Transcript 0:00 Hey, Matt here. If you are running a newsletter business the way most people do, I've got some bad news. You're probably doomed to fail. 0:08 And I know that might sound harsh, but after spending years helping newsletters like The Hustle grow to millions of subscribers and get acquired, and working with over one hundred media companies and creators at my agency, Growletter, I've watched the newsletter business model completely transform, and I've been behind the scenes at some of the largest and most successful newsletters. 0:25 I've helped clients add over ten million subscribers and over one hundred million in sales, and I know this firsthand. 0:33 So today I'm gonna break down why the traditional newsletter ad-only business model is dead, and more importantly, what you need to do to adapt and thrive in what I call Newsletters three point O. 0:45 To understand where we're heading and what has changed, we need to look where, where we've been. So we need to look at the past. 0:51 I wanna break down the history and evolution of newsletter businesses for you and then explain what's next. So I call this phase from the year two thousand to two thousand and twelve Newsletters one point O. 1:04 And it was very early. So really the first pioneer was a company called Daily Candy, and they really had the first at scale online email newsletter. 1:13 They started with about seven hundred subscribers, friends and family, grew it to two point five million subscribers by two thousand and eight, and they were acquired for one hundred and twenty-five million dollars. 1:23 And so there were a couple other people early on, but that really inspired the next wave, which happened in twenty twelve to twenty twenty-two. Companies like The Skimm, which grew to over twelve million subscribers. 1:34 The Hustle, which reached two point five million subscribers before being acquired by HubSpot. Morning Brew grew to over four million subscribers and w- was acquired for seventy-five million dollars. 1:43 And these companies really crushed it. Now, more recently, I call this Newsletters two point five, really from twenty twenty-two to twenty twenty-five. 1:51 We saw a lot of niche-focused newsletters do well, like The Peak, which is essentially Morning Brew for Canada. They sold for three point seven five million. 1:59 Milk Road, which is kinda like The Hustle for crypto, was acquired for seven figures in ten months. And there's a lot of AI newsletters like Superhuman, The Rundown, The Neuron. 2:08 Most of them started in twenty twenty-three, and they quickly built their newsletter audiences to five hundred thousand or even over a million people by summarizing the news in the trending AI space. 2:20 Now, what made the model so successful from two thousand to twenty twenty-two? It really comes down to these three key pillars. The first is content. 2:31 All of these newsletters that I've talked about and, and many others that I'm, I'm not gonna mention here but are still amazing, 2:37 they all created pretty fun, digestible content that was easy to read and usually under a five-minute read time. They focused on summarization and curation. 2:46 They made readers more smart and informed after reading a short daily newsletter. Then they mastered growth. They acquired subscribers at low cost, usually between twenty-five cents to a dollar fifty per subscriber. 2:59 They use growth sources like referral programs, Facebook ads, co-registration, audience sharing, stuff like that, and they've built large audiences in the inbox. And then finally, monetization. 3:10 The primary revenue source for newsletters like this was advertising. Typically, you would have one to two ads per newsletter, and you would send five newsletters per week. 3:19 So that's a total of twenty to forty ad spots per month. And most of these ad slots are, like, usually in the top twenty to thirty percent of the email, fifty to a hundred words. 3:30 They're called primary ads, and that model worked very well. So the unit economics of these businesses were really good. 3:36 We have subscriber acquisition cost of about a dollar or less, revenue per open of a nickel or five cents or more for every single email open. Usually, these newsletters had open rates of forty-five to fifty percent. 3:51 The revenue per subscriber per month was about fifty cents or more. 3:54 The payback period to make back the money that they invest-- that they invested into growth was two to three months, and the return on ad spend was three hundred to five hundred percent. When I worked at The Hustle, 4:06 these numbers made scaling a no-brainer. Basically, the more we spent on paid acquisition, the more profitable and the faster that we grew. Now, here's the thing. 4:15 Around twenty twenty-two to twenty twenty-three, everything changed. The newsletter ad-only model that I just described started to break down due to five major changes. The first is more competition. 4:27 Platforms and software tools like Substack, Beehiiv, and Kit made it very easy for anyone to start a newsletter, and the competition for both readers' attention and advertisers' budgets exploded. 4:38 Then there was rising acquisition cost. Apple's App Tracking Transparency that happened in twenty twenty made it a lot harder to grow your newsletter effectively with Facebook ads. Costs went up a lot. 4:50 Now, costs did improve later after Facebook adapted around twenty twenty-two, twenty twenty-three, but they're never gonna be as low as they were back in twenty fifteen to twenty nineteen when newsletters like Morning Brew were acquiring subscribers for twenty-five to fifty cents from Facebook and Instagram. 5:06 Number three is declining ad rates, especially newsletter ad rates. Basically, the macroecon-- macroeconomic environment shifted a lot in this time period. 