Transcript 0:00 Before we even started focusing on, like, growing the newsletter list, we had a beta newsletter, and that- we had that for, like, three or four months, just family and friends, and that was just to get kind of the initial feedback and figure out what the newsletter was that we wanted to fully go to market with. 0:16 Consumers and audiences in, in this day and age, especially Gen Z and, and millennials, like, they wanna go deeper than just, like, what is the utility I'm getting out of this product or service? 0:26 Like, they do care about the mission or purpose behind it and if their values align with that. And entrepreneurship is a very spiritual journey. 0:35 It really forces you to take a hard look at yourself and figure out the ways that you're getting in your own way of your own success. [upbeat music] Okay. We are here with Rosalind McLarty. Did I get that [laughs]? 0:51 [laughs] Yeah, that's good. Um- That's right... we've known each other for a long time, which is interesting, probably since 2020, right, when we first met? Yeah. You were at The Hustle. 1:00 I was running growth at The Gist, and before we had things like Newsletter Operator, we had to just get together and talk about how we were growing newsletters. 1:08 So I feel like that's how we initially connected, exchanging- Yeah... strategies. Yeah. I think Scott Nixon, um, had been working with y'all for a little bit or, or known y'all for a little bit. Mm-hmm. 1:17 And, um, we just randomly connected on a call just to talk about what, what's up and what's going on. 'Cause there w- at that time, there wasn't that many newsletters, which wasn't that long ago. Yeah. 1:25 The, like, the big ones when we started that we looked up to were The Hustle, Skimm, and Morning Brew, and that's, like, really where we had mentors and were getting ideas and seeing the different ways that they were running businesses, 'cause, 1:38 yeah- That was about it... there was no... There was no Newsletter Operator. Yeah. Yeah. So, um, tell me a bit about you. I know a lot about you, but for people who don't know. So- Mm-hmm... 1:47 you started a new newsletter, a new company recently called Within. But previously you were the co-founder of The Gist, and I think you wore a lot of different hats [laughs] there as a co-founder does. 1:57 [laughs] But, um, what did that look like as far as your, your role and title at The Gist? Yeah. For sure. I, um, I was the head of Growth, Operations, and Finance. So [clears throat] that meant a lot of things. 2:09 That was obviously running the growth strategy, marketing, data analytics to support that, the operations, like setting up processes, scaling the operations as our team grew from three co-founders to around 20, um, full-time, 40 total when I left. 2:26 And then all the finances from, you know, bookkeeping up to fundraising and strategic finance. So- Yep... lots of different things. 2:35 [laughs] I wanna talk about The Gist first, and then we're gonna get into the new stuff you're working on that you just launched literally maybe, maybe two weeks ago, um, as of this conversation. Yeah. It... 2:45 W- when did The Gist start, by the way? What was the... When, when was it founded? Yeah. We had the initial idea for The Gist back in 2017. 2:52 It wasn't 'til 2018 when we quit our full-time jobs and went full-time on The Gist. So it's been, it's been around for a long time. And were you, like, was that one of your first jobs? 3:03 Were you out of college at that time? Where were you at in your, in your life at that point? Yeah. So actually, um, my first job was working in the Big Four accounting. Oh, fun. So I am a CPA. 3:14 [laughs] I am also a, a CPA in addition to being an entrepreneur. 3:18 So, um, actually me and both of my co-founders were all working in different areas of financial services in Downtown Toronto when we founded The Gist, and it was part of an being downtown in a big city that is crazy about sports that we kind of came up with the idea for The Gist, because one of us, not myself, my co-founder, Alan, was a massive sports fan, and the other two of us, you know, had played sports growing up, watched sports growing up, but just weren't really resonating with the ESPNs and the Fox Sports and the, certainly not the Barstools of the world, um, because it felt very male-dominated in terms of- Yeah. 3:57 And I wanna break that down, too, and the, the mission and the, the content behind The Gist too, because I think that's really interesting and not, uh, not, not typical, right? But that's cool. 4:07 So from, like, a CPA to a media founder, that's not a, like- [laughs]... transition a lot of people make, but- Yeah... I love it. Yeah. 4:13 Tell us about the, like, the idea for The G- You explained it a little bit, but go deeper- Mm-hmm... into, like, how you saw that gap in the market- Mm... that problem that was happening. Uh- Yeah... 4:24 you do a great job of explaining it on your website, that people should check out, but just break that down for us real quick. Yeah. We honestly came up with the idea and saw the opportunity really organically. It... 4:34 We were three friends from business school, and we were just catching up one night, and Alan, the one who's, like, the big sports fan, was telling us about sports. 4:41 And JC and myself just kind of noticed how much more fun it was to get sports f- from a female friend that is just more relatable and can prov- provide, can provide context and, and break things down. 4:54 And just thought about how there wasn't really anything out there sports-news wise that was really appealing to us and inviting us into the fold. And 5:04 so we just kinda had a moment where we were like, "There's probably a lot of other women that feel this way, that feel like, you know, sports is this really male-dominated place, from the coverage that you're seeing on TV with so little of it being on women's sports, to who is talking and providing sports news, to who it's really targeting." 5:24 And it actually has come further, I think, since then, but back when we came up with the idea in 2017, it was, um, even worse kind of than it is now. 5:34 And it just felt like a really big white space and opportunity, um- Yeah... 5:39 with women making up half of the population and, uh, having, like, 80% of con- consumer spending power, and a lot of them actually are sports fans or wanna be sports fans or could be sports fans if there was something that was m- inviting them in and actually feeling like it was for them. 5:58 You have a lot of good stats on your website about this, where-I don't know what the numbers are, like 80 or 90% of the sports coverage is e- either on men or, or by men. I don't know- Mm-hmm... the numbers exactly. 6:10 And I, I f- I don't know what the numbers are now, but I think initially it was about, like, you were focusing on covering men and women's sports 50/50, which, which no one was doing. Mm-hmm. Right? Yeah. 6:20 And, and I think a lot of people mistake The Gist who, who don't read it or don't know, and they think it's like it's a women's sports media company, but that's not exactly what it is. Can you break that down too? Yeah. 6:31 Yeah. So we're not covering only women's sports. 