Transcript 0:00 Did you ever do a number of like number of ad sales for Mad Rev, The Hustle, all those throughout your career? Definitely well over 15 million. Yeah, I'm gonna conservatively say 15 million just so no one fact checks me. 0:14 [upbeat music] What's up, Katie? How you doing? Matt, looking gorgeous. Great to see you. For everyone who's listening, Matt is in a ball gown, full beat of makeup. No, uh- [laughs]... 0:26 but sweet cherry glasses, great beard. Um- Yeah, thanks for doing this. Good to catch up. So I'm here with Katie Huff. Katie, you are the co-founder of Mad Rev, 0:35 and you were formerly one of the topper, or the top salespeople at The Hustle. For people who don't know, The Hustle was a newsletter or is a newsletter [chuckles] with like two million, 2.5 million subscribers now. 0:46 Uh, back in the day when we were both working there, they were doing like eight figures in ad revenue and some other reve- revenue streams too. Yeah, anything you wanna add to that is like... 0:55 Also, tell us what Mad Rev is, by the way, 'cause I didn't explain it. Yeah. Um, no, that, that's all accurate. 1:01 Uh, so Mad Rev, we are like a commission-only sales agency that specializes in newsletters, so where we would potentially overlap with you, if you have a newsletter and you need help selling your ads, hit us up, or if you're a brand and you want help buying ads, even better. 1:16 Awesome. And what I wanna do on this call is basically, you know, this is for people who have a newsletter, have a media company, and wanna sell ads better. 1:25 And I wanna take us through like in a very rapid-fire way, the A to Z of what we need to do to sell sponsorships on our newsletter successfully. This is definitely for people who wanna sell their first sponsorship. Wow. 1:37 Um, but also we're gonna talk about the more advanced stuff, how you can scale your sponsorship operations or team or go out and get bigger advertisers, stuff like that too. Does that sound good? Yeah. Yeah. 1:48 So I'm happy to focus this on like those, those newer newsletters, and then if you ever have any questions about bigger newsletters, feel free to fire those. But I'll, I'll keep everything on like- Yeah... 1:58 10K and less subscribers. We'll talk about both. I would say, yeah, I would say like 10 to 25K subscribers is who might... Who are our main target for this? 2:08 Maybe it's 80% of the people listening, and 20% would be bigger than that. Okay. Set. And there's also a lot of people listening who don't have a newsletter, but they just wanna learn, right? 2:17 So but let's target towards that. And so let's talk about the fundamentals real quick. Like, what do I need to have in place before I sell a sponsorship? Yeah. Well, for sure know who your audience is. 2:30 Ideally, and what I mean by that is like, if, if you have a sense of like if it's a business newsletter or a professional one, um, what kind of titles are in there, what industry are they in, are they marketers? 2:43 And if they're marketers, are they e-commerce marketers or are they B2B marketers? Like, having a good sense of your readership will help you figure out who you should pitch to, which I expect everyone would. 2:55 If it's more consumer, um, knowing male, female, age, affluence is useful. Um- That means income, right? Yeah. H- household income. Like, if, if I... And if you don't have that information, that's totally fine. 3:11 Uh, a lot of newsletters, even The Hustle when we were, you know, a million, two million newsletter, we would do just Google surveys. Like, you don't have to be complicated with it. 3:21 Send a survey out, put it in the top of your newsletter, and just ask those basic questions, age, gender, household income. 3:30 And then if, yeah, if you're in the B2B space, ask more questions about like are you a budget decision-maker, title, and, and you can do title as, as simply like VP or above, yes or no, um, and, and different things like that. 3:44 I would, I would say that's like a good starting point. Excellent. And we'll also just... 3:50 And this is, goes without saying in some ways, but just your, your audience information, how many subscribers, you need open rate, you need click-through rate, and the average number of clicks that your advertisements are getting i- if you have run advertisements in the past before, right? 4:05 Definitely. And Matt, I'd be curious your opinion on this. You know, I, my standard lately has been like a 40% total open rate or above is healthy. 4:13 What's like, what's the new normal now with like all those Apple updates and such being rolled out? I think that's good, and like 40% and above is good. I would say like 50% and above is great. Okay. 4:24 So that's another thing to, to keep in mind, like if you are reaching out to advertisers, you're talking to them, 4:29 anything below that, it's not gonna kill any deals, but it certainly, it does send a signal that the audience might be a little bit lower quality or the list health isn't as good. 4:39 However, if you're at even 50% and above, I think that's a really strong signal that like this is probably your or- organic audience or you've grown it from really high-quality sources, which is like a positive signal to would-be advertisers. 