailwind for, for those who aren't familiar, is a newsletter as a service, uh, kinda content agency. So we, we create newsletters for bus- for businesses. 27:11 Um, and this year we really focused on B2B, uh, businesses, agencies, um, uh, coaching offerings, consultancies. Uh, so folks that can really benefit and drive meaningful revenue from a newsletter. 27:27 Um, and that was a... That focus, we didn't have that when we started in August of 2023. Um, we, we thought, "Hey, we know what makes a great newsletter. We know how to write engaging content. 27:39 We have great writers that we have access to. Um, why don't we just build newsletters for businesses that want them?" 27:45 What we found, and, and v- very much on theme with what we were talking in the beginning, or what we were discussing in the beginning, is that, uh, newsletters aren't always gonna be a high revenue, uh, channel or high revenue activity for folks that don't necessarily, uh, that, that don't have a, a firm strategy in place with how to utilize it. 28:04 So if you're, if you're looking to start a newsletter for just to earn sponsorship revenue or earn, or earn revenue from, from folks sponsoring the newsletter, that's a, that's a long road. 28:14 Um, and it doesn't necessarily have a, uh, a, a high return on investment up front. Um, and as an agency, and I'm sure as you, [chuckles] as you would, uh, attest Matt, 28:24 um, agencies are all about they live or die by retention. 28:27 And so, uh, a- and your retention defines your customer LTV and, uh, and just how sustainable it is and, and how, and how stressful your life is as an agency owner. 28:37 Um, so we had to find, uh, a focus that justified, uh, us existing really. 28:44 And what we found was newsletters do work very well for B2B businesses a- and businesses with high ticket, uh, offers or services or products that they want to provide, um, uh, to their audiences. 28:59 Because all you need is, is, is some qualified leads that come through that funnel in order to just- justify it from like a RO- uh, an ROI perspective. 29:07 And so what, what we did this year was really just clarify our focus, clarify who we serve, really work on the operations and the systems to make sure that fulfillment is, is smooth and we're always delivering content that we're, um, that we're proud of, that we would post anywhere. 29:23 And I-- It was an incredibly worthwhile exercise to spend, um, the first part of this year doing that. 29:31 Uh, so that was probably the first six months of 2024 was redefining our messaging, redefining our offer really at a base level, um, a- and, and figuring it out from a pricing perspective, from a, a deliverable perspective, from how we communicate with our clients, how we, how we, how we intake resources. 29:50 Just really just all the systems that make an agency tick, we kind of overhauled those in the first six months of the year. 29:55 And then the second half of the year has been growing that offer, which has been very rewarding and seeing it work. And so that's, that's 2024 in a nutshell. 30:04 Uh, and it's been an incredible learning experience, and it's been very stressful at times as agencies are. But, uh, yeah, I feel, I feel in a very good spot for 2025 moving forward. Yeah. 30:15 I've had some of the same experiences too in, in a different way. 30:18 So we started, you know, before you started Tailwind, probably at least a good bit before that, maybe even a yearAnd early on, you don't really know who you're gonna work with, and you just take people who wanna move forward and who you think are a good fit, kind of just based off of whatever you talk about. 30:34 And so we've defined more clear criteria about who we're gonna take on, who's not. And if you don't meet this criteria, you can't work with us, and we say no to a lot of people. 30:44 And I'll, I'll just tell you what that is for me. So we do totally different things. We help people grow and monetize their newsletters. We don't write any of their content. We don't do any editorial. 30:53 We help them get more subscribers from paid acquisition, help them recoup that ad spend as fast as possible, and help them convert that subscriber into a customer with automated email marketing. 31:05 We also do s- ad sales for some clients, but that's something we started recently. We do a couple other things too, but that's all I'll share now. And so we found, like, 31:14 you really need to have a minimum of $30,000 per month in revenue, and that revenue has to come from sponsorships and/or information product sales. Mm. 31:24 Information products, it could be a course, coaching program, paid subscription, like something along those lines in that category. 31:31 And you should also probably have at least 20 to 30,000 active newsletter subscribers with, with good engagement. 31:38 Because if the newsletter has, like, a 10% open rate and we're, we're adding more subscribers to that, it's not a good product to, to grow, so it's not worth investing in paid growth. 31:47 And, um, we might have one more criteria too, but th- those are the two main things. 