6:33 We're covering men's and women's sports, 'cause they're both part of the cultural conversation, and, um, that is part of, you know, the value proposition is it's a quick and easy and really fun way to stay up to date on all sports that are kind of being talked about in the mainstream. 6:49 Um, but we thought it was really important to give women the spotlight that they deserve in an effort to do, um, our part in starting to close that gap in, in society. 6:59 And that has been to the benefit of our audience too, because if you're a sports fan, it's pretty likely that you're gonna... You can grow kind of your fandom of the WNBA and the NWSL and all women's sports. 7:12 If you're into sports, it's just a matter of kind of exposure and, and it being put in front of you. 7:17 So yeah, we, we looked at it more as who we are, are targeting and what, what voices, um, are being represented in media to make a space that felt more inclusive, not only for women, but also for anybody that has felt left out of the kind of, like, white male dominated sports industry. 7:37 So that also extends to- Yeah... the queer community, people of color. So like anyone that doesn't resonate what was already out there. 7:46 And this might be easy, but when, you know, later on when you were bringing on writers and other people on the team, like, how did you communicate what it's about to them? Was there like a, a document? 8:00 Was there like a, um, a culture guide or a writing guide or a mission statement that you put out there to like, just to make it s- clear? Or was it just clear based off of everything that you've, you've done? Yeah. 8:12 I think it was a combination of both. 8:13 I think, um, I think we've always been really clear with our brand of explaining what our mission is, and high level, that's to level the playing field in sports, and that's kind of the umbrella for everything that we do. 8:26 And so I think it was pretty clear in the market, and so we tended to attract people that were really passionate about that mission, um, and maybe had, you know, unique experiences. 8:35 Maybe they were athletes, maybe they experienced the pain point. And so the people that we attracted were already pretty passionate about that mission. 8:42 But yeah, of course, like, when they were onboarded, it's something that we would take people through, like, "This is our mission, this is our long-term vision. These are some of our company values. 8:51 These are how these things come into play and how we do things at The Gist," just to get everybody kind of on board. Yeah. 8:59 I think a lot of, um, a lot of regular companies don't do that, but as a media company, that's even more important than a regular company because what, what you're putting out there is your voice and, and your values, especially if you're coming on board as a writer and editor. 9:13 So I'm always curious about how people do that. Mm-hmm. Let's talk about getting that off the ground, right? Mm-hmm. Um, oh, one more thing I want to add before that is, is I, I love that you mentioned 9:24 this kind of all came about just from your friend Ellen just talking to you about sports. Be- because that's... 9:31 It kind of also reminds me of like the Hustle's old headline or tagline they used, like, back, I don't know, five, seven years ago now, where it's like, "Your smart, good-looking friend who tells you the news you need to know for the day." 9:41 [laughs] And that was kind of the, the tone that they had in their content of their newsletter. It was about business and tech news. Um, but I think that's just a style of writing a lot of people can learn from. 9:52 And in my personal experience, I'm not a huge sports person, but I enjoy sitting down with a friend who knows something well- Mm-hmm... 9:59 whether basketball, football, whatever it is, and then just watching a game with them and then just asking them questions. Exactly what- Yeah... similar situation to what, what you were in, right? Um- Yeah, 100%. 10:08 And so it's cool to see that in, like, newsletter or in media forums, take that real world conversation into, to a one to many conversation with, with media. Yeah. Yeah, 100%. So it's funny you mention that. 10:20 So that's actually something we did, and I'm sure we'll get into kind of the early days, but one thing that we did in the early days was a lot of watch parties and Super Bowl parties and things like this, and we would literally have Ellen up there, you know, commentating, answering questions about, like, what's going on, strategies, rules, that kind of thing. 10:36 So it's funny that you mention that because that's something that our audience was definitely seeking and that we leaned into. Awesome. Cool. 10:43 So tell me about, like, how we built that audience or how you, how you built that audience initially. Or if we would even break it down, like, how you got the first 1,000 newsletter subscribers. Mm-hmm. 10:52 Let's talk about that. I also want to talk about later why you even decided to start with a newsletter or s- I don't know exactly what you started with, but, um- [laughs] Yeah... let's reverse that. 11:01 So did you start with a newsletter? If so, why? And then how did you get those first 1,000 subscribers? We did start with a newsletter. I think it just felt, like, very kind of low friction. 11:11 Um, at the time that we came up with the idea, like, The Skimm was big and, like, the new hot thing, and we kind of looked at that for inspiration, and we were like, "Oh, why don't we just, you know, 11:22 do what The Skimm is doing, but for sports, for women and un- underserved sports fans?" It just felt, like, pretty easy to get off of the ground and start to get some feedback and, and go from there. 11:34 But it did continue to be kind of the, the main offering. But at, in the very beginning, it was just a local Toronto sports newsletter before it evolved into- Really? I didn't know that. Yeah. Was that a good strategy? 11:47 I mean, you went broader over time, of course. Mm-hmm. But are you happy with, like, starting there? Yeah. I mean, 11:54 I feel like you just want to start with whatever is, like, easiest to get it off the ground and start, you know, getting an earlier, an early audience and getting some feedback, and we were-Running events in Toronto when we were capitalizing on, you know, playoff runs and stuff that were happening in Toronto. 12:09 So it just felt like an easy way to get going and then expand from there. But- One more- To answer your question... Oh, go ahead. 12:16 One more question before you get to that, that one is, um, I tend to recommend to people to start maybe too niche because it's easier to expand later or go broader later than to niche down later. Mm-hmm. 12:29 In your experience, do you think that... Is that a good idea? I mean, there's people who have broke the mold and b- been, gone big both ways, but what do you think? I think it's a good idea. 12:38 I think, like, if you start niche, you can really create a really good foundation for high engagement, and then you can learn from your audience about the other ways that you can start to expand. But I think when you, 12:54 yeah, really take the effort to understand, like, who that, like, key ICP 13:02 is and, like, what are their pain points and how can you provide them value in, like, a very specific way, that's gonna be to your benefit in terms of engagement. 