4:53 Yeah. I wanna double-click on that in a second. 4:55 One thing I, I want you to tell us is, um, you know, like throughout your career at The Hustle and like other media companies, do you have any idea of like the total number of ads you've, you've sold? Oh, heavens. 5:07 Um- [laughs]... I mean, total number of ads, like not, not just like brands, definitely in the hundreds, like probably close to a thousand. 5:17 Um, at Mad Rev, we're three years old, and I think Ben and I, my friend who I work with, uh, I think we did a tabulation earlier this year, and we had like in total over 110 brands that we'd worked with so far. 5:29 So if it's by ads, yeah, definitely at least a thousand, which is sick. Did you ever do a number of like, number of ad sales for Mad Rev, The Hustle, all those throughout your career? Like a dollar amount? Yeah. 5:43 Oh, definitely well over 15 million. Um, yeah, I'm gonna conservatively say 15 million just so no one fact checks me. I like that. Okay. That's for the YouTube clip. Uh [laughs] Yeah. We're trying to, um, do some more... 5:59 Like, we'll publish this conversation in fullSo people will listen to all this, but like- Mm... with YouTube, you gotta be, like, be a little bit more catchy. [chuckles] And so- Oh, okay, yeah... 6:07 I'm trying to ask those questions. Um- No, you s- you said it perfectly. You don't, I don't... no need to cover it again. Okay. 6:12 I was like- But I just, I j- I try and ask those questions just so we have, like, stuff to, to pull and put at the beginning of the video, you know? 6:17 I'm trying to think of, like, the MrBeast videos that I've seen him, like, "We put 100 marketers in a room, and-" [chuckles] "... the last one standing gets a million newsletter ad dollars." Um, is that what he does? 6:29 I don't know. He's always putting- Yeah, I think so... someone in a room or a coffin. 6:32 Well, I think people should really know, like, Katie has done this at a higher level and more than just about anyone, especially when it comes to newsletters, and those numbers are, are really impressive. Um- Yeah. 6:44 I, I've, I've sold a lot of newsletter ads, um, for better or for worse. Let's get into the, the details of, um, all that stuff. 6:55 So tell me, like, what advertisers are looking for, because you alluded to it and you gave some examples, but, um, what... if there's, like, the top three... If you're an advertiser, or what do you hear from them? 7:05 What are the top three to five things people are looking for when they're buying an ad? And there's some obvious ones, but there's also some nuanced things too, right? Yeah. 7:12 So I do think, as we touched on briefly, like, open rate, like, email health is, is a big one. Uh, I would imagine once an advertiser is confident that at least the audience is generally a fit, 7:24 the probably second thing they're doing is napkin math, figuring out, like, cost per click. 7:28 Even if you're selling it on a flat fee, which I recommend starting, if you're charging, let's say, $1,000 an ad, and on average driving, like, 100 clicks, that would be about a $10 CPC. 7:42 If you're more niche, you could get away with that. If you're more general, like a consumer news newsletter or something like that, that's tougher. 7:48 So trying to constantly keep a pulse on what competitors or the industry going rate is. Um, and if it is a little bit more expensive, that's fine. Being able to defend it, I think another 8:01 underreported stat, I s- I don't see a lot of people mention this, but if you have a great renewal rate, I would definitely share that in your pitch, and I would quantify healthy as, like, I don't know, if you run 10 ads and four people renew, I think that's pretty good. 8:18 So if you have anything higher, I would really highlight that, or highlighting if I'm talking to a brand and some of their competitors have ran and renew, I would always highlight that as well. Yeah. 8:31 And then a third stat, um, if you can, if it... 8:36 like, not everyone can do this, like, paid growth is so important, but if you do happen to have, like, a lot of your readership, especially in these early days where you're at, like, that 10,000, 15, 20,000 mark, if, if you are a person who had, like, a social media following and that's how you grew, like, your first core user base, I think that's also interesting to advertisers, 'cause in general, those folks tend to be more open-minded to your recommendations. 9:03 Um, and paid growth will, like, over time, but if that is a place that you're in, I would definitely put that information forward as well. Yeah, I haven't heard that. 9:13 Um, I, I've heard that before, but I haven't heard it from... like, putting that in your media kit, I haven't heard that advice. 9:18 But I think that's really smart, because a lot of advertisers are worried, like, did this newsletter just go and buy a bunch of subscribers from co-regs or paid recommendations, and now they're trying to sell me- Right... 9:26 some ad. But if they say, "Okay, you have 10,000 Instagram followers, and, you know, 50% of your audience came from there," it shows that people actually care about what you have to say. 9:35 They care about your perspective, and they're more listened to... more likely to listen to your recommendations from the things that you offer, um, the ads that you offer in your newsletter. Definitely. 