5:14 So interest rates went up, crypto and stocks went down, VC funding slowed down a ton, and then newsletter CPMs on their ads, and really all digital advertising CPMs went down. 5:25 So people used to be able to sell a newsletter ad for a fifty dollar to seventy-five dollar CPM. So that means for every one thousand impressions, that newsletter makes fifty to seventy-five dollars. 5:36 That dropped to twenty dollars, thirty dollars, sometimes even lower, and most of the publishers couldn't sell all the ad inventory that they had in every single newsletter. 5:46 The fourth thing that changed was inbox tracking. So there's this new thing that Apple released, I guess not a new thing. 5:51 It happened, I believe in twenty twenty, um, two or twenty twenty-one called Apple Mail Privacy Protection, and this made tracking open rates completely unreliable. 6:02 The challenge is open rates are the main metric that newsletters use to price and measure their advertising. 6:08 Number five is AI.AI is essentially solve summarization, and one of the core value propositions of many of the newsletters that I just mentioned was summarization and curation. 6:19 Now, most people aren't choosing to read AI content over newsletters yet, but it's a growing threat when eighty percent of your job as a newsletter publisher could be done by AI, at least if you focus on summarizing in your newsletter. 6:32 So these changes devastated the model. You simply can't make a newsletter advertising-only business work when you're selling ads that less-- at less than a forty to fifty dollar CPM, and that's your only revenue channel. 6:44 Your cost to acquire subscribers exceeds two to three dollars. 6:48 Your unique open rate with privacy protection is below forty-five percent, and there's dozens of other similar newsletters that are competing for your readers' attention. 6:58 This is why so many newsletter businesses, quote-unquote, "are struggling right now." Now, before you panic and think that I'm saying newsletters are dead, that is not all. Okay? 7:09 The title for this video might be a little bit misleading because email is still the best way to sell things. That hasn't changed at all. 7:17 Email provides a direct audience relationship or an owned audience relationship that's better than all the other options out there, and newsletters are the best way to build trust and readership in the inbox, so the emails you send are more effective at driving revenue, engagement, et cetera. 7:33 Now, the problem isn't newsletters themselves, it's how most newsletter advertising-only businesses approach selling and building trust with an audience that's completely backwards. 7:45 There are two fundamental problems right now. Newsletter ads are one of the worst ways to sell things and make money from your audience. It's a very poor way to market other people's products, your sponsors. 7:57 It's also a very poor way to monetize your audience if that's the only way that you make money in this business. 8:03 Now, newsletter ads can work to sell things for your sponsors, but not nearly as well as something like a dedicated email, custom content, webinars, lead generation, or a more comprehensive partnership that you could put together for sponsors. 8:15 You gotta keep in mind when you run any type of media or creator business that the only way that you make money from an audience is by selling products or services. 8:23 That could be your own product, or it could be your sponsor's product. 8:27 And if the only revenue source that you have, newsletter ads, is not an effective way of fulfilling your customer's primary goal, which is selling their product, that's probably not a good business model. Okay? 8:38 So that needs to change. The second thing is that daily newsletters with summarized content don't build trust anymore, and they aren't unique anymore. 8:46 This content style that really Morning Brew, The Hustle, The Skimm pioneered back in twenty-fifteen, twenty-sixteen was really cool back then, but it's commonplace now, and most of the newsletters that have this type of summarized content, you know, daily five-minute newsletter, they all look identical, and they're not really unique or standing out in the inbox. 9:03 This brings us to what I call Newsletters three point O. It's the next evolution of media and education businesses that are focused on owned audience channels like email. 9:13 Here's what needs to change for your newsletter, your media business, or your creator business to win in this new model. The first thing is to ditch pure summarization. Okay? 9:22 Summarization and repurposing content to create a newsletter is not gonna cut it anymore. You need to have original insights, indispensable content, and world-class human curation. So curation still matters 9:34 because taste matters, but summarization is not that helpful. Now, this could mean publishing your newsletter less frequency. Maybe you have a five-time-a-week newsletter. 9:43 You might go down to one to three newsletters per week that are better and more insightful. The second thing is to diversify your revenue model. Newsletter advertising should not be your primary revenue source. 9:55 A successful media business needs to be able to sell both your own product or service, which is direct revenue, and other companies' products or services, which are sponsorships, and you need to do that effectively. 10:05 Number three is to master multiple owned audience channels, not just email. There are basically five different audience channels with-- where you have direct audience relationship. 10:17 Those are email, SMS, podcast, private communities, and then print. Now, you shouldn't try and do all these at once. That's a recipe for disaster. But only having one long term, like only email, is also very risky. 10:30 You should try and master two of these channels and build a targeted engaged audience there. 10:35 If you have an audience of a hundred thousand plus people on two channels like email and podcast, for example, you have an incredible advantage. If you only have one, you're in a difficult position. 