13:10 So, so, like, for us, we started with, with Toronto, and then we expanded to Canada. And then as we became more a resource, we were able to launch in the US and expand into all these different sports markets. 13:22 Eventually, we expen- expanded laterally into sports business and college sports because we just saw lots of opportunities in the market and from our audience that were indicators that, like, this is a good opportunity for us to capitalize on. 13:38 But yeah, if we had started as a sports newsletter that covered all sports, men's and women's college sports, sports business 13:48 in all of the different markets into one newsletter, I feel like that wouldn't have been as valuable. Absolutely, yeah. 13:56 And it's hard to do all that, and it's also hard to stand out when you're, when you're brand new and you're not really serving a clear niche. 14:02 And before we get into the growth stuff, one other question is, did you start as a weekly newsletter covering Toronto sports, daily, or what was- Mm-hmm... the frequency and content back then? Yeah. 14:13 We started weekly, pretty soon after expanded to twice weekly. And then I think ultimately... 14:20 Well, once we had kind of the resources to hire a team, because initially it was just Ellen writing all the newsletters and JC and I editing. 14:28 And then [laughs] we were able to take things further when we were able to, you know, onboard more writers and people with more experience. 14:34 Eventually, we went to Monday, Wednesday, Friday, and then Sunday for a deeper dive, and that's where it is today. 14:44 And did that ex- that, that frequency, how long did that take to go f- to four, from one day a week to four days a week? Hmm. That's a good question. Um, I would say a few y- a few years. Yeah. That makes sense. 14:59 And I, I just like to explain that to people because a lot of people think I'm starting a newsletter, [laughs] I got to do it seven days a week, and they have no audience, and they get burnt out very quick. 15:07 And it's- Yeah... it's cool to see that transition o- over years with, with you. Yeah. I think especially, especially when you're... 15:15 Especially with, like, kind of the saturation in the newsletter space today, like, having one newsletter a week, that's, like, really special, that you put a lot of effort into, rather than, like, spreading yourself thin and having kind of, like, only an okay newsletter five days a week. 15:29 You know, there's so much inbox clutter, so if you have an average newsletter, it's an easy one to unsubscribe from, right? So I say better to start off- I agree... with something really strong. Yeah. 15:41 So really everybody needs to have a high signal to noise ratio, but especially when you're just starting and you haven't really earned attention, you have to have a very high signal to noise ratio, um- Mm-hmm... 15:51 so people can actually pay attention to you when you have no social proof, no audience, no, no nothing. Cool. Yeah. Okay. So to, to... I know I asked this question before and ha- had a bunch of follow-ups for you. 16:02 Yeah, let's talk about those first 1,000 subscribers and what happened there. Yeah. 16:06 So before we even started focusing on, like, growing the newsletter list, we had a beta newsletter, and that, we had that for, like, three or four months, just family and friends, and that was just to get kind of the initial feedback and figure out what the newsletter was that we wanted to fully go to market with. 16:24 The way that we got our first, I would say, like, 300 to 500 s- subscribers is we actually had a launch party. So we sent invites to friends, family, colleagues, people in our network. We 16:35 managed to get a space in the Shopify offices in Toronto, and we just, like, threw a big party and had a PowerPoint deck and got up there, and we were like, "This is what we're launching. This is why." 16:46 And it was really well received, and everybody that attended, um, we got them signed up. And so that's how we got our first, I want to say, like, 300 to 500 subscribers. 16:56 And then, yeah, in the early days it was, it was super, super scrappy, super organic. We obviously didn't have, like, a lot of capital to put towards it. 17:05 So I remember, like, [laughs] when I quit my job, I hit, like, reply all on, like, the department and was just like, "Hey guys, like, thanks. I'm leaving. By the way, sign up for The Gist." So lots of- [laughs]... 17:17 just, like, getting existing network to sign up. We did some illegal out of home advertising. Um, we created- [laughs] I don't know if you have to call it that. You can call it [laughs] guerrilla marketing or something. 17:32 Yeah. Yeah, yeah. That's a better- [laughs]... that's a better word for it. But we created a, like, a stencil that said, "Leveling the playing field," and then thegistsports.com. 17:39 And we actually got a lot of people, a lot of high quality subscribers from that. We would, like, go to parks and, like, downtown Toronto financial distri- district and, like, just, like, ask people to sign up. 17:49 I don't recommend that one, but I'm just saying we were trying everything at that point in time. Um- Yeah. You got to be scrappy. One, one question going back to the, the launch party. Mm-hmm. Did, um... 18:00 I think I've, I've heard this story before. Did you have people just give you their email to get in? Like, how do you just col- what's the mechanics of how you collected the email? Hmm. That's a good question. 18:09 It was such a long time ago. I think it was probably, like-Give you your email to get in And then in that presentation, was it like, was it like B2B or was... 18:19 I guess I should say, was it about the business of The Gist, or was it like about the content and why you should read it, or, or both [laughs] in that presentation? 18:28 Um, it was probably a little bit of both in that we came in, like, explaining our vision for The Gist from like this is like why this business is being launched. 18:39 Um, going back to like some of the stats that you mentioned on the website of like w- the inequity in the space, and then, 18:47 yeah, kind of pitching the content and why it was different and, and why people should sign up and share it and whatnot. Awesome. Any other scrappy stuff that, that worked early on? 18:58 Those are the, those are ones that come to mind. We, uh, I... This wasn't that early. In 2019 we did the [laughs] 19:05 we went to a Eagles tailgate and, like, did the same thing of like going around just to all the women trying to get them to sign up. But again, I w- I wouldn't necessarily recommend that. 19:14 Yeah, I think it's good to talk to people. It's just hard to like cold sell people [laughs] on something. Totally. But, um- People don't like it when you walk up to them. 19:21 [laughs] Definitely talk to people who are already subscribed, I think that's, that's, uh, definitely a good idea. Yeah. 19:26 What do you think about people who are in the situation you were in back then, they're in that situation today, uh, how would, how would you recommend people go out and get their first 100 or 1,000 newsletter subscribers? 