9:46 And yeah, as far as, like, the napkin math that s- that advertisers are doing, obviously they're, they're figuring out how many clicks they're getting, what's, what's their cost per click. 9:53 And then, um, because a lot of beginners listen to this, they're also looking at things like, "Okay, how many leads am I gonna get? What's my conver- what's my cost per lead?" Um, sales. 10:03 Like, any, any other metrics that as a newsletter publisher we should know about that the advertiser is thinking about when they're buying these ads? I mean, sometimes if... 10:14 and this is a case by case basis, like, if you have RAM pubs and they've shared back with you, like, if it was an apparel brand and they say, "Yeah, the clicks were great, but on top of that, you know, we got $2,000 in cart sales," or something like that, and I say as long as you anonymize it, I think that's okay to share, although that is rare. 10:36 I find brands are a little bit close to the vest with those types of metrics. Yeah, I'm trying to, I'm trying to think of what other metrics are interesting. Definitely, uh... 10:46 oh, well, this doesn't answer, but I'll say a metric that is not helpful, only 'cause I see people include this on their media kits and I think it's just confusing, and it can set you up for misaligned expectations, like, from a, a publisher to the advertiser, is if you include your overall click-through rate, like, through the whole email in your media kit. 11:09 I find that's largely a useless metric because some newsletters have a ton of links, like, they'll have, like, a resource section, for example, and they list a bunch of links, and that might give them a lot of clicks. 11:19 Or some newsletters are very, like, story-based, like Sahil Bloom, where he has a lot of text, not a lot of out clicks. 11:26 So it doesn't really tell you anything about the newsletter health, and if you have a brand misinterpret that as, like, advertiser CTR, which I've done before, they might buy the campaign thinking they're gonna get, you know, an ass load of clicks, and then when it runs, they're mad, they want make goods, or worse, they're gonna, you know, talk to their peers and, and say negative things about your newsletter. 11:46 So I find overall CTR of newsletter, like, not worth sharing in media kits. Okay. That's good to know. And if people do decide to share both, make sure it's very clear on, on which is which, of course. 12:00 Yeah, another thing is, um-Like, who's sponsoring newsletters? It obviously depends on the newsletter, but I think there's some similarities on, you know, who the sponsors out, are out there. Mm-hmm. Right? 12:12 As far as, like, industry, company type, product type. What does that look... At least in your experience at Matterhav, what does it look like for you? Uh, like who... Uh, sorry. 12:22 Re- Like, what type of companies are sponsoring newsletters? You know, is it like SaaS, consumer SaaS? Is it D2C- Yeah... is et cetera? 12:31 I mean, I don't wanna say there's something for everyone, but it kind of feels like that. Um, like I see newsletters like- That's good... Payload, which seem, like, really niche. 12:40 I think they're probably sold out like several weeks in advance. Like, and the- and they're, for those who aren't familiar, it's like a space and I think defense contractor newsletter. So there is someone sponsoring. 12:51 So if you think like, "Oh, my newsletter might be too niche," like I've seen a psychedelic newsletter, for example. They have tons of sponsors. Um, who is probably doing it most? 13:00 Like, definitely consumer health and wellness brands. 13:05 I do find B2B SaaS to be probably more popular, just because those are probably the perfect reader of, like, a Morning Brew or Hustle or insert any other, like, tech news newsletter. 13:18 So they're familiar with it, um, they're probably lower hanging fruit that would be able to convert. 13:25 If you are considering a brand to reach out to and you're like, "I haven't seen them in any newsletters, but I know they're a fit," I would say I personally, if it's a really small company, I'm going on LinkedIn and I'm like, "Oh, heavens, they got two employees," like the chance that they have newsletter spend is gonna be slim. 13:42 Or if they do have it, they're gonna have really intense goals. Like, "Okay, I'll give you $1,000, but I need to make 10,000." 13:49 That can give me a little pause, but if anyone's gotten at least like a Series A, Series B, they probably have earmarked newsletter budget and, and I would definitely hit those folks up. 14:00 And then, yeah, use tools like, lastly, Who Sponsors stuff, that's the one I personally use. You can go in there- Yep. That's good... and it'll give you a full, um, really printout. 14:09 It'll export it to a CSV file, and you can categorize it and say like, "I wanna know everyone that sponsors a newsletter in," I don't know, "women's interests," and it will, it'll show you all that info. 14:21 Is there a sweet spot for like company size and revenue? Um, so you gave fundraising examples, but like what does that look like? I, I'm... Yeah. Company size, 14:33 I would say, how would, what I'd like to seem like at the smallest have at least 10 employees. 