10:46 The fourth thing you should do is become a marketing partner, not just a publisher. 10:50 Instead of selling just ad space in your email newsletter, offer a comprehensive marketing partnership or campaign with things like this. 10:59 You could offer webinars, sponsored social content, sponsored blog or email content, custom content and advertorials, lead generation, where you create a lead magnet for your advertiser and you promote it and share the lead with them, dedicated marketing emails to segments of your list based off of your users' engagement or first-party data that you've collected about those users, and more. 11:21 Now, these services are tricky to do at first, but after you do a couple and understand what your advertisers need, it gets a lot easier. 11:29 And these allow you to sell bigger packages at higher rates and higher CPMs that will deliver better results for your sponsors. 11:36 And when you do that, sponsors will pay you more, renew more, and work with you over the long run. The fifth thing you need to do is focus on one paid and organic acquisition channel. 11:46 You need to master both paid and organic growth. You can't just have one in this current environment. 11:52 Organic growth channels like YouTube, SEO, social media, ex-et cetera, those are all algorithm dependent, and they can go away in an instant. It's still important to have them. 12:03 And then paid growth channels alone are not a reliable way to grow because you have to pay to get every new subscriber and customer. You really need to have both. Okay? 12:11 Paid is a challenge, but also it's beneficial because platforms like Facebook, Google, et ceterahave an incentive to make you successful with paid advertising, so it can be more consistent and scalable over the long run than organic growth. 12:24 But you don't wanna have one without the other. You wanna find one paid channel that works and one organic channel that works and double down on those two things. 12:32 Then you want to ten-x LTV and don't obsess over reducing CAC. So LTV is subscriber lifetime value or customer lifetime value, and CAC is customer acquisition cost or subscriber acquisition cost. 12:45 You should spend way more time focusing to increase your audience's lifetime value than trying to decrease the acquisition cost of acquiring a customer or acquiring a subscriber. 12:55 Whoever can spend the most to acquire a customer or subscriber will win, and if you can do that, you will out-compete everyone else. Acquisition costs, no matter how hard we work, are always gonna rise over time. 13:06 The only way to build a sustainable media business is to make more money per subscriber, per customer, and per client. Now, there's two main ways you can increase your LTV. 13:18 The first is what we've already talked about, becoming a marketing partner, not just an ad-supported publisher. You can sell ads at a much higher rate and have longer retention of your advertisers. 13:29 The second way to ten-x LTV is to build and sell a flagship product, have direct revenue, and that is number seven, develop a flagship product. 13:38 If you know your audience and you're having conversations with your readers, you're studying your sponsors' results, and you're analyzing the replies you get over email, you can start to identify your audience's problems. 13:50 And after doing that, you can create a product or a service that solves that problem and is also aligned with the category and the niche that you want to own. 13:59 You're never going to unlock your audience's true revenue potential without a flagship product that you can sell to them successfully. Now, all of this is difficult. 14:07 It might take you six to twelve months to identify the problems and create and sell this product successfully, but it's worth it if you want to win. I recommend you try and keep this simple. 14:16 So always sell before you build a product, okay? That means you should always do a pre-sale before you spend months or years building a product to sell. 14:26 You may not even know if people want it until you actually do this pre-sale. I also recommend that you focus on media and digital style products that are simpler to create and fulfill. 14:34 Don't tr-- go out and try and build a SaaS business or build a service business or an agency. That becomes very complicated, and it's an entirely different model than media or content. 14:44 So focus on media content, media products rather, like digital products, events, courses, coaching, memberships, or hybrids of these things. Okay. That is what you should do. 14:54 If you implement these principles, and if you build a team with help from AI and automation that can run the operations effectively, you're gonna create a valuable media asset that could eventually be acquired and/or provide cash flow without you running the day-to-day operations. 15:08 That's the ultimate goal of your newsletter, and this is how you're gonna do it. Now, newsletters should still be a core part of your media asset. They are for many world-class media companies. 15:19 Or you might wanna start with a newsletter, build that, and then later on you may choose to focus on other direct audience relationship channels like podcast, SMS, community, et cetera, and your newsletter could become secondary. 15:32 That's okay. The key is recognizing that the old newsletter advertising-only model doesn't work. 15:38 But newsletters themselves are still a powerful tool when they're used as a part of a more comprehensive and diversified media business model. I hope that breakdown helps. If you enjoyed this, subscribe to the channel. 15:50 And I'm also h- hosting a workshop on how to build a media asset that can run without you, and the link for that workshop will be down below, and it's totally free to attend, and you'll get access to all the recordings and slides. 16:02 All right. Thanks for watching.