19:39 Yeah. I think it kind of depends on like what your newsletter is about and who your audience is. Um, but I would just think about like where, where are these people hanging out? What are they doing? 19:50 What are the things that they like? Like how do you, how does what you're offering overlap with stuff that they're already doing and places that they're going? And what are creative ways that you can reach them that way? 20:03 I guess it's like a little bit broad, but that's probably how I would think about it. Yeah. And I think 20:10 th- this is a little bit intangible, but w- when you have a newsletter that solves a pro- or, or it doesn't have to be a newsletter, but a media company newsletter that solves a problem, 20:19 is o- on a clear mission, it's a lot easier to grow, and I think that's what, what you had at The Gist and, and a lot of people have, but also a lot of people, most people don't have. Mm-hmm. 20:30 Um, and like doing a launch party can be fun and, and meaningful versus like if you're just another newsletter covering AI, 20:37 I mean, I'm not going to the launch party for that because it's not different in any way and it's not, it's not impactful. Right? So- Yeah... 20:43 I think if people can figure out, you know, what's their job to be done, uh, how, what's their white space that they're actually serving, that they can do all those scrappy, the, all these things in a much more effective way. 20:54 Yeah. I totally agree. People love to get behind a mission or a purpose they believe in, and that's t- true. 21:02 That's been true for like starting out The Gist in the beginning, and it's been true as we have scaled our growth channels to... 21:10 'Cause it's not just a, it's not necessarily just about the value of the product or service. I think, yeah, consumers and audiences in, in this day and age, especially Gen Z and, and Millennials, like, 21:23 they wanna go deeper than just like what is the utility I'm getting out of this product or service. Like, they do care about the mission or purpose behind it and if their values align with that. 21:34 And so that's definitely been something really important for us as we've grown, not only with user acquisition, but also with, um, growing our team, working with brands. 21:45 It just makes all aspects of the business easier when you're aligned behind a, a cohesive mission. 21:54 It really does, and I've, we've seen that with the people that we've worked with out of the, you know, 30 or 50 clients that we worked with. The ones that... And we, we don't 22:02 help them in every aspect of their business, just really on the growth side. The ones that have that, and it really doesn't matter what it is or [laughs] who it's for, that helps, you know? 22:12 'Cause we work with people like across the spectrum from B2B to consumer, to all that type of stuff. Mm-hmm. But it's hard to like... 22:20 Yeah, it's like media is not just like a logical thing, like, oh, is this gonna help me save time or make more money? 22:24 They, they wanna see like what, what, what is your perspective and what is, what is your purpose too, which I think kind of founders who aren't like from the media space or aren't from the creator space, I think they miss that. 22:36 Um, I need a better framework for it, but [laughs] we'll work on that. [laughs] Yeah. Okay. That makes sense. Couple more questions about The Gist, and I wanna, uh, transition to another topic. 22:46 Um, I just kinda w- wanna walk through like the beginning, the middle, um- Mm-hmm... and like how you grow. So we talked about starting. Yeah. Like h- how did, how did you, on the growth side, 22:59 go from, you know, 1,000 subscribers to hundreds of thousands of subscribers? Um- Yeah... what was like the 80/20 of like what actually worked? Because I imagine you did dozens of different... 23:10 tested dozens of different growth methods. What, what worked for you? Mm-hmm. Yeah. I think it's worth mentioning that soon after we launched The Gist, we got into an incubator program that gave us some initial capital, 23:25 and we did continue to raise more money after that. 23:28 And so that did help us with, you know, jump-starting both like the growth of our audience acquisition and the growth of our team to be able to create more content and increase kind of our, our frequency with the newsletter and- Yeah... 23:41 and social content and whatnot, which certainly helped the growth as well. And the other big thing that happened was in 2019, 23:50 we launched in the US, and so that just like really opened up our, our market, and I think that's when we really started to see a lot more growth. But in terms of, yeah, like 24:02 kind of our growth strategy, we tested a lot of different things, [laughs] as you do. 24:08 I think one thing that we did pretty well early on when we-Had some of this capital and were ready to go out and start spending and, and testing different things was set up kind of a structure for measurement and tracking, and understand our unit economics so that we had a bit of a, a structure for, um, testing different growth channels. 24:29 So we were like super lucky to have a mentor that ran growth at The Skimm that helped us put the analytics in place for us to be able to start to track like open rate per growth channel. 24:42 And when we were able to get an understanding of what our lifetime value of a user was, and then start to compare that to the co- the, the CAC per channel. 24:52 But then also like the cost for, um, like opening or clicking, like engaging user too, um, that allowed us to like get pretty specific around like this is the growth channel we wanna increase, this is the one we wanna decrease, this is the one we need to cut. 25:09 In terms of the actual channels that we did test and the ones that were successful for us over time, paid social was huge. Obviously Facebook ads, TikTok ads being like the bigger ones. 25:23 I think we tested Twitter ads, didn't, wasn't like working as well for us. We had got some Google ads, but um, really like the bulk of the volume was Facebook and TikTok. 25:32 Um, which made sense 'cause that's where a lot of our audience was hanging out. 25:37 And as a content company, like I think we had a strength there of like really understanding our audience and being able to create content, um, on the paid side or leverage content on the organic side for paid. 25:50 Other big things that worked well, like partnerships was a big one for us. Um, so not only like newsletter cross promotions, which um, was amazing for like high quality subscribers, but less scalable back then. 26:03 It is more so now I think with platforms like SparkLoop and Beehiiv, but I don't know if you remember like the old days of like everybody was on DojoMojo. [chuckles] Oh yeah. Yeah, some people still use a lot of that. 26:18 Yeah, tell us about that a little bit, how those partnerships went. Yeah. 26:22 So yeah, for those of you who don't know, that was the platform, is the platform I guess, people are still using it, that allows, um, multiple different brands to collaborate on, uh, giving something away, and each of the brands promotes giveaways and all of the people that enter their email into the giveaway, then all of the brands get, get to have those emails. 26:43 So as you can imagine, it can be like really high volume, really low CAC, but also really high churn and potentially lower quality. 