14:38 And the caveat to that is, look, if you've seen someone with two employees advertising a newsletter, hell, maybe they have a newsletter revenue source or, or an advertising revenue source that 14:47 is magic or, or we don't know about. I mean, who knows? So I would hit those people up. But if you haven't seen someone in a newsletter and you're wanting to sell them on, on your audience, 14:58 I would, I would hope they have at least 10 employees, and the 10 meaning, uh, generally I find if you have 10 employees, that means you have at least a marketer. Absolutely. 15:08 And, okay, since we kinda got an idea of those things and we got our, our media kit and stuff together at this point, if, if we're brand new, like 10,000 subscribers and we never had a sponsor before, how, how would you get that first direct sale sponsor? 15:22 Like, and also some people have like they've used the Beehiiv ad network or something, or maybe they plugged in an affiliate. Yeah. 15:27 So they might have some data on like what, um, you know, what type of clicks they're getting. And that also might be a good piece of advice. 15:33 I don't know if you would give this advice, Katie, but like should people, like before they get their first sponsors, test some affiliate offers, test some like, um, automated ad network offers from Beehiiv or ConvertKit- Yeah... 15:43 so they have something to show to that first direct sold sponsor? Does that make sense? Yeah. No, I, I actually do think that's a good approach. Yeah. If you, if, if you're not getting... 15:54 So first off, I think it's in your best interest in your newsletter every time you send it, have a section, uh, probably at the top if you haven't gotten one yet, at the bottom if maybe you have more inquiries, like, "Interested in this newsletter?" 16:07 Give up just a tiny overview, like, "10,000 people interested in marketing news," whatever, like to, to try and drum up interest from your own readers, 'cause those will be the easiest to convert. 16:18 But let's say you don't have that yet, definitely what those ad networks will give you is at least a barometer on what click-through rate you're getting. 16:28 So if you're curious, like, okay, per primary ad as an example, how many clicks will this drive? That can be helpful. 16:36 The only blind spot, I think, and, and this isn't a knock on them, it's just the way they're set up, the only blind spot they have is you're not able to get advertiser feedback. 16:46 So if you did run someone from those, and I do think you should to start, uh, the only thing you're not able to collect is direct advertiser feedback, so that is helpful in terms of like how did these convert? 16:57 Do they convert above average, your other partners below average, in average? 17:01 So once you do get a direct sponsor, definitely ask those questions so when you pitch other people, you can know, like, how premium is your audience? 17:10 Um, 'cause that'll help you defend if you are gonna charge more premium rate. Yeah. That'll help you do that. 17:15 And the tough thing about these ad networks, some of them you can't customize the copy or the creative, so you're gonna have a lower click-through rate than you would- Mm-hmm... with a direct sold sponsor. 17:23 I've seen a lot of that. So there's definitely some... It's, it's like a means to an end, in my opinion, uh, doing something like- Yeah... a Beehiiv ad network. 17:31 But with an affiliate offer, maybe you can customize more copy, and maybe you don't make a lot of money from that, but you just get some idea of how things are performing. Right. 17:38 Um- And some, I mean, if you're open to doing affiliates, most often you can probably set up a direct affiliate deal with someone. 17:46 Like, there are affiliate marketers, like that's their full-time job at brands, and so they're probably happy to run that, and you can make a, an agreement with them like, "Hey, I'll run this at the whatever the rate is, if you promise to give me all the results. 17:59 Like, so I can know if I drove 100 clicks, how many conversions did I get?" 18:03 And that'll help you understand the engagement and value of your audience.Yeah, that is the good thing about affiliate marketing, you can see that stuff versus ad network you can't. Mm-hmm. 18:13 Um, but then, yeah, pros and cons to each, right? Because affiliate you only get paid for what results you drive directly, and- Right... there's attribution that's missing sometimes. 18:20 Anyways, so after we have that, like getting to like the, the very, very first sponsor and we have like... And let's mention we have no connections or anything, we just have this audience, we have some data. 18:28 How do we get the first one? So what I would do is go through my subscriber list. 18:36 The first thing I would do, go through, get rid of the Gmails, the Hotmails, the Yahoos, whatever, like the generic email domains and, and filter it to see what all the business email addresses are, and go through and see if there's anyone in there that relates to your target audience. 