31:52 And, um, when we have people who, who meet that, they're really successful, and when we have people who don't meet that, they weren't successful in the past. So we've, we've had that criteria. 32:01 And most people we work with are well above that mark, but that's, like, the bare minimum criteria. We've also seen clients have... And we've had success with a lot of different clients in, in many different niches, 32:11 but the most successful have been B2B media companies, financial publishers, and the final one is people who have some type of information product that's already at six or seven figures of revenue. 32:24 So they have a success- a successful subscription course, program, whatever it might be. And, um, yeah, B2B media has been awesome to work with. That's one of my, one of my favorites. 32:37 The, um, f- financial publishers means someone who covers things, topics like personal finance, investing, trading, those types of things. And then people who have information products as, as, as I described. 32:48 Um, but that's what's worked for us. I mean, we've had success with, like, sports and lifestyle and, and a lot of other stuff too, spirituality, religion. 32:54 We have a lot of successful clients outside of those, but that's just the, the patterns that I've been seeing with the clients that we work with. Love it. Yeah. I think it's, uh... 33:03 You know, I've only been operating, like, a... I mean, before Tailwind, it was more of just kind of a broader consultancy where we'd come in and help folks with strategy and, and thinking through growth and monetization. 33:14 Um, so really, I've only been operating an agency outside of a W2 for, I guess this is year t- this is the end of year two, or I guess like, you know, y- year zero, year one, whatever. 33:25 Um, so, so two, two full years is, is what it's coming up on. Um, and it is a, a really... It's tough. [chuckles] It's, it's, it's always... 33:34 I mean, just working across, uh, uh, across so many clients and so many projects, it is, it is a challenge, but it is very rewarding when you start to, to learn these lessons and apply them. 33:45 And yeah, it's been, uh, it's been, it's been really, really, uh, just a, a learning experience. 33:51 But, um, at the end of 2024, I was speaking to somebody else who has built and sold, uh, multiple agencies, and he was saying that, uh, it generally takes two years to figure, to, to get, to get, like, the, the re- the machine really going at, at a high level. 34:08 Um, and in my experience, I mean, I'm very hopeful for 2025. Um, but yeah, this, this two-year period has felt like just really refining what we do, and it feels like we're in a good spot now. Yeah. 34:20 It's, it really does take time. And I had a situation where, like, what I started doing... Like, essentially when we started, we were a newsletter growth agency. We're much more than that now. 34:30 We're, we're basically a marketing agency for media and education companies. Mm-hmm. I hate when people call us a newsletter growth agency, but that's not what we are. But [chuckles] um, that's being more nitpicky. 34:40 But, um, when we started, we were really the only people that did that, and so that was a huge advantage. Um, but now there's more people that do it. 34:49 No one does it as well as us, and no one provides the stuff that we do. But there's, there's definitely more competition, and we've had to shift in ways that just make more, more sense for us and also for the clients. 35:00 And so it's, it's all been a good experience, but it's just like where you start and where you're at now is, is completely different because the market shifts too. 35:09 I wanna talk about 2025, but I just wanna run you through a couple things that I did this year that I think are worth noting and that, um, were just learning experiences for me and stuff we can talk about. 35:20 So one, I launched a program which we could describe as a cohort-based course in January of this year. So that was originally called Grow System, and then I changed the name to Write Grow Sell. 35:33 That's probably been the best thing that's happened to our business this year. The agency has been great, but just expanding beyond that has been really great, even though 35:43 it's doing two different things, which is, which is a challenge, but I'm really happy with it. So we've had over 500 people go through that, gotten great feedback. 35:51 We actually have the next cohort opening up in January, or probably now when you're listening to this. Yeah. Let me know if you have any questions on that. But basically, 36:01 it's just a kind of like an entirely different market than the agency. We're at a entirely different price point. But I just real- I enjoy doing it. 36:08 Like, we get great feedback on it, over 250 five-star reviews from 500 people. And what's nice about that is just the margins. It's, it's just an entirely different business than the agency. 36:19 Like, the margins are entirely different. Way better, right? The, it's a lot more scalable. Like, I think we can double this a lot faster than the agency doubles. 