26:53 We were able to get it down to a place where like we just had an automated churn system where we would bring those people on if they didn't open the first couple of newsletters, an email being like, "Hey, we're gonna take you off the list if they, if you don't open or engage." 27:07 And then eventually take them off if they didn't open from there on. 27:11 So it was kind of like a self list cleaning system to make sure that we were only getting, only retaining kind of the people that actually did wanna like stick around. 27:24 Eventually we evolved our partnership, our like giveaway partnership strategy to be where we were owning all of it. 27:31 So we weren't running it through a platform, we were just running it ourselves and that allowed us to have like a lot more control over the process and the different brands involved, and also make sure that the prize was really relatable for the people that we wanted to attract. 27:45 So for example, we would give away a trip to New York where you can have tickets to the New York Liberty and Gotham FC games, which are the women's soccer and basketball teams. 27:58 And so it was attracting people that actually were interested in, would, would be interested in our content, and that worked a, a lot better in terms of the quality of subscribers. 28:09 And then I would say like we, we kind of took that strategy even like a step further with, um, instead of having giveaway... Well not instead of having give- giveaways, but in addition to doing that we also would do, 28:22 um, sports brackets and pools as a way to like incentivize people to get into our community. 28:28 Um, so we would for, I think we now have the technology to host those ourselves, but it would be like you need to submit an email to participate, but that was a good way to- Just break that down so the audience is clear on like a sports bracket. 28:42 Um, 'cause I, 'cause I know like March Magnet, Madness brackets- Mm-hmm... but that's about the extent of my experience with those. Yeah. No, the- Tell me a little bit more. Yeah. 28:50 No, that's, that's right, and that's kind of how they're structured too. 28:53 Like you could have a bracket for a playoffs, like any sports playoffs for instance, where you go in and you make your predictions of, you know, who's gonna win each match up throughout, and there's a prize at the end for the winner, and usually there's like a leaderboard and it's fun and competitive. 29:09 Um- What type of prizes would you, would you do if you're hosting one of these? Or have you had, did you do in the past? Cash usually. There we go. [laughs] That's what, that's what people want. 29:22 Well, I, I'm, I wanna underscore what you said there. When you have a prize or reward that is aligned with what your content is, it works a lot better and- Mm-hmm... I've seen that. 29:31 I've used The Gist as an example of this. Um, and I didn't know about the bracket and the, the tournament sweepstakes or thing. 29:38 I think that's, that's really cool too, and also a lot more interactive than just like enter to win something. 'Cause you got, [chuckles] you have more skin in the game. You're keeping track of what's going on and- Yeah. 29:48 If you can combi- if you can like have a growth strategy that also creates engagement or serves other purpose, purposes too, like if you can get a partner to sponsor a giveaway or if you can have a growth strategy that increases engagement, like I think those are the places where you're winning. 30:03 Absolutely. One... So the DojoMojo stuff, tho- those are partnership giveaways where there's one host and there's a handful of partners. When you did this more yourself, did you still have partners? 30:14 Um, that were like other publishers or newsletters, or were the partners just like to provide a reward, like you're giving awayI don't know, basketball merch, for example, and you have a partner provide the merch or something. 30:25 Also, I'm gonna let my dog in, so if you see me walk out for a second, [laughs] that's it. [laughs] It's okay. Um, do you mean on, uh, Dojo Mojo or when we were doing it ourselves? 30:37 When you were doing it yourselves, like, did you have multiple people that you partnered with to share the giveaway and then share the, um, entries from the giveaway, or was that just through Dojo Mojo? 30:48 Did you ever do that on your own? Oh, yeah. Like, when we were doing it on our own, we would partner with other brands too, 'cause that's kinda how we would expand the, the reach of the, of the giveaway. 30:58 And were there any types of brands that worked well for you, like other newsletters? What types of companies? Yeah. 31:05 Usually the best ones were other newsletters, and especially newsletters where you, like, know that they're also, like, cleaning their list and know that they're prioritizing quality. 31:17 Yeah, I would say other newsletters were the best kinds of brands, 'cause you just are getting people who are already reading newsletters. And if we could target some kind of, like, 31:27 similar demographics or anything like that, like maybe it would be a finance newsletter for women or, like, a career newsletter for women, where it's, um, similar demographics and probably, like, similar... 31:39 They would benefit from the gist. Yeah, that makes total sense. And was there any tool you used to, like, streamline this, like a software for, like, doing the sweepstakes, or how, how did that work? 31:50 Eventually, um, we just built it ourselves. Um, in... When was it? 31:56 2022, I think is when we brought on our director of technology, and he started, like, building a lot of stuff out for us, like, on the back end instead of us having to rely on external platforms, just so that, again, we could have kind of more control over the brand experience and, and the process. 32:20 So he did that. We're on, uh, Contentful, and I don't know how he did it, but he did. [laughs] Yeah. 32:28 I think there's some tools out there like UpViral, but, like, the tools that you might've used before 2022 may not be relevant anymore, so I, I don't, I don't know the best tool for this. 32:37 But there is stuff out there that can kinda do that for people who don't wanna build it custom. Yeah. 32:41 And one final question about the mechanics of that is, um, when you're partnering with other people for this, like, a lot of people feel like, "Well, if I partner with people, maybe I'm gonna promote it a lot and they won't, they won't promote it at all, and it's not gonna be fair." 32:52 Like, how did you make it fair? Were there terms around this that you had with the partners, um, or was it all kind of handshake agreement? Um, did you have to nudge people? Like, h-how did that work? Yeah. 33:05 It didn't always end up being, like, 100% fair, um, which is fine. I think, like, usually if somebody has a smaller audience, you ask them to promote more times to kind of 33:19 try and increase the entries from any given, um, partner. Uh, so we did our best to, to do that, but it didn't always work out perfectly. But what are you gonna do, you know? Yeah. It's never gonna be fair. 33:31 I think if there's some type of agreement around, you know, what are the inputs that we're gonna do, you know- Yeah... 33:36 is everybody gonna do this amount of social posts or this amount of newsletter sends, you know, if that's all agreed upon and, and there's, like, a various amount for different people. 