18:51 So if you are doing, I don't know, let's say it's for product marketers, and you see some companies that maybe are a good fit @, I don't know, amazon.com. 19:02 Like, it is a little time intensive, but it can be worth the squeeze to like look those people up on LinkedIn to see what their title is. That's like a low-hanging fruit again of, okay, this person's probably a fit. 19:15 Maybe they don't know we do advertising. I'm gonna cold outreach them and see if they would have an interest. 19:20 The other thing that's a no-brainer that you probably all have heard before is seeing who's sponsoring your competitive newsletters or newsletters that are at least like in your space, um, and hitting up all those people. 19:34 So if you have like five newsletters that you think are pretty similar in audience tiers, subscribe to all of them and every morning go through, see who the sponsors are, and hit those brands up. 19:45 Um, if you're curious, like what titles to, to reach out to- Yeah, I was gonna ask that. Yeah. Okay, perfect. Um, growth marketer, paid media, acquisition marketing, and there's kind of variations of these titles. 19:59 Uh, demand gen marketer. Sometimes CMO if it's a smaller company, like sub 50, why the hell not? And then sometimes it can just be generic marketing. Like, those are, are the titles that most likely place that ad buy. 20:15 And so if they're on your list... O-one more tactical thing is if they're on your list, you got their, you have their email, and then you can find them on LinkedIn and contact them. 20:23 But if you're just finding them in another newsletter, how do you get the contact information? We talked about who sponsors stuff, which will give you that, but- Mm-hmm... 20:30 most people are not gonna buy that if they're just starting. Totally. Any, any tips for getting that email? So I use a tool. There's probably something more useful, but I, I use something called Clearbit, and it's free. 20:41 It's a Gmail plugin, and you can go in and type in the company name and type in the person's name, and pretty accurately it'll tell you who the, the... what their email is. If that... 20:55 Let's say I go in there and, and it's, uh, Matt McGarry, I type him in. He's not in their database, but a coworker at his company is. I'd still get their email, 'cause then you know the formula. 21:05 Maybe it's first name, last initial @business.com. Great, then you can figure it out. Um- Yeah... there's a ton of tools like that. Clearbit is the one I use. Yeah. 21:17 And I've used hunter.io, which is the same thing, but just another option for people in case one of those is more or less expensive or has a better free plan. Um- Yeah... so, uh, initial outreach is just like Gmail. 21:28 And do you send like a, a LinkedIn message too, or do you do both? Or doesn't matter- Sure... do you just do one? Um, you can do both. What I suggest, if you are gonna go the LinkedIn route, um, 21:39 pay for Navigator, 'cause I think you can send a higher volume of messages. Uh, and what I like to do is send a connection request and then add a note. 21:51 You can add, I think it's up to 300 characters, and that's your, like your small window to customize it. For the love of God, don't go, "Hey, I saw you're in the marketing industry, let's connect." 22:01 Like, that, that will never get you noticed. But if you say, "Hey, I saw you were in this newsletter. Just so you're aware, we have a similar audience. Um, does this sound interesting?" 22:12 Word that a little bit better, but that's the gist of, of what I would say. Uh, double-tapping doesn't hurt. I know newsletter can get like... 22:20 or, or cold email can get very crowded in people's inbox, but I would, I would straight... 22:25 I think InMail's not very successful, and that's when you just like straight up send someone a message, only 'cause that'll go to a different mailbox if you're not connected. I would say do the connect, add a note. 22:36 And I imagine you recommend if you're doing that, do email too. Yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah. Always email as well. I think that's a common mistake people make is like just LinkedIn, like a lot of people. 22:46 LinkedIn can get very crowded. Email can too, but if you have both, you're in a better position. And then- Mm-hmm... uh, one, one thing, I have- Mm-hmm... a couple more questions if we can get to all of them. Um, 22:58 any like lines that have worked well for you that you can share, whether it's a subject line, opening line for an email or message? Um, "Hey beautiful, saw you sponsoring that ad." 23:10 [laughs] Um, yeah, lines that work well. For... If I see them in a newsletter, I like to mention that in the subject line of the email. So say like, uh, "Brand name in Morning Brew," or, "Saw you in Morning Brew." 23:24 Kind of play with that. Um, so always be iterating with the subject lines, 'cause something that might work one week could just die on you the next. Um, I always like to mention where I saw them. And then 23:37 in the body of the email, obviously you need to talk about yourself, but try and be mindful of how lengthy it is. Like, I think bullets are a really helpful thing. 