36:28 And, um, in some ways it's, it's, it's more fun, but there's, there's also pros and cons to everything.That's awesome. Yeah. 36:37 I, I, I love the idea of, um, serving folks that maybe aren't quite ready for, for the agency, uh, based on, based on the, uh, the qualifications that you just, uh, laid out. I mean, I think it's a, a great call. 36:51 It's like obviously you have so much of this, uh, this experience and knowledge to share across, you know, every, every piece of, um, uh, every aspect of, of building a, a high revenue newsletter. So, um, yeah. 37:04 And that's the idea. It's like people who can't afford to work with us as an agency, which, which has been a lot of people, and not proud of that, but also it's just am happy that we have more people that we can take on. 37:15 Mm-hmm. And so doing a course makes sense in that context. I don't think it's a good idea for everybody because it can distract you from the main thing. Um, but, but it worked out for me, 37:24 and I think it's, I think it's gonna be a good thing long term. We, we grew our team from one full-time person to seven full-time people, which has been awesome. 37:32 Most of those are around serving agency clients and helping me grow my audience, do paid ads, stuff like that. I started posting on some different platforms, so I started on LinkedIn and YouTube. 37:45 We post the podcast on YouTube. I've done like one dedicated video that wasn't really even dedicated. But both of those I've been happy with. Like LinkedIn definitely brought in more clients. 37:56 I might have like 10K followers there. Not as fast as I would like it to grow. YouTube, I think 2,000 or 3,000 subscribers. But the business results have been good, even from a relatively small amount of audience there. 38:10 Are you-- do you have a social strategy at all outside of Twitter? I, I see your post a lot, but I don't know how much- Yeah... you're thinking through for next year. 38:18 Twitter and sporadically LinkedIn this year, and I think that's gonna be, um, as we grow, uh, like we've nailed down what we're, uh, what we are, who we serve, how we do it. 38:31 Um, and so growth in 2025 is definitely a big focus now. Um, and yeah, I think the, uh, even the experimental kind of posting s- uh, on LinkedIn, you do see results from it, which, uh, is, is really, uh, 38:47 uh, encouraging, uh, to, to keep doing that. So I think LinkedIn is definitely a big area of focus for me. Um, continuing the consistency on Twitter, 38:58 uh, or j- or doubling down on, on consistency on Twitter, I should say. Um, and then video to some degree as well. I think video on LinkedIn and sharing video to, on LinkedIn I think is a big thing. 39:08 Um, and potentially longer form on YouTube. Uh, haven't really scoped that out, but I think, uh, the big one for me is definitely LinkedIn next year. Yeah. I wanna talk to you about social strategy in a second. 39:20 Just the, the final things I've done here in 2024. So I spoke at two events, which was awesome. 39:27 I don't know if we got a ton of clients from those, because I can be bad at follow-up, and I don't really pitch myself super hard in person. But I did enjoy going to those events. 39:38 We launched an event, um, that's gonna be in February 2025, and so I'm gonna s- you're gonna be there, right? We sent you- Yeah. Oh yeah. We've talked about this over email, but [chuckles] it's, it's been a couple weeks. 39:50 Um, but that'll be fun. Ryan will be... We're still figuring out the agenda and like what, what you're gonna do there. Um, but that'll be awesome. I'm really looking forward to that. So we got... 39:59 I won't go through all the speakers, but we have them at newslettermarketingsummit.com. Some cool people involved there. Yeah. I'm excited for that. That's gonna be, uh... 40:08 It's impressive the, uh, the list of speakers that you've put together there. Um, and yeah, I'm excited to, to get out there and, and see everybody. And the attendees are awesome too. 40:19 We haven't talked about that, but like the people who are buying tickets are, are very impressive founders, creators, operators, all that stuff. I'm also... 40:27 This is, this is kind of basic, but I'm, I'm happy that I published a newsletter every single week. That's not easy to do, as you know, because you probably publish a lot of newsletters every single week. 40:37 And doing that, no breaks for, for a year is not easy. And that's been hard, but it's had a really positive impact on my business. Yeah. I mean, that's, uh, very impressive. 40:49 Like, yeah, consistency in that is so underrated, honestly, and I think it's one of the first things that people learn when they try and start something, uh, when they try to start a weekly newsletter, is it's not always easy to just sit down and hammer out something that's gonna be valuable to your audience. 41:03 Um, so to do that, uh, 52 weeks in a row, uh, super impressive. So kudos to you. I, I pulled up Beehiiv. 41:10 I don't know if you see this for some of your clients, but I'm on a 101 week streak of sending at least one newsletter every single week. 