33:45 You know, some people might have the audience that's half the size of yours. I think that's about the best that anyone can do. It's never gonna be perfect. Yeah. 33:52 You can nudge people a little bit, for sure, and, you know, like, send out the... where everything's at, you know, before it's over and be like, "Hey, this brand has hit their, hit the requirement. You guys haven't. 34:02 Maybe send it some more times." But, you know, I think that's kinda like the best, the best you can do. Yeah. And you're, and you're getting the growth regardless of if they do exactly that or not, so- Mm-hmm... 34:14 I, I think it's a strategy we should see more of. Um, but a lot of people just don't wanna do the... It's not a lot of work, but they don't wanna do the work to put it in. Let's see here. Yeah. 34:24 One, one question is I know you're mostly focused on growth, right? So you weren't focused on sponsorship sales or, or how did that work? I know you as a co-founder, you have your hands in a lot of stuff, you know. Yeah. 34:35 That, one of my other co-founders, JC, oversaw all of our, um, brand partnerships. But ask away, and if I can answer. [laughs] One question I have is, like, um, how do you think about expansion? 34:48 Because you, the initial expansion going from, you know, Toronto to Canada makes sense. The one... Going to the US is pretty straightforward. Like, how do you think about when you decided to go into college sports 35:01 or the business of sports? Was there a framework for making those decisions? Yeah. I think the way we thought about it was 35:10 it made sense to expand newsletters, because we already had really good, like, team and brand and voice and processes. Like, we already knew how to do newsletters really well. 35:23 We were already selling newsletter placements to brands, so this was just creating more inventory. So we kinda had the foundation in place to expand through newsletters. 35:36 Um, I think with the sports business newsletter, we just, because we kinda had front row seats to the growth in the women's sports space by virtue of who we are and, and what we were covering and who we were interacting with, it just felt like a really big opportunity that we didn't 35:52 wanna miss. Like, we were starting to see, like, increases in viewership numbers and more deals happening in the space, so it just, 36:03 it felt like there was a lot of demand for someone to be covering just, like, the business of, of women's sports. 36:11 And then with college sports, it's funny, as, like, Canadians, I still find it, like, funny how, like, how crazy everybody [laughs] is about college sports in this country. Oh, yeah. It's way different down here. 36:21 [laughs] I think we just kind of wanted to capitalize on that, and we felt, you know, again, positioned to, to be able to do that. 36:27 So I, I think that was the thinking of just, like, learning from the audience and the space of, like, where there was opportunity and seeing that, like-We could, we could execute on it based on what we had in place, and it would just be synergistic with, like, kind of our brand partnership operations and our content operations and growth operations and whatnot. 36:47 Yeah. 'Cause a lot of people who, who are newer don't realize, like, this opens up so much more inventory that you can sell and, and more revenue- Mm-hmm... 36:53 you can make and, uh, another way to be connected with the audience. So it ma- makes total sense. Let's talk about Within. Um- Okay... tell me about what that is, why you started it, what's the story behind it? 37:07 And wanna get into the, the mission and the content behind all that. Also wanna talk about, like, how you're planning to grow it because you have a... You're in a really unique position, right? 37:16 Where you've started a media company that's grown to hundreds of thousands, now over a million subscribers. 37:22 You've been there, done that, now you're doing something brand new, but it's, it's really recent, so I wanna kinda get, like, what your plans are for the future too. But tell us the story first. Yeah, for sure. 37:30 So I mean, the reason I have the capacity to launch a new business is actually, sadly, because I, I burned out from The Gist, um, pretty badly about a year ago. 37:44 And burnout is a bit of a spectrum, like, you know, a lot of people have, like, experienced some level of burnout, and I kind of let it get to the point where I wasn't really able to, to go on. Like, it was a really, 38:00 a really bad, um, situation unfortunately. 38:03 So yeah, I made the decision to transition out of the company, which was obviously very, um, heartbreaking and, and devastating, and a really big change as any, like, founder can imagine. 38:17 And took, like, the last year to, to heal and think about what would feel aligned for me next. And so I decided to become an executive coach and to launch Within, which is a personal development platform for founders, 38:33 um, offering, right now, coaching and content, but definitely see it expanding into different areas over time. It is very new though. 38:42 Um, and really, like, that was just born out of my experience of, of building a startup and, and burning out, and realizing that 38:52 there's probably a lot of inner work that I could've been doing as a founder that would've helped me avoid burnout and avoid getting into the situation that I did. Um, a- in my opinion, entrepreneurship is a very 39:06 spiritual journey. It really forces you to take a hard look at yourself and figure out the ways that you're getting in your own way of your own success. 39:16 And I think that there are lots of media companies out there that talk about entrepreneurship and how to build a business tactically, and how to fundraise and how to grow, and then there's lots of, um, outlets that talk about spirituality and personal development, but I kind of wanted to marry the two and create a platform where you can use personal development, um, as a way to show up in your business as somebody who is a better leader and more aligned, and more energized, and more conscious and aware of how you're building your business- Yes... 39:54 and doing it in a way that is, like, joyful and, and aligned and with more ease. Well, I think th- that's something I think we would all like, and something I feel like is lacking from my personal experience sometimes. 40:06 But also sometimes there... That's also the thing about, uh, being a, a founder is, like, uh, there's... 40:11 It's so cliché, but, like, the highs and the lows that you have, it's, it's said so often, but, like, sometimes- Mm-hmm... you, you wake up excited to, to get started, and sometimes you're dreading what you're doing. 40:21 Mm-hmm. And [laughs] and having that, like, um, s- personal or spiritual base, whatever you wanna call it, I think would help a lot. I also think, and just to tell you, like, my, 40:31 my thoughts is before I started the company, I don't think I really related to burnout at all. Mm-hmm. 40:37 And I still think it's hard for people to relate i- if you're, if you're not in a business or started the business yet, because it's just, it's a, it's just a lot different unless you're not there, I don't think. 40:46 It's like I always say, like, you don't really know what hard work is until you've actually done it. Like, I used to think I was working really hard at my job, and then I [laughs] 40:54 had a whole different experience starting the company, and I'm like, "Well, this, this is a totally different thing. I've never done anything like this before. Um, never felt this way before." Yeah. 41:03 So in some ways it's hard to relate to un- unless you're in it, but as someone in it, it totally makes sense. But yeah, like, t- tell me... It's not really a question, just getting [laughs] my thoughts out there. 41:13 Um, how do you think about burnout? How do you... What are you writing about it? How are you helping people with it? But also maybe how do you prevent it? Yeah. 41:20 'Cause I think that's what a lot of people would like to hear. [laughs] Yeah, for sure. Yeah, I mean, the way I'm approaching it and how I'm writing about it is, one, just, like, just talking about it a bit more openly, 41:35 um, and, and some of the different things that can contribute to it. 'Cause to your point, it's not, it's not just about how many hours you're working. 41:44 There's so much stress that's put on you as a founder, and so many things that can be moving you towards burnout. So I really just wanna create awareness for 41:53 some of the things that can contribute to it, and how you can avoid it. I think, you know, for me, 42:02 my experience of, of burnout at The Gist, like, there was a lot of different things at play that I, I talk about and share with my audience, I think. Like, one, just 42:12 being in go mode for, for over five years of, of building and, you know, you sacrifice a lot and you're working really hard. 42:20 And so every year that you go on creates even more pressure for you to succeed, and that's a lot to carry, as I'm sure you know. And so if you're not thinking about, like... 42:31 If you're not finding ways to blow off some of that stress or kind of, like, reframing this pressure, it can really start to weigh on you. 42:39 Another thing for me-As you grow your company, you wanna think about really intentional scope evolution, 'cause as we talked about, I was wearing a lot of different hats at The Gist, and if I'm really honest with myself, there are probab- there's, like, aspects of my role that I really didn't enjoy. 42:57 And I think when you're the founder, you get into this mentality of like, "Oh, I have to do everything." But then as you grow a team, it's possible to, like, start to delegate the things that you don't like. But I think 43:09 I thought there were areas where I was really providing a lot of value even though I wasn't enjoying them. And so 43:16 as you grow your company and have the opportunity to build a team, you wanna think really mindfully about, like, what are the things that really light me up? What do I enjoy doing? 43:25 Where are the places where I'm providing a lot of value for the company as a founder that also energize me, not just, like, I'm doing them because I, everybody thinks I should be doing them 'cause I'm good at them? 43:36 That's something that I wish I had done kind of more carefully. 43:41 The third thing I'll mention is, um, there were a lot of ways that, like, my own behavior and my own relationship with myself were contributing to my burnout. 43:50 So, like, for me, perfectionism, people pleasing, over-giving, wanting to be the person that, like, swoops in and solves, solves the problem, wanting to make sure everybody is having a good experience and likes me, which when you're a company that is, like, 20 full-time people, 40 total people, doing millions in revenue, serving millions in audience, working with 100-plus brands, like, it's not possible to keep every stakeholder happy. 44:18 But that is something with my personality that really weighed on me. And so there's a lot of, like, work that I've been doing since then to understand, like, why... where do these behaviors come from? 44:30 What is, like, the root cause of these things, and how can I start doing some work on myself to, to not feel that way anymore? 'Cause those can really, um, contribute to burnout in a big way. Yeah. 44:43 [laughs] I could keep going. [laughs] Yeah. I think that, you know, the final one actually might be one of the biggest things, because there's just so many people that are reliant on you 44:53 at all times, especially when you have, like, a media company where there's, like, all these clients and employees and other things going on, too. Mm-hmm. Um, and pleasing everybody is tough. 45:03 I- is there a way that you've dealt with that that's like, uh, like, like any tactical advice you would give for that? There's not, like, an easy solve for, uh, that one, I wouldn't say. 45:12 But I will say that a lot of the time, like, if you're someone that feels like they need to compulsive- compulsively people please or, like, make sure something's perfect, um, often there's, like, some kind of... 45:26 It's, like, triggering something that's, like, stored in our bodies where we're not able to respond to the stress in, like, a healthy way, where, like, normally 45:35 if some- a stressor comes up, you go into fight or flight, and then you come back down into rest or digest, which is, like, where you can be a bit more calm and, and make better decisions and access your intuition and all these kinds of things. 45:48 But sometimes, like, because of things that happened in your upbringing or, like, other programming, it can feel extra, like, activating and unsafe. 45:59 And so I would say nervous system regulation practices, working them into your daily life, and also in the moment, like, when you realize you're in an activated state, instead of just, like, pushing forward and, like, 46:15 saying yes to something you don't wanna say yes to or, um, just, like, continuing to, like, work really hard to, like, make sure you get the thing done that everybody wants you to get done or, like, whatever it is that you would normally do, just, like, taking a pause and breathing and engaging in practices to bring your nervous system back down to a more calm place where you can make better decisions that align better with your values and, like, your goals and what's in integrity for you. 46:42 So not a simple answer, but that's [laughs] what I would recommend on the spot. No, that's, that's what I'm looking for. And are, are you someone who's, when... 46:50 especially when you were at The Gist, was it just, like, all on 24/7, like hard to turn your brain off? And I imagine that doesn't help with burnout. Um- Oh my gosh, no. 'Cause I certainly am that type of person. 47:02 [laughs] Yeah, and I think, I think it's a cultural thing in, like, Western cultures where, like, a lot of us grow up and we learn from our parents and our schools and our first jobs that, like, that's just how you work. 47:15 Like, if you're resting, you're lazy, and we equate our productivity to our value. 47:20 And so even if you're someone that has the intention of being like, "I need to cut it off," there can be, like, something under the surface, something unconscious that, like, 47:31 makes you continue going even if that, like, wasn't your intention. 47:36 And, um, it's really hard when you're a founder too, because, like, yeah, you can, like, finish working, but then, like, for me, I would just, like, stay up in bed, like, worrying about things [laughs] at night. 47:47 Um- Yeah... it's tough. So, like- Have you talked to any people and shared advice or written about, like, that, that yet? 47:55 'Cause I think, I think, like, for me personally, I think that's one of the biggest reasons for burnout is, like, just not turning things off and, um- Yeah... 48:03 even if I'm stressed out from 9:00 to 5:00, at least it's, like, 9:00 to 5:00. [laughs] Totally. It's hard to be able to turn things off. Yeah. I would be curious for you, like, 48:12 yeah, what are the, what are the beliefs kind of underlying that need to, to keep working? Oh, man. You know, this is, um... 48:20 You know, I've never thought about things in terms of beliefs, but I think it's a good question to ask, and maybe those are some questions I gotta ask myself because, uh, w- when it's prompted, I think back to, like, 48:31 some of the beliefs are that, like, um, I've only really been ever good at one thing at a time in my life, and that's something that I tell myself. Like, when I was in high school, I was all in on sports, good at that, 48:42 and I, I, I feel like it's hard for me to do two things at once, whether that's work and family or work, family, and fitness, and I feel like, um-Yeah, I don't know. 48:52 It's, like, it's hard to describe that a little bit, but that's one of the beliefs, I think. Oh, one of the other beliefs is, like, being a provider, and like- Mm-hmm... 48:58 that's, I, I see that as my, one of my bigger values to my family or just in general. 49:04 And, you know, like, being on all the time or being obsessed with something is, is probably gonna s- serve that provider role better than turning things off. Yeah. 49:14 There's probably more, but that's just some things that come to mind immediately. Yeah. And it, like, this is a great first step even just to be aware of some of the beliefs that are driving you. 49:23 Um, I would say the next step would be to just start to question some of those beliefs. 49:27 So, like, is the only way that I provide for my family and, like, show up as a good dad and partner by working, or are there other ways that, you know, I can show up, show up for them? 49:40 And for the first one of, like, I would just question, like, is it true? Is it true that I can only do one thing well at once? 49:49 And it sounds like you have a lot of evidence that you go back to that your brain, like, defaults to that, like, yeah, that time in high school when it was sports and, and then this. 49:56 But, like, what, what, what's the evidence that shows that that's the opposite is actually true? And I, I would bet 50:03 that there is a lot of evidence because you're a very successful entrepreneur and you're, you're doing a lot of things really well. You're helping a lot of people. So, um, I think you can probably find 50:14 some evidence to disprove those two limiting beliefs. I like that. I wish we could talk more about that stuff. [laughs] We're, we're coming up on time here. Maybe another conversation. That'd, that'd be fun. Yeah. 50:24 Tell us, I think the last thing we'll, we should cover is just, um, because d- did you announce this, like, two or three weeks ago, two or four weeks ago? But you've probably been doing it before then, right? 50:33 I just saw the public announcement then. How are you thinking about growth as far as getting, uh, the audience off the ground, getting revenue off the ground? Whatever plans you have would be awesome to hear about. 50:46 Yeah, for sure. I'm approaching it very differently, I would say fr- from The Gist as someone that burned out and has, like, taken some time to think about doing things differently. 50:58 The growth strategy's gonna be really different because the monetization strategy is really different. 51:02 Where The Gist was monetized on a CPM or cost per thousand impressions basis for the most part, I'm starting with selling coaching, which is a high-ticket item. 51:13 And so it's less about how many people are opening and engaging with this email and more about, like, I just need a smaller number of people to deeply trust me enough to help them through coaching. 51:28 And so the metrics are different. It's, it's not necessarily about, like, likes or how big the audience is. 51:34 It's more about, like, how many people are, like, saving and sharing my posts, how many people are commenting, how many people are DM-ing me, how many 51:43 people are replying to my emails and telling them about themselves and, and, and what they need and, um, how I'm using that information to understand them more deeply to be able to serve them through coaching. 51:57 Um, I, I definitely see opportunities, like, down the line around something priced more accessibly. So something like cohort-based learning, group coaching, online community, in real life events. 52:14 Those are all things I want to, like, stay close to my audience on right now or with my customer base on right now, like, understand their problems and, like, start thinking creatively about how those could take form. 52:26 But I really am trying to just focus on one thing at a time for now. And so rolling out the coaching program is my number one goal for this quarter, and we'll just kind of have to see how it goes down the line. 52:38 I love that, and I love that as a place to start, um, 'cause I like... I think about structuring business models a lot and, and I think it's... 52:46 Most people do the opposite where they start with, like, "Let me sell something inexpensive. Let me sell a $10 thing." Mm-hmm. 52:52 But the opposite is often better, where what's my, what's like the top of or the bottom of my funnel? 52:57 The, the one-on-one coaching, the most expensive thing, and then later on I'll figure out how to do something more accessible in the middle or, um, even something that's just digital that's entirely, um, has no marginal cost of reproduction that you could sell at a very, very lower price, and moving backwards in that way I like to see. 53:14 Yeah. And it's also just asking myself, like, what do I love doing? And like, I love coaching. 53:19 I love pr- working with people one on one on things like their limiting beliefs and, um, you know, getting realigned on their vision and re-energized in their business. So that was part of the, the decision too. 53:30 Like, it wasn't all strategic. It was just like, what am I gonna do well at, because I, I love it. Yeah. That's often the better way to go about it. [laughs] Um, I love it. 53:40 So, um, we'll put the link for that down low, but, but tell us where people can find Within, where people can find you. Yeah. 53:46 For now, I'm still rolling everything out, so my personal Instagram, @roslynmclarty, R-O-S-L-Y-N-M-C-L-A-R-T-Y, and then the same thing for LinkedIn would be where you can find me. Okay. Cool. 54:00 And we'll put the link to the newsletter below in the description of the video or the episode, so check that out, folks. Thank you for doing this. This was a lot of fun. Perfect. Yeah. Thanks so much, Matt. 54:10 This was great.