23:46 So what I do is, "Hey, saw you in Morning Brew newsletter, and I cr- am I correct in assuming you're trying to reach, uh, affluent tech professionals?" And the next line I'll say, "Reaching out because my newsletter..." 23:59 Then give a quick overview. Maybe it'd be like, "My newsletter," or "The Tech Daily, um, reaches 20,000 people, similar audience." Um, and then maybe you wanna put down like some bullet points like-Uh, 53% open rate. 24:15 Uh, past advertisers include, and then include brands that are similar to them if you can. I realize not everyone will have that luxury. 24:23 Um, and that kind of goes back to like, that is a nice thing about Beehiiv, is it allows you to just like quickly get some brand names under your belt so you can say like, "Oh, yeah," like Vanta I'm pretty sure is like one of Beehiiv's top brands and that like, they'll pretty much run anywhere if the price is right. 24:39 So it's a good household name just to have it there and be like, "Oh yeah, Vanta's advertised, HubSpot's advertised." And then obviously meetings are amazing. 24:47 Uh, some people will try and keep it over email, but I would ask for the meeting, keep it brief, definitely 15 minutes or less, 10 is ideal. 24:54 Say, "Do you have 15 minutes, 10 minutes open next week to see if this is a fit?" Include a Calendly link if you have one. That's always helpful as well. Matt, you, uh, feel like you had a question? Yeah. 25:07 No, just, uh- Yeah... one question. I don't, I didn't wanna interrupt your flow, but like at Madrev nowadays, shifting a little bit, what percent of ads are you selling like in a, on a call versus just email? 25:20 That's an interesting question. Um, honestly, probably majority over phone still. Uh, some people will do, I would say 80% or more phone call, then it transitions to email. 25:35 So on the phone call you introduce yourself and then they end up, you know, buying through the email correspondence. 25:40 But for smaller pops, like, oh, you know, it's just a $2,000 ad, yes or no, and it's a bit more transactional, that's generally what stays to email. Yeah. 25:51 And then to, to go into the final part of this, we can probably cover the next five minutes or less, is how do you price that first ad or that first couple ads? 25:59 You know, when that sponsor says, "Yeah, I'm interested, let's, let's do it," like- Mm-hmm... and you haven't shared pricing yet, like w- how, how do you price this just at, at the basic level? Yeah. 26:09 Um, again, I would go back to like that CPC math. It's figuring out, okay, I'm in a more consumer space. So to give everyone a range, if you're more consumer, the expectation of CPC is like $1 to $3. 26:25 And, and use your judgment, like if you're talking to a brand where their product costs 40 bucks, they're gonna need a lower CPC to make the numbers work. 26:34 If you're talking to a finance investment type brand where they could get someone who signs up for an account and gives them 20 grand, you could probably price that a little bit more premium, premium being defined as like 5 bucks a click. 26:49 Um, and you can scale that up as you run more ads and learn the value of your audience. 26:53 If you are in a niche area, like especially B2B software where they get a customer and they're making 10 grand a month indefinitely, you know, you could maybe price that 5 to 20 bucks estimated cost per click. 27:07 I would start at five just 'cause if you are in the early days, you sh- you wanna get as many folks in the door as you can just to have data and have past advertisers to quote. And then 27:19 by all means, once you've gotten that flow together and you're think- and you're seeing like, "Oh, okay, people are renewing at a good rate, they're giving good feedback, let's go ahead and up that price tag," 27:30 I, I would s- basically start low and, and price it up. That's key. Uh, it... 'cause a lot of people will think I wanna maximize the price of my very first ad. It's the first ad, let's just get it done. Yes. You know? 27:39 It, it, even if it's a low rate- Mm-hmm... let's get our first couple ads in the door, and then we can raise the price later for future advertisers and existing advertisers. Yeah. And one question I have is like 27:50 if that rate is a low, like it could be a couple hundred bucks. Mm-hmm. Should there ever sh- what type of minimum should they give? Should it be like you have to 27:57 a minimum order of, you know, $500, which might get you two or three ads at a low rate? 28:02 You know, should there be something like that for first time people instead of not trying to sell like $50 ads, $150 ads, things like that? Yeah. 28:09 I would, I would totally try and start with a bundle, 'cause the worst they can say is no, but... So see if you can get up the bundle cost to like 1, 2,000 bucks. I mean, shit, if you wanna go for 5,000, by all means. 28:24 'Cause if they're interested, the worst case scenario is they'll go, "Can't do that, but could you do a single ad or just three ads?" You know? I don't think it hurts. 28:35 And yeah, like Matt said, it'll save you from having to just continuously grind out these $50, $100 deals. Yeah, bundles are key. You don't wanna sell a bunch of one-off ads. 28:46 And, um, obviously a lot of people have already done this, but for people who are new, that's important. Okay. And then w- after you, 28:56 you get that aver- ad done, do you have any tricks for getting renewals, where maybe you fulfill that bundle of three ads, for example, how do you get them to, to re-up and, and buy more? 29:06 So before you run the campaign, as best you can, try and get a clear picture of what success looks like. So that could be simply clicks. They're like, "Hey, if we got 1,000 clicks, we'd be over the moon." 29:19 It could be conversions, demos, trials, gated asset downloads, or sales. That'll help you have something to, to measure the campaign success. Always try and get them on a campaign renewal call. 29:34 If you're a smaller newsletter, that might be harder 'cause it just might not be like worth their time if they're like, "I only spent $50 for me to get on a 30-minute call." Like is it worth it? 29:43 And that's okay if they say that. Let's say scen- a scenario where the ad ran, you go, "Hey, how'd it do?" And they're like, "Eh, not so good. I don't think we're gonna renew." It's not the end of the world. 29:54 I would ask questions like, "Sorry to hear that. What other newsletters are working for you? And if you don't mind, like what a- what, uh, offers did you put, promote?" 30:04 So, uh, if, if they say, "Oh yeah, it's been working really well in XYZ newsletter, but we promoted, um, this asset," and it's not an asset they promoted with you, I would see, okay, well, could we try that one? 30:15 It seems like that asset sen- tends to resonate better. Um, you know, and, and this is of course also if you're-To give you too much information. You have to be really confident that the audience is a match. 30:26 All of us are guilty of running advertisers that we're like, "Uh, this is probably not a good fit, but whatever. If they wanna run, I'll let them do it." I gave them all the information. Yeah. 30:34 Um- Just assuming that it is, of course, yep. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This is assuming someone you're like, "This doesn't make sense. This should have killed." Um, 30:41 ask them those questions, and then also understanding what price point would they run again. So you sold it at $100, they come back and they go, "Yeah, didn't hit our marks." Go, "Sorry to hear that. 30:54 Um, out of curiosity, is there a price... If, if in the future I have an unsold ad and I'm discounting it, what price do you want me to reach out to you at?" And then you have now the line in which they would run again. 31:08 Maybe today you wouldn't take that deal, but at some point you're gonna get in a tight spot where you have an ad and the next day you don't have an advertiser, you can have someone quickly to fill in that spot. 31:19 Um, or maybe you wanna sell them a bundle. You're like, "Well, if you would buy five ads, I'd sell it to you at that rate per ad." And then, you know, you can sell a bigger package like that. So those are, are some, 31:31 some strategies you can try. Um, definitely always get like that, I call it the no-brainer price in which they'd run again. And do you have time for like two more quick questions? Mm-hmm. 31:41 So insertion orders are just like the contractual things to actually get this done. For your first ad, maybe that's not needed, but like would you recommend people have an insertion order- Mm. Sure... 31:52 a contract going forward? Mm. Or, or when should they get one? I do think you should have one. Even though 32:01 you should trust people to an extent, I, I would have some sort of IO just 'cause it puts a little teeth in the arrangement. You don't have to come up with one that's super complicated. 32:10 A lot of people use what's on the IAB website. That's pretty straightforward. If you want something a little bit easier, I, I... To everyone listening to this, I would definitely have a page on Passion Fruit. 32:24 It's free to create, and if you wanted to, even if someone didn't come in through your newsletter through Passion Fruit, you could have them convert there, 'cause they have like a Stripe integration. 32:35 I think there is like some T's and C's on there. Like, I think you actually have to pay upfront, if I'm understanding, remembering it correctly. Yeah. 32:42 Um, that could be like a little cheat code if someone's like, "Yeah, I'll buy, you know, an ad for $100." Just go, "Hey, can you fill out this Passion Fruit page?" 32:50 That way they can give you their ad copy, you have their money, it's easily transacted, and there's like some sort of contractual obligation there. It definitely streamlines things. 33:00 And, um, i- if you're not doing something like Passion Fruit, do you need an insertion order for every single bundle or ad campaign that you're running? Or like how do you typically do that? 33:10 Or is it just like one initially and then... Uh, yeah. I would sell one for every deal. So even if you sell a bundle of five, you can make one IO and, and- Yeah, absolutely... put like five ads in there. But 33:22 I would s- I, I'll tell you what I do. I have an IO for every single deal, just 'cause you never know- Yeah. The next bundle you have another IO for, for that one. Yeah. And if they're like, "Oh, this is great. 33:32 Can we buy another five?" Great, here's another contract for those five. Okay. I know it's maybe obvious to some people. Just wanna clarify if people have like no idea- Yeah... um, and never done that before. 33:43 The, the last question I have is like what are some of the bigger brands you've sold ads to, um, just throughout your career in general? Mm. Um, my biggest client was probably Goldman Sachs. I loved their money. 33:55 It was brand awareness, which is heaven on Earth. Uh, I did do a Showtime campaign once at The Hustle, which was kind of fun. We were promoting a show. Billions, I think it was. 34:06 And then- Yeah, that's a good fit for The Hustle. [laughs] Yeah. Uh, I ended up watching it, so they got one conversion at least. Uh, and then right now, probably, I mean, our biggest sponsor for sure, HubSpot probably. 34:19 I'm trying to think of publicly traded companies. Yeah, that's probably the biggest one. Is Plaid public? I don't know, but they're big. Those are all great companies. Um- Yeah. Ben works with Plaid. I'm like, I don't... 34:28 I have no idea if they're, they're public or not. Um, and then we're doing something with The Washington Post soon. Oh, yeah. I don't know if they're public or not. 34:38 I mean, you know who they are, but I have no idea if they're public. I think they used to be. You know, you know who they're owned by now, of course, but, um- I know. Mr. Bezos. Yeah. 34:46 [laughs] Base- base- I always call him Bozo. Bezos. Bezos. [laughs] Um, sorry, Jeff. I'd like to come on your yacht if the offer still stands. Yeah. Maybe give him some free ads. 34:55 Um, any difference between, you know, working with those types of companies at that scale versus the average client that you work with? Mm. 35:04 And any advice you could give to people who wanna get bigger and bigger sponsors? Uh, so the bigger companies definitely have more 35:13 legal red tape, so they're most likely gonna be able to do like these really quick on-the-fly deals. However, the bigger companies will have brand budget, which is every seller's, publisher's dream. 35:27 Uh, it's basically free money, and it rocks. 35:31 But my favorite companies to work with, I think, honestly, are like the Series C, Series D, because they have a mix of brand and demand, but they have the flexibili- like the... 35:42 It seems like there's just not as much red tape when it comes to buying new ads on the fly, and they generally like can pay their bills pretty quick. Like the bigger the company, the larger... 35:53 They're like, "I need a 90-day payment terms or 45 days." And like that can be kind of painful as a small brand. Absolutely. Any, um, any final thoughts? 36:04 Like i- is getting those bigger companies been any different in the sales process than, than small or medium sized ones? [coughs] Yeah. Um, it is really hard to get those big deals. 36:14 I feel like largely-And this isn't to say it doesn't happen, but largely these, like, mega companies are inbounds. Like, that's how you get those. Like, for Goldman, I, I didn't hit up anyone at Goldman. 36:28 They reached out, and it just happened to be my turn to get that lead. Same time for-- Same thing for Showtime. 36:34 Um, it's because someone high up at the company reads the newsletter and is like, "Hey, I want to see my brand here. Can you reach out to them?" But I still hit them up. 36:42 Like, if I see someone big in, you know, 1440 or Morning Brew, I'm still gonna try and, and reach out to them, 'cause miracles do happen. I got a meeting with Apple recently from a cold email, which blew my mind. 36:54 But, you know, if you do have the right fit, like, it just happened to be that I reached out about a brand that was a fit for what they were looking for, so it worked out. 37:01 But that's why I like the Series C, B companies, 'cause if you are smaller, you can still get their attention. Their inbox isn't crazy just yet. Um, and you can get substantial dollars from them. 37:15 And then maybe they'll-- that marketer will go work at the big company, you'll have that relationship, and that's how you, you get your foot in the door. Yeah, that's really good advice. Cool. 37:23 So if people want to learn more about Madrev, that's madrev.co. We'll put a link down below. Any other things, uh, people should know? Any final thoughts or call to actions? 37:33 Um, if you're thinking about growing your newsletter, you'd be a fool not to use Matt. Uh, he- [laughs] Thank you. I, I t- I know, Matt, you know this story, but... and I tell it to anyone that's thinking about it. 37:43 But no joke, when he started the hustle, we were in this, like, phase of just, like, stagnation. 37:49 And the sales team, we were frustrated because we were like, "We keep pitching these increased subscriber numbers, and we're not hitting it." Matt comes in, all of a sudden, up and to the right. That's no exaggeration. 37:59 It was, as a seller, music to my ears. So he really does know what he's talking about. Uh, he's not a diva, and you're, you're in good hands if you should go that route. Oh, thank you. I appreciate that. 38:12 And I literally recommend every publisher that's qualified o- over to you guys at Madrev. Um, so awesome. Thank you. Okay. This was a lot of fun, and, um, I'll talk to you soon. We'll wrap it up here. Yeah. 38:25 I will talk to you soon.