'Cause I started my newsletter in January of 2023. Nice. 41:21 And I don't think I missed a week since. That doesn't mean I'm creating original content every week. 41:26 Sometimes I gotta recycle something or even just send like half a newsletter on a holiday, but like it's, it's still getting out there every single Saturday. Love it. Yeah. It's [chuckles]... 41:37 I've, I've worked a lot of Saturdays doing that. So honestly- Geez... it's like one of the most challenging things I do. 41:42 But I could probably have a, a easier way to write the newsletter, but I tend to like go way too deep into stuff and spend a lot of time writing. Um, but anyways, 41:52 over our last few minutes here, like what are you excited about for 2025? Do you have any goals or things that you're looking forward to doing in the business or just in general? Yeah. I think, um, a couple things. 42:02 I mean, one is just now that we've figured out, you know, or, or really clarified, uh, who this works the best for, uh, who we can provide the most value for, is just growth. Um, and so, 42:15 uh, you know, I think founder-led growth for an agency is super important, so I'm doubling down, uh, on, uh, posting, which, uh, has historically been uncomfortable for me. 42:27 But, um, will, will put myself out there and do that. 42:30 Um, and then the other is just deepening the, the value that we provideUh, both to the clients that we're currently working with and then for clients in the future that we take on as well. 42:42 Um, we've already started piloting, um, some, uh, kind of value add, uh, deliverables to, to what we already do. 42:49 So for example, now along with every newsletter that we create for a client, we also create, um, a LinkedIn post for them that teases the content of the newsletter and, and ideally drives new subscribers, uh, to the newsletter. 43:02 So kind of some built-in organic growth. I think we'll continue to develop what we do there. 43:07 Uh, so, uh, the long-term-ish vision, uh, or e- not even really long term, but really just kind of medium term, is, uh, developing more of a, uh, a B2B content studio with the lessons that we've learned on just creating hyper-valuable newsletters, uh, that, that convert, uh, folks further down the funnel, uh, and turn leads into, into customers and clients for, for the people, uh, for our partners. 43:32 So really, yeah, growth, uh, uh, which is probably what every agency is focusing on [chuckles] in 2025, um, but also just, uh, providing more value in what we do. Yeah. I'm... 43:46 You know, my goals are probably, like, a lot different this year than they were the previous years because it was really all about how do we basically get as many clients for our agency as possible and retain them as long as possible and improve the client success. 44:00 All that's still in there, but I'm, I'm being a lot more modest with, with m-moderate with, um, client growth next year because I-I'm shifting my focus more towards Write Grow Sell, which might be news to, to you, 44:16 um, because I haven't really talked about this outside of my team. But that product is, like, working. We're getting incredibly good results and feedback. Like, our MPS score is 89. Students are crushing it. 44:28 And so we have, like, three things in our business now. We have Write Grow Sell, the program. We have Grow Letter, the service, and we have Newsletter Marketing Summit, the event. 44:37 And so I c- I can almost share the numbers of what I wanna achieve with Grow Letter and Write Grow Sell. Newsletter Marketing Summit we're gonna have... 44:43 Our goal is to have over 300 attendees, and we actually have, like, a cap of, like, 310 people at that event. 44:48 We've sold a third of the tickets so far, so I think we'll definitely hit that goal, and then we'll figure out the 2026 goal for that. But for Write Grow Sell, I want that to be way, way, way bigger than it is now. 45:01 And I've been able to go in, like, every cohort, improve the content, improve the resources, and then, you know, luckily get better feedback and results from the students each cohort, which b- which has been great too. 45:13 So I feel like we can keep doing that, but also we gotta grow the marketing engine to get people into it. Mm-hmm. Because what, what I have now is not gonna get me the, the customers that I want for this. 45:24 So like I said, we've had, like, 500 people enroll this year, not including people who are enrolling in this cohort in J- for January, because we just opened enrollment recently. And we, we wanna go way bigger. 45:34 And so I'm thinking about, okay, like, what are, what are the numbers that I need to get to as far as, like, audience size to actually do that? I'm kinda doing some, some simple math on how to reverse engineer that. 45:44 And so basically that's-- I need to have an email list of over 100,000 engaged people to get to the amount of customers that I wanna get to for Write Grow Sell. And that's the, that's the number one goal. 45:54 Obviously the customers, but also getting the audience to get there. And so then it's like how do I get those people on the email list? 'Cause I feel that the email list, my newsletter is really good. 46:03 It has great engagement. We have great automated sequences that get people to learn stuff and get value very, very quickly, so they trust us and are more likely to become a customer. 46:12 But we need to get more people on the list. And what I've learned the hard way is, like, I just don't focus enough on things. I do way too many things at the same time. And in 2025 I wanna focus way more. 46:24 And so I basically just wanna focus on one paid growth channel and one organic growth channel. 46:32 And the plan right now is the paid growth channel is gonna be meta ads, which we're already doing successfully and we're gonna do even better at a higher scale. 46:39 And the organic growth channel is gonna be YouTube long form. I don't know how you feel about, you know, Twitter, LinkedIn, but I feel like I've-- it's really hard to get 46:48 the audience growth and engagement that I want on those platforms. And I'm-- it's not necessarily tapped out, it's just, like, it's not gonna get me to where I wanna go. 46:58 And I feel like YouTube is the, is the best path for what I'm trying to do, like, educational content to get people to, to join an email list and buy a program. 47:08 I think YouTube long form is the way to go, and we've had some success there so far. I love that. Um, yeah. I mean, first of all, very exciting goal and, um, 47:18 i-it's super, uh, it's exciting to hear the focus o-on, on the course as well because, yeah, I know that you've been really, uh, hyped about that, um, and have seen a lot of success there. Yeah, I think, uh, YouTube... 47:29 I mean, based on, based on the folks that I've spoken to that have put, uh, a lot of focus on YouTube and, uh, specifically people that have courses, uh, or, or paid communities that they're driving to, they've seen a great deal of success, uh, with, with long form educational videos. 47:46 So, um, I'm sure you've heard the same, and that's maybe what's, uh, what's, uh, guiding, uh, uh, the focus there, but that's very exciting. 47:55 And yeah, with-- so the 100,000 email list, that's, that's also a very, uh, exciting goal. Are you thinking about... 48:03 I mean, is the, is the focus gonna remain just on kind of, like, newsletter ops, or are you broadening at all? Or I guess, how are you thinking about that? Yeah. So w- I'll explain that, but... 48:13 So I'm kind of thinking, like, half that growth is gonna come from Facebook ads, so 50K subscribers from Facebook ads, 50K from YouTube. 48:20 The rest, like Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram, we're still gonna do those, but they're kinda gonna take a side seat and, like, it's just gonna be repurposed content from the newsletter, from the YouTube channel, and, like, occasionally me tweeting out a one-off thing. 48:32 I have a great person who helps me with those things, and that's-- we're gonna keep doing that. But the YouTube is, like, the main thing that's gonna grow the audience and probably grow those other social channels too. 48:41 Now what was the question again? Sorry, I totally skipped that. [chuckles] No, no. I, I was just... I was curious, and maybe upon reflection, like, it wouldn't make sense to broaden the, uh, the focus of the newsletter. 48:51 Oh, like the focus-- Yeah, the focus of the newsletter. So yes, a-and the content in general. Yeah, ev-everything's gotta be broadened to do this. Mm-hmm. So I mean, the name stays the change, like, stays the same. 49:01 Newsletters are still the core focus, but it's more about, um... I, I explained this elegantly to another person on another meeting, but I forget how I said it, but basically it's about how do you, um, 49:13 how do you grow your business using an owned audience? So things like email newsletters, SMS, podcast, community. Or how do you start a business doing those things? Not necessarily how do you better do a newsletter? 49:26 How do you better grow a newsletter or monetize a newsletter? It's basically going, like, one level up. So it's like, how do you grow your business? And then newsletters are part of that strategy. 49:36 Or how do you start a business, and newsletters are part of that strategy. And the audience for that stuff is, is very, very big, right? And so, like, newsletters are 49:45 a tool in the toolkit, but it's not the only thing I'm gonna be talking about. But it all, it all... It's, it's still a core theme, right? Yeah. I love that. And I think [chuckles] 49:54 kind of puts a bow on everything that we've talked about today, about newsletters being a tool in a toolkit and, uh, and continuing to gain in popularity over 2024 and into 2025. So that's exciting, man. 50:05 I'm excited to see how the course develops and, uh, excited to see the continued growth of the list and, and everything you're doing. Yeah. We'll talk about it soon. 50:12 We also gotta talk about doing more, more podcasts 'cause that's definitely a part of this. But, like, a big part of the YouTube strategy is gonna be podcasts, not just standalone YouTube videos. Yeah. 50:22 So yeah, that's a good place to wrap. And, uh, thanks everybody for